You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Great Academy or a neglected one
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Great Academy or a neglected one


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Dan89 Flag Se25 28 Jun 17 6.16pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

As people have said. It's pretty difficult to give youngsters time during religated battles.

Currently our back up to Puncheon is Lee. I would prefer to give Williams a go.

I'd also like Kaikai to be given preference over Sako.

With Lesley gone maybe Boateng will get a chance.

If we bring in 4 to 6. This stops the progression of the youth. The main question is our Crystal Palace youngster good enough or is it there not being given a chance.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 28 Jun 17 6.22pm

Steve parish was waxing lirecal about the academy. While I understand that it's far difficult to play younger players in the prem. Even the likes of Zaha and Williams came through under Simon Jordan tenure as chairman. The reality is our academy is not good enough, because if your good enough, your old enough. I'd love to be proved wrong but can you really see the likes of Williams getting in the side. When there's about 4 players ahead of him already and will be more if new recruits join. The perfect example last season, we have a left back problem with soaure accident. Why didn't we try an academy left back, couldn't of done worse than what ward, Kelly did in that position.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 28 Jun 17 6.46pm

Originally posted by Dan89

If we bring in 4 to 6. This stops the progression of the youth. The main question is our Crystal Palace youngster good enough or is it there not being given a chance.

Parish recently said he feels we have up to three midfielders who may be able to break through and he didnt want to block there progress by buying players in there positions.

I'd imagine FdB will make his own mind up once he's had some time reviewing them.

With that being said it wouldn't suprise me if no new midfielders joined in this window. Although personally I think we could do with a play maker.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 28 Jun 17 6.54pm

Originally posted by Johnny Byrne

Be interesting to see if our youngsters make the first team squad.

Joniesta
Anderson
Ladapo
KaiKai
Boateng
Wan-Bissaka
Flanagan
Kirby
Dreher

Interesting pre season looms.

Dreyer's the one I feel could make the breakthrough. Think he has a big future.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Jun 17 6.56pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Parish recently said he feels we have up to three midfielders who may be able to break through and he didnt want to block there progress by buying players in there positions.

I'd imagine FdB will make his own mind up once he's had some time reviewing them.

With that being said it wouldn't suprise me if no new midfielders joined in this window. Although personally I think we could do with a play maker.

Yes I agree.

Perhaps Will Hughes might have been a good signing at £7.5 Mill but of course he has no PL experience.
We need a 'Jonjo Shelvey'.
Not been impressed at all with Puncheon last seaason.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 28 Jun 17 7.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I agree.

Perhaps Will Hughes might have been a good signing at £7.5 Mill but of course he has no PL experience.
We need a 'Jonjo Shelvey'.
Not been impressed at all with Puncheon last seaason.

Puncheon not to score a single goal in last season is terrible. Personally think we need 2 midfielders. After losing Ledley and flamini. If Luka gets a long term injury, then we have no first team defensive mid.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

GladAllOver27 Flag 28 Jun 17 8.48pm

Question- should Gary `Issot be shown the door. In a new revamp in the academy structure.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 28 Jun 17 9.10pm

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

Question- should Gary `Issot be shown the door

Wow - he's been with us all this time and he still doesn't know how to get in

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 28 Jun 17 9.43pm

When in the Championship, within a few years of one another we produced Watson, Soares, Borrowdale, Wilf, Clyne, Moses, Williams and Bostock and at that stage our academy was being talked about as being one of the most productive in the country. However, with the benefit of hindsight, it's only really Zaha, Moses and Clyne who have done anything of note (Watson to a lesser degree). Is that enough over a ten year period for a club with relatively little competition in South East London? Not so sure.

Would be extremely happy if we invested heavily in the academy, as fun as marquee signings are, the fans will always take a local player to heart.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jun 17 10.18pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

When in the Championship, within a few years of one another we produced Watson, Soares, Borrowdale, Wilf, Clyne, Moses, Williams and Bostock and at that stage our academy was being talked about as being one of the most productive in the country. However, with the benefit of hindsight, it's only really Zaha, Moses and Clyne who have done anything of note (Watson to a lesser degree). Is that enough over a ten year period for a club with relatively little competition in South East London? Not so sure.

Would be extremely happy if we invested heavily in the academy, as fun as marquee signings are, the fans will always take a local player to heart.

Fulham were treading into our territory picking up players during their long stint in the prem. And that wasn't just London boroughs but also Redhill postcodes. Now Brighton are venturing into that area. Really we should be aiming to get the best lads right down to Horley, but we aren't. Not only Arsenal pick up the best but smaller clubs have been picking up the next best.

