You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > ok enlighten me
November 16 2026 12.07pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ok enlighten me


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 May 14 10.38am

Quote silvertop at 13 May 2014 9.56am

Well, I think it was either one or the other; and Liverpool have played the most exciting football in this division. Very easy on the eye. To get 2nd by playing lovely flamboyant football [other than e.g. the score once and then park the bus Chelsea way] deserved the big prize.

Pulis was the Prems MOTY - also deserved for reasons given by others.

If you can't defend, and your midfield cannot close off games, then you're only playing 33% of the football well. Defensively liverpool were shocking, and outside of Coutino and Gerrard their midfield was very average.

Football isn't about scoring goals, its about not conceeding them. Rogers inability to shore up his midfield and defence speak of a 'one trick pony' rather than a great manager.

By the time the premiership finished, we were increasingly successful in all aspects of the game.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Plane Flag Bromley 13 May 14 10.39am

Quote silvertop at 13 May 2014 9.56am

Well, I think it was either one or the other; and Liverpool have played the most exciting football in this division. Very easy on the eye. To get 2nd by playing lovely flamboyant football [other than e.g. the score once and then park the bus Chelsea way] deserved the big prize.

Pulis was the Prems MOTY - also deserved for reasons given by others.


On that basis, give it to Pellegrini, as he actually won something, City's football is even easier on the eye and his defenders knew how to defend.

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 13 May 14 12.16pm

TP has done much the hardest job in the prem this year. Wetspam done well, but finished lower, Hull had a head start. Any of the top teams have only done as expected with boundless cheque books and unchallengeable spending power. May even be found to be illegal. From England's position , they have let us down, having bloodied only one (!) England qualified player in this whole season (Wilson, Manure). If the manager of the season is selected from this bunch of underachieving millionairs, then England's failure in the World Cup will be easily explained.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 13 May 14 12.21pm

I blame James Beattie. Pulis was starting with a deficit.

Edited by Stuk (13 May 2014 12.22pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 13 May 14 12.35pm

Quote Dan Theolmesdaleroad at 13 May 2014 1.05am

Maybe Rodgers does deserve it, but not for taking Liverpool from 7th place to 2nd in only a year. The remarkable way in which he skilfully guided them from 1st place to 2nd in only a couple of weeks was truly a joy to behold. Well done, Brendan.


 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

Stuart_Eagle Flag Kent 13 May 14 12.36pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 May 2014 10.38am

Quote silvertop at 13 May 2014 9.56am

Well, I think it was either one or the other; and Liverpool have played the most exciting football in this division. Very easy on the eye. To get 2nd by playing lovely flamboyant football [other than e.g. the score once and then park the bus Chelsea way] deserved the big prize.

Pulis was the Prems MOTY - also deserved for reasons given by others.

If you can't defend, and your midfield cannot close off games, then you're only playing 33% of the football well. Defensively liverpool were shocking, and outside of Coutino and Gerrard their midfield was very average.

Football isn't about scoring goals, its about not conceeding them. Rogers inability to shore up his midfield and defence speak of a 'one trick pony' rather than a great manager.

By the time the premiership finished, we were increasingly successful in all aspects of the game.



????

Is that a joke,whilst I agree all teams need a tight defence, without goals you'll draw every game.

I think people are getting too carried away, Rodgers had a great season and well done to Liverpool.
TP got a deserved award and we are potentially entering the best period in our clubs history, lets just enjoy it

 


we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur, we're the Arthur over here!

Positive! Proud & Palace - W block, AW

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 13 May 14 12.36pm

Jaime must have some Italian dna

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 May 14 12.50pm

Quote Stuart_Eagle at 13 May 2014 12.36pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 May 2014 10.38am

Quote silvertop at 13 May 2014 9.56am

Well, I think it was either one or the other; and Liverpool have played the most exciting football in this division. Very easy on the eye. To get 2nd by playing lovely flamboyant football [other than e.g. the score once and then park the bus Chelsea way] deserved the big prize.

Pulis was the Prems MOTY - also deserved for reasons given by others.

If you can't defend, and your midfield cannot close off games, then you're only playing 33% of the football well. Defensively liverpool were shocking, and outside of Coutino and Gerrard their midfield was very average.

Football isn't about scoring goals, its about not conceeding them. Rogers inability to shore up his midfield and defence speak of a 'one trick pony' rather than a great manager.

By the time the premiership finished, we were increasingly successful in all aspects of the game.



????

Is that a joke,whilst I agree all teams need a tight defence, without goals you'll draw every game.

