You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > PSHE Bill 'Filibustered' by Conservative MPs
November 22 2026 12.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

PSHE Bill 'Filibustered' by Conservative MPs


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
matt_himself Flag Matataland 22 Jan 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by A_JsShorts

There are many teachers who would do a terrible job at teaching PSHE, so in that sense you are not wrong! In my last school I led on the PSHE curriculum and organised it's delivery across the school. It involved a lot more than sex education, things that some parents may not know how or what to teach their own children. that's not disrespectful to parents or limiting choice, if left to parents that also may limit the choice of what their children learn. Many children don't want to talk to their parents (and vice versa) about STI's, p***. grooming etc.

So the reason I think it is should be taught in schools (for which when I led it we oftenused outside speakers who were trained in certain aspects, such as doctors and nurses, counsellors,police officers etc) and every child was given an equal and broad PSHE education.
Which for me is what is important, that young people all have an opportunity to access the same education.

Good answer, Soph. My point was two fold, surely parents should be given a choice on whether this is taught at school. There are many parents who would not want their kids taught it at school and I do believe that their wishes should be respected. Secondly, I am not sure that teachers are the right people to do this all the time. The outside speakers, such as health care professionals, is a good example of how it could be done.

Teaching respect of others to eliminate bullying is important. Whether the kid is fat, ginger, a 'gaylord' (80's schoolyard slang) or wears the 2017 version of Simod trainers, one would hope that there is a government initiative to give kids the tools to deal with it.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 22 Jan 17 3.05pm

Parents are allowed to opt out their kids from the lessons if they so wish.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 22 Jan 17 3.14pm

Originally posted by susmik

I second that one....as I cannot see for the life of me why any child would want a teacher to tell him/her if she is a male or a female. No wonder so many kids think they are in the wrong bodies. It never happened 50 years ago the world has gone mad!

F*cking hell mate

School doesn't teach you what sexuality you are, society as a whole is a lot more liberal than when you was a confused teen which I expect was the late fifties.

 

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 3.21pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Good answer, Soph. My point was two fold, surely parents should be given a choice on whether this is taught at school. There are many parents who would not want their kids taught it at school and I do believe that their wishes should be respected. Secondly, I am not sure that teachers are the right people to do this all the time. The outside speakers, such as health care professionals, is a good example of how it could be done.

Teaching respect of others to eliminate bullying is important. Whether the kid is fat, ginger, a 'gaylord' (80's schoolyard slang) or wears the 2017 version of Simod trainers, one would hope that there is a government initiative to give kids the tools to deal with it.

Kermit is right, a schools PSHE policy should be freely available for parents to read, as all policies are and if a parent does not wish for their child to participate then they can withdraw their child if they want. I've never come across a parent making that request myself.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 22 Jan 17 3.26pm

Originally posted by A_JsShorts

Kermit is right, a schools PSHE policy should be freely available for parents to read, as all policies are and if a parent does not wish for their child to participate then they can withdraw their child if they want. I've never come across a parent making that request myself.

Wasn't the proposed bill going to make it mandatory, in the same way English and Maths is a mandatory subject?

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Jan 17 3.31pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Wasn't the proposed bill going to make it mandatory, in the same way English and Maths is a mandatory subject?

It's phse not just s.

 

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 3.46pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Wasn't the proposed bill going to make it mandatory, in the same way English and Maths is a mandatory subject?

Mandatory to offer it. Not mandatory for every child to participate, same as religious education.

I'd have to read the whole thing but that's my take on it.

 

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 3.54pm

Yeah I've just read the bill and it's to require all schools to offer and deliver PSHE in whichever way that they choose. Couldn't see anything that suggested children would be forced to participate if their parents didn't want them to.

 

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 4.00pm

Very few schools teach it as a subject on its own as a timetabled lesson like English and Maths. It's usually taught in drop days where timetables are collapsed or in tutor times for example. There are it assessments for it. So it can't be compared to core subjects like maths and english. I don't know how it is taught in primary school, I have no idea how it's taught at Evans school!

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 22 Jan 17 4.23pm

Originally posted by A_JsShorts

And this sadly is where you are ignorant of what is actually taught in PSHE lessons.

I've encountered two boys in my 8 years who have chosen to wear girls uniform and be called by a girls name. Whether they go on to have gender reassignment surgery or chose to live their life as a transgender person is nothing to do with school.