If we can't do that then it's always an uphill battle. We need the best to play the laws of probability. It's not enough to sign up the best in the old Shirley league which I think is now the Tandridge 'A' league and the best in the few borough teams around us, and I bet they're shared between the usual suspects. We should start having a more proactive and, dare I say it, a more aggressive recruiting policy like Southampton. It's what Man Utd did before they recruited 'the class of 92.' I'm not saying that can be done again in the premier league today, but it could give us an edge over the bottom half and save and make a lot of money at some point in time.

If Parish is reading this then it is something that could do with addressing. But I guess we need category A status first as a selling point when a scout speaks to kid, parents and his coach after the match they've been watched in.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (28 Jun 2017 10.20pm)

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Jun 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

When in the Championship, within a few years of one another we produced Watson, Soares, Borrowdale, Wilf, Clyne, Moses, Williams and Bostock and at that stage our academy was being talked about as being one of the most productive in the country. However, with the benefit of hindsight, it's only really Zaha, Moses and Clyne who have done anything of note (Watson to a lesser degree). Is that enough over a ten year period for a club with relatively little competition in South East London? Not so sure.

Would be extremely happy if we invested heavily in the academy, as fun as marquee signings are, the fans will always take a local player to heart.

It's a romantic idea, that we put youngsters in the first team, but in reality it ain't going to happen. It doesn't matter how good the academy is, it's just to bigger jump in standard. The only possible way they can ever get in the first team now is by going on loan in the lower leagues and impressing against older players, not other youngsters.
Look at England U23s, outclassed by the Germans who had 40 shots on goal, these were the top U23s we have and hardly any play in their clubs first team regularly.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 28 Jun 17 10.38pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Fulham were treading into our territory picking up players during their long stint in the prem. And that wasn't just London boroughs but also Redhill postcodes. Now Brighton are venturing into that area. Really we should be aiming to get the best lads right down to Horley, but we aren't. Not only Arsenal pick up the best but smaller clubs have been picking up the next best.

If we can't do that then it's always an uphill battle. We need the best to play the laws of probability. It's not enough to sign up the best in the old Shirley league which I think is now the Tandridge 'A' league and the best in the few borough teams around us, and I bet they're shared between the usual suspects. We should start having a more proactive and, dare I say it, a more aggressive recruiting policy like Southampton. It's what Man Utd did before they recruited 'the class of 92.' I'm not saying that can be done again in the premier league today, but it could give us an edge over the bottom half and save and make a lot of money at some point in time.

If Parish is reading this then it is something that could do with addressing. But I guess we need category A status first as a selling point when a scout speaks to kid, parents and his coach after the match they've been watched in.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (28 Jun 2017 10.20pm)


Yeah, some good points there. I reckon there is room for us between Arsenal and the smaller clubs though. If we could develop a state of the art academy and also demonstrate that we are willing to give young players a real chance in our matchday squads, no reason we couldn't start nicking some of them from under Arsenal's nose. I'd really like to see us fighting for some of the best young players about in the Championship and League 1 as well, the rise of Alli has shown how rewarding that can be.

As an aside, I read a fairly interesting article earlier about how even Real Madrid are largely abandoning the Galacticos era to concentrate on young players now...

[Link]

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 28 Jun 17 10.49pm

Originally posted by Painter

It's a romantic idea, that we put youngsters in the first team, but in reality it ain't going to happen. It doesn't matter how good the academy is, it's just to bigger jump in standard. The only possible way they can ever get in the first team now is by going on loan in the lower leagues and impressing against older players, not other youngsters.
Look at England U23s, outclassed by the Germans who had 40 shots on goal, these were the top U23s we have and hardly any play in their clubs first team regularly.


Don't forget that we have several players who qualified to play in that tournament but are now attached to the senior side. We could have put out a stronger 11 and we've actually performed better overall than anyone in youth football this summer.

There are plenty of young players who have been bought or promoted to the first teams of bigger clubs than us in the league; Rashford, Davies, Pickford, Sterling, Alli, Kane and have performed admirably. We might not have these types of players in our academy at the moment but with the right investment and management I don't see why we shouldn't in the future. If we produce a single one and flog them to City for £30 million after a season then it pays for itself.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (28 Jun 2017 10.52pm)

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

HeathMan Flag Purley 28 Jun 17 11.26pm

Two considerations

Staying in PL this season

Being in PL in five years' time.

