You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dunkirk
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dunkirk


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
YT Flag Oxford 31 Jul 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Sounds like a blockbuster movie have often seen the 1958 version starring John Mills.

In all the years of WW2 history and new understanding I have only recently begin to wonder that surely the RAF should be protecting the soldiers on the beaches from the stukas.

And where is the rest of the luftwaffe? Stukas were pretty useless and discontinued after heavy losses.

Still lots we don't really know about WW2 that's why its still so interesting.


The RAF fighter squadrons were shattered by the retreat from France.
As portrayed in the movie, a 1940 fighter had precious little flying time (and therefore minimal fighting time) over the beaches before it would have to turn for home. It simply wasn't feasible to fly across then fly around waiting for a Junkers to appear,
Perhaps less well portrayed is the pitiful amount of ammunition a fighter plane had. I haven't double-checked before posting but I seem to recall reading that a Spitfire in the Battle of Britain would only be able to fire at the enemy for about 30 seconds. Fighter planes were therefore OK as short-range interceptors (finest hour and all that) but not very useful in longer-range 'search and destroy' operations.

Edited to acknowledge that JamieM got this point in first!

Edited by YT (31 Jul 2017 5.53pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 31 Jul 17 6.04pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

The range of fighter aircraft was limited at the time, with the operational range of most being about the French coastal area, from bases in the South of England. Add to that that the Blitzkrieg had resulted in the loss of a lot of fighter aircraft in France - the capacity of the Airforce to protect the Dunkirk beaches were limited due to numbers and being close to the maximum operational range of the British Aircraft that were available.

If the Battle of Britain was their finest hour, Dunkirk was seen as a failure by the RAF (that usually gets glossed over in the telling of the Dunkirk story). However, for reasons you cite, they were doing their best with what they had.

A bit of movie trivia: Nolan used real Spits and "Yellow-Nosed b******s" making the movie. No CGI involved; he had the real aircraft flying around and chased them with a camera plane.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Jul 17 6.04pm

Originally posted by chris123

My great uncle Reg from Potter Heigham in Norfolk took his boat over and did three trips I think - years later the boat was used as a fishing deck on Hickling Broad. My dad and went fishing with Reg in the early 70s and used his old hulk as our base - it was in poor condition but the stove in the galley still worked. But we did not know the history of the boat until years later when one of the lads from the village gave an eulogy at Reg's funeral - we had no idea what Reg had done 40 years later and he had never once mentioned the history of his old boat - I think the lad said that he was a school boy at the time and only went along as there needed to be a crew - just unbelievable.

Yep, a hero from a generation chock full of them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 31 Jul 17 6.08pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Sounds like a blockbuster movie have often seen the 1958 version starring John Mills.

In all the years of WW2 history and new understanding I have only recently begin to wonder that surely the RAF should be protecting the soldiers on the beaches from the stukas.

And where is the rest of the luftwaffe? Stukas were pretty useless and discontinued after heavy losses.

Still lots we don't really know about WW2 that's why its still so interesting.


Stukas were very effective in Holland / Belgium / France etc. as they had little airborne opposition. Once they came up against Hurricanes and Spitfires, however, they were sitting ducks. You're right that, shortly after the start of the Battle of Britain, Stukas were taken out of the theatre because their losses were horrendous.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Part Time James Flag 31 Jul 17 6.09pm

Originally posted by YT

Er....that's the bit I didn't really want to give away in my first post.

If it's any consolation PTJ, Mrs YT came out of the cinema completely oblivious to the fact that she'd seen the same events a number of times over. I did kinda wonder which direction she'd been looking for an hour and three quarters. She's actually very intelligent (she married me, for example) but she does sometimes have problems with 'non-linear' stuff. Like, she would really enjoy Doctor Who if it wasn't for all those confusing time-travelling scenes!!

Edited by YT (31 Jul 2017 5.38pm)

I don't think that's a spoiler, not in the slightest. It happens with insignificant things before it happens with significant stuff.

