You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alan Shearer new Englan manager
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alan Shearer new Englan manager


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Pussay Patrol Flag 05 Jul 16 9.58pm

Originally posted by OknotOK

I'm going to defend Shearer here....


... I think he has been a relatively entertaining pundit for the Euros. If only purely because he has deliberately set out to be a harsh critic of the England team.

But fcuk me I would not want him as England manager. A guy with a win ratio of 12.5% and 8 games experience as a manager should not be being offered the nominally biggest role in British football.

that's defending him?

I don't see why you need to be experienced, the last 2 managers had experience coming out of their ears, didn't count for s***

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 06 Jul 16 12.10pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

that's defending him?

I don't see why you need to be experienced, the last 2 managers had experience coming out of their ears, didn't count for s***

I was defending him as a pundit only.

Selecting the wrong candidates from a pool doesn't mean that selecting someone with experience is the right thing.

Being a good player does not make you a good manager or coach. Shearer has none of the relevant coaching badges, extremely limited experience, and his record from said limited experience is woeful.

There is nothing to suggest he would be a successful manager for England.

Was a good player though.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 06 Jul 16 4.57pm

Alan Shearer has been s*** at everything for 10 years now. Don't let the memories of of Euro '96 cloud your judgement. If you gave Shearer a task, he would probably be s*** at it.

That said, he's still less s*** than Mark Lawrenson. Lawrenson has been s*** at everything since 1991.

Although neither are as s*** as Steve Claridge. Steve Claridge has been s*** for half a century. Even his mum thought he was s***. In his auto biography, there's a chapter about his mum on her death bed, and her last words were "Steven, bloody hell, look at you. Go and brush your hair, you bloody s***."

True story.

 

chateauferret Flag 06 Jul 16 11.28pm

On the matter of sh!te pundits did anyone else hear the wallies on TalkSh!te this morning singing the praises of Clattenburg as though the sun shone out of his arse and there were no finer referee on the planet. "Completely professional, of course he would put self interest to one side when he was reffing the Wales game this evening".

Except he wasn't...

 


============
The Ferret
============

richard shaw (og)65 Flag my minds eye 07 Jul 16 8.13am

Originally posted by chateauferret

On the matter of sh!te pundits did anyone else hear the wallies on TalkSh!te this morning singing the praises of Clattenburg as though the sun shone out of his arse and there were no finer referee on the planet. "Completely professional, of course he would put self interest to one side when he was reffing the Wales game this evening".

Except he wasn't...

not wanting to come over all willo but did you hear on the commentary that the ref last night is a multi millionaire , just refs for the fun of it

 


interviewer " iggy , do you think you influenced anybody?"
iggy pop " I think I wiped out the 60`S "

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 07 Jul 16 8.21am

By that logic (ie, you need passion, not experience) then it should be Gary Neville, not Shearer. Shearer's got about as much passion as a wet Wednesday in Wigan.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 07 Jul 16 9.22am

Originally posted by Johnny Eagles

By that logic (ie, you need passion, not experience) then it should be Gary Neville, not Shearer. Shearer's got about as much passion as a wet Wednesday in Wigan.

His stock has dropped. Not sure who's better though. Would be interesting to see how the FA view the rumours he was disagreeing with Hodgson's decisions during the tournament.

However....

I read the original article in the Guardian, now when searching for it, the results bring this up..


England's Euro 2016 undermined by friction between Roy Hodgson ...
[Link] › Soccer › Roy Hodgson
4 days ago - This article is the subject of a legal complaint made on behalf of Gary Neville. England’s Euro 2016 campaign was undermined by a deterioration in the working relationship between Roy Hodgson and Gary Neville and a series of disagreements among the coaching staff, the Observer ...

So either the story was false, or Neville recognises the damage it may have to his reputation and is going on the front foot.

[Link]

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 07 Jul 16 9.31am

Given the terrible choice of candidates, my personal preference would be Arsene Wenger.

Experienced, talented, good with young players and about as 'English' as you can get if you're going to get a foreigner.

