You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 16/17 Season review
November 16 2026 9.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

16/17 Season review


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 21 May 17 9.42pm

The team ran out of steam the season before. For the season just finished, we started with Benteke and Tomkins as the key improvements. Townsend was bought to replace Bolaise. Our net spend over the Summer was very low considering. We lost Soare and then Wickham soon after for the whole season and suffered many injuries in midfield.
In hindsight the squad was getting older and the additions were not enough. It took 4 quality signings in January to bring the squad up to scratch but it was too late by then to think about a top 10 finish.
I would be surprised if the owners expected more than a mid-table finish and we nearly managed that.

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 21 May 17 10.24pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

But it's just that; if's and buts. If we'd won that we would have had to suffer longer with Pardew with decreasing fitness and another transfer window to mess up the squad. The way things happened were the way things happened, we were in real danger of going down for a long stretch of the season, that's definitely not what the owners would have wanted at the start of the season and having spent a lot in the transfer window.

Lets just put it this way:
Pre-season target - Failed
Revised target after December - Achieved

Given where we were in December-January I'm happy where we've finished.


I'd agree with that, although I remember a preseason interview with Pardew where he said this would be a 'transitional' season; when pressed by the interviewer (may have been Lineker even?!) where would be an acceptable placing he said 15th. So we exceeded Pardew's lower-end target at least!

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 21 May 17 10.25pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

The team ran out of steam the season before. For the season just finished, we started with Benteke and Tomkins as the key improvements. Townsend was bought to replace Bolaise. Our net spend over the Summer was very low considering. We lost Soare and then Wickham soon after for the whole season and suffered many injuries in midfield.
In hindsight the squad was getting older and the additions were not enough. It took 4 quality signings in January to bring the squad up to scratch but it was too late by then to think about a top 10 finish.
I would be surprised if the owners expected more than a mid-table finish and we nearly managed that.

Agreed. Although, 14th is kinda midtable but I take your point.

 

Mad4palace Flag 21 May 17 10.26pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

The team ran out of steam the season before. For the season just finished, we started with Benteke and Tomkins as the key improvements. Townsend was bought to replace Bolaise. Our net spend over the Summer was very low considering. We lost Soare and then Wickham soon after for the whole season and suffered many injuries in midfield.
In hindsight the squad was getting older and the additions were not enough. It took 4 quality signings in January to bring the squad up to scratch but it was too late by then to think about a top 10 finish.
I would be surprised if the owners expected more than a mid-table finish and we nearly managed that.

Let's not forget the misstep that was Mandanda, Parish (I think on hol radio) has said that he was brought to the club to improve the build up from the back, the misstep was compounded by not getting any defensive midfielders comfortable on the ball, we were laughable at times during the first half of the season and our players were exposed from poorly thought out tactics and transfer policy.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 May 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme


I'd agree with that, although I remember a preseason interview with Pardew where he said this would be a 'transitional' season; when pressed by the interviewer (may have been Lineker even?!) where would be an acceptable placing he said 15th. So we exceeded Pardew's lower-end target at least!

With Pardew in charge for the rest of the season 15th would have been available only to business-class customers on Porkair flights.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Mad4palace Flag 21 May 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

Agreed. Although, 14th is kinda midtable but I take your point.

It's a mid table finish but arguably Watford and Burnley had better seasons because at no point did they look like they'd be going down.

 

deleted9 Flag 21 May 17 11.00pm

I am more than happy under the management of Sam. I feel a sense of security that I never felt under Pardew. What infuriates me is how close we were to a really decent finish of 8th and I can't help cast my mind back, like others have already said, to Burnley , Hull , Swansea , Watford , Sunderland (H), Swansea (H) when in my opinion we could have and should have gained more (13) points.

I believe Sam has proven himself in one transfer window and trust him to be clever with his summer signings. I'm hoping for Begivic, Ake, Sakho to bolster the back and simply add Defoe to our attacking options.

Roll on 2017/18!

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 21 May 17 11.01pm

6 points between 8th and 17th.


Fine margins and all that

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 21 May 17 11.11pm

Yes Alex we are safe with Sam. Not sure we're safe under him or we might not get off the ground again. Sam is a pro, as was Pulis. Pardew has a short skill and then it regresses.

 


COYP

RougeFish Flag 22 May 17 2.20am

I'd say "Recovered well".

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 22 May 17 2.34am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

It's a mid table finish but arguably Watford and Burnley had better seasons because at no point did they look like they'd be going down.

I agree with Burnley, but Watford would probably be disappointed; they have been shocking for a while now - once safety was all but assured really - and finished lower than they did last season.

But you're right in another sense... at the very start of the season I might have said '14th isn't great' but, 10 games in, I probably would have said 'snap your bloody hand off for that!' In isolation, 14th is actually fine and basically midtable. But our season does a feel a bit 'meh'. I wonder if beating Man Utd would have changed things? I remember when we made 10th and to do so we had to beat Swansea on the last day (I think?) that just felt great. Sure, 10th was good anyway, but we probably wouldn't have finished much higher than now had we not won. A league of fine margins really. Sure, Hull, Sunderland and Boro were clearly poorer than every one else (a BIG gap between 18th and 17th... bigger than from us to 8th!) but most of the bottom 13 are really not that dissimilar. West Brom supposedly had a great season but only got 4 more points than our 'meh' season. I guess it shows how much is down to context.

