You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-4-3 Do we have the players
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3-4-3 Do we have the players


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Username Flag Horsham 25 Jul 17 6.51am

Originally posted by beak

I find the insistence on 3-4-3 rather odd! A new manager comes to a club,he looks at the players he has and then (with a few weeks to the start of the season)works out the best formation that those players will fit into.If a manager is fond of a particular formation he uses the whole of the next summer break to get the players in that suit that system,this to me is obvious and FDB may have a very rude awakening.

We've been playing 4-5-1 for years now.

There is absolutely no need to spend preseason games using a formation that the players, at this stage, could most likely prepare for by themselves. Much better to spend time trying something out that might fix the problems we've had against teams in the bottom half at home.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 7.01am

Originally posted by Username

We've been playing 4-5-1 for years now.

There is absolutely no need to spend preseason games using a formation that the players, at this stage, could most likely prepare for by themselves. Much better to spend time trying something out that might fix the problems we've had against teams in the bottom half at home.

The central cb has to act as a sweeper in 3 back formation, like Luiz at Chelsea. If we persuaded Sakho he'd play there.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jul 17 7.14am

Originally posted by Dan89

Conte blueprint

[Link]

My opinion is that dann and Tomkins are to similar to be affective together.

It's worth noting some of the warnings in that article:

"A 3-4-3 is an infamously tricky formation to sustain for an extended period of time. Few sides have ever truly realised its potential"

"Many other managers who have tried to make use of it have ultimately seen its demands for high-energy, especially from the players deployed at wing-back and in central midfield lead to burn out, injuries and disarray"

"Without the right personnel it is unsustainable and unwise to try"

Let's hope we're not biting off more than we can chew.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 7.21am

Originally posted by bexleydave

It's worth noting some of the warnings in that article:

"A 3-4-3 is an infamously tricky formation to sustain for an extended period of time. Few sides have ever truly realised its potential"

"Many other managers who have tried to make use of it have ultimately seen its demands for high-energy, especially from the players deployed at wing-back and in central midfield lead to burn out, injuries and disarray"

"Without the right personnel it is unsustainable and unwise to try"

Let's hope we're not biting off more than we can chew.

In this 3-4-3 taking Chelsea for example at club doing it well. First you need a goalie that can distribute well, a central centre back that acts as sweeper prepared to bring the ball out from the back. There's to many specialists positions in this formation that we currently haven't got.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jul 17 7.46am

Originally posted by Dan89

In this 3-4-3 taking Chelsea for example at club doing it well. First you need a goalie that can distribute well, a central centre back that acts as sweeper prepared to bring the ball out from the back. There's to many specialists positions in this formation that we currently haven't got.


I agree, which begs the question, why would a manager. looking at our current squad, conclude that it's the ideal formation for us? I sincerely hope that we're not the subject of someone's vanity experiment.

That article suggests that, apart from Chelsea, 3-4-3 has only been successfully deployed by Cruyff's Barcelona. Barcelona, Chelsea and Crystal Palace; with the best will in the world they're not three names you expect to hear in one sentence.


Edited by bexleydave (25 Jul 2017 8.08am)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Dan89 Flag Se25 25 Jul 17 7.52am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I agree, which begs the question, why would a manager. looking at out current squad, conclude that it's the ideal formation for us? I sincerely hope that we're not the subject of someone's vanity experiment.

That article suggests that, apart from Chelsea, 3-4-3 has only been successfully deployed by Cruyff's Barcelona. Barcelona, Chelsea and Crystal Palace; with the best will in the world they're not three names you expect to hear in one sentence.

I agree, we haven't even got a first eleven to do it successful, let alone if we had a similar injury problem to last season. We haven't got sufficient replacements, unless de Boer gonna be seriously backed in the market.

Edited by Dan89 (25 Jul 2017 7.53am)

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Midlands Eagle Flag 25 Jul 17 7.56am

Originally posted by bexleydave


I agree, which begs the question, why would a manager. looking at out current squad, conclude that it's the ideal formation for us? I sincerely hope that we're not the subject of someone's vanity experiment.

I would like to have been a fly on the wall during the initial discussions between SP and FdB

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jul 17 8.30am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I would like to have been a fly on the wall during the initial discussions between SP and FdB


Indeed. I hope that there was more to it than two egos inebriated with the exuberance of their own verbosity (to slightly misquote someone or other).

If you put the available evidence together, SP wants a more attractive style of football that also produces results (Pardew's transition, with nobs on, if you like). FdB says you have practically everything you need here already in your current squad and if you made better use of your academy, with a few low cost (i.e. young and unproven) additions.

Now that would be music to SP's ears and would give FdB a chance to try to realise an ambition to repeat Cruyff's achievements with the 3-4-3 when at Barcelona. IF that's the case, it'll be fantastic if it works, but disastrous if it doesn't. Only time will tell, so I suppose we just sit back and see what happens

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 25 Jul 17 8.39am

You lads all seem to think that the 343 is rigid.
It's not .
It's fluid,when where up against it ,we will obviously be 541 or all back !!!!
Frank will make us difficult to beat and will get the best out of Wilf,Christian and Andros.
PS Chelsea changed there system after several defeats early last season.
Enabling them to get the best out of Victor Moses.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 25 Jul 17 8.44am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

You lads all seem to think that the 343 is rigid.
It's not .
It's fluid,when where up against it ,we will obviously be 541 or all back !!!!
Frank will make us difficult to beat and will get the best out of Wilf,Christian and Andros.
PS Chelsea changed there system after several defeats early last season.
Enabling them to get the best out of Victor Moses.

