You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew Out. Why did we sell Gayle?
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardew Out. Why did we sell Gayle?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Woolsy Flag Essex 19 Oct 16 12.52pm

Scoring in the Championship, doesn't make a Premiership player. Hence the last 3 seasons top goalscorers.

2015-2016 - Andy Gray - 25 goals (this season 1)
2014-2015 - Daryl Murphy - 27 goals (still playing championship football)
2013-2014 - Ross McCormack - 28 goals (still playing championship football)

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 19 Oct 16 12.53pm

Originally posted by paperhat

What division does Gayle now play in??

What division does Wickham play in??

oh, I see....do you??

I always wanted to see both of them do well in Palace shirts but, with all due respect, Wickham doesn't seem to be up to the job and may find himself in the Championship sooner rather than later.

Gayle was never going to cut it as the "Lone Striker" but he definitely had an eye for goal.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

South Devon Eagle Flag Newton Abbot 19 Oct 16 1.10pm

Originally posted by Woolsy

Scoring in the Championship, doesn't make a Premiership player. Hence the last 3 seasons top goalscorers.

2015-2016 - Andy Gray - 25 goals (this season 1)
2014-2015 - Daryl Murphy - 27 goals (still playing championship football)
2013-2014 - Ross McCormack - 28 goals (still playing championship football)

Jordan Rhodes
Cameron Jerome

 


SUPPORTING PALACE SINCE 1986

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 19 Oct 16 1.51pm

All of the people on here now slagging off Gayle sound like my Chelsea supporting colleague at work.

When they sold Mata to Manure he said that he was 'shyte anyway'. The same applied when David Luiz went to PSG, but now he's back 'he's improved no-end'.

Pah.

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 19 Oct 16 2.02pm

Originally posted by South Devon Eagle

Jordan Rhodes
Cameron Jerome

Add Gestede to that list

 

Palace_Jack Flag Croydon 19 Oct 16 2.04pm

God this is tedious

As someone said, he failed to impress a number of managers at this level and whenever he did start, he normally got subbed because he wasn't half as effective from kick-off as he was as a sub.

Yes he's killing it this season but he's playing in the strongest team in the league, by quite a distance. Also, sometimes it's better to take a step back, to take a step forward. He should become a better player and be more effective in the Prem' next year as a result of this season.

That doesn't mean we were wrong to sell him. £10m for a player who hadn't kicked on was a cracking deal.

If you still think we were wrong to sell 30yr old, ACL recover'ie Murray, you're beyond help.

 

Username Flag Horsham 19 Oct 16 2.26pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

I always wanted to see both of them do well in Palace shirts but, with all due respect, Wickham doesn't seem to be up to the job and may find himself in the Championship sooner rather than later.

Gayle was never going to cut it as the "Lone Striker" but he definitely had an eye for goal.

Wickham has had more impactful performances for Palace than Gayle. Without Wickham up front last year we really struggled and when he got a run of games he showed he can do it. I'm not suggesting he should replace Benteke, but from what I've seen he's more useful to us than Gayle was as he fills a key position and, even if he doesn't score, he is involved in the game.

He's also still only 23.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 19 Oct 16 2.41pm

He's a top class forward when playing in a team that dominates possession and the pitch. Get the ball to him in and around the box with his face to goal and he'll score a hat full. Palace played on the break with little last third possession, so not his game.

I have a £10 at 9/1 for top scorer

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Part Time James Flag 19 Oct 16 3.05pm

Originally posted by Palace_Jack

God this is tedious

As someone said, he failed to impress a number of managers at this level and whenever he did start, he normally got subbed because he wasn't half as effective from kick-off as he was as a sub.

Yes he's killing it this season but he's playing in the strongest team in the league, by quite a distance. Also, sometimes it's better to take a step back, to take a step forward. He should become a better player and be more effective in the Prem' next year as a result of this season.

That doesn't mean we were wrong to sell him. £10m for a player who hadn't kicked on was a cracking deal.

If you still think we were wrong to sell 30yr old, ACL recover'ie Murray, you're beyond help.

I agree.

I am putting my tin hat on, but I think we were more than adequately compensated for Bolasie, Gayle, Jedinak and Murray. If they are worth more than we sold them for to their new clubs then so be it, but we've gone from being a club that used to let all our players through the revolving door on free transfers to a club that is selling our players for very acceptable prices.

 




bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 19 Oct 16 3.23pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I am putting my tin hat on, but I think we were more than adequately compensated for Bolasie, Gayle, Jedinak and Murray. If they are worth more than we sold them for to their new clubs then so be it, but we've gone from being a club that used to let all our players through the revolving door on free transfers to a club that is selling our players for very acceptable prices.


Exactly! And I'd add improving the team in the process.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Part Time James Flag 19 Oct 16 3.25pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


Exactly! And I'd add improving the team in the process.

I almost added that. When you think of the players we've brought in and their net cost we've done ok I'd say. And I am including Cabaye and Wickham in that statement, who may not have set the world alight yet at Palace, but are a marked improvement on some of the personnel we've previously had to call upon.

 




NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Oct 16 3.36pm

A better question would have been '' why did we sign Gayle ? ''

We didn't try very hard to get the best out of him, only persisted with trying to turn him into something he isn't.

I was never a huge fan of his, but there is a lot of people that thought he could be effective with a target man alongside...unfortunately none of them were Palace managers !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Part Time James Flag 19 Oct 16 3.38pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

A better question would have been '' why did we sign Gayle ? ''

We didn't try very hard to get the best out of him, only persisted with trying to turn him into something he isn't.

I was never a huge fan of his, but there is a lot of people that thought he could be effective with a target man alongside...unfortunately none of them were Palace managers !

My only guess (and it is a guess) was that we were expecting to play a different formation than we ended up with. Similarly I often wondered why we'd signed Bannan and Guedioura. They seemed decent players but not really suited to the system.

 




Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Oct 16 5.31pm

Originally posted by Part Time James


Similarly I often wondered why we'd signed Bannan and Guedioura. They seemed decent players but not really suited to the system.

Weren't they part of Ian Holloway's efforts to buy up every available player?

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 19 Oct 16 6.13pm

Originally posted by Palace_Jack

God this is tedious

As someone said, he failed to impress a number of managers at this level and whenever he did start, he normally got subbed because he wasn't half as effective from kick-off as he was as a sub.

Yes he's killing it this season but he's playing in the strongest team in the league, by quite a distance. Also, sometimes it's better to take a step back, to take a step forward. He should become a better player and be more effective in the Prem' next year as a result of this season.

That doesn't mean we were wrong to sell him. £10m for a player who hadn't kicked on was a cracking deal.

If you still think we were wrong to sell 30yr old, ACL recover'ie Murray, you're beyond help.


Even Pardew-adoring Steve Parish has confessed letting Murray go when we did was a terrible decision.

 

jeeagles Flag 19 Oct 16 6.26pm

The top 5 scorers in the Championship currently include 3 former palace players.

I'd take Benteke and Townsend over Gayle and Bolassi any day of the week.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 19 Oct 16 6.34pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

The top 5 scorers in the Championship currently include 3 former palace players.

I'd take Benteke and Townsend over Gayle and Bolassi any day of the week.

agree.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 19 Oct 16 7.03pm

Since when 23 is young for a football player? If he was in his teens it might be apprpriate but 23 is the early prime age. I hope I'm wrong but I don't think he cuts it at mid table PL level.

Originally posted by Username

Wickham has had more impactful performances for Palace than Gayle. Without Wickham up front last year we really struggled and when he got a run of games he showed he can do it. I'm not suggesting he should replace Benteke, but from what I've seen he's more useful to us than Gayle was as he fills a key position and, even if he doesn't score, he is involved in the game.

He's also still only 23.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 19 Oct 16 7.24pm

It depends on the position and type of player. For a big striker that will never really rely on speed 23 is young. As the tactical mouse of a player grows with the ability to buy free Kicks and play smart the player improves. It's clear with Players like Murray whose careers take off when they hit 28/9 and have that skill. Wickham is the sort of player who could potentially have a breakthrough and become a real handful. I'd like to see how he looks with the team playing well and getting balls in to him. I don't think he has had that yet and I reckon Benteke would have struggled last season for us as well. Benteke is fast approaching 5 yellow cards and hopefully that will coincide with a good game for us that we are in form for.

 

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 19 Oct 16 8.43pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Gayle had three years and three managers to impress enough to pick him every week. He failed.

Scoring two against Brentford today? Well in that case we should bid £20mill for him in January.

He's a very decent second level footballer. If Newcastle get promoted he won't last very long.


The correct answer. Now can we please move on & quit crying about Murray & Gayle finding the net against lesser teams


Edited by thechaddyboy (19 Oct 2016 8.43pm)

 


Red & Blue since 73'

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardew Out. Why did we sell Gayle?