This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Sedlescombe
They were done under discrimination legislation because that was the legislation they were in breach of, which seems appropriate. It is an interesting point if a straight couple going into the same shop would have been prosecuted in the same way - and I don't know the law well enough to answer that. That part was simply to write off Jamie's assertions that they'd broken their contract with the client as irrelevant. Interestingly, it made me think, so I did a quick Google search and there are quite a number of pages and Facebook groups etc. of homosexuals who oppose gay marriage. I wonder what would have happened if on of those people had been the baker and refused the cake order?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
That the service it provides to the public is fair and within the law. This means that it must abide by UK trading laws, without exception.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by carlonoil
So you can go into a Jewish owned bakery and say you want a cake with "the Holocaust was a lie" on it? Well the first would be illegal, as its directly anti-semetic and racist. The second could be refused on the basis that its promotion of a criminal act, but the third maybe - but hypothetically yes, provided they're a bakery, rather than a say a Jewish Bakery. A Jewish Bakery is different, in law, than a bakery that is owned by, or employs some, people who are Jewish - If you had a specific religious business - that clearly identified itself as such, then you might have a case. Even if they were a Christian Bakery, it would be problematic, possibly, as marriage is NOT a state of Christianity, but a state of in law, that can also have a Christian ceremony - Marriage is defined by law not religious views upon marriage - and as such is secular.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by npn
That part was simply to write off Jamie's assertions that they'd broken their contract with the client as irrelevant. Interestingly, it made me think, so I did a quick Google search and there are quite a number of pages and Facebook groups etc. of homosexuals who oppose gay marriage. I wonder what would have happened if on of those people had been the baker and refused the cake order? It depends on whether it was because they were gay. But the same law applies.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well the first would be illegal, as its directly anti-semetic and racist. The second could be refused on the basis that its promotion of a criminal act, but the third maybe - but hypothetically yes, provided they're a bakery, rather than a say a Jewish Bakery. A Jewish Bakery is different, in law, than a bakery that is owned by, or employs some, people who are Jewish - If you had a specific religious business - that clearly identified itself as such, then you might have a case. Even if they were a Christian Bakery, it would be problematic, possibly, as marriage is NOT a state of Christianity, but a state of in law, that can also have a Christian ceremony - Marriage is defined by law not religious views upon marriage - and as such is secular. which was exactly the case here. The cake in question was supporting gay marriage which is still illegal over there, so advocating a change in the law to make something legal, just as the example above is. Whether it should be illegal is clearly a totally different debate - the fact is that it currently is
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
It depends on whether it was because they were gay. But the same law applies. But this cake was not refused because the customer was gay - if I remember the case correctly, the order was taken by a junior member of staff, and it was only later, when the owners got it, that they said no. They never actually met the client until it all blew up (again, if my memory is right) which is why I say they would have rejected the order if the client had been straight or gay, as it was the message they objected to, not necessarily the person requesting it.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by npn
I guess the obvious example would be to go into a gay bakery in England and request a cake with "make gay marriage illegal". They both request a change to existing laws in their respective countries, and both would be unpalatable to the proprietors regardless of the sexuality of the person making the order. My point has always been that the sexuality of the people requesting the cake was completely irrelevant - if I'd asked for the same cake (as a straight bloke) they wouldn't have liked it either, so nobody was discriminated against. Jamie's point on contract law may have had some bearing, if the bakery was sued for breach of contract, but they weren't. They were done under discrimination legislation, which just seems plain wrong. Incidentally, I have no problem with gay marriage - you could marry a horse for all the difference it makes to me! Its important, because it establishes that there were no such clear policies or statements in effect. It establishes, that the owner, who took payment for the order, clearly was only later troubled by the idea. Had a policy existed and been in place for the business, they would clearly have not taken such an order. Its important because it shows discrimination, rather than refusal to accept business (You don't have to trade with people as a business). Basically, its a silly case, in which some uptight homophobes tried to use religious expression as a defence for being homophobes, and lost, and its being re-structured as a 'Human Rights issue' in an area where human rights legislation is not applicable.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by npn
