This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Michaelawt85
Totally get what everyone is saying about alcohol and tobacco and I agree.. But this isn't a good idea. I have posted in the past about this. Cannabis is often seen as a gateway drug to other harder substances. We are already have two two legal drugs which cause a ton of social and health related problems let alone adding a third to the mix. I do however think it should be made better use of for medical reasons such as ms and cancer but that would be a different grade and type than stuff sold for recreational use. Actually been recognised today as an exit drug.
|
|
|
Should we legalize all drugs but ban Russell Brand?
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyb1
Actually been recognised today as an exit drug. It was for me when I was thrown out of Bar Rumba for having a toke...
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
It was for me when I was thrown out of Bar Rumba for having a toke... Just made me laugh out loud
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
Just made me laugh out loud
Two or three wrongs do not make a right.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
sorry but normal cannabis with nothing changed in it, and with the same laws abided like booze, ie no driving etc, theres nothing wrong with it imo. causes no bodily cancers like the other two and if anything is now being proved to fight illnesses such as cancer if consumed albeit in a different way. forget my argument and comparison to the other two, what the hell is wrong with natural weed? Mental illness and the tendency for its users to forgo the use of capitals for no apparent reason.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
or just so i don't get told off by my boss for not doing my work, who incidentally used to be a pot head.
have we bought sakho yet?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Two or three wrongs do not make a right. Might help to ease the stress on food banks
Lend me a Tenor 31 May to 3 June 2017 John McIntosh Arts Centre with Superfly in the chorus |
|
|
Originally posted by We are goin up!
The problem with our current policy is that is neither prohibition nor is it legalisation. Not prohibition: if you get caught with cannabis on you by a police officer, absolutely nothing will happen to you. Frankly, if you get caught with an E or a bag of coke nothing will happen either, you'd have to have large quantities on you to be prosecuted. That is not fully-fledged deterrent prohibition, which aims to stop people taking drugs in the first place. Not legalisation: The production and distribution of pot and other substances isn't in the hands of private companies, it's in the hands of criminals, causing a vast black market which damages society both culturally and financially. I find the "well it's worse than alcohol" argument a bit daft. Just because one thing is extremely bad for us, doesn't mean we should legalise something that is still bad for us. I know from family experience that regular use of cannabis causes paranoia and psychotic illness. It's horrible stuff. There's a far better argument for it, that it would make criminal activity far more difficult, increase income for the exchequer, make the products' ingredients known... That is the argument for legalisation, but it's based on the premise that we accept that drug-taking happens. Either you accept widespread drug-taking and legalise, or you don't and enforce prohibition. Otherwise you end up with what we have at the moment. Government needs to make its mind up one way or the other. I think you bring a balanced view to the debate. It's one that I'm always suspicious of because the legalise supporters nearly always come across as users and so have an inherent self interest. As someone who has never smoked pot, indeed never smoked a full cigarette I still came from parents who were confirmed 40 a day Benson and Hedges merchants for most of their days. So like most of us I've seen the damage that smoking habits have. I've known druggies and I've rarely been impressed by what I regard as the personal weakness of it. Nevertheless I've also heard some good arguments like yours and Jamie's on this topic that have moved my view a little on exactly what the model society should use in this respect....Well moved it to a place where I'm honestly not sure anymore. The current practice you describe, is tantamount to surrender due to a lack of willingness to really tackle the problem....though of course if they did, in effect, it would be criminalizing a lot of people who are...for the most part only harming themselves.....And in the case of those irregular and small users probably not even harming themselves at all. That said I don't think it's ok to say drug taking of anything recreational is a good thing. As a teacher I always recommended that regular smoking or alcohol were poor habits. That exercise and sport and study were lifelong useful and healthy pursuits. You try to move them towards the light and away from the darkness...while recognising that, quite rightly, our influence is extremely limited compared to families. I think in society...outside of good families and rather exclusive schools... we are losing that concept of any responsibility for 'building' basic healthy attitudes....That said I know schools still try but it's a voice that's dimming its intensity. So what is the ethical position for the state to take? I'm not sure any position is ideal. I could probably live with a total legalisation of all drugs that came with a strong ethical commitment and remit from schools to push an anti drugs attitude.....But I still feel that this is the state making money from..in some cases misery... as it does from smoking and alcohol. Or perhaps I could live with building more prisons and drawing a line in the sand and saying....from this date...we will send users to prison and no excuses...make your choice now....and invest in rehabilitation and so on. This would at least be the state taking a stand.....Maybe tough love would work in the long run?...If there were some love behind the initial punch.....But prison usually wrecks lives so perhaps this is nonsense. What course of action ultimately reduces the number of drug takers within society? What course of action best promotes healthy attitudes for our youngsters?....who in many examples are extremely impressible. All I know is that I'm not really happy with where we are right now.