Might also suit Arsenal to get rid by having him poached by a non-rival.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

A_89_M Flag Streatham 07 Jul 16 10.07am

We’ve just gone from a manager with no tactical nous and now some are saying Shearer or Neville just because they’re passionate, it’s such an out dated logic. Stuart Pearce had plenty of passion but couldn’t even cut it at U21 level for England why would the above two be any different at senior level? Yes we need passion in our managers, not a soulless dictator like Capello but we need someone with tactical knowledge as well, someone who can get the players to understand and enjoy the tactical side and implement it in a game with confidence.

It’s Glen Hoddle for me, he talks so well in interviews and as a commentator and he actually played a 3-5-2 system that worked (almost) for England on the big stage.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 07 Jul 16 12.42pm

Originally posted by A_89_M

We’ve just gone from a manager with no tactical nous and now some are saying Shearer or Neville just because they’re passionate, it’s such an out dated logic.

I was saying that *if* you think passion is a selection criterium (I don't) then you'd be barking up the wrong tree with Shearer.

I was *not* saying Neville should get the job!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 07 Jul 16 1.16pm

The Players are not good enough.
And at the end of a Season, we are no good in Knock Out Tournament Football.
So unfortunately you youngsters will never see England win anything.
So anyone can be the Manager as far as I'm concerned.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

crvenaeagle Flag 11 Jul 16 6.47am

State of Origin is very different to the football World Cup man.

As for your estimation on how many people would say "f*** off" to Southgate, I think you're a little off the mark.

Now for Shearer. I know it's not on TV here but do you ever watch Match of the Day? Shearers post match commentary never really extends beyond "at the end of the day if you don't get the ball in the net, you don't score goals" and other such pearls of wisdom. These errrr 'classic' one liners are not the sort of thing that will take the England team further than they curently are.
He was hired for a managerial job once before simply based on his status, at Newcastle, and they plummeted. Right down into the next division in fact. The man coudln't manage a [insert cliché] at a [insert relatable cliché].

 

blackpalacefan Flag 11 Jul 16 7.15am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

The Players are not good enough.
And at the end of a Season, we are no good in Knock Out Tournament Football.
So unfortunately you youngsters will never see England win anything.
So anyone can be the Manager as far as I'm concerned.

You're probably not far off the mark. We need a miracle worker not a manager.

 

2095 Flag Manly 11 Jul 16 7.17am

I would have thought that 'get the ball in the back of the net'is fairly sound tactics. Roy obviously forgot to say it

 

blackpalacefan Flag 11 Jul 16 8.23am

Originally posted by 2095

I would have thought that 'get the ball in the back of the net'is fairly sound tactics. Roy obviously forgot to say it

Woy never looked up to the task.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 11 Jul 16 9.05am

I'd love Neil Warnock. We might still be s*** but we'd play with passion, excitement and would love to see the foreign managers and players reactions to him. It'd be great fun

 

Pussay Patrol Flag 11 Jul 16 9.58am

the players are good enough.

Portugal just won a tournament with a team that has Nani, Ricardo Carvalho - and Eder who scored the winner was a flop in the premiership

They didn't win cos they had superior players, they had team spirit and a game plan

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

miles18 Flag Telford 11 Jul 16 10.25am

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

the players are good enough.

Portugal just won a tournament with a team that has Nani, Ricardo Carvalho - and Eder who scored the winner was a flop in the premiership

They didn't win cos they had superior players, they had team spirit and a game plan

They won one game in 90 mins and finished third behind Hungary and Iceland.

They played much better without Ronaldo in the final as it wasn't Ronaldo FC anymore.

England won't win anything no matter who the manager is. Players just don't give a s***.

Also when players who hardly play all season and who are out of form get picked, I'm not surprised we don't do anything.

 



.

crvenaeagle Flag 12 Jul 16 5.06am

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

I'd love Neil Warnock. We might still be s*** but we'd play with passion, excitement and would love to see the foreign managers and players reactions to him. It'd be great fun

Oooo eeee, well we might notta won anything but A've 'ad a lovely time and ai think the lads did too, it's a real treat, not been t'Russia before me! Crackin' match fer t'neutrels weren'tet?

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 12 Jul 16 5.16am

Followed by that statement, - this is definitely the last job for me ........

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alan Shearer new Englan manager