But this cake was not refused because the customer was gay - if I remember the case correctly, the order was taken by a junior member of staff, and it was only later, when the owners got it, that they said no. They never actually met the client until it all blew up (again, if my memory is right) which is why I say they would have rejected the order if the client had been straight or gay, as it was the message they objected to, not necessarily the person requesting it. That was their defence, however gay and gay issues are interchangeable in law. Their staff clearly had never been told of their business policy - neither was this clearly displayed or reasonable to deduce from the premesis. And I'm pretty sure the order was taken by one of the owners. As such, it was discrimination on the basis of sexuality (it doesn't have to be the individuals sexuality - it would be just the same if the individual was straight).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its important, because it establishes that there were no such clear policies or statements in effect. It establishes, that the owner, who took payment for the order, clearly was only later troubled by the idea. Had a policy existed and been in place for the business, they would clearly have not taken such an order. Its important because it shows discrimination, rather than refusal to accept business (You don't have to trade with people as a business). Basically, its a silly case, in which some uptight homophobes tried to use religious expression as a defence for being homophobes, and lost, and its being re-structured as a 'Human Rights issue' in an area where human rights legislation is not applicable. IIRC the order was taken by a junior, not the owners, and they rejected it when they saw the message. I doubt there was a policy in place, but if there was, it was probably a vague one along the lines of "distasteful or offensive messages" - of course, what that constitutes differs from person to person (hence the junior staff member not deeming it a dodgy order, but the owners overruling). Unless you list the things you won't do, you're wide open in that case, and you can't list what you won't do because you'll never second guess all the crazies and people with warped senses of humour there may be. All you could do is say "we reserve the right to refuse orders" and, as you said earlier, because this happened some time later, it's quite right and proper that the client may have recourse through contract law to claim back any losses or inconvenience which may have been caused by having to get the cake made elsewhere, after thinking the order was done
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by npn
which was exactly the case here. The cake in question was supporting gay marriage which is still illegal over there, so advocating a change in the law to make something legal, just as the example above is. Whether it should be illegal is clearly a totally different debate - the fact is that it currently is Gay marriage wasn't /isn't illegal over there. Its not on the statue of laws, but its not a crime either - its recognised as a lawful state of marriage. Whilst you can't get married as a same sex couple in Northern Ireland - people who are married elsewhere still have legal status - and have not committed a crime by being married. Also I believe civil partnerships were legal. As such, its in support of a lawful petition for change, not a crime under UK law.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Gay marriage wasn't /isn't illegal over there. Its not on the statue of laws, but its not a crime either - its recognised as a lawful state of marriage. Whilst you can't get married as a same sex couple in Northern Ireland - people who are married elsewhere still have legal status - and have not committed a crime by being married. Also I believe civil partnerships were legal. As such, its in support of a lawful petition for change, not a crime under UK law. That's a fairly hazy distinction in semantics, but I don't want to get caught up in it. The fact that the law does not allow you to marry over there, by this argument, makes the law itself at odds with this very same legislation, surely? Why are there not mass lawsuits against the government for discrimination? I've just had a very quick look back at the original case, BTW, and it doesn't say who took the order, only that it was declined 48 hours later. I can't assert either way, but it also says they employ 80 people, so that may make it less likely that the order was taken by an owner (or not)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well the first would be illegal, as its directly anti-semetic and racist. The second could be refused on the basis that its promotion of a criminal act, but the third maybe - but hypothetically yes, provided they're a bakery, rather than a say a Jewish Bakery. A Jewish Bakery is different, in law, than a bakery that is owned by, or employs some, people who are Jewish - If you had a specific religious business - that clearly identified itself as such, then you might have a case. Even if they were a Christian Bakery, it would be problematic, possibly, as marriage is NOT a state of Christianity, but a state of in law, that can also have a Christian ceremony - Marriage is defined by law not religious views upon marriage - and as such is secular. Which is quite ironic, given that up until the 1850's you could ONLY get married in a church - there was no 'civil' mechanism for marriage. So in fact, marriage is much more of the 'church' than of the 'law'.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers |
|
| carlonoil |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Gay marriage wasn't /isn't illegal over there. Its not on the statue of laws, but its not a crime either - its recognised as a lawful state of marriage. Whilst you can't get married as a same sex couple in Northern Ireland - people who are married elsewhere still have legal status - and have not committed a crime by being married. Also I believe civil partnerships were legal. As such, its in support of a lawful petition for change, not a crime under UK law. So why did you say that my hypothetical slogan of "support lowering the age of consent to 10" could be refused on the basis that it's promotion of a criminal act.
