You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back


Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 Jul 17 9.11pm

Which academy products though. Who is actually good enough to play for the first team at the moment. Maybe Kaikai is just about good enough to make the bench, maybe. That's about it. We all want our academy to have a pathway to the first team but they just are not good enough. If Boateng can't establish himself as a top player at Northampton Town he is hardly going to boss the midfield of the PL. MacArthur is a proven quantity and a quality squad player. We are not going to find much better to come off the bench and I highly doubt we would get anywhere close to 11 million for him.

Lesley and Flamini have gone. We can't afford to let anyone go in the middle until we have cover. It would be a direct copy paste of the mistakes of the last season when we failed to replace Jedi.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 9.16pm

Originally posted by moylerg

...no need to buy him, already ours, the question was should we sell him. Which I answered. Is Delboy from Sydney? Swear that was Peckham.

Sketch from only fools and horses. Buy,buy,
Rodney sell, sell,sell

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 9.20pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Which academy products though. Who is actually good enough to play for the first team at the moment. Maybe Kaikai is just about good enough to make the bench, maybe. That's about it. We all want our academy to have a pathway to the first team but they just are not good enough. If Boateng can't establish himself as a top player at Northampton Town he is hardly going to boss the midfield of the PL. MacArthur is a proven quantity and a quality squad player. We are not going to find much better to come off the bench and I highly doubt we would get anywhere close to 11 million for him.

Lesley and Flamini have gone. We can't afford to let anyone go in the middle until we have cover. It would be a direct copy paste of the mistakes of the last season when we failed to replace Jedi.

Of course we need to replace him but if we can use the funds to put towards ziyech for instance a number 10 and get m'villa for 6m. Then it's good business sense. We would of never been able to buy Benteke, if it wasn't for the sale of bolaise. Do I think boateng good enough, probably not but when I saw him play against Swansea 2 seasons ago, he looked good.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 01 Jul 17 9.24pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Sketch from only fools and horses. Buy,buy,
Rodney sell, sell,sell

Sorry, with you now mate, was a bit woooooshed

 


Most certainly not European.

Sussex fella Flag Haywards Heath 01 Jul 17 9.30pm

Jimmy Mac is a great guy who tries hard every week. If we are going to shake off midfield players surely Sako, Chungy & Mutch must go first

 

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 01 Jul 17 9.32pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Yeah that what he done in 2016. It's time the academy product are given a pathway to the first team. In 2017 he was shocking bad. I was disappointed when we sold jedinak last summer but 12m for a jimmy mac, sub makes total sense to sell. He's not an out and out defensive mid or a attacking mid.

Edited by Dan89 (01 Jul 2017 8.58pm)

He was poor in 2017 because he wasn't fit and was used because we were light and in deep trouble , a big reason we have struggled for the last year is because of squad depth ,when injuries occur to certain players , it was so obvious the difference under sam when we had dann , McCarthur , schlupp/van aanholt to bring on in games.

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 01 Jul 17 9.33pm

Of course, we would replace him if sold. What we currently got in midfield. Also if a number 10 is bought in.
Current Cm- attacking & defensive- Luka,punch,Cabaye, boateng, Williams, chungy and mcarthur.

If we got defensive mid like Kirchhoff- free transfer to be Luka replacement and decent attacking mid. Then would we need mcarthur.

If we had to lose mcarthur or Cabaye? Who would you sell?

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 01 Jul 17 9.36pm

Originally posted by Sussex fella

Jimmy Mac is a great guy who tries hard every week. If we are going to shake off midfield players surely Sako, Chungy & Mutch must go first

I agree fella but no one wants the players you listed. Also you lucky to get 5m for those 3. Mcarthur 29, sometimes you need to risk selling a player to potentially get better. What if we now had enough funds for Sakho, plus to sign other players.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

matthau Flag South Croydon 01 Jul 17 9.39pm

Ultimately Mccarthur can't play cam or Dmc that well. He's a cm and a player that doesn't give the opposition a moments peace. However. In a fdb side that wants to start playing continental football... I'm not sure he can offer that much.

