You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a keeper
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need a keeper


Page 2 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Salford eagle Flag 15 Jan 17 10.58am

I've been a strong critic of Hennesey's since he got the no. 1 position. At best he is a back up and it's definitely time to regain his place on the bench.

Sam has to make a decision, get a competent keeper, whether it be a new acquisition or Speroni.

I can't remember such a period where there has been constant criticism of goalkeeper.

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

VinceHilaire Flag London 15 Jan 17 11.02am

Originally posted by Salford eagle

I've been a strong critic of Hennesey's since he got the no. 1 position. At best he is a back up and it's definitely time to regain his place on the bench.

Sam has to make a decision, get a competent keeper, whether it be a new acquisition or Speroni.

I can't remember such a period where there has been constant criticism of goalkeeper.

Agreed..,Hennesey is a championship goalkeeper and no more. A few outstanding saves, but too many woeful decisions. I believe the defence have no confidence in him. Sam is not stupid....he knows..

 

Jaha Flag 15 Jan 17 11.08am

To be fair pardew tried to fix the problem by bringing in mandanda so he wasn't oblivious to it. People's memories are very short on here, in the weeks approaching this match Hennessy has been one of the only players on the pitch performing, making some fantastic saves. Yesterday he was crapola but like others have said, it can't be easy with our defence in front of him. Not sure jules is the answer to be honest. Wait until mandanda comes back and give him another go, even if he does seem like a bit of a moany Frenchmen

 

trub3101 Flag 15 Jan 17 11.10am

Originally posted by curlyeagle

Unfortunately he has never filled me with any confidence. It's ok to come out but for fcuk sake come out with some conviction. Everything he does is half hearted and almost cowardly. We have conceded so many goals because of his shall I Sharnt I decision making.

This is so true.

 

Hoof Hearted 15 Jan 17 11.12am

I hate to worry you all.... But we need a completely new defence (as well as strengthening midfield with a ball winner and a striker that can actually score!)

Hennessey was only another contributory factor in all 3 goals.

The first goal was his worst effort, but the defenders/midfield were also to blame for conceding it.

He had no chance with the 2nd but Ward could have got closer to Carroll, like Antonio did to Benteke earlier.

The 3rd goal was a fcuking shambles... we had possession on their goal line and allowed Lanzini to sprint the length of the pitch and chip it over Hennessey FFS.

Big Sam/Little Sam have a monumental task on their hands to sort the team out.

I don't expect to see immediate improvement it is so bad, but by February... IF we can get in a few more tidy players and the coaching methods kick in.

Scott Dann has gone from being a potential England prospect to a liability of late.

Luckily the 3 clubs below us have some tough fixtures coming up, so we should not lose much ground whilst we rebuild our bunch of misfits into a winning team.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 15 Jan 17 11.22am

At least we know that Jules cares about the club,not sure Wayne is showing the same devotion at the moment.All keepers make mistakes but yesterday especially with the first goal and the incident in the first half he looked like a Sunday morning keeper.The third goal wasn't too good either,how do you chip a 6'5" keeper,easy wait for him to commit early,faced with those situations Wayne does not stand tall for long enough to put the oppo player in two minds thus giving him a better chance of a save.
Given these facts Jules should get the No1 shirt back,which he actually has(as per programme).I think that he is a calming influence and the back four know his game set up much better than Waynes.

 

Durban Road Eagle Flag 15 Jan 17 11.27am

Originally posted by Elpis

Jules is 37 Most keepers 'sell by date ' is a couple of years beyond that at least . I don't know why Speroni was replaced but that he is considered good enough for the bench would maybe say he is not past it and to be honest could not be any worse than WH who is a (I thought he had turned the corner with some good performances before Christmas) disaster waiting to happen .
Put Jules back in and prove the doubters wrong

Whatever happens in the future, I shall remember Jules' clean sheet last week.

 


Kentish Maid, born Beckenham, Kent; lifelong Palace supporter.