 




Ray in Houston Flag Houston 31 Jul 17 6.12pm

Originally posted by YT

The RAF fighter squadrons were shattered by the retreat from France.
As portrayed in the movie, a 1940 fighter had precious little flying time (and therefore minimal fighting time) over the beaches before it would have to turn for home. It simply wasn't feasible to fly across then fly around waiting for a Junkers to appear,
Perhaps less well portrayed is the pitiful amount of ammunition a fighter plane had. I haven't double-checked before posting but I seem to recall reading that a Spitfire in the Battle of Britain would only be able to fire at the enemy for about 30 seconds. Fighter planes were therefore OK as short-range interceptors (finest hour and all that) but not very useful in longer-range 'search and destroy' operations.

Edited to acknowledge that JamieM got this point in first!

You're right that Spitfires and Hurricanes had only about 30 seconds of ammunition. Also, they were fitted with (relatively) small calibre machine guns, whereas the Messerschmidts had cannons with about 90 seconds of ammunition. The mismatch - on paper - was unsurvivable.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 31 Jul 17 6.14pm

I have been rescued !!!!!!!!!

It has been pointed out to me (as though I am an idiot how absurd) that there is a reason for the RAF and luftwaffe seemingly being absent.

In fact there was a pitch battle going on inland with the RAF attacking airfields and the luftwaffe in the air and that this was to prevent them finishing off our men at Dunkirk.

Sounds much more feasible to me and apparently from the records of the men who flew at the time must have been many personnel lost.

And seemingly the men on the beach did resent the RAF not being there but had no idea why. Bad feeling that was restored by the forthcoming battle of Britain?

France well within range of our aircraft - closer than Birmingham.


 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 31 Jul 17 7.20pm

I saw it last week & thought it was effective. As someone else said on here, it was loud!
My father was brought out of Dunkirk in a hospital ship-his heavy-gun crew having been blown up. He survived into his 90s with shrapnel in his leg which weirdly started moving a few years before his death.
He was 19 when he went there. A London lad, he'd only travelled as far as the coast before the war, but ended up in the desert, the Far East, Monte Casino & elsewhere.
Like many, he scarcely spoke about it.
As a teacher, I've taken early semi-retirement, but do share stories of the heroism of some in the wars. Children always seem respectful & interested in my experience if it's presented interestingly.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 31 Jul 17 7.41pm

Sexist.

[Link]

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 31 Jul 17 7.51pm

I enjoyed it. Great sense of tension from start to finish.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 31 Jul 17 7.54pm

Originally posted by Lakeview

I saw it last week & thought it was effective. As someone else said on here, it was loud!
My father was brought out of Dunkirk in a hospital ship-his heavy-gun crew having been blown up. He survived into his 90s with shrapnel in his leg which weirdly started moving a few years before his death.
He was 19 when he went there. A London lad, he'd only travelled as far as the coast before the war, but ended up in the desert, the Far East, Monte Casino & elsewhere.
Like many, he scarcely spoke about it.
As a teacher, I've taken early semi-retirement, but do share stories of the heroism of some in the wars. Children always seem respectful & interested in my experience if it's presented interestingly.

Was he in the royal artillery..because my father was a 25 pounder gunnery sergeant. And he was in all the same places.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Jul 17 7.59pm

Just another annoying feminist in today's seemingly endless line of them.

She attacks the film for appealing to males. Incredibly sexist if you apply feminism's rules for men equally towards women as well....But I don't....Still, I don't mind pointing out the hypocrisy.

But what does she care.....she's just another journalist looking for attention.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Jul 2017 8.00pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

YT Flag Oxford 31 Jul 17 8.13pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

Just another annoying feminist in today's seemingly endless line of them.

She attacks the film for appealing to males. Incredibly sexist if you apply feminism's rules for men equally towards women as well....But I don't....Still, I don't mind pointing out the hypocrisy.

But what does she care.....she's just another journalist looking for attention.

Edited by Stirlingsