You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Books to Films
November 22 2026 1.57am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Books to Films


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 02 Jun 15 12.44pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 12.30pm

A rarity is Ian Fleming and early Bond movies. Both as good as each other. Obviously the books are a bit deeper, well written too, but Connery's Bond and the scripts don't fail the author.

The books paint a much darker and nastier Bond, much more of a necessary evil man, hard drinking, misogynistic and borderline sociopathic than any of the Bonds until Daniel Craig (Casino Royal) managed (Noteworthy I thought that Goldeneye had more a nod to the Bond of the novels, than the movies).


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

wollongongeagle Flag wollongong 02 Jun 15 12.44pm


One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest

To Kill a Mockingbird

Enjoyed both books, but preferred the films. Maybe because I saw the films first and Gregory Peck and Jack Nicholson owned the part.

 


We are the goon squad and we're going to town. Beep Beep!

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Jun 15 12.47pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 12.35pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 12.28pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 12.10pm

Quote derben at 02 Jun 2015 11.39am


Most of the original books are better than the films. They are different mediums anyway, what makes one good doesn't necessarily make the other good. By the the way, the shark gets it in the end.

Great novels don't usually adapt well, but s**t books tend to do quite well, probably because there is more scope for the film maker to do what they want.


True - and some are obviously open to censorship.

The ending of Grapes of Wrath with Henry Fonda, which is btw one of my top 5 fave reads was cut dramatically as the Hollywood studios of the time simple couldn't allow a woman to breast feed a grown man to keep him from dying anywhere near a screen


Irony being that the studio heads at the time would have been paying copious amounts to 'working' women to do exactly that themselves all nappied up.

It also is a lot more toned down politically and is a lot less 'dark' at the end...cant have 'mericans having a real life s***ty ending

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

the_big_shipp Flag Kent 02 Jun 15 12.48pm

2 spring to mind:

I am legend and blade runner. Both use the original novel as more of a rough guide rather than the film aiming to be a true adaptation. I guess that's the key.

You can never beat the imagination you construct personally of course.

 


It takes two to lie. One to lie and One to listen.

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Jun 15 12.50pm

Quote wollongongeagle at 02 Jun 2015 12.44pm


One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest

To Kill a Mockingbird

Enjoyed both books, but preferred the films. Maybe because I saw the films first and Gregory Peck and Jack Nicholson owned the part.


So the other way on that one.

I think the film does the novel a huge disservice - agree with Peck though he owns the movie, but the subtlety and the nuances that move the story along in the novel just gets thrown away in the movie and become just stilted little 'set plays' and it just quickly becomes a bit of a courtroom drama based on the racial prejudice of the south - the book is sooooo much more than that

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 02 Jun 15 12.59pm

Don't give up 'jaws'. The word 'v@gina' is mentioned later. First time I ever saw it in print aged 11. Naughty stuff back then.

Edited by Kermit8 (02 Jun 2015 12.59pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 02 Jun 15 1.03pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 02 Jun 2015 11.58am

Usually adaptations to the screen lack the depth of the book, and in order to truly excel need to be based on very poor source material or be excellent adaptations.

Apocalypse Now is actually better than Conrad's, admittedly very good novella.

True Blood as a series far exceeded the frankly s**t books.

The Godfather I+II is actually cheapened by a very poor throw away book.

Nothing Lasts for Ever - Was remade as the first Die Hard movie.

The Shinning - Whilst there is a lot more to the book and the characters are more well rounded, it suffers from Stephen King ten thousand page overload, and lacks the vision of Kubrick and Nicholson.

Goodfella's is better than the book, but its actually not a bad book per se, it just 'pops' more as a fictional movie based on an informants story..

The Exorcist - Good novel, better movie.

Children of Men - PD James foray into Science Fiction isn't all that good but its interesting enough to help spawn one of the best dystopian movies in the genre.

Also the TV series Game of Thrones is actually a lot better than the books, something even the author agrees.

Requiem for a Dream / Last Exit from Brooklyn - I love Hubert Selby jnr's novels, but both of these exceed even his ability to translate the bleakness of the world and its careless horror.


First thing I thought of was Last Exit (To Brooklyn though JM - you're going the wrong way ). The film would've been easy to mess up (it's so controversial that it would have a viewers market whatever the quality) but it nailed it I think. Seriously bleak.

I've said my piece on Requiem a couple of times before. No need to stir up old wounds

Possible shouts for films better then the books could arguably be ...
Carrie
One flew over the cuckoos nest
Ghost World

There's others like Perfume & Fear and Loathing where I think the film did the best job it could, but possibly should never had been attempted in the first place.

Of course, there's lots of classics (Shakespeare, Dickins, Austin etc) that have been made into superb films - although it would take a brave man to say they're better than the novels

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

Dixie Eagle Flag Chatham 02 Jun 15 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Jun 15 1.16pm

Quote Dixie Eagle at 02 Jun 2015 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

I am stuck on Ellen Brody masturbating in a diner at the moment.


