You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So who do we let go?
November 16 2026 9.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So who do we let go?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Sansbup Flag Norfolk 14 May 17 7.29pm

I'd love Damo to retire from playing and join the backroom staff...

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 14 May 17 7.42pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

We've discussed this before. This was my view a couple of weeks ago and I've not changed it.

Out of our current squad, who are nailed-on for the starting XI?

I'd suggest:

Tomkins
Van Aanholt
Luka
Cabaye
Zaha
Townsend
Benteke

There or thereabouts:

Hennessey
Schlupp
Dann
Ward
Wickham
Puncheon
McArthur
Kelly

In bold are those positions could do with an upgrade. The others need some competition.

Can't see any future for:

Mutch
Ledley
Lee
Campbell
Fryers
Mandanda
Sako
Delaney
Speroni
Flamini
Williams
J Benteke

Souare - impossible to say what will happen

Analytical Bender ...

 


Pro USA & Israel

palace99 Flag New Mills 14 May 17 8.26pm

Originally posted by se25 rudy

A new number 10/creative midfielder must be a priority - I know Punch has his admirers on here but he's scored 0 goals this season. It's simply not good enough to have no goal threat from that position. Imagine how many more points we'd have if, for example, Sigurdsson played there instead of Puncheon.......

competely agree, Punch is just not a No10 and at times is our deepest midfielder. Playing 4-3-3 this position is crucial and has been lacking all season and most of last season too if we're honest.

Benteke has been too isolated at times.

I think Cabeye is on his way - his waving as he was substituted was a strong indicator that he is on his way back to France.

Edited by palace99 (14 May 2017 8.27pm)

 

Palace 1979 Flag Surrey 14 May 17 9.57pm

Originally posted by Holmesdale Hibs

All those listed in the first post although we should do everyone can to keep Cabaye. Is he unhappy/homesick?

Really disappointed at Flamini, thought he'd be a really important player for us.

Add Mutch to the list. Thought he was decent when we signed him but hasn't worked out.

I'd have said Kelly a few months ago when he was playiing at full back but he's looked much better as centre half. Happy to be proved wrong on that one.

Wilf should, and probably will be, offered a massive contract. If he leaves it should be for £40mn minimum on the grounds that he's better, younger, fitter and more lived than Bolasie was at £30mn.

How the hell did I forget him. he should be top of the list!

From other comments, I fully trust Sam's ability in the market and the days of desperate last minute panic buys are long gone. He is a shrewd operator and I can only see the squad getting stronger every year he stays.

My only worry for next year are holding on to Zaha, Cabaye and Benteke. 3 very important players for us this season.

 


Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.

Baz Eagle 14 May 17 10.22pm

My two penceworth

Appiah - shame I liked but injury has crippled his career.
Cabaye - Although we should try and keep but if a good offer came along (i.e. 10mil +) I would go for it.
Campbell - I would actually try and keep if we don't bring any strikers. If we bring in some striker competition then let go.
Chung - yep get rid - peripheral at best
Delaney - luv the guy - maybe retire to coaching staff?
Flamini - no real impact. bought for name only.
Fryers - We now have at least 2/3 better left sided players.
Hennessey - keep. We probably need a young understudy
Ledley - A position I think we can improve on. But if Cabaye goes then keep. If Cabaye stays then Ledley should go.
Mandanda - get rid. I think he wants to go.
Mutch - get rid
Remy -Thanks but no thanks. Too injury prone.
Sakho - PLEASE BUY !
SAKO - If Kaikai is up for it then I'd get rid if not then keep for one more year.
Williams - I think the time is up and perhaps best for both parties if he moves on.
ZAHA - PLEASE KEEP !

We'll need a GK (back-up) CB, RB Cover (why did we get rid of Mariappa??) Central Midfield (if we get rid of Cabaye) and if Zaha goes then we'll be needing a replacment and I think we need a back up striker.

 

Part Time James Flag 14 May 17 10.37pm

Reading these lists has reminded me we still have some real sh*te on our books. Half these players I thought had left or quit to become shelf stackers.

 




Part Time James Flag 14 May 17 10.38pm

I ought to add though, I'd like to see us sign replacements before shipping all of these. Not asking for expensive replacements per se, if we are only looking to upgrade the squad depth, but no point shipping all those players if we just sign equally pants players.

 




Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 14 May 17 10.58pm

I actually agree with keeping Campbell (and Delaney if not too selfish). Both players totally committed and devoid of destructive egos.

 

Username Flag Horsham 15 May 17 9.01am

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

I actually agree with keeping Campbell (and Delaney if not too selfish). Both players totally committed and devoid of destructive egos.

