You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour hire Varoufakis as advisor
November 22 2026 1.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour hire Varoufakis as advisor


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Hoof Hearted 01 Mar 16 11.02am

Sorry to have posted so late, but I ruptured my spleen laughing at Gusset's response to this news heralding Varoufakis' appointment as very good.. I'll have to be careful or the stitches will go again.

-.-'

The Greeks are just lazy incompetent and corrupt.... Gusset himself has acknowledged Matt's point about their inept tax collection and ridiculously early state retirement age. It is in their DNA.

They also built an underground system in Athens that commuters largely don't pay fares on when travelling and the cost of building it was paid for by Brussels as a sweetener to join. State of the art stuff with air conditioning and plasma tv screens on board - read all about it here:-

[Link]

This highlights the fundamental flaw in the EU - it is trying to create political and financial union between too many different cultures.

Greece will never be able to be in accord with the UK or Germany's economy and it was a folly to even suggest it, let alone implement it.

Were the Greeks stitched up?

Were they fcuk.

They went into this deal with eyes open and hands ready to clutch all the freebies they thought were coming their way and looked upon the EU as a rich sugar daddy who would always bail them out. The chief architect of this strategy was Varoufakis.

When the sh1t inevitably hit the fan.... quelle surprise... he started playing silly buggers and brinkmanship making matters worse.

They deserve all the financial pain they are getting right now.

As for Labour appointing Varoufakis as an advisor.... mmmmmmm.... not really a shock to anyone as Corbyn is rapidly confirming he is a political fcukwit and seems to be assembling a dream team of advisors (literally!).

Edited by Hoof Hearted (01 Mar 2016 11.02am)

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 01 Mar 16 11.12am

Greece definitely was a stitch up. I can't believe this but I agree with nickgusset. He's very eloquent and convincing with his arguments, even though a lot of the time he's completely wrong. Not to be scoffed at IMO.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

DanH Flag SW2 01 Mar 16 11.15am

Yep, and Varoufakis is very widely respected.

 

Hoof Hearted 01 Mar 16 11.29am

Originally posted by DanH

Yep, and Varoufakis is very widely respected.

Explain why?

I've demonstrated the opposite view with supporting evidence.

Show me what good he has done and why Greece being financially fcuked now isn't in any part down to him even though he was a major player?

 

johnfirewall Flag 01 Mar 16 11.57am

Greek Finance Minister...

You can't give Corbyn credit for sticking to his principles when you're implementing policy proven to fail. He must be a lunatic if he thinks you can actually look after people the way the Greeks did. Perhaps he thinks can resurrect the coal and steel industries to support it. This eccentric idealism is evidence that the he has less of a clue about the economy than previously suspected.

Edited by johnfirewall (01 Mar 2016 12.06pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Mar 16 12.03pm

I think maybe a lot of the Greeks ended up being stitched up, but the country wasn't. It was entirely corrupt in reporting statistics up until around 2010 when the s**t started to get real. People tend to believe governments, even when the deal they offer seems 'remarkable', as they were delivering on this right up until the fan made contact with the s**t.

But the country was spending money that the governments proceeding 2009, must have known they couldn't possibly afford to keep up - I'll imagine that a lot of that money didn't end up in the pockets of the average Greek citizen either.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

DanH Flag SW2 01 Mar 16 12.07pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Explain why?

I've demonstrated the opposite view with supporting evidence.

Show me what good he has done and why Greece being financially fcuked now isn't in any part down to him even though he was a major player?

Well, you haven't really, you've spouted your opinion.

Blaming Varoufakis for Greece's financial plight is like blaming Parish now for us going to administration under Goldberg.

Varoufakis resigned his post when it became clear that the EU weren't going to release their stranglehold on Greece's debt and that his ideas weren't even going to be contemplated. He's had ideas in papers which have been widely supported, not just among the left, in relation to the European debt crisis. It's only EU politicians that have shut down his ideas, not academics, as it relates to restructuring debt in a way which allows a bit of breathing space for future growth.

Trying to discredit him by lumping him in with decades of social and economic mismanagement of Greece just because he was Finance Minister for a couple of months is completely disingenuous.

 

johnfirewall Flag 01 Mar 16 12.14pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think maybe a lot of the Greeks ended up being stitched up, but the country wasn't. It was entirely corrupt in reporting statistics up until around 2010 when the s**t started to get real. People tend to believe governments, even when the deal they offer seems 'remarkable', as they were delivering on this right up until the fan made contact with the s**t.

But the country was spending money that the governments proceeding 2009, must have known they couldn't possibly afford to keep up - I'll imagine that a lot of that money didn't end up in the pockets of the average Greek citizen either.


I'd use the analogy of an employer reporting losses while increasing pay, but it wouldn't happen. That's capitalism.

What can the public do when it's the government paying you?

Some savvy Greeks were probably sceptical and saved their cash, unfortunately that would have sat in Greek banks.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 01 Mar 16 12.29pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


You are right about tax collection, however...
Being forced to give away public assets as part of a bail out at interest rates that prohibit the debt being paid off. Not a stitch up?
People living in poverty as a result and no support - Not a stitch up?
Being told on top of this they have to deal with an influx of people being driven out of their own countries with little support and having borders closed all around them whilst many countries wash their hands of any help or shared responsibility not a stitch up?

Wow just wow, two pages and you managed to get refugees into the mix.

And how can you dismiss tax collection, it is the mainstay of governments coffers, and the money they were borrowing instead of getting it off their own people came back to bite them in the ass.

Have a quick hope across the med to Greece now and see how its working out for them now.

Greece were masters of thier own downfall. The fact that Corbyn obvioulsy loves this bloke should come of no surprise, who's next I wonder a quick sauna with Mao Tse tung to discuss the peoples Army ?

Give it a rest corbyn and his cohort (including the racist pig Abbott) are about as electable as fly covered dog egg. And whats more you know it.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

matt_himself Flag Matataland 01 Mar 16 12.46pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


You are right about tax collection, however...
Being forced to give away public assets as part of a bail out at interest rates that prohibit the debt being paid off. Not a stitch up?
People living in poverty as a result and no support - Not a stitch up?
Being told on top of this they have to deal with an influx of people being driven out of their own countries with little support and having borders closed all around them whilst many countries wash their hands of any help or shared responsibility not a stitch up?

The last two items are emotive nonsense and I struggle to understand how they are related to the Greek bailout per se, as they are throwaway lines.

The fact is that the Greeks and the EU systematically lied and/or accepted lies that allowed the Greeks to join the EU.

The resulting chaos is their fault. I don't understand how you cannot see this. This is not some imperial takeover, it is the result of spendthrift governance, corrupt governance and ineffective governance.

Being asked to privatise property to us as collateral for bailout loans seems fine. If you buy a house or flat you leave a deposit, why shouldn't it be the same with bankrupt governments?

If I was a lender, given Greece's history, I would want collateral.

Finally, unless you can explain yourself more, one cannot feel the breath of the unreconstructed leftie wafting through your position. It doesn't matter that the Greeks spent like kings and earned like paupers, what really matters is bashing the bankers & investors who bail them out. And you want a bailout with no consequences for the Greeks! How is that beneficial for the Greeks, tax payers in other EU countries and the EU project at large?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Hoof Hearted 01 Mar 16 1.16pm

Originally posted by DanH

Well, you haven't really, you've spouted your opinion.

Blaming Varoufakis for Greece's financial plight is like blaming Parish now for us going to administration under Goldberg.

Varoufakis resigned his post when it became clear that the EU weren't going to release their stranglehold on Greece's debt and that his ideas weren't even going to be contemplated. He's had ideas in papers which have been widely supported, not just among the left, in relation to the European debt crisis. It's only EU politicians that have shut down his ideas, not academics, as it relates to restructuring debt in a way which allows a bit of breathing space for future growth.

Trying to discredit him by lumping him in with decades of social and economic mismanagement of Greece just because he was Finance Minister for a couple of months is completely disingenuous.

disingenuous - get you all grown up with your fancy words.

He wasn't just a minister for a few months, he had been an adviser to a previous minister.

His CV looks like a person who flounces around with his airy fairy ideology and gets out before the sh1t hits the fan.

Economics is an area where too many variables come into play and chancers like him have excuses to make about why their original forecasts don't bear fruit.

Like it or not he is tainted by the Greek financial collapse.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 01 Mar 16 2.47pm

Originally posted by DanH

Well, you haven't really, you've spouted your opinion.

Blaming Varoufakis for Greece's financial plight is like blaming Parish now for us going to administration under Goldberg.

Varoufakis resigned his post when it became clear that the EU weren't going to release their stranglehold on Greece's debt and that his ideas weren't even going to be contemplated. He's had ideas in papers which have been widely supported, not just among the left, in relation to the European debt crisis. It's only EU politicians that have shut down his ideas, not academics, as it relates to restructuring debt in a way which allows a bit of breathing space for future growth.

Trying to discredit him by lumping him in with decades of social and economic mismanagement of Greece just because he was Finance Minister for a couple of months is completely disingenuous.

Varoufakis wasn't responsible for Greece's problems but he did exacerbate them with his naive game of chicken.