I think people are getting too carried away, Rodgers had a great season and well done to Liverpool.
TP got a deserved award and we are potentially entering the best period in our clubs history, lets just enjoy it

As determined by statistical analysis of games. Not conceeding is far more significant factor in obtaining points, than scoring. Obviously you can't win games by not scoring goals, but its less important than conceeding goals - See Soccernomics.

The sign of a really good form in a team is one that keeps clean sheets. Even if it only wins games 1-0 or draws 0-0

Interestingly, in terms of scoring goals, the second goal scored in the game will determine the result in more games than not.

Consequently, I say football is about not conceeding goals, rather than scoring them. You still have to be able to score goals, but its far less important than not conceeding goals.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 13 May 14 12.58pm

I will only refer to you as Giacomo Martino - hardnut no quarter given azzuri poster from know on, Jaime.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stuk Flag Top half 13 May 14 12.59pm

Are you going crackers, Kerm?

 


Optimistic as ever

midlandeagle Flag Coventry 13 May 14 1.04pm

It should have been between Pullis and Martinez at Everton.

We all know what Pullis has done for us, Martinez has done a great job for them this season, some good loan signings and on less than half the budget of Liveerpool. For me a much better achievment than what Rodgers has done

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 13 May 14 1.06pm

Quote Stuk at 13 May 2014 12.59pm

Are you going crackers, Kerm?


"going"????

five hours kip only

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stuk Flag Top half 13 May 14 1.42pm

Quote Kermit8 at 13 May 2014 1.06pm

Quote Stuk at 13 May 2014 12.59pm

Are you going crackers, Kerm?


"going"????

five hours kip only

Unlucky. You must've walked under a ladder.

 


Optimistic as ever

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 May 14 1.53pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 May 2014 12.50pm

Interestingly, in terms of scoring goals, the second goal scored in the game will determine the result in more games than not.


That is a point worth highlighting. When you think about it for half a minute it's not surprising that it is so. We will do well to get to that stage where we can go 2-0 up or draw level to 1-1 and salvage a draw or even a win more often.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 14 2.10pm

Quote Plane at 13 May 2014 9.34am

Quote Ian J at 13 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Eagle_SA at 13 May 2014 9.00am

Brenda took them from 7th to 2nd, TP took us from bottom to 11th. A feat never previously achieved by any manager. Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them. TP took us up 9 places!

There may well have been far fewer points dividing the teams in the bottom half of the table until the last couple of weeks as I seem to recall that the points difference between the team in 10th place and the relegation zone was only a few points at one stage.

Whilst it may well be true that "Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them" let's not forget that Pulis wasn't the only manager to break that record as Gus Poyet did it too


Why don't you sign up to a Sunderland site and you can be amongst your own.

Why don't you find a site devoted to people with low IQs and you can also be amongst your own

 

Plane Flag Bromley 13 May 14 2.16pm

Quote Ian J at 13 May 2014 2.10pm

Quote Plane at 13 May 2014 9.34am

Quote Ian J at 13 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Eagle_SA at 13 May 2014 9.00am

Brenda took them from 7th to 2nd, TP took us from bottom to 11th. A feat never previously achieved by any manager. Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them. TP took us up 9 places!

There may well have been far fewer points dividing the teams in the bottom half of the table until the last couple of weeks as I seem to recall that the points difference between the team in 10th place and the relegation zone was only a few points at one stage.

Whilst it may well be true that "Previously the highest a change of manager had managed to take a team was 3 places above where he found them" let's not forget that Pulis wasn't the only manager to break that record as Gus Poyet did it too


Why don't you sign up to a Sunderland site and you can be amongst your own.

Why don't you find a site devoted to people with low IQs and you can also be amongst your own


That's really clever of you Ian, have you been working on that since 9.34 am, well done!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 13 May 14 2.20pm

Quote Plane at 13 May 2014 2.16pm

That's really clever of you Ian, have you been working on that since 9.34 am, well done!

Oh dear, repartee isn't your forte either.


 

Stuk Flag Top half 13 May 14 3.01pm

A decent write from an annoying website, so I've copied and pasted rather than linked to it:


by Samuel Coyne Junior Contributor
Published40 minutes ago
Read by 420 People
Comments ...
Flag article &#59397;

Football News 24/7


Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers has been awarded the League Manager's Association Manager of the Year award in a season his side finished second.

Having guided the Reds from seventh last season to runners-up and a Champions League position this time around, he has had a hugely successful year. However, he must consider himself fortunate to have been given the accolade by his peers.

His side have not had to contend with the mid-week pressures of European football and were knocked out of both domestic cups at a relatively early stage.

Furthermore, a squad containing stars such as Luis Suarez, Daniel Sturridge, Phillippe Coutinho and Steven Gerrard should under no circumstances be finishing below the squads that Everton, Manchester United and Tottenham currently have at their disposal, as they did last season under Rodgers.

