|
This thread is about refugees primarily,not economic migrants or "immigrants".Your take on my motivations is, to use your phrase "imaginary",but on your part.
What I mean is that a significant number of those trying to come here or potentially trying to,are refugees,ie those from Syria.But that a significant number of people wishing to come here are not,but are rather economic migrants.I don't propose illegal entry to the UK for economic migrants or wholesale legal entry.I do propose admission to refugees who qualify under the Convention.The refugees tend IMO to get tarred wholesale with being the same as economic migrants and demonised as such.
I think the distinction between the two is more readily definable than Stirling does and certainly not reasonable to describe an alternate view to his as "nonsense".Its a lot more arguable than that.
As Kermit posted earlier,the UN Convention defines a refugee as:
"someone who has been forced to flee his or her country because of persecution, war, or violence. A refugee has a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group. Most likely, they cannot return home or are afraid to do so. War and ethnic, tribal and religious violence are leading causes of refugees fleeing their countries."
Leaving aside questions of making application in the first "safe place" reached (which I agree with) and questions of countries agreeing to share the load from mass fleeings (ie like that from Vietnam after the Vietnam war),refugees should be granted asylum.
When the Iron Curtain was up,there was no hesitation in suggesting people fleeing from Eastern Europe were refugees fleeing persecution on say political grounds.
If you take Syria, we acknowledge the country is in civil war,we acknowledge ISIS are filth who must be opposed and carry out horrendous acts.Seems to me in those circumstances,bit hard to say people fleeing Syria aren't refugees in the same way we've defined refugees for more than 60 years.
As for the link, that related directly to posts in the thread about comparisons with Jewish refugees in the 30's and to Stirling's comment in response to an earlier post that "that does stop them being refugees".I think there are interesting comparisons with how Jewish refugees were regarded in some quarters as ""aliens" who mustn't be allowed to "flood here" rather than the genuine refugees they plainly were.If you or Stirling don't agree,fair enough.
Edited by legaleagle (24 Aug 2015 10.42pm)
|