You and nick seem to entirely blame the EU for f***ing over Greece yet you, presumably, want us to stay in this club that f***s over it's members?

 


Optimistic as ever

DanH Flag SW2 01 Mar 16 3.57pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Varoufakis wasn't responsible for Greece's problems but he did exacerbate them with his naive game of chicken.

You and nick seem to entirely blame the EU for f***ing over Greece yet you, presumably, want us to stay in this club that f***s over it's members?


Not really. I'm still very undecided.

I don't blame the EU for the problems, they were very much instigated in Greece, but the EU have done as much (or little) as the Greek people to resolve the problems.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 01 Mar 16 3.59pm

Originally posted by DanH


Not really. I'm still very undecided.

I don't blame the EU for the problems, they were very much instigated in Greece, but the EU have done as much (or little) as the Greek people to resolve the problems.

Fair enough. Put that in your "cons" list.

f*** over it's own members.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Mar 16 4.12pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall


I'd use the analogy of an employer reporting losses while increasing pay, but it wouldn't happen. That's capitalism.

What can the public do when it's the government paying you?

Some savvy Greeks were probably sceptical and saved their cash, unfortunately that would have sat in Greek banks.

Plenty of companies offer incentives that turn out to be unachievable, and are withdrawn - such as final salary pensions.

Thing about Greece, is that money wasn't just going to the people. 45% of the Greeks insane defence spending went to the US. Goldman Sachs was involved in essentially defrauding the EU and Greek people and facilitating the capacity of the Greek Government to meet Monetary Union requirements. I suspect that a lot of that deficit ended up going into private hands, and interests.

Greek Nationals currently hold as much 20bn in evaded tax sitting in Swiss bank accounts which the country argues is the 'under reported tax'.

There is a point where mismanagement is actually fraud.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (01 Mar 2016 4.36pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 01 Mar 16 4.16pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


You are right about tax collection, however...
Being forced to give away public assets as part of a bail out at interest rates that prohibit the debt being paid off. Not a stitch up?
People living in poverty as a result and no support - Not a stitch up?
Being told on top of this they have to deal with an influx of people being driven out of their own countries with little support and having borders closed all around them whilst many countries wash their hands of any help or shared responsibility not a stitch up?

This is untrue - Greece is paying less than 3%, less than Spain, Ireland and Portugal. Given the amount that has already been written off by Sovereign lenders and bond holders, I'd say anything but a stitch up.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Mar 16 4.16pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Varoufakis wasn't responsible for Greece's problems but he did exacerbate them with his naive game of chicken.

You and nick seem to entirely blame the EU for f***ing over Greece yet you, presumably, want us to stay in this club that f***s over it's members?

In fairness to Varoufakis, there wasn't really much to lose, the economy was as f**ked as f**ked gets. It always seemed like a Hail Mary.

Its not the EU's fault that Greece defaulted on its debt payments. They presented fraudulent evidence of their qualification year on year, and paid commercial interests to help them achieve that fraud (allegedly Goldman Sachs).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stuk Flag Top half 01 Mar 16 4.17pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

In fairness to Varoufakis, there wasn't really much to lose, the economy was as f**ked as f**ked gets. It always seemed like a Hail Mary.

Its not the EU's fault that Greece defaulted on its debt payments. They presented fraudulent evidence of their qualification year on year, and paid commercial interests to help them achieve that fraud (allegedly Goldman Sachs).

And the EU let them because they wanted and needed more members, and they still do.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 01 Mar 16 4.28pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Varoufakis wasn't responsible for Greece's problems but he did exacerbate them with his naive game of chicken.

You and nick seem to entirely blame the EU for f***ing over Greece yet you, presumably, want us to stay in this club that f***s over it's members?

Presumably? There you go, projecting your own ideas on what I think again.

I'm actually torn on the referendum.

Varoufakis is one of the most respected economists in the world, yet because he is anti-austerity he's dismissed by people who more than likely haven't even read any of his work.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 01 Mar 16 4.33pm

Originally posted by chris123

This is untrue - Greece is paying less than 3%, less than Spain, Ireland and Portugal. Given the amount that has already been written off by Sovereign lenders and bond holders, I'd say anything but a stitch up.

Forced to sell of public assets and infrastructure in the name of neoliberalism. Most definitely a stitch up.

Still banks can be bailed out and not allowed to fail. That's a stitch up too.

Yes the pre Syriza government failed, the rich hid their assets (there was a program about Greece on BBC2 a couple of weeks ago that covered this - I suggest people actually find out a little bit about what happened before jumping to conclusions) now ordinary people are suffering because of it.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour hire Varoufakis as advisor