You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Next Labour fall guy
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Next Labour fall guy


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 08 May 15 1.57pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 1.44pm

Quote The Sash at 08 May 2015 12.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 11.48am

Nicola Sturgeon? lol.

Nick Clegg will be free by tomorrow afternoon. Farage maybe?

Those Transfer day deadline deals in full

Ed Milliband: Labour (Contract Cancelled by mutual consent)

Nick Clegg: Liberal Democrat to Labour (Free)

All joking aside, Labour rather than rebranding themselves as the third way, conservative lite, would be better off actually looking at how the SNP have succeed in Scotland in going from a small nothing party to being its sole political power in 20 years - Even whilst surviving the failure of their 'one issue' campaign (Independence).

For Labour to resurrect itself, it needs to reestablish itself as a political party of the people that delivers actual real tangible benefits to the people, rather than the faux s**t of New Labour.

Across an era that's seen the idea of 'left wing' politics diminish, the SNP has flourished as a left wing nationalist party and destroyed the Scottish Labour Party as a force north of the border (including areas traditionally regarded as being stalwart Labour).

Because if they don't, in five years they'll be rapidly approaching insignificance.


Labour, especially in the South, needs to stop sneering down its Islingtonian middle class nose at the 'white van, flag of St George in the front garden' white working class voter and try to engage them again.

They have abandoned them and what, in the face of a pretty piss poor and unpopular Tory Government should have seen a walk in the park in picking up the disaffected white working class vote they have seen it go to UKIP (in the main) and the SNP (although the SNP were always going to win big in Scotland for the same reasons as England).

Millibands legacy as leader is to be filed with Michael Foot and Neil Kinnock in the A for Absymal draw....really shocking.


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 08 May 15 2.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 1.44pm

Quote The Sash at 08 May 2015 12.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 11.48am

Nicola Sturgeon? lol.

Nick Clegg will be free by tomorrow afternoon. Farage maybe?

Those Transfer day deadline deals in full

Ed Milliband: Labour (Contract Cancelled by mutual consent)

Nick Clegg: Liberal Democrat to Labour (Free)

All joking aside, Labour rather than rebranding themselves as the third way, conservative lite, would be better off actually looking at how the SNP have succeed in Scotland in going from a small nothing party to being its sole political power in 20 years - Even whilst surviving the failure of their 'one issue' campaign (Independence).

For Labour to resurrect itself, it needs to reestablish itself as a political party of the people that delivers actual real tangible benefits to the people, rather than the faux s**t of New Labour.

Across an era that's seen the idea of 'left wing' politics diminish, the SNP has flourished as a left wing nationalist party and destroyed the Scottish Labour Party as a force north of the border (including areas traditionally regarded as being stalwart Labour).

Because if they don't, in five years they'll be rapidly approaching insignificance.


Not that long ago (relatively - Blair in his heyday) that people were saying that about the Tories.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Hoof Hearted 08 May 15 4.13pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 08 May 2015 2.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 1.44pm

Quote The Sash at 08 May 2015 12.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 11.48am

Nicola Sturgeon? lol.

Nick Clegg will be free by tomorrow afternoon. Farage maybe?

Those Transfer day deadline deals in full

Ed Milliband: Labour (Contract Cancelled by mutual consent)

Nick Clegg: Liberal Democrat to Labour (Free)

All joking aside, Labour rather than rebranding themselves as the third way, conservative lite, would be better off actually looking at how the SNP have succeed in Scotland in going from a small nothing party to being its sole political power in 20 years - Even whilst surviving the failure of their 'one issue' campaign (Independence).

For Labour to resurrect itself, it needs to reestablish itself as a political party of the people that delivers actual real tangible benefits to the people, rather than the faux s**t of New Labour.

Across an era that's seen the idea of 'left wing' politics diminish, the SNP has flourished as a left wing nationalist party and destroyed the Scottish Labour Party as a force north of the border (including areas traditionally regarded as being stalwart Labour).

Because if they don't, in five years they'll be rapidly approaching insignificance.


Not that long ago (relatively - Blair in his heyday) that people were saying that about the Tories.


Yes... but they were also saying "they had put an end to boom and bust".

 

derben Flag 09 May 15 9.07am

I see David Lammy says he will stand. Lol, should ensure a few more years of Labour electoral defeat.

 

JL85 Flag London,SE9 09 May 15 9.11am

Quote Catfish at 08 May 2015 11.33am

They should beg David Miliband to come back.

Hasn't got a seat so no chance really.

 

Rubin Flag 10 May 15 1.01pm

Tristram Hunt - the only one that isn't annoying.