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 02 Jun 15 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.16pm

Quote Dixie Eagle at 02 Jun 2015 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

I am stuck on Ellen Brody masturbating in a diner at the moment.



So am I now

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Jun 15 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.16pm

Quote Dixie Eagle at 02 Jun 2015 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

I am stuck on Ellen Brody masturbating in a diner at the moment.



So am I now

Its not as exciting as it sounds SF....imagine female w@nking as written by Barbara Cartland...


Edited by The Sash (02 Jun 2015 1.35pm)

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

derben Flag 02 Jun 15 1.36pm

Quote Kermit8 at 02 Jun 2015 12.59pm

Don't give up 'jaws'. The word 'v@gina' is mentioned later. First time I ever saw it in print aged 11. Naughty stuff back then.

Edited by Kermit8 (02 Jun 2015 12.59pm)

Sure it wasn't Viginia, eleven-year-old imagination running away with you.

 

liamcpfc92 Flag cheam 02 Jun 15 1.51pm

Saw Stephen King's It before i read the book (all 1,000+ pages) and both scared the crap out of me, but both were very good,never been a fan of clowns since though.

 


interviewed on 2/5/2010 at hillsborough by BBC, highlight of my tv career.

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 02 Jun 15 2.05pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.16pm

Quote Dixie Eagle at 02 Jun 2015 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

I am stuck on Ellen Brody masturbating in a diner at the moment.



So am I now

Its not as exciting as it sounds SF....imagine female w@nking as written by Barbara Cartland...


Edited by The Sash (02 Jun 2015 1.35pm)


Would

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

ghosteagle Flag 02 Jun 15 2.06pm

Quote liamcpfc92 at 02 Jun 2015 1.51pm

Saw Stephen King's It before i read the book (all 1,000+ pages) and both scared the crap out of me, but both were very good,never been a fan of clowns since though.

The film was great until the very end when Pennywise was revealed in his true form.......a giant plastic spider.

 

Part Time James Flag 02 Jun 15 2.30pm

For me books better than films:
Virtually every Stephen King book (especially Needful Things, Dark Half and Pet Semetary).
I quite liked the Shining but the Kubrick film did miss a lot of important detail and Stephen King hated it.
A Clockwork Orange (the film totally missed the main point of the book).
The Hunger Games. The books are amazing (IMO). The films are almost as good but you're left there wondering what happened to some of the story.

Films better than books:
Trainspotting. I love Irvine Welsh but I thought the film flowed better and made more sense than the book. It was turned more into a storyline by the film. Still a good book though.


 




npn Flag Crowborough 02 Jun 15 2.38pm

Stephen King is a good shout.

The Green Mile was a decent book turned into a great film.

Stand By Me also

 

ghosteagle Flag 02 Jun 15 2.41pm

Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 2.30pm

For me books better than films:
Virtually every Stephen King book (especially Needful Things, Dark Half and Pet Semetary).
I quite liked the Shining but the Kubrick film did miss a lot of important detail and Stephen King hated it.
A Clockwork Orange (the film totally missed the main point of the book).
The Hunger Games. The books are amazing (IMO). The films are almost as good but you're left there wondering what happened to some of the story.

Films better than books:
Trainspotting. I love Irvine Welsh but I thought the film flowed better and made more sense than the book. It was turned more into a storyline by the film. Still a good book though.


I think the missing out of the final chapter was a deliberate attempt to change the tone of the film by Kubrick rather than him missing the point.

 

Part Time James Flag 02 Jun 15 2.51pm

Quote ghosteagle at 02 Jun 2015 2.41pm

Quote Part Time James at 02 Jun 2015 2.30pm

For me books better than films:
Virtually every Stephen King book (especially Needful Things, Dark Half and Pet Semetary).
I quite liked the Shining but the Kubrick film did miss a lot of important detail and Stephen King hated it.
A Clockwork Orange (the film totally missed the main point of the book).
The Hunger Games. The books are amazing (IMO). The films are almost as good but you're left there wondering what happened to some of the story.

Films better than books:
Trainspotting. I love Irvine Welsh but I thought the film flowed better and made more sense than the book. It was turned more into a storyline by the film. Still a good book though.


I think the missing out of the final chapter was a deliberate attempt to change the tone of the film by Kubrick rather than him missing the point.

Interesting. I kind of thought the last chapter of the book was the moral of the story though so I was left a bit cold by the Kubrick ending!

 




The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 02 Jun 15 2.54pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 2.05pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 02 Jun 2015 1.21pm

Quote The Sash at 02 Jun 2015 1.16pm

Quote Dixie Eagle at 02 Jun 2015 1.14pm

I read Peter Benchley's Jaws book many years ago and thought it was really good. There's a lot of factual information in there about the science of sharks, as far as I can recall.

I am stuck on Ellen Brody masturbating in a diner at the moment.



So am I now

Its not as exciting as it sounds SF....imagine female w@nking as written by Barbara Cartland...


Edited by The Sash (02 Jun 2015 1.35pm)


Would


Have

 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Books to Films