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I think you bring a balanced view to the debate. It's one that I'm always suspicious of because the legalise supporters nearly always come across as users and so have an inherent self interest. As someone who has never smoked pot, indeed never smoked a full cigarette I still came from parents who were confirmed 40 a day Benson and Hedges merchants for most of their days. So like most of us I've seen the damage that smoking habits have. I've known druggies and I've rarely been impressed by what I regard as the personal weakness of it. Nevertheless I've also heard some good arguments like yours and Jamie's on this topic that have moved my view a little on exactly what the model society should use in this respect....Well moved it to a place where I'm honestly not sure anymore. The current practice you describe, is tantamount to surrender due to a lack of willingness to really tackle the problem....though of course if they did, in effect, it would be criminalizing a lot of people who are...for the most part only harming themselves.....And in the case of those irregular and small users probably not even harming themselves at all. That said I don't think it's ok to say drug taking of anything recreational is a good thing. As a teacher I always recommended that regular smoking or alcohol were poor habits. That exercise and sport and study were lifelong useful and healthy pursuits. You try to move them towards the light and away from the darkness...while recognising that, quite rightly, our influence is extremely limited compared to families. I think in society...outside of good families and rather exclusive schools... we are losing that concept of any responsibility for 'building' basic healthy attitudes....That said I know schools still try but it's a voice that's dimming its intensity. So what is the ethical position for the state to take? I'm not sure any position is ideal. I could probably live with a total legalisation of all drugs that came with a strong ethical commitment and remit from schools to push an anti drugs attitude.....But I still feel that this is the state making money from..in some cases misery... as it does from smoking and alcohol. Or perhaps I could live with building more prisons and drawing a line in the sand and saying....from this date...we will send users to prison and no excuses...make your choice now....and invest in rehabilitation and so on. This would at least be the state taking a stand.....Maybe tough love would work in the long run?...If there were some love behind the initial punch.....But prison usually wrecks lives so perhaps this is nonsense. What course of action ultimately reduces the number of drug takers within society? What course of action best promotes healthy attitudes for our youngsters?....who in many examples are extremely impressible. All I know is that I'm not really happy with where we are right now.
I tend to be more libertarian, I believe that citizens' personal freedom is essential and it is up the individual what they ingest/inhale. The problem that you have with this position is that the drug taker's personal freedom could impact on the freedom of others, because society may have to pay for the cost of the healthcare/rehabilitation of the drug user. I would prefer that we had a system of personal responsibility where the state says "If you want to take drugs despite being informed of the consequences, that's your choice. But don't expect the state to pay for your rehabilitation." It's an absolutely toxic policy in this country but some form of privatised healthcare would deter people much more than prison IMO. If you knew that drugs could ultimately cost you everything, rather than having the backup of rehab/healthcare free-of-charge, I think that would be a massive put off. Why should responsible members of society pay for drugs rehab for irresponsible drug users? The legalisation of drugs would at least bring in some funds for this. It's a really tough issue, and I can see both sides of the argument. In countries where drugs are linked to extraordinary sentences in prison, you just don't take them. It's not worth it. To that extent, I agree with you that the current position is unacceptable. I would rather see enforced prohibition than what we have now, which is a sham and only benefits criminals.
The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Two or three wrongs do not make a right. Except of course Alcohol and Cigerettes generate around 10-12bn in revenue for the government each year, where as drug enforcement costs run to somewhere in or around 20bn a year. With cannabis, its a pragmatic solution, not an ideal or moral one. The cost of enforcement, massively outweigh the benefits, plus in doing so, you can eliminate a very lucrative source of income for organised crime and street gangs, whilst also raising revenue from the sales. Doesn't mean you condone or have to take cannabis, it just means that the acceptance that plenty of other people do, and that the criminalisation has been a waste of time, money and produced no tangible benefits. In Colorado, the tax revenue from legalised cannabis resulted in a tax refund for the citizens!
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3166512] That's because the dealers offer harder drugs free to new clients in the hope to get a new market. Same as all gateway stuff. "This is good, but this is even better, try it free". Not in my experience. Most 'dealers' tend to be friends or friends of a friend. Whilst I've gotten other drugs from cannabis dealers in the past, its usually because I asked them if they knew someone or could help. Also usually other fairly soft drugs (E, Acid or Speed). Most people selling cannabis don't generally sell things like heroin or crack. That's a very different market, and game. Further up the chain, when you're talking bulk its the case, but then that doesn't tend to be 'street retail' (i.e. someone who deals in kilos of weed might also deal in bulk anything).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Except of course Alcohol and Cigerettes generate around 10-12bn in revenue for the government each year, where as drug enforcement costs run to somewhere in or around 20bn a year. With cannabis, its a pragmatic solution, not an ideal or moral one. The cost of enforcement, massively outweigh the benefits, plus in doing so, you can eliminate a very lucrative source of income for organised crime and street gangs, whilst also raising revenue from the sales. Doesn't mean you condone or have to take cannabis, it just means that the acceptance that plenty of other people do, and that the criminalisation has been a waste of time, money and produced no tangible benefits. In Colorado, the tax revenue from legalised cannabis resulted in a tax refund for the citizens! This sounds simple but criminals will just look for other avenues of income which will then have to be policed at a cost.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by We are goin up!
