You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Why are 'refugees' just called 'migrants' now?
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why are 'refugees' just called 'migrants' now?


Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Stirlingsays Flag 24 Aug 15 6.51pm

What we should be doing is moving them all to the socialist republic of Scotland.

I think we would probably see the rise of Scottish Ukip.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

johnfirewall Flag 24 Aug 15 6.54pm

Because they're just people moving from one country to another. Neither side of the political spectrum seem willing to drill down in to the where and why. That would be racial discrimination deciding who you don't want or opening the floodgates deciding who you do.

Edited by johnfirewall (24 Aug 2015 6.58pm)

 

Hoof Hearted 24 Aug 15 6.56pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Aug 2015 6.51pm

What we should be doing is moving them all to the socialist republic of Scotland.

I think we would probably see the rise of Scottish Ukip.


"Bloody A Rabs coming here eating all our deep fried mars bars an drinkin all our Irn Bru!"

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 24 Aug 15 8.24pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 6.32pm

Quote Catfish at 24 Aug 2015 6.00pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm

Quote Jamesrichards8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.33pm

Well, these people, as true 'refugees' wouldn't be allowed to pick and choose which country they seek asylum in. They are in France, and other non-violent countries, yet seek asylum elsewhere. Refugees seek refuge in the first peaceful country they enter.
I've got to get off this site. The liberal bulls*** is doing my head in.
Cue some sarcastic reply applauding my decision to leave. Gee this site has really gotten boring.[/quote


But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants. if you are genuinely fleeing a war or murderous persecution wherever you end up surely you are still a refugee and not a migrant.

It is the manipulation of language that is interesting and our subservience to it.

It is entirely possible that the media are manipulating language but the expressions used officially are based on statute and conventions. Some expressions are used wrongly by the media such as deportation - which has a very precise meaning in law. The expressions such as illegal immigrant have bad connotations because of the way they were used as euphemisms in the 60s. Illegal immigrant is actually a reasonable description of someone who has entered the UK without permission.
What is a poorer use of language is to label someone a refugee without knowing anything about their motives.


I would hope that being a citizen of Aleppo would tell those that can help that that is motive enough. Anyone who is on the receiving end and coming from a severe war-zone is a refugee.

I agree. Anyone fleeing a war zone who fears persecution is a refugee.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

legaleagle Flag 24 Aug 15 8.36pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Aug 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 6.26pm

I meant just in the 1930's and before Poland was invaded. Many Jewish 'refugees' got out and the diaspora went worldwide. My point being of course that just because some chose to go further afield than the nearest safe haven did not stop them being refugees. Any Syrians fleeing IS and murderous persecution by their own government who end up here or in Germany or elsewhere are not 'migrants' however much the media or others with an agenda try to make it so.


It does stop them being refugees.

Unless they have a family or previous connection to a particular country they should be taking the first safe haven.

The use of WW2 as an excuse for moving towards richer northern European countries is patently ridiculous.

Italy or Greece are in absolutely no danger of an fundamentalist Islamic takeover.

The conceit that there is a binary choice between refugee and economic immigrant in many of these situations......is nonsense.



The conceit that many of "these people" are not genuine refugees is also nonsense. Thats far from saying all are.

Very few people now question that Jews seeking to leave Germany in the late 30's were genuine refugees worthy of asylum.Its therefore salutary (and precisely why history is not irrelevant) to look back at the way the "anti-alien" anti-refugee lobby were pitching things back then

See below from the Daily Mail.


[Link]

 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 24 Aug 15 8.40pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 24 Aug 2015 6.50pm

I call them Cuckoos.

Waits for indignant backlash.........


Or agreement, Chris.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Beastie Flag 24 Aug 15 8.45pm

To be honest, I thought the media were trying to be PC by calling them 'migrants' instead of 'immigrants'.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 24 Aug 15 9.28pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 24 Aug 2015 6.50pm

I call them Cuckoos.

Waits for indignant backlash.........


Or for someone to clock you one.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 24 Aug 15 9.30pm

The Vietnamese boat people seem to have been accepted and have integrated ok in many places.

 

SwalecliffeEagle Flag Swalecliffe 24 Aug 15 9.54pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 6.19pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 24 Aug 2015 6.14pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm

But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants.


I'm not sure that taking refuge in Poland or France would have been a good strategy for them.


Quite a few though thought it would be. That didn't work out well for them at all.