As many have said players who might break through can be regarded as poor against first team players. I am looking forward to going home after seeing introductions without worries - who can freely express themselves. Three up at 65 minutes is a suitable indication for a youngster to come on, and impress.

COYP

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 29 Jun 17 9.02am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

When in the Championship, within a few years of one another we produced Watson, Soares, Borrowdale, Wilf, Clyne, Moses, Williams and Bostock and at that stage our academy was being talked about as being one of the most productive in the country. However, with the benefit of hindsight, it's only really Zaha, Moses and Clyne who have done anything of note (Watson to a lesser degree). Is that enough over a ten year period for a club with relatively little competition in South East London? Not so sure.

Would be extremely happy if we invested heavily in the academy, as fun as marquee signings are, the fans will always take a local player to heart.

I would say anyone who plays in the premier league regularly (injury permitting) has made it. And Watson scored the winner in the fa cup final.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 29 Jun 17 9.18am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


Don't forget that we have several players who qualified to play in that tournament but are now attached to the senior side. We could have put out a stronger 11 and we've actually performed better overall than anyone in youth football this summer.

There are plenty of young players who have been bought or promoted to the first teams of bigger clubs than us in the league; Rashford, Davies, Pickford, Sterling, Alli, Kane and have performed admirably. We might not have these types of players in our academy at the moment but with the right investment and management I don't see why we shouldn't in the future. If we produce a single one and flog them to City for £30 million after a season then it pays for itself.

Edited by Canterbury Palace (28 Jun 2017 10.52pm)

That's only 6 players you have named, 4 of which didn't play in U23 tournament, Spain has all its best U23s playing. We just don't take youngsters seriously.
What's the point of us investing time and money to produce a player then sell them for £30m if we're lucky. How does that help the team?

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 29 Jun 17 10.23am

None of Kai Kai, Williams or Boateng are good enough. All it takes is too look at how average they have been on loan to league 1 sides and you can see why they've never got their chance in the PL. You have to be good enough to earn it.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 29 Jun 17 10.44am

Originally posted by Painter

That's only 6 players you have named, 4 of which didn't play in U23 tournament, Spain has all its best U23s playing. We just don't take youngsters seriously.
What's the point of us investing time and money to produce a player then sell them for £30m if we're lucky. How does that help the team?

If you're talking international level, I don't agree. Big progress has been made over the last few years and, as a result, we've done exceptionally well across the varying age groups this summer.

We lost the U17 European Championship final, won the Toulon tournament, won the U20 world cup and reached the U21 semi-finals. Both of the losses were on penalties. No other side can claim that level of success. We're also 2nd favourites for the U19 Euros so should do well in that.

Regarding the second highlighted quote, the point is that it is the only way we can possibly compete in the long term. Southampton and Tottenham have both enjoyed tremendous success in recent years on the back of developing young players that they have either bought from lower leagues/abroad or plucked from their academies. Whether they have permanently integrated them in their first team or sold them on for huge profits and subsequently used that money to strengthen again, they have grown stronger and stronger. It is exactly the model we should be looking to emulate.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

jeeagles Flag 30 Jun 17 8.36am

Originally posted by steven_t92

None of Kai Kai, Williams or Boateng are good enough. All it takes is too look at how average they have been on loan to league 1 sides and you can see why they've never got their chance in the PL. You have to be good enough to earn it.

That's a view shared by lots of people and I see your point.

In my view they don't have to come into the 1st XI and set the world on fire, some just need to be good enough to come in as cover for injuries and put in a half decent performance every now and then.

That way we can concentrate on buying one or two real quality players who can improve the starting team without needing to divert funds signing squad players.

A bit of first team exposure would probably boost the value of the youngsters too, so if they don't make it we can still get some cash when they move on....which again can then be spent on paying for quality players to take the club forward.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 30 Jun 17 9.05am

Originally posted by est1905

Our lack of youngsters coming through more or less coincides with our promotion to the Premiership. The pressure on all clubs to win is enormous. Playing an untried youngster is a massive risk. Kaikai has done very well on loan but is he ready to make the step up to the Prem? On sub appearances I would say its a difficult one to call but probably not.
I'm sure I am right in saying our academy gets more investment now than it ever has year on year. Problem is those youngsters have to be so much better than when we were in the Championship in order to get a chance. Under Frank I cannot see too much changing too soon. Yes he wants to bring kids through but his brief is to keep us well away from the relegation zone. Blooding youngsters when you need points and are under pressure to win is not smart.

Exactly! Good post

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Great Academy or a neglected one