 

Plane Flag Bromley 10 May 15 1.02pm

Quote Rubin at 10 May 2015 1.01pm

Tristram Hunt - the only one that isn't annoying.

With a name like that, he is annoying

 

Eagle_SA Flag Just outside Cape Town 10 May 15 1.23pm

Quote derben at 08 May 2015 10.19am


Who will it be?

Ian Holloway is available.


So is Colin.

 


And I see signs of half remembered days, I hear bells that chime in strange familiar ways

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 10 May 15 2.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 08 May 2015 1.44pm

All joking aside, Labour rather than rebranding themselves as the third way, conservative lite, would be better off actually looking at how the SNP have succeed in Scotland in going from a small nothing party to being its sole political power in 20 years - Even whilst surviving the failure of their 'one issue' campaign (Independence).

For Labour to resurrect itself, it needs to reestablish itself as a political party of the people that delivers actual real tangible benefits to the people, rather than the faux s**t of New Labour.

Across an era that's seen the idea of 'left wing' politics diminish, the SNP has flourished as a left wing nationalist party and destroyed the Scottish Labour Party as a force north of the border (including areas traditionally regarded as being stalwart Labour).

Because if they don't, in five years they'll be rapidly approaching insignificance.



Completely disagree. Labour will never win another election if they carry on trying to be a left wing party. Scotland is not England. The SNP won up there because they peddled unworkable policies and also campaign now for devo-max, which is what most of their electorate want. Fair enough.

Which leaves Labour with England, and the more they veer to the left, the more they alienate the aspirational middle class. That's why they lost, they appealed to their core vote to try and get it out (35% strategy) and didn't appeal to anybody else. There was too much business bashing and not enough appeal to those who wish to create wealth.

I highly doubt Labour will win votes back off the Tories by becoming even more socialist. Barmy.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 10 May 15 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 10 May 15 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 10 May 15 3.51pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2015 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.


Appealing to people with my views would be to move to the left of any Labour leader ever. Digging up Lenin's corpse out and parading it round with a red rosette would still leave me unconvinced!

A slight shift to the left, which would involve strong arguments around a living wage, electoral reform, Keynesian economics and large-scale house building would not exactly be a leap to full Communism. Yes, the centre-left hasn't won an election for pushing on 40 years now but it still has the apparatus there to do so: a far larger membership base than the Tories, much greater numbers on the ground and union funding, which let's not forget still amounts to millions of pounds. Sure, all but 2 of the mainstream newspapers are right wing, but their power is waning really.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

derben Flag 10 May 15 4.37pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 3.51pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2015 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.


Appealing to people with my views would be to move to the left of any Labour leader ever. Digging up Lenin's corpse out and parading it round with a red rosette would still leave me unconvinced!

A slight shift to the left, which would involve strong arguments around a living wage, electoral reform, Keynesian economics and large-scale house building would not exactly be a leap to full Communism. Yes, the centre-left hasn't won an election for pushing on 40 years now but it still has the apparatus there to do so: a far larger membership base than the Tories, much greater numbers on the ground and union funding, which let's not forget still amounts to millions of pounds. Sure, all but 2 of the mainstream newspapers are right wing, but their power is waning really.

So you think Labour lost because they were not far enough to the left? So I guess the electorate thought, hmmm, Labour is not far enough to the left for me, I know, I'll vote for the Tories, they are more to the left than Labour.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 10 May 15 4.51pm

Quote derben at 10 May 2015 4.37pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 3.51pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2015 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.


Appealing to people with my views would be to move to the left of any Labour leader ever. Digging up Lenin's corpse out and parading it round with a red rosette would still leave me unconvinced!

A slight shift to the left, which would involve strong arguments around a living wage, electoral reform, Keynesian economics and large-scale house building would not exactly be a leap to full Communism. Yes, the centre-left hasn't won an election for pushing on 40 years now but it still has the apparatus there to do so: a far larger membership base than the Tories, much greater numbers on the ground and union funding, which let's not forget still amounts to millions of pounds. Sure, all but 2 of the mainstream newspapers are right wing, but their power is waning really.

So you think Labour lost because they were not far enough to the left? So I guess the electorate thought, hmmm, Labour is not far enough to the left for me, I know, I'll vote for the Tories, they are more to the left than Labour.

Labour lost in scotland against an anti austerity party...

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 May 15 5.00pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2015 4.51pm

Quote derben at 10 May 2015 4.37pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 3.51pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2015 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.