I'm currently studying the treatment of enemy aliens during WW2 (internment and all that jazz) for my dissertation. The story of refugees who escaped to France is just terrible. Having made such a dangerous journey, and having once had hope, they often ended back where they came from, or worse. But in the years leading up to WW2 there were decent vetting processes conducted by the various refugee bodies which had sprung up. They testified to the character and integrity of individuals and were responsible for their welfare. We have no such official, semi-official, or voluntary infrastructure to deal with the issues facing us today.

Many have recently contrasted out present hard-nosed attitude with our willingness to take in huge numbers during the refugee crisis of the '30s. Such comparisons are invalid. Where we once had systems of security and sound knowledge of the backgrounds of such people, we now have none. And as it was back then, the trojan horse threat is real. All too real.

 

johnfirewall Flag 24 Aug 15 9.57pm

Quote legaleagle at 24 Aug 2015 8.36pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Aug 2015 6.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 6.26pm

I meant just in the 1930's and before Poland was invaded. Many Jewish 'refugees' got out and the diaspora went worldwide. My point being of course that just because some chose to go further afield than the nearest safe haven did not stop them being refugees. Any Syrians fleeing IS and murderous persecution by their own government who end up here or in Germany or elsewhere are not 'migrants' however much the media or others with an agenda try to make it so.


It does stop them being refugees.

Unless they have a family or previous connection to a particular country they should be taking the first safe haven.

The use of WW2 as an excuse for moving towards richer northern European countries is patently ridiculous.

Italy or Greece are in absolutely no danger of an fundamentalist Islamic takeover.

The conceit that there is a binary choice between refugee and economic immigrant in many of these situations......is nonsense.



The conceit that many of "these people" are not genuine refugees is also nonsense. Thats far from saying all are.

Very few people now question that Jews seeking to leave Germany in the late 30's were genuine refugees worthy of asylum.Its therefore salutary (and precisely why history is not irrelevant) to look back at the way the "anti-alien" anti-refugee lobby were pitching things back then

See below from the Daily Mail.


[Link]


So not all are genuine but not many aren't?

I read that as denial of wanting to let everyone in, while either letting your feelings repeatedly steer your posts in that direction, or getting caught up in imaginary debates with people whom you deem to simply dislike immigrants.

Perhaps I am disproportionately concerned with, for want of a better term 'economic migrants', due to the continuing trend over the last couple of decades, but the country often cited as top of the table for taking migrants has a clear policy of deporting anyone who has fled hardship of a purely financial variety.

I'll leave Stirling to take exception to the article you've used in response to him.

 

legaleagle Flag 24 Aug 15 10.24pm

This thread is about refugees primarily,not economic migrants or "immigrants".Your take on my motivations is, to use your phrase "imaginary",but on your part.

What I mean is that a significant number of those trying to come here or potentially trying to,are refugees,ie those from Syria.But that a significant number of people wishing to come here are not,but are rather economic migrants.I don't propose illegal entry to the UK for economic migrants or wholesale legal entry.I do propose admission to refugees who qualify under the Convention.The refugees tend IMO to get tarred wholesale with being the same as economic migrants and demonised as such.

I think the distinction between the two is more readily definable than Stirling does and certainly not reasonable to describe an alternate view to his as "nonsense".Its a lot more arguable than that.

As Kermit posted earlier,the UN Convention defines a refugee as:

"someone who has been forced to flee his or her country because of persecution, war, or violence. A refugee has a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, nationality, political opinion or membership in a particular social group. Most likely, they cannot return home or are afraid to do so. War and ethnic, tribal and religious violence are leading causes of refugees fleeing their countries."

Leaving aside questions of making application in the first "safe place" reached (which I agree with) and questions of countries agreeing to share the load from mass fleeings (ie like that from Vietnam after the Vietnam war),refugees should be granted asylum.

When the Iron Curtain was up,there was no hesitation in suggesting people fleeing from Eastern Europe were refugees fleeing persecution on say political grounds.

If you take Syria, we acknowledge the country is in civil war,we acknowledge ISIS are filth who must be opposed and carry out horrendous acts.Seems to me in those circumstances,bit hard to say people fleeing Syria aren't refugees in the same way we've defined refugees for more than 60 years.

As for the link, that related directly to posts in the thread about comparisons with Jewish refugees in the 30's and to Stirling's comment in response to an earlier post that "that does stop them being refugees".I think there are interesting comparisons with how Jewish refugees were regarded in some quarters as ""aliens" who mustn't be allowed to "flood here" rather than the genuine refugees they plainly were.If you or Stirling don't agree,fair enough.