To a large extent, it can be said that Liverpool's success this season has been aided by the demise of two of their rivals; Spurs and United. This season, Tottenham have failed to settle their summer signings and have bemoaned the loss of talents such as Gareth Bale and Luka Modric. Likewise, the effect of Sir Alex Ferguson's retirement at United and David Moyes' failure to rejuvenate the squad has seen the Manchester side plummet.

Everton, much like their Merseyside rivals, have benefitted from these short-fallings too, however even their squad pales in comparison to Liverpool's. Is Steven Naismith comparable with Sturridge? Even Romelu Lukaku is far behind the shining light of Suarez.

If 'management' is explicitly being rewarded, can it be said that Rodgers has had the best season? Without the squad rotation necessary with Champions League football and a considerable transfer budget, Rodgers has not strictly demonstrated the qualities to make him this season's best manager.

Overlooked was Tony Pulis, who has rightly enjoyed much praise after ensuring Crystal Palace's survival this season. He has transformed a squad that looked certain to be relegated without his direction. In doing so, he has got the most out of a modest group of players and basic facilities.

Clearly Pulis did not have to rotate for mid-week football either, yet in his formations and tactics over the final weeks of the season, his management abilities have been proven beyond those of Rodgers.

When the two sides faced each other a week ago, Rodgers failed to make his Liverpool side close out a 3-0 lead. Understandably they were chasing goals to make up the difference on Manchester City, however once Palace scored their first Rodgers should have ensured that his side held out for victory. Pulis, in contrast, made positive substitutions, including bringing on Dwight Gayle, leading to a dramatic 3-3 draw.

Rodgers also fell short against Chelsea the week before, when faced with what he described as 'two buses.' Jose Mourinho's Blues may be well-versed in closing up shop, however Liverpool could find no way through. His post-match comments only served to highlight that he still is well-below the level of tactical acumen of his old mentor Mourinho. Pulis, however, 'managed' to shut-up shop against the same Chelsea and go on and win the game.

Liverpool have had a very successful season and their manager deserves substantial credit for his work. They play an attractive brand of football, free-flowing and attacking, which has rightly drawn many admirers.

Luis Suarez has impressed greatly, with this year all about his incredible performances on the pitch rather than his controversies. The improvement in players such as Jordan Henderson and Raheem Sterling - along with Rodgers' clever deployment of Gerrard in a deeper role - is a testament to his work, however if the LMA award is to celebrate 'management' strictly, then Rodgers can consider himself somewhat fortunate to be picked ahead of Pulis.

For the last four years, the award has gone to the manager of a side competing in the top half of the table. Twice that man was Sir Alex Ferguson, in a season in which his Manchester United side won the title.

On both of these occasions United were also contesting the Champions League. This season, Rodgers has not had to manage in this way, whilst Pulis has picked his players up from the relegation zone and secured them in mid-table. The level of actual 'management' that both individuals have done differs greatly.

When Liverpool are in the Champions League next season, which they thoroughly deserve, Rodgers' management skills will be truly delivered. How he balances mid-week football and picks up his players after running City so close this year will show the measure of the man. If he comes through that he would deserve all the awards going.

For this season, however, managing a side containing superstars who will light up this year's World Cup pales in comparison to picking up a side like Crystal Palace and giving their fans another year worth of Premier League football.

 


Optimistic as ever

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 13 May 14 3.29pm

Quote Plane at 13 May 2014 10.39am

On that basis, give it to Pellegrini, as he actually won something, City's football is even easier on the eye and his defenders knew how to defend.


This!

Man City's win at Selhurst was the most comprehensive jobs done on us I saw all season. They scored early and snuffed out everything we tried to do thereafter. A complete team from front to back...and it only cost 1.2 billion*!

* Hence no MOTY for Pellegrini.

Edited by Ray in Houston (13 May 2014 3.40pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 13 May 14 3.33pm

Quote Stuk at 13 May 2014 3.01pm

When Liverpool are in the Champions League next season, which they thoroughly deserve, Rodgers' management skills will be truly delivered. How he balances mid-week football and picks up his players after running City so close this year will show the measure of the man. If he comes through that he would deserve all the awards going.


Very good piece. The second last para, highlighted above, is key for me. If Rodgers can get Liverpool challenging for the title while dealing with Champs League too then he'll have done very well. I suspect he won't and that this season was their best chance of winning it, with no CL distractions.

I don't think they'll be anywhere near the title next season and Brenda will be shown up to be the one-dimensional manager he actually is.

Edited by Seth (13 May 2014 3.34pm)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > ok enlighten me