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 15 Jan 17 11.34am

Originally posted by Durban Road Eagle

Whatever happens in the future, I shall remember Jules' clean sheet last week.

So will BFS he gets off on them ! He may never see another unles he starts earning his money.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 15 Jan 17 11.52am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

I hate to worry you all.... But we need a completely new defence (as well as strengthening midfield with a ball winner and a striker that can actually score!)

Hennessey was only another contributory factor in all 3 goals.

The first goal was his worst effort, but the defenders/midfield were also to blame for conceding it.

He had no chance with the 2nd but Ward could have got closer to Carroll, like Antonio did to Benteke earlier.

The 3rd goal was a fcuking shambles... we had possession on their goal line and allowed Lanzini to sprint the length of the pitch and chip it over Hennessey FFS.

Big Sam/Little Sam have a monumental task on their hands to sort the team out.

I don't expect to see immediate improvement it is so bad, but by February... IF we can get in a few more tidy players and the coaching methods kick in.

Scott Dann has gone from being a potential England prospect to a liability of late.

Luckily the 3 clubs below us have some tough fixtures coming up, so we should not lose much ground whilst we rebuild our bunch of misfits into a winning team.

Agreed. Again yesterday Ward at left back was all over the place and constantly giving the ball away as well as defending badly. He needs to fight for the right back position only. The sooner we get a left back (I think Schlupp is left midfield) and a further cover player for left back the better. Still think Ward with Kelly as cover is good enough but if Jenkinson comes in all the better? Still out on Tomkins, but I suppose he is good cover for Dann and Delaney? Also need to find a new captain as Dann has suffered with his form since being given it? Basically we need a constant back four with players playing in there rightful positions?

 

cpj Flag Kent 15 Jan 17 11.52am

Originally posted by Durban Road Eagle

Whatever happens in the future, I shall remember Jules' clean sheet last week.

... against a League 1 side. Hoofhearted summed up the situation nicely.

We keep conceding too nay goals to balls played over the top The marking isn't tight enough. There's no closing down or pressing. We have too many Championship-level players, and those that are Premier-level (too few) don't seem to care greatly. WH made a mistake coming out for the first goal, but where was Ward for the second, and the whole defence for the 3rd?

 

bodge Flag 15 Jan 17 11.59am

WH was poor for the first and third goals i thought keepers made themselves big he made himself small. He is still our best fit keeper until Speroni proves me wrong on Tuesday fingers crossed.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 15 Jan 17 12.01pm

Originally posted by TrickyBoy

Sorry but like many other players he's sh!t at present.

Its pathetic - they get paid millions and we make excuses their confidence is down ... oh poor f**king lambs ...

Try working a bit harder and for each other ...

I do think the sentiment about us signing big names is one to think about. Burnley, Bournemouth, WBA, they don't have superstars

Time to build a team of guys with something to prove.

We had that team,its when a manager tries to improve it,that it can go tits up.

Pulis purchased Wayne but this made Jules improve.Wayne was back up.

Pardew did not rate Wayne or Jules so he purchased Mccarthy who did so so then went to pot.

Wayne got back in but Pardew purchased Mandanda now injured.

Wayne now a liability so do we go back to Jules.?

Possibly he is the best of the lot.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 15 Jan 17 12.02pm

Originally posted by curlyeagle

Unfortunately he has never filled me with any confidence. It's ok to come out but for fcuk sake come out with some conviction. Everything he does is half hearted and almost cowardly. We have conceded so many goals because of his shall I Sharnt I decision making.

Spot on. He is a wimp. Also has a mistake in him every game. Unfortunatly for us he gets punished for it nearly every time.He is not a Premier league standard keeper.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 17 12.03pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Agreed. Again yesterday Ward at left back was all over the place and constantly giving the ball away as well as defending badly. He needs to fight for the right back position only. The sooner we get a left back (I think Schlupp is left midfield) and a further cover player for left back the better. Still think Ward with Kelly as cover is good enough but if Jenkinson comes in all the better? Still out on Tomkins, but I suppose he is good cover for Dann and Delaney? Also need to find a new captain as Dann has suffered with his form since being given it? Basically we need a constant back four with players playing in there rightful positions?