Edited by legaleagle (24 Aug 2015 10.42pm)

 

johnfirewall Flag 24 Aug 15 11.01pm

I would have to disagree with Stirling's take on the meaning, as Jews were persecuted beyond Poland and Germany after the WWII, but you're conflating the idea of deemed asylum-worthiness with the varying definitions, one which you've plucked from 80 years ago with connotations bearing no relevance to the attitudes of anyone here.

Overall the term migrant encompasses the number of people however small who aren't seeking refuge.

Edited by johnfirewall (24 Aug 2015 11.02pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 24 Aug 15 11.11pm

Its the UN Convention from 64 years ago, endorsed by a Protocol in 1967.It is the current internationally accepted and signed up to definition and that by which the UK bases determination of applications for asylum,so I'm hardly plucking a random one .I accept completely its connotations may bear no relevance to the attitudes of some on here,it may be the majority on here.They do bear some relevance to some on here.

Edited by legaleagle (24 Aug 2015 11.14pm)

 

legaleagle Flag 24 Aug 15 11.29pm

Its also worth bearing in mind when talking about refugees from Syria,that there is very much a widespread "burden" rather than,as might be thought at times here,they're all heading to the EU or within the EU,the UK.

According the the UNHCR,2.2 million are registered by UNHCR in Egypt, Iraq, Jordan and Lebanon, and 1.8 million Syrians have been registered by the Government of Turkey.

Taking the latest European figures, in 2014 122,115 Syrians applied for aslyum in the EU,of which 2.410 were in the UK.

Edited by legaleagle (24 Aug 2015 11.31pm)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 24 Aug 15 11.54pm

Quote nickgusset at 24 Aug 2015 9.30pm

The Vietnamese boat people seem to have been accepted and have integrated ok in many places.


That's mainly because they have the 'tory' gene and are hard working and have entrepreneurial flair...

 


Pro USA & Israel

legaleagle Flag 25 Aug 15 12.14am

.Only Tories work hard then?

 

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 25 Aug 15 2.50am

Quote SwalecliffeEagle at 24 Aug 2015 9.54pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 6.19pm

Quote Ray in Houston at 24 Aug 2015 6.14pm

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 5.38pm

But Jewish refugees from Nazi Germany in the 1930's went all over and didn't just end up next door in Poland or France and they weren't called migrants.


I'm not sure that taking refuge in Poland or France would have been a good strategy for them.


Quite a few though thought it would be. That didn't work out well for them at all.

I'm currently studying the treatment of enemy aliens during WW2 (internment and all that jazz) for my dissertation. The story of refugees who escaped to France is just terrible. Having made such a dangerous journey, and having once had hope, they often ended back where they came from, or worse. But in the years leading up to WW2 there were decent vetting processes conducted by the various refugee bodies which had sprung up. They testified to the character and integrity of individuals and were responsible for their welfare. We have no such official, semi-official, or voluntary infrastructure to deal with the issues facing us today.

Many have recently contrasted out present hard-nosed attitude with our willingness to take in huge numbers during the refugee crisis of the '30s. Such comparisons are invalid. Where we once had systems of security and sound knowledge of the backgrounds of such people, we now have none. And as it was back then, the trojan horse threat is real. All too real.


The approach in tne30s was possibly unique in that the Home Office effectively devolved the decision making to a consortium of refugee charities. The arrangement was very discreet and allowed a lot of discretion behind the scenes. I am sure you have already discovered them but, just in case, suggest looking up Tony Kushner, Louise London and AJ Sherman.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Aug 15 3.11am

Quote legaleagle at 25 Aug 2015 12.14am

.Only Tories work hard then?

You're on this board all the time Legal.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 25 Aug 15 7.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 24 Aug 2015 4.56pm

It's obvious the Syrians that are fleeing are refugees not migrants yet they don't seem to be allowed that title by the media and we are following their lead by lumping them in with others who are heading to Europe but who are not being persecuted.

Someone somewhere is manipulating emotive language to suit certain agendas. Something is going on.

Remember reading an article last year about a Yale or maybe Harvard grad - can't remember his name annoyingly - in the US who heads up a team who work on a mission to confuse the media and world opinion to such an extent that no one is quite clear about what is really going on anymore.

One of Murdoch's kids by any chance because that's what his family are about.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Page 2 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Why are 'refugees' just called 'migrants' now?