 

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 22 May 17 6.56am

It's been a crazy season all round.
We were screwed by Pardew and thankfully Big Sam dug us out of a gaping hole.
The season ended with the gap between 7th & 8th being bigger than the gap between 8th & 17th. Everton are in a mini league all of their own. LOL

Personally I think 14th is a fair finish given all that we went through. What many pundits failed to grasp as they slagged us off was the level of injuries we were dealing with. Had our fitness been better it may have been a different season, so here's hoping for Big Sam's revolution.

My only grumble is that there were too many games in which we simply lacked passion and desire and that is not acceptable. If I could change one thing it would be to rid us of that mentality.

Overall I'm happy with survival and 14th.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 22 May 17 8.12am

Generally a very poor season with a couple of highlights in the run in. Big Sam got us out of a real hole but for sure another season like that and we'll not get out of trouble. Saying that I'm not expecting a Big Sam team, if backed by SP, to be in trouble.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

YT Flag Oxford 22 May 17 9.00am

Originally posted by sa_eagle


We were screwed by Pardew and thankfully Big Sam dug us out of a gaping hole.


Oooh err missus.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 22 May 17 9.02am

Originally posted by YT

Oooh err missus.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 9.08am

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

I agree with Burnley, but Watford would probably be disappointed; they have been shocking for a while now - once safety was all but assured really - and finished lower than they did last season.

But you're right in another sense... at the very start of the season I might have said '14th isn't great' but, 10 games in, I probably would have said 'snap your bloody hand off for that!' In isolation, 14th is actually fine and basically midtable. But our season does a feel a bit 'meh'. I wonder if beating Man Utd would have changed things? I remember when we made 10th and to do so we had to beat Swansea on the last day (I think?) that just felt great. Sure, 10th was good anyway, but we probably wouldn't have finished much higher than now had we not won. A league of fine margins really. Sure, Hull, Sunderland and Boro were clearly poorer than every one else (a BIG gap between 18th and 17th... bigger than from us to 8th!) but most of the bottom 13 are really not that dissimilar. West Brom supposedly had a great season but only got 4 more points than our 'meh' season. I guess it shows how much is down to context.

14th isn't 'basically' mid table. It's bottom third.

Don't kid yourself. We were never in a comfortable place the watfords etc were because of the damage Pardew did. It's like Arsenal fans crowing they finished above Spurs last season yet there was only one team challenging Leicester last season and that was Spurs. Look at Spurs and Arsenal now. We won't go backwards though because Sam is a professional. We will go forwards so we can all relax and hope the squad will get closer to having 20+ players who can actually produce 7+ performances in the premier league every week rather that Mutch etc.

 


COYP

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 22 May 17 9.14am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

It's a mid table finish but arguably Watford and Burnley had better seasons because at no point did they look like they'd be going down.

To a degree but since SA took over we have gained more points than them so the start under Pardew was clearly our (near) downfall. In fact, since the loss to Chelski in December we have picked up more points than:

Sunderland
Boro
Burnley
Watford
Stoke
West Brom
Bournemouth
Southampton

We got the same as West Ham & Hull so, if the season ran from the time Sam took over we'd be 11th thanks to goal difference.

Overall. I'd rather have not gone through all the s***e however, it's left me feeling much more positive about next season. Anything above 14th would be a step forward but there's no harm in aiming for top 10.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 May 17 9.43am

What nobbybm said ^^^^.

 


COYP

ItsCPFCforme Flag 22 May 17 1.03pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

14th isn't 'basically' mid table. It's bottom third.

Don't kid yourself. We were never in a comfortable place the watfords etc were because of the damage Pardew did. It's like Arsenal fans crowing they finished above Spurs last season yet there was only one team challenging Leicester last season and that was Spurs. Look at Spurs and Arsenal now. We won't go backwards though because Sam is a professional. We will go forwards so we can all relax and hope the squad will get closer to having 20+ players who can actually produce 7+ performances in the premier league every week rather that Mutch etc.

We basically agree really; it is really about context. Had we beaten UTD we may have finished 11th or 12th say but that doesn't suddenly make our season that much better. But I do think Watford fans wouldn't be THAT happy with their season (beyond not getting relegated).

And yeah you're right I guess about 'bottom third'' but we are top of that league of 7 that Sam referred to earlier in the season. Still, need to do better next season.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 22 May 17 1.35pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Some alternative season stats:

9th Highest scorers (50)
8th Highest Wins (12)
11th Best GD (-13)
6 of our 7 clean sheets have come under Allardyce
We finish with a 1.08 points ratio per game; 1.24 under Allardyce, that ratio would have given us 47 points over a season. Pardew was on 0.88 this season when he was sacked.

I think you forgot to mention 11 home defeats =19th

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 16/17 Season review