No I am not ignorant as you put it as many schools are now talking about gender "mal functions" which I think is rather stupid. These boys/girls should be told what their different body parts they have show what gender they are. So many kids nowadays get the idea sewn into their heads that they should change gender. It is very sad as 90% of the ones who want change do not know what they really want. Sign of the times I am afraid.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 4.37pm

But they do learn about male and female body parts in biology. I'm interested in what you say though as I've not come across it, so if you could point me in the direction of some information about this then it would be useful for me. Thanks &#128522;

 

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 4.38pm

If a young person makes it known that they are gender confused then hey are referred to outside agencies that specifically deal with this. No-one in a school would be qualified in that capacity.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 22 Jan 17 5.02pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

Wasn't the proposed bill going to make it mandatory, in the same way English and Maths is a mandatory subject?

At present, no school has to teach PSHE as it is NOT a statutory curriculum subject. Even DfE has effectively outsourced responsibility for the curriculum to partially state funded advisory body, PSHE Association.

Even from this Bill, it is only likely to attain FOUNDATION subject status as opposed to CORE subject status therefore rendering the subject virtually glossed over by Ofsted - see Primary PE & Sports Premium that the tax payer covers and that is being used by too many state schools to offset core budget cuts = don't wholly believe what is provided online as a measure of 'true' spend and impact, and certainly sustainability.

In defence of Matt's comments, there is a reported lack in teaching and learning standards as researched by HMI:

[Link]

But then you have to explore the lack of wisdom from previous Govt Ministers including Nicky 'Utterly bumptious yet provenly out of touch & incompetent' Morgan:

[Link]

'40% of PSHE teaching is less than good. As such, while we will continue to keep the status of PSHE in the curriculum under review, our immediate focus will be on improving the quality of PSHE teaching in our schools.'....AND SHE DIDN'T!

Schools are consequently focused upon HMI inspection priorities and league tables therefore quality of PSHE education from ALL schools is never going to excel until DfE makes it a required priority. Surely children's health and well-being IS a priority and a major gateway to improved behaviour; attainment and achievement. I haven't suggested that ALL parents are feckless to teach their children the important stages in life development, but c'mon...we could ALL benefit from learning further but better still working in collaboration. But Ministers are blind to the reality of what children and young people earnestly need in terms of whole person development as a key stepping stone to contentment and then achievement. Meanwhile, our schools have no other option than to test their little darlings to the hilt....

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 22 Jan 17 5.21pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Well done, Nick! The voice of common sense and real experience in life who likewise understands the consequences of last Friday's crazy behaviour in the House of Commons. Other core themes to PSHE curriculum include health and well-being as well as living in the wider world (including economic wellbeing and aspects of careers education).

Perhaps Matt also believes that parents are just as capable of exercising sound judgment as to how their offspring receive adequate access to active healthy lifestyle provision when the evidence is all around us as to spiralling levels of childhood obesity.


Real experience in life ? How can teachers have real experience in life when they start school at the age of 4 and leave at 65 ?

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 22 Jan 17 5.35pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Real experience in life ? How can teachers have real experience in life when they start school at the age of 4 and leave at 65 ?

Retire at 65? If only! We'll be literally pegging it in front of pupils eventually...

I also suggest that you study other comments and research everyday practice...

 

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 5.46pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Real experience in life ? How can teachers have real experience in life when they start school at the age of 4 and leave at 65 ?

I started teaching at 28. Had a whole decade of "life experience" beforehand. In fact most teachers I know didn't start teaching straight out of uni either.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Jan 17 5.46pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Real experience in life ? How can teachers have real experience in life when they start school at the age of 4 and leave at 65 ?

Many teachers have other life experience before entering the profession. I didn't start my Ba(Ed) until I was 30

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 22 Jan 17 6.04pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Real experience in life ? How can teachers have real experience in life when they start school at the age of 4 and leave at 65 ?

As previous posters have indicated, you couldn't be more wrong. Time to join Matt within The University of Misguided

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 22 Jan 17 7.50pm

Originally posted by A_JsShorts

I started teaching at 28. Had a whole decade of "life experience" beforehand. In fact most teachers I know didn't start teaching straight out of uni either.

'lo.

The names change but the politics don't.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

A_JsShorts 22 Jan 17 9.17pm

Originally posted by pefwin

'lo.

The names change but the politics don't.

Nothing's changed

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > PSHE Bill 'Filibustered' by Conservative MPs