The problem with our current policy is that is neither prohibition nor is it legalisation. Not prohibition: if you get caught with cannabis on you by a police officer, absolutely nothing will happen to you. Frankly, if you get caught with an E or a bag of coke nothing will happen either, you'd have to have large quantities on you to be prosecuted. That is not fully-fledged deterrent prohibition, which aims to stop people taking drugs in the first place. Not legalisation: The production and distribution of pot and other substances isn't in the hands of private companies, it's in the hands of criminals, causing a vast black market which damages society both culturally and financially. I find the "well it's worse than alcohol" argument a bit daft. Just because one thing is extremely bad for us, doesn't mean we should legalise something that is still bad for us. I know from family experience that regular use of cannabis causes paranoia and psychotic illness. It's horrible stuff. There's a far better argument for it, that it would make criminal activity far more difficult, increase income for the exchequer, make the products' ingredients known... That is the argument for legalisation, but it's based on the premise that we accept that drug-taking happens. Either you accept widespread drug-taking and legalise, or you don't and enforce prohibition. Otherwise you end up with what we have at the moment. Government needs to make its mind up one way or the other. Odd as this is going to sound, drugs are not banned based on their harm or potential to cause harm. Their legality is based on potential for abuse and medical use. Which is why heroin and cocaine have a lower schedule rating than cannabis and ecstasy (and its also why dissolved amphetamine is class A and solid (powder / pill) is class B (dissolved speed can be injected which amphetamine in legal medical use is not). Most of the common illegal drugs have had very extensive periods of being legal. The media tends to over report their dangers, and does so according to a moral agenda. Oddly in the UK we are now in a weird situation in which we have more dangerous drugs in circulation than the ones we're trying to prevent (PMMA and PMA instead of MDMA, the first killed more people in the last few years than MDMA did in over a decade). Adulteration of street heroin kills more people than diamoprphine (medical heroin). Of course its probably true that less people use drugs now than would do if they were legal. However, its interesting that among the Dutch, where weed is legally available, the number of regular smokers of cannabis is around the same as in the UK (25%), and they've seen no rise in heroin addiction either (dismissing the idea of it being a gate way drug).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by We are goin up!
I tend to be more libertarian, I believe that citizens' personal freedom is essential and it is up the individual what they ingest/inhale. The problem that you have with this position is that the drug taker's personal freedom could impact on the freedom of others, because society may have to pay for the cost of the healthcare/rehabilitation of the drug user. I would prefer that we had a system of personal responsibility where the state says "If you want to take drugs despite being informed of the consequences, that's your choice. But don't expect the state to pay for your rehabilitation." It's an absolutely toxic policy in this country but some form of privatised healthcare would deter people much more than prison IMO. If you knew that drugs could ultimately cost you everything, rather than having the backup of rehab/healthcare free-of-charge, I think that would be a massive put off. Why should responsible members of society pay for drugs rehab for irresponsible drug users? The legalisation of drugs would at least bring in some funds for this. It's a really tough issue, and I can see both sides of the argument. In countries where drugs are linked to extraordinary sentences in prison, you just don't take them. It's not worth it. To that extent, I agree with you that the current position is unacceptable. I would rather see enforced prohibition than what we have now, which is a sham and only benefits criminals. Perhaps your approach would work best in practical effect. I guess there is a part of me that feels each society has a responsibility to all within it....Good/bad/positive/negative/useful/not useful. But I agree with you that still also comes with its own unfairness. I also agree that seeing it within the authoritarian vs libertarian spectrum is more useful that the usual left/right knockabout roundabout....enjoyable as I may find that. The problem with the 'hands off' personal responsibility libertarian stand point is that ultimately you let those less fortunate have more access to ultimately unhealthy drugs, similar to how we do with fags and booze and so we also ultimately increase their chances of falling into it more easily.....I mean the causes of drug taking can really lets face it be all about where and to whom you are born..it might be a family culture they were raised in or they were bullied or pressurized into it, abusive boyfriend and so on... Is it tenable that the state walks on while the worst examples self destruct and probably harm innocents in the process?..Still as you say maybe if the tax take from legalising these drugs can be exclusively used for rehabilitation then maybe the circle can....at least be partly squared. I don't like the results of pure libertarianism....which ultimately is that if you are born into bad circumstances, which is purely luck, then the state isn't really going to help you when negatives result. Then again an authoritarian approach would punish and damage lives to make a point to others. When many are not directly hurting others . I'm sure it would work to a certain extent but I also don't feel the price in damaged lives is worth paying. It would be great if those in actual positions of power who are supposedly smart people could actually end up pushing us towards better outcomes rather than just continually dressing the wounds...Or often not even accomplishing that.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.