Appealing to people with my views would be to move to the left of any Labour leader ever. Digging up Lenin's corpse out and parading it round with a red rosette would still leave me unconvinced!

A slight shift to the left, which would involve strong arguments around a living wage, electoral reform, Keynesian economics and large-scale house building would not exactly be a leap to full Communism. Yes, the centre-left hasn't won an election for pushing on 40 years now but it still has the apparatus there to do so: a far larger membership base than the Tories, much greater numbers on the ground and union funding, which let's not forget still amounts to millions of pounds. Sure, all but 2 of the mainstream newspapers are right wing, but their power is waning really.

So you think Labour lost because they were not far enough to the left? So I guess the electorate thought, hmmm, Labour is not far enough to the left for me, I know, I'll vote for the Tories, they are more to the left than Labour.

Labour lost in scotland against an anti austerity party...

I have lost count of the number of times I heard Sturgeon used the words "Austerity" and "Progressive".


 

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 May 15 5.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 10 May 2015 4.51pm

Quote derben at 10 May 2015 4.37pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 3.51pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2015 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.


Appealing to people with my views would be to move to the left of any Labour leader ever. Digging up Lenin's corpse out and parading it round with a red rosette would still leave me unconvinced!

A slight shift to the left, which would involve strong arguments around a living wage, electoral reform, Keynesian economics and large-scale house building would not exactly be a leap to full Communism. Yes, the centre-left hasn't won an election for pushing on 40 years now but it still has the apparatus there to do so: a far larger membership base than the Tories, much greater numbers on the ground and union funding, which let's not forget still amounts to millions of pounds. Sure, all but 2 of the mainstream newspapers are right wing, but their power is waning really.

So you think Labour lost because they were not far enough to the left? So I guess the electorate thought, hmmm, Labour is not far enough to the left for me, I know, I'll vote for the Tories, they are more to the left than Labour.

Labour lost in scotland against an anti austerity party...


Get rid of the Barnett Formula and let Scotland get the same public expenditure as England - the delta is about £1500 per person, and raise tax to pay for free prescriptions and uni fees if they want. The SNP and Labour in Scotland may not be pro paying down the debt by reducing spending, but they get much more from the public purse than we do.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 May 15 5.32pm

Quote Rubin at 10 May 2015 1.01pm

Tristram Hunt - the only one that isn't annoying.


He is annoying.

 

Rubin Flag 10 May 15 5.47pm

Quote chris123 at 10 May 2015 5.32pm

Quote Rubin at 10 May 2015 1.01pm

Tristram Hunt - the only one that isn't annoying.


He is annoying.


Perhaps, but no where near as bad as 'Chuka'.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 May 15 5.55pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 3.51pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 10 May 2015 3.18pm

Quote serial thriller at 10 May 2015 2.11pm

Labour need to decide on what their tack is and just hammer it home. Their failure in this election was that they didn't sufficiently set their stall out: while the Tories banged on about the deficit and jobs and the SNP, Labour switched from one thing to another.

Sadly I think this means they'll bring in some Blairite like Chukka Umunna and move to the right. I think arguing they can't win from the left is presumptuous as I still believe that there is a very convincing anti-austerity egalitarian argument to be made. They have 5 years, so plenty of time to alter public discourse.


The 'tack' is obvious. Blair won 3 elections by appealing to middle class aspirational types and business.

With the greatest of respect, appealing to people with your views is a route to defeat.

The same is incidentally true of me and the Tories. I would only vote for them if their leader was Norman Tebbitt, Mrs Peter Bone or Attila the Hun.


Appealing to people with my views would be to move to the left of any Labour leader ever. Digging up Lenin's corpse out and parading it round with a red rosette would still leave me unconvinced!

A slight shift to the left, which would involve strong arguments around a living wage, electoral reform, Keynesian economics and large-scale house building would not exactly be a leap to full Communism. Yes, the centre-left hasn't won an election for pushing on 40 years now but it still has the apparatus there to do so: a far larger membership base than the Tories, much greater numbers on the ground and union funding, which let's not forget still amounts to millions of pounds. Sure, all but 2 of the mainstream newspapers are right wing, but their power is waning really.


I think Ed Miliband is far more left wing in his thinking than he ever portrays.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 10 May 15 5.57pm

Quote Rubin at 10 May 2015 5.47pm

Quote chris123 at 10 May 2015 5.32pm

Quote Rubin at 10 May 2015 1.01pm

Tristram Hunt - the only one that isn't annoying.


He is annoying.


Perhaps, but no where near as bad as 'Chuka'.


Chukki is an Eagle.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Next Labour fall guy