Plus I think big Sam had ideas on selling him too. Cabaye offers a much better range of passing and go threat so you'd keep cabaye.

Edited by matthau (01 Jul 2017 9.45pm)

 

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 01 Jul 17 9.47pm

Originally posted by matthau

Ultimately Mccarthur can't play cam or Dmc that well. He's a cm and a player that doesn't give the opposition a moments peace. However. In a fdb side that wants to start playing continental football... I'm not sure he can offer that much.

Plus I think big Sam had ideas on selling him too. Cabaye offers a much better range of passing and go threat so you'd keep cabaye.

Edited by matthau (01 Jul 2017 9.45pm)

The way, you describing is the way Sam used him. To see out games in the last 20 minutes. Definitely should sell as long , we recoup at least 10m.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

slubglurge Flag welling 01 Jul 17 10.14pm

FdB says he has done his homework. If he has he will surely sell Macca at that price. Hes not first choice anymore and had some alarmingly poor games last season.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 01 Jul 17 10.20pm

I know his form dropped off but I would seriously hope he'd be back to normal soon, he was our best player by far in my opinion.

Its a no from me, we can't afford to make too many changes at once besides it would be foolish to write off an international class player.

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Jul 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Yeah that what he done in 2016. It's time the academy product are given a pathway to the first team. In 2017 he was shocking bad. I was disappointed when we sold jedinak last summer but 12m for a jimmy mac, sub makes total sense to sell. He's not an out and out defensive mid or a attacking mid.

Edited by Dan89 (01 Jul 2017 8.58pm)

Have you ever seen any of the academy players play..... I thought not.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Have you ever seen any of the academy players play..... I thought not.

While their not setting the world alight. There needs to be a pathway. A club like Palace needs to recoup funds every summer. We can't spend 40m to 50m a summer , without recouping some back.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

weaselpop Flag Southeast London and damn proud of... 01 Jul 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

He's average? What does that make boateng. A player that has played once or twice for us and has failed to set league one alight and isn't even championship standard. This is what I mean about us being short of cover and relying on those who are not good enough. As for his best position, he is an absolute terrier in the middle of the park and can let Lula boss the space in front of the defence and set cabaye free behind the strikers. He has an incredible engine and reads the game well and if we are playing a high press recovery of the ball style, we have no one better in the squad at pressuring players in to mistakes.

Absolutely spot on! I'm sick of people wanting to junk good players on the basis of some recent bad form (which has affected the whole team, btw).

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 01 Jul 17 10.31pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

Have you ever seen any of the academy players play..... I thought not.

What's the point of an academy then. Yes the academy needs restructuring, how will we ever produce the next Zaha. If these players aren't given a shot.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 01 Jul 17 10.37pm

We got good service but we need to move on. Too much sentiment in football. 12m for someone who has 12 months left. Crazy not to sell. But I love mcarthur, as long as a adequate replacement found. I don't see the drama.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

GladAllOver27 Flag 01 Jul 17 10.45pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

No way, we saw what happened when we sold Jedi, we were woefully short of cover in the middle of the park. We need a 25 of players who can all do a job. The fat we want to trim are people like Lee and Sako who don't ever contribute to the squad. MacArthur can still do a job and he proved this as he had his most productive season with regards to goals and assists last season.

No one wants sako and lee. If another player comes in. Where the big deal. If we bring in a player that starts in the first team. Then he better than Jimmy mac.

Edited by GladAllOver27 (01 Jul 2017 10.45pm)

Edited by GladAllOver27 (01 Jul 2017 10.46pm)

 

Pinkfluff1981 Flag 01 Jul 17 10.51pm

Macca was a great player and it's a shame of the injury. You gotta be cruel in business and are business is to have the best possible squad we can. Sadly that means selling and re investing the money towards a better replacement.

 

jason7 Flag croydon 01 Jul 17 10.59pm

Players that fight for the team, throw there body's on the line, that is who we need. Jimmy mac is one of those, we see to many teams struggling down at the bottom because the players don't have the fight in them.keep him , because when we need battelers you can count on James.

 

Page 2 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sell Jimmy Mac, he ain't coming back