|
|
| bubble wrap |
|
|---|---|
|
Gay cakes?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by becky
Which is quite ironic, given that up until the 1850's you could ONLY get married in a church - there was no 'civil' mechanism for marriage. So in fact, marriage is much more of the 'church' than of the 'law'. Yeah but that's 160 odd years ago... Interestingly there is no explicit law other than precedent that prohibited gay marriage until I think the 1960s...
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
Why are gayers so f**king touchy about literally everything. You like dick we get it. now shut up and if you don't want to be treated differently, come and join the rest of the down trowden and stop being so fcking precious about everything. Are they though. His rights were denied, he goes to court, wins, and then wins the appeal. It doesn't really seem to be gay people that are making a big issue about it. I think there are a lot more people being 'precious' about homosexuals having the same rights as other people, than there are homosexuals demanding special privilege.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Are they though. His rights were denied, he goes to court, wins, and then wins the appeal. It doesn't really seem to be gay people that are making a big issue about it. I think there are a lot more people being 'precious' about homosexuals having the same rights as other people, than there are homosexuals demanding special privilege. I was going to say something about you obviously have never been to gay bar, but we all know that would be a lie. You know what I mean jamie, I've got gay mates in the Army and fcuk me (not literally) do they go on and on about it. It's like they are some kind of special off shoot of the human race that are entitled to bitch an moan about everything. Look I agree, that the cake owner was being a dick, but I also see a slippery slope of enforcement on business to accommodate a customer base they don't want to encourage. What happended to free choice, you can't just cherry pick which choices are free and which are not.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by npn
That's a fairly hazy distinction in semantics, but I don't want to get caught up in it. The fact that the law does not allow you to marry over there, by this argument, makes the law itself at odds with this very same legislation, surely? Why are there not mass lawsuits against the government for discrimination? No, because the Discrimination Act is about discrimination on issues of sexuality, gender, race and religion, and the owners discriminated on a basis of sexuality and then claimed they were protected by religious freedom of expression - However that doesn't apply to business responsibilities. As such, individual rights to freedom of expression and speech aren't covered, as the owners individual rights were not involved or at least did not trump legislation around business trading laws. Originally posted by npn
I've just had a very quick look back at the original case, BTW, and it doesn't say who took the order, only that it was declined 48 hours later. I can't assert either way, but it also says they employ 80 people, so that may make it less likely that the order was taken by an owner (or not) Does it matter who took the order. Owner or the junior trainee, either way it was against the law to deny service on the basis of sexuality. The only issue really around this is whether sexuality only applies to individuals, or to wider ideas of sexuality. If you refused someone service because you thought they looked gay, or the service was related to gay issues, it doesn't matter - its still discrimination. The only exceptions I think are Religious organisations (under the same law they we sued over) and where necessity that benefits the client's interests. Its not reasonable for a bakery to refuse service on the basis of sexual orientation. Any more than it is on race, religious or gender grounds.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
I was going to say something about you obviously have never been to gay bar, but we all know that would be a lie. You know what I mean jamie, I've got gay mates in the Army and fcuk me (not literally) do they go on and on about it. It's like they are some kind of special off shoot of the human race that are entitled to bitch an moan about everything. Look I agree, that the cake owner was being a dick, but I also see a slippery slope of enforcement on business to accommodate a customer base they don't want to encourage. What happended to free choice, you can't just cherry pick which choices are free and which are not. Ha, quite right, I've been to gay bars and clubs on a number of occasions (usually with gay friends). You're right of course, some people do f**king bang on about it all the f**king time. I think its the novelty. I know straight people who bang on and on about their sex lives and conquests. Boring f**kers, the lot of them. Free choice applies to individuals, not to businesses, they accountable to the law. As an individual, you have free speech and expression.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.