You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Neville blames the players
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Neville blames the players


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 26 Nov 16 11.32pm

Danny Murphy asking why a Benteke marking their strongest / biggest threat in the box.

That said really pathetic all round.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Nov 16 11.34pm

Originally posted by Mr. Mainstand

I'm at a loss to explain why a defence with Scott Dann in now looks so clueless and is shipping so many goals. Does is not work with him and Tomkins? I don't think today would have happened with a Dann / Delaney defence. Is it lack of instruction from Pardew? Anyone who went today have any thoughts?

Danny Murphy's point about not putting our best defender on Fer seemed pretty fair.

Personally I think Tomkins played better than Dann today. Danns been awful since HD came back from injury and if anyone deserves to be dropped it's him.

 

meatpienz Flag brisbane 26 Nov 16 11.48pm

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Delaney was the obvious choice imho to carry on in the captain's role but he's out of favour at the moment.

but Delaney is not a 90 min player anymore ,still he could come on for Dann with 30/40min to go,would not take Tomkins off.i would of taken Cabaye off not McArthur though

 


Zaha has some green grass in front of him here. Finds Ambrose
not a bad effort ooooooooooh! what a goal by Darren Ambrose absolutely stunning strike!!! And, Crystal Palace lead @ Old Trafford.

CheeseRolls Flag Cheshire 26 Nov 16 11.50pm

All Neville's analysis appeared to do was highlight the fact that Benteke had lost his man for 3 of the goals. Why are we relying on Benteke to defend as well as score our goals?

 

Toocs Flag 26 Nov 16 11.55pm

Neville has a point. The players are letting Pards down at the minute. Palace have some fantastic players but they just aren't pulling their weight at the minute.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 26 Nov 16 11.56pm

Against a team who are good frpm set pieces, we gave away 24 free kicks..Pardew's fault?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Nov 16 11.56pm

The manager instructs the players and over too many games the end result is juvenile. It's over.

 


COYP

Toocs Flag 27 Nov 16 12.07am

The players need to start listening to instructions from the manager and his coaches. It was only the other week Pards said one of his players didn't pass on instructions to the other players whilst defending a set piece, and the opposition scored from it. The players need to start listening to what they are told from Pards.

Pards got us to the cup final last season so he is obviously a great manager.

 

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 27 Nov 16 12.32am

Last 2 paragraphs:

"Pardew must stay positive too. He was clearly very disappointed straight after the Swansea game but sometimes as a manager you cannot do anything about a defeat.

He just has to accept what went wrong, keep working hard and hope that, when it comes to stopping set-pieces, the penny will eventually drop for his players."

...If that is the extent of his 'analysis', I think I see why it went so badly for the Nevilles at Valencia.

 

Gidge Flag Romsey 27 Nov 16 1.00am

One big thing that Neville has missed in his analysis is the selection of Martin Kelly at left back. If you can bear to watch today's game again in full, you will see that our biggest problem today was Kelly. We were totally in control of that game and deserved to be 1-0 up. However, Swansea knew our weakness and put all their attacks down their right (our left).

Kelly was either beaten by that Barrow or fouled him/gave away a corner every single time he went near him. I accept that our defending from set pieces is laughable (at best) but don't forget, you've got to give away a set piece in the first place to concede from one.

Pardew has to take the blame for playing Kelly again when we have Fryers available.

I would also add that we look ridiculously unfit and off the pace after about 60 minutes in every game. Pardew should take some blame for that too.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 27 Nov 16 1.06am

I'm sorry but anyone suggesting that Delaney starting or being captain would of made the slightest bit of difference is deluded.

He has been past it and over the hill for sometime now.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 27 Nov 16 1.38am

Originally posted by Toocs

The players need to start listening to instructions from the manager and his coaches. It was only the other week Pards said one of his players didn't pass on instructions to the other players whilst defending a set piece, and the opposition scored from it. The players need to start listening to what they are told from Pards.

Pards got us to the cup final last season so he is obviously a great manager.