This, hopefully.

It seems to be how he turned things round at Ajax - sort out the defence & work from there. Clearly looking at flexibility trying a DM as CB & signing a CB that's comfortable playing DM.

We might, for once, have something more than just a plan A to work with.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 25 Jul 17 8.57am

Originally posted by Nobbybm

This, hopefully.

It seems to be how he turned things round at Ajax - sort out the defence & work from there. Clearly looking at flexibility trying a DM as CB & signing a CB that's comfortable playing DM.

We might, for once, have something more than just a plan A to work with.

Exactly, for the first time in years we have a plan B and people are complaining it's not our style. Make your minds up...

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 25 Jul 17 10.12am

Really happy to hear FDB talk about working from the back. However all the talk of 3-4-3 really worries me. Happy to hear it might be possible, eventually. but I'm currently hearing a manager dogmatically sticking to a system he knows. Hope i'm wrong and there is more to FDB than that.

Why am I always so nervous just before a season starts? Oh yes, that's it, I support Crystal Palace.

 

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 25 Jul 17 11.01am

343 seems to be a bit fashionable, I think we are currently playing more 541

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jul 17 11.43am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Really happy to hear FDB talk about working from the back. However all the talk of 3-4-3 really worries me. Happy to hear it might be possible, eventually. but I'm currently hearing a manager dogmatically sticking to a system he knows. Hope i'm wrong and there is more to FDB than that.

Why am I always so nervous just before a season starts? Oh yes, that's it, I support Crystal Palace.

The system he's always played and managed is actually 4-3-3. Which he says we'd be ok at but that he'd like us to learn 3-4-3 as he thinks this will be better for us.

So unfortunately he's not actually sticking to his guns but trying to build a team that actually has TWO options.

How long have we been crying out for that..?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Jul 17 12.08pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


I agree, which begs the question, why would a manager. looking at our current squad, conclude that it's the ideal formation for us? I sincerely hope that we're not the subject of someone's vanity experiment.

That article suggests that, apart from Chelsea, 3-4-3 has only been successfully deployed by Cruyff's Barcelona. Barcelona, Chelsea and Crystal Palace; with the best will in the world they're not three names you expect to hear in one sentence.


Edited by bexleydave (25 Jul 2017 8.08am)

This is what concerns me and vanity project or advertisement hopefully isn't what it is.

 


COYP

Dan89 Flag Se25 26 Jul 17 8.32am

I think what de Boer wants is a formation that can interchange

Can play 3-4-3 and can easily transform into 4-3-3

Maybe this is why he's playing Townsend as a wingback, not ideal but without making subs , it can be 4-3-3. This is why I think a signing like Chambers instead of ward is ideal.

Hennessy
Ward (Rcb)
Dann
Riedewald (Lcb)
Townsend (rwb)
PVA (Lwb)
Luka. (Cm)
Cabaye (cm)
Puncheon (LF)
Zaha (RF)
Benteke (st)

That can easily play 4-3-3 with the same personnel

Hennessy
Ward (rb)
Dann. (Cb)
Riedewald (cb)
PVA (Lb)
Luka (cm)
Cabaye (cm)
Puncheon (cm)
Townsend (Rw)
Zaha. (Lw)
Benteke (st)

Thoughts

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

JohnB Flag 26 Jul 17 9.39am

Just imagine

................Speroni
....Chambers....Sakho.......Riedewald

van der Wiel....................PVA/Schulpp

...........Luka.........Cabaye/RLC

..Townsend....................Zaha
............Benteke

Bench

Punch
Dann
Wickham
PVA/Schlupp
Cabaye/RLC
Hennessey
Ward

Won't happen, but it would be nice.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 26 Jul 17 10.09am

Originally posted by JohnB

Just imagine

................Speroni
....Chambers....Sakho.......Riedewald

van der Wiel....................PVA/Schulpp

...........Luka.........Cabaye/RLC

..Townsend....................Zaha
............Benteke

Bench

Punch
Dann
Wickham
PVA/Schlupp
Cabaye/RLC
Hennessey
Ward

Won't happen, but it would be nice.

I think that's the dream, liklehood is that we won't see both Chambers and Sakho straight away. Would be perfect for Frank's style though as he was our only defender who did any good at bringing the ball forward last season.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jul 17 10.56am

Originally posted by JohnB

Just imagine

................Speroni
....Chambers....Sakho.......Riedewald

van der Wiel....................PVA/Schulpp

...........Luka.........Cabaye/RLC

..Townsend....................Zaha
............Benteke

Why would you spend a small fortune in buying up better players than we already have and then stick an old man in goal?

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 26 Jul 17 11.06am

This for me:

Adrian
Chambers Sahko Riedewald
Van der Wiel Milevoyevic Cabaye(C)/Loftus-Cheek PVA
Zaha Benteke Townsend

SUBS: Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins/Dann, Schlupp, Puncheon/McArthur, Loftus-Cheek, Wickham/Ladapo/Anderson

My idea of a decent line-up (and I don’t care about Puncheon being made captain)

 


[Link]

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-4-3 Do we have the players