We need another centre half anyway though, at which point Delaney will be fifth choice, and at times he was dreadful this season.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 15 May 17 10.44am

Originally posted by palace99

competely agree, Punch is just not a No10 and at times is our deepest midfielder. Playing 4-3-3 this position is crucial and has been lacking all season and most of last season too if we're honest.

Benteke has been too isolated at times.

I think Cabeye is on his way - his waving as he was substituted was a strong indicator that he is on his way back to France.

Edited by palace99 (14 May 2017 8.27pm)

Add me to that list. I've been critical of Punch for ages and for all the reasons described. He's too one sided (barely pass with his right foot), slow and too many ambitious long balls that are invariably intercepted. However since SA made him captain he's form has improved markedly. If we can't get Sakho then a CB is the No. 1 priority. Keep Kelly for cover but Delaney's time is over. Wasn't impressed with Ward this season either so competition for that spot is required too.

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 15 May 17 2.13pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Because SA took him out of the position AP obstinately played him wrongly game after game - where Lula is now.

exactly. AP wasted him during his time. now he's flying.

 

Kishishev Flag Crystal Palace 15 May 17 3.17pm

Nice to finally be able to think about this.

Have a lot for big Damo, he will always give you 100% and ideally a spot on the staff would be great as I for one never thought he would make it this long with us ( was convinced he'd be the first one out the door post playoff win)

Guess we're at as crossroads as a club. I'm still not Sams biggest fan, but respect the job he has done. Club spent a stack last summer and in Jan, ,so sure we're not going to be going crazy this summer.

Would like a bit more experience at the back.(maybe Zabaleta)

And be good to take a chance on someone in the lower leagues. Someone like Britt Assamblonga.

Think our keeper situation could be a problem if not resolved sooner rather than later.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 15 May 17 4.54pm

Any idea when club will be announcing who they are releasing? Noe our EPL status is confirmed must be fairly soon.

Edited by Palace in the Blood (15 May 2017 4.54pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 May 17 5.05pm

Originally posted by Username

We need another centre half anyway though, at which point Delaney will be fifth choice, and at times he was dreadful this season.

I think there is a case for keeping Delaney as the 'last choice' centre back. He's had some shockers but he's also had a few blinders as well. Lots of experience and reliable. Depends I guess if he doesn't mind sitting on the bench and keeping fit.

Similarly, Speroni, you always need a spare keeper. Why not go for one you can trust and know, rather than an unknown. We should also go in for Pickford as first choice, see 'Steve' or 'Hennesey' off.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 15 May 17 5.42pm

Largely who we release will be in relation to their contracts. It is the wages that are the crippling factor and not the fees. Players won't move unless they get a better offer. The wages are so high that fringe players will be happy to sit tight. I thought we did well in the last summer transfer under Pards as all the signings had real potential including Mandanda. Think we will do the same and bring in 4-5 new quality players with a few more leaving but not a major off load.

Edited by Booted Eagle (15 May 2017 5.43pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Aolcpfc Flag Finchley, London 15 May 17 7.46pm

Originally posted by ger20
Need a new CB, Possibly Sakho, need a new RB, and need a new striker or two, possibly Defoe, and one other. Sam will sell Ledley, Sako, Cambell, Delaney.

Players we need:
Keeper
Center back
RB cover/competition for Ward
Cover for Milio
Cover for Cayabe
Striker

Is Duncan Watmore worth a punt?

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 May 17 7.52pm

Originally posted by se25 rudy

A new number 10/creative midfielder must be a priority - I know Punch has his admirers on here but he's scored 0 goals this season. It's simply not good enough to have no goal threat from that position. Imagine how many more points we'd have if, for example, Sigurdsson played there instead of Puncheon.......

totally

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 May 17 7.54pm

Originally posted by Username

We need another centre half anyway though, at which point Delaney will be fifth choice, and at times he was dreadful this season.

He's lost it hasn't he? I mean, he is going on 36 and trying to mark 20 year olds, its expected...not every CB can play on to 37/38

 

YT Flag Oxford 15 May 17 7.55pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

We've discussed this before. This was my view a couple of weeks ago and I've not changed it.

Out of our current squad, who are nailed-on for the starting XI?

I'd suggest:

Tomkins
Van Aanholt
Luka
Cabaye
Zaha
Townsend
Benteke

There or thereabouts:

Hennessey
Schlupp
Dann
Ward
Wickham
Puncheon
McArthur
Kelly

In bold are those positions could do with an upgrade. The others need some competition.

Can't see any future for:

Mutch
Ledley
Lee
Campbell
Fryers
Mandanda
Sako
Delaney
Speroni
Flamini
Williams
J Benteke

Souare - impossible to say what will happen

Shrewd, CF, IMO. Not sure about the 'Analytical Bender' reaction from a subsequent poster, though. A tad harsh!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 15 May 17 11.40pm

I read today that Speroni and Delaney have signed new deals.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So who do we let go?