I think we are all missing an important point: 'captaincy'. Jedinak captained with ferocity when the team looked disorganised or confused. Pardew's recent excuses about messages not getting out to players is the indicator that there's no-one managing the players on the pitch. Pardew let Jedinak go (rightly perhaps) but he simply was too stupid not to see the deficit in captaincy. He should have replaced Jedinak with a strong leader or kept him until such time as one was available. TP created a 5 man defensive unit with Jedinak plugging holes and being in charge. Pardew's hope that Dann could do Jedi's job was a MISTAKE. Pardew then went further and replaced Delaney with Tomkins. Delaney supported Jedi's captaincy at the back. Pardew has ruined a good defence and captaincy. The team is being captained from the bench. You cannot fault the players' committment when they fight back from 3-1 to get to 3-4. They simply lack any sense of unity of purpose when trying to defend. They are all looking around for instructions and motivation and there is no-one there fit to do it.

 


[Link]

crvenaeagle Flag 27 Nov 16 2.12am

Why are any of you surprised by their performance? Their manager actually came out and publicly said he doesn't care about them, albeit in different words. It's absolutely ludicrous.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 27 Nov 16 4.01am

Phil Neville doesn't have enough brains to fill an egg cup. Gormless f***er

 

bigpapi34 Flag La Crosse, Wisconsin 27 Nov 16 4.35am

Neville is partially correct do blame the players. Especially Scott Dann as Captain. There is ZERO in-Match Leadership shown by Scott Dann week in and week out. But I think my criticism of the players stops there. The lack of preparation leading up to Match Time falls squarely at the feet of Alan Pardew and his coaching staff. There appears to be Zero Accountability both on and off the pitch from Pardew and his staff. That is what we witnessed yesterday at Swansea and also how you lose at Swansea.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 27 Nov 16 5.35am

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

They were some shocking goals we let in today. Howlers some of them. 3-from set pieces. Can't lay it all at pardews door there's 1 of him and 11 of them. They have to take some of the blame. Plain and simple. Hardly like any of them.are new to the footballing world or the premier league. 20th highest wage bill in Europe. They should know what they are doing ffs

From what I understand there is very little respect for him at the club and when that happens players switch off. Just put yourself in their position, you have a manager who never accepts responsibility for the teams failings with yesterday as a classic example sighting that "there will be changes". Hopefully Alan there will be ....you!

 


Bring back Brolin

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Nov 16 5.58am

The board need to look at comparable for a solution to our crisis.
Chelsea...Mourinho... last season.....fans loved him but he disconnected with the game. They were playing really badly. Then Mourinho blamed HIS players. Finally he was sacked. Now look at them. Pretty much the same squad......top of the league.
AP was our saviour. Then we overlooked our league performance camouflaged by our run to Wembley.
AP chose a load more players to strengthen HIS squad and yesterday he blamed HIS players....HIS CHOICE along with the clueless Neville boy.
Enough said. Just like Chelsea with their Messiah our board need to face up to this and act NOW.

 

Croydon Sunset Flag London 27 Nov 16 6.16am

this point about captaincy/ Jedi is spot on

I think we are all missing an important point: 'captaincy'. Jedinak captained with ferocity when the team looked disorganised or confused. Pardew's recent excuses about messages not getting out to players is the indicator that there's no-one managing the players on the pitch. Pardew let Jedinak go (rightly perhaps) but he simply was too stupid not to see the deficit in captaincy. He should have replaced Jedinak with a strong leader or kept him until such time as one was available. TP created a 5 man defensive unit with Jedinak plugging holes and being in charge. Pardew's hope that Dann could do Jedi's job was a MISTAKE. Pardew then went further and replaced Delaney with Tomkins. Delaney supported Jedi's captaincy at the back. Pardew has ruined a good defence and captaincy. The team is being captained from the bench. You cannot fault the players' committment when they fight back from 3-1 to get to 3-4. They simply lack any sense of unity of purpose when trying to defend. They are all looking around for instructions and motivation and there is no-one there fit to do it.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 27 Nov 16 8.22am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

From what I understand there is very little respect for him at the club and when that happens players switch off. Just put yourself in their position, you have a manager who never accepts responsibility for the teams failings with yesterday as a classic example sighting that "there will be changes". Hopefully Alan there will be ....you!

The cracks between him and punch showed at the cup final and the fact Jedi left and went down a league tells me all isn't well. Why can't we have someone like klopp. He always believes in his players and the love is clear to see

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Dodger Lane Flag Merstham 27 Nov 16 8.32am

Keith Millen is the answer he's the defences coach wtf is he doing in training . AP can only pick what he has available to him, although I do belong to the get him out brigade Millen needs to get to grips with them asap or i fear the drop is on the horizon.

 


A Lie travels round the world quicker than a man can put his trousers on

[Link]

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Neville blames the players