This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by leejaneagles
I think your comment was a little reactionary and ludicrous. On the face of it, you are saying we spent 3 years to get a 15 goal striker and now we have one, we shouldn't let him go. I agree with you mostly on this point. But why would we replace them with Jerome and Bamford? That wasn't Hastings suggestion at all. If Benteke cannot play possession football (I'm not saying he definitely can't) then he's not a 15 goal a season striker anymore. Fair enough, neither are Bamford or Doyle but that wasn't suggested and presumably if we sold Benteke we'd definitely be getting in a top striker for the new tactics. As the original post in this topic is how would we free up funds for De Boer, it's not outrageous to say sell our 30 mil striker to free up a lot of money to get a striker he prefers. Of course Benteke won't go anyway, so don't worry too much. Exactly. I never once suggested going back to playing the likes of Jerome or Doyle. Benteke would not have ended up on 15 goals had Big Sam not come in and changed our style of play to something that suited him. That is not a style of play that I think FDB will adopt. At one point Benteke was being linked with a 40 - 50 million pound move to China, who's to say we couldn't replace him with Iheaneacho and Batshyuai.
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!! |
|
|
Originally posted by hastingseagle67
Exactly. I never once suggested going back to playing the likes of Jerome or Doyle. Benteke would not have ended up on 15 goals had Big Sam not come in and changed our style of play to something that suited him. That is not a style of play that I think FDB will adopt. At one point Benteke was being linked with a 40 - 50 million pound move to China, who's to say we couldn't replace him with Iheaneacho and Batshyuai. Who are both unproven at prem level. Who have a handful of games between them. Iheanacho - prem record 12 goals in 46 games (over 2 seasons) Benteke prem record- villa 101 games 49 goals I'm glad your not the manager. Selling Benteke. Would be the biggest backward step we've made. Edited by CPFC/SCCC (04 Jul 2017 12.52pm)
Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat |
|
|
Originally posted by hastingseagle67
Exactly. I never once suggested going back to playing the likes of Jerome or Doyle. Benteke would not have ended up on 15 goals had Big Sam not come in and changed our style of play to something that suited him. That is not a style of play that I think FDB will adopt. At one point Benteke was being linked with a 40 - 50 million pound move to China, who's to say we couldn't replace him with Iheaneacho and Batshyuai. I disagree with that bit. What you have to realise is Benteke had been at Liverpool for a season where he played a bit part and most of his limited minutes were from the bench. The first half of the season compared to the second half were two different Bentekes. He got match fitness, match sharpness and confidence back which as much as we'd like to say, he's a professional footballer so should turn it on instantly, just doesn't happen and takes time. I fully expect Benteke to have a better season, having had a full season under his belt last year playing regularly. It's the same with Begovic, I would expect he'll be a tad rusty for half the season at Bournemouth having sat on Chelsea's bench for 2 years.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CPFC/SCCC
Well why come out with such a ludicrous comment. What I trying to say is it took years to find a forward to get into double figures in terms of league goals. It's extremely unlikely that we'd sell Benteke after spending the best part of all summer. Trying to convince him to come. 15+ goal striker are hard to find ask West Ham and stoke and many other mid table teams. That full stop after the word summer, killed me. Edited by matthau (04 Jul 2017 12.50pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
That full stop after the word summer, killed me. Edited by matthau (04 Jul 2017 12.50pm) I edited it now. Thanks mr.matthau Edited by CPFC/SCCC (04 Jul 2017 1.09pm)
Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat |
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
That full stop after the word summer, killed me. Then how can you post if you're dead?
|
|
|
Originally posted by hastingseagle67
I like Benteke, and I felt sorry for him when loads of Palace fans criticised him for lack of effort, when clearly we were not playing to his strengths. I fear the same is going to happen this season with the way we play. Selling Benteke to bring in one or two top quality players to suit FDB's system would be an option. As in the title of the thread. Correct me if I wrong but de Boer used a target man striker at Ajax in Milik. Millik style is a target man he got 23 goals in 34 games under de Boer. Edited by Dan89 (04 Jul 2017 1.41pm)
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football |
|
|
Originally posted by hastingseagle67
I like Benteke, and I felt sorry for him when loads of Palace fans criticised him for lack of effort, when clearly we were not playing to his strengths. I fear the same is going to happen this season with the way we play. Selling Benteke to bring in one or two top quality players to suit FDB's system would be an option. As in the title of the thread. Agree with this.
|
|
|
Originally posted by elky30
Agree with this. You would swap Benteke for iheanacho and Sakho. Ha ha
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football |
|
|
Originally posted by Dan89
You would swap Benteke for iheanacho and Sakho. Ha ha Agreed. We take all the risk but we won't benefit if there is a reward. Edited by Bexley Eagle (04 Jul 2017 3.30pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by aquickgame2
Yeah I liked that too
|
|
|
Originally posted by elky30
probably saving over 100k a month on salaries after all the players have been released. Could sell: We couldn't replace all these players in the time available and the money raised wouldn't be enough. We have already released 6 from the squad we have yet to replace. Parrot
Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello" |
|
|
Originally posted by hastingseagle67
I like Benteke, and I felt sorry for him when loads of Palace fans criticised him for lack of effort, when clearly we were not playing to his strengths. I fear the same is going to happen this season with the way we play. Selling Benteke to bring in one or two top quality players to suit FDB's system would be an option. As in the title of the thread. Selling your only fit striker and top scorer isn't a very prudent move to avoid relegation. I cannot believe anyone would suggest such a move, then think we can bring in cheaper players to replace him. Strikers are at a premium, as there aren't many that are any good at this level, every team is searching for them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Selling your only fit striker and top scorer isn't a very prudent move to avoid relegation. I cannot believe anyone would suggest such a move, then think we can bring in cheaper players to replace him. Strikers are at a premium, as there aren't many that are any good at this level, every team is searching for them. Finally a sensible Palace fan. We already need 4 or 5 players. Why would we weaken our squad to then replace with 2 more risks. One thing you can guarantee with Benteke is he will score at this level.
Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat |
|
|
Centre backs are very injury prone and collect lots of cards,I think four c.b.'s and a utility defender are required.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CPFC/SCCC
Finally a sensible Palace fan. We already need 4 or 5 players. Why would we weaken our squad to then replace with 2 more risks. One thing you can guarantee with Benteke is he will score at this level. It's all about opinions isn't it. I really hope I'm proved wrong and Benteke flourishes under FDB, but having seen the way he struggled at the end of Pardew's "transition" experiment, I have concerns. The thread asked who would be best to sell, and considering the style of play I expect us to adopt, and the money we could demand for him, I consider Benteke to be an option to move on. Chelsea and City tend to buy some of the best young strikers in Europe and then don't play them. I think people soon forget how good some of these young second string players actually are.
has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!! |
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
Benteke has already mentioned took time for him to get used to having less possession. Cos we play counter attacking football. Whenever he plays for Belgium they played pass and move. As did Liverpool whenever he played. As he did also with villa. Yes they popped it up to him a few times but villa are certainly not famous for direct play. So hell be absolutely fine The criticism at Liverpool was they didn't get it to him early enough. Not to random parts of his body but just drilled to his feet when there was nobody in front of him blocking the pass. He would be an option 6 times before it was knocked around looking for a runner to collect a pass. I suppose Rogers signed him and not Klopp so wasn't going to adapt to one player, but still, ignore a dangerous player for possession in front of 11 players?
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.