Yes. And the lack of pace and mobility n the back four is obviously a concern. Generally, across the pitch we are less than impressive when the opposition have possession.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 15 Jan 17 12.05pm

Originally posted by Durban Road Eagle

Whatever happens in the future, I shall remember Jules' clean sheet last week.

So will we seeing that is at least the third thread where you've posted the exact same line.

Anyway as Hoof has intimated goalkeeper is only part of the problem. Defensively we are just bloody awful. Damo is shot, yes he has the heart but he is not good enough, Dann, is a good CB and certainly good enough starter but I've always said he is overrated by most Palace fans. Remember the Dann for England shouts?

What currently concerns me most is we look even less organised than under Pardew. I thought the one thing Allardyce would bring is discipline without the ball.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 15 Jan 17 12.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes. And the lack of pace and mobility n the back four is obviously a concern. Generally, across the pitch we are less than impressive when the opposition have possession.

We are now not that good when we have possession either. BFS has made the players nervous about going forward.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Jan 17 12.11pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

So will we seeing that is at least the third thread where you've posted the exact same line.

Anyway as Hoof has intimated goalkeeper is only part of the problem. Defensively we are just bloody awful. Damo is shot, yes he has the heart but he is not good enough, Dann, is a good CB and certainly good enough starter but I've always said he is overrated by most Palace fans. Remember the Dann for England shouts?

What currently concerns me most is we look even less organised than under Pardew. I thought the one thing Allardyce would bring is discipline without the ball.

Give him a chance - he hasn't been there all that long and there is no "Magic wand" which can turn around a horrific run since the start of 2016.

I'm sure he realises that he has taken on a much bigger job than he anticipated.Maybe he wishes he hadn't joined !!!!

Edited by Willo (15 Jan 2017 12.12pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 15 Jan 17 12.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

Give him a chance - he hasn't been there all that long and there is no "Magic wand" which can turn around a horrific run since the start of 2016.

I'm sure he realises that he has taken on a much bigger job than he anticipated.Maybe he wishes he hadn't joined !!!!

Edited by Willo (15 Jan 2017 12.12pm)

In three weeks I would expect to see players having a better idea of their roles without the ball. I'm not talking about being error free, I'm talking about defence in a straight line not a snake, compact, CBs closer together etc. Three weeks and five games in do I expect miracles? No but I haven't seen anything encouraging so far either.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

gerry theagle Flag newbury 15 Jan 17 1.24pm

Another thing that nobody has really mentioned is how much we are missing Wilf,not only for his forward play but his tracking back to help out the defence,just shows the effort he puts in that others do not.
Hope Wilf has a good tournament,Ivory Coast go out in early stages and he comes back uninjured asap.

 

Sussex fella Flag Haywards Heath 15 Jan 17 1.54pm

The whole issue with the team is around confidence. Poor play and a number of horrendous refereeing decisions have taken our guys to rock bottom on confidence. Good players do not become bad overnight, but good players without confidence are bad players. Therefore SA needs to rebuild confidence from the back through the team. Hennessy must be dropped. He always has the look of someone about to drop a clanger (yesterday he had 3, 2 were goals) and last season when he started away to Villa he went on to drop changers in consecutive games. Speroni has the confidence of Dann, Tomkins, Damo, Wardy etc and this means a lot. A new left back (due imminently) will make a huge difference to the defence. In midfield we need a fit Jimmy Mac and Flamini to give us the basis of cover for the central defenders. We then need 3 creatives and a centre forward. Wilf will obviously be a shoe-in on his return and Punch is a good club man and trier. Cabaye is safer in a forward position and Remy seems to want it more than Benteke. Having said that we take far too long to get the ball forward to Benteke. I would give Kai Kai a run against Bolton and see if we can leave Townsend on the bench for a few games. He looks shell shocked right now.

 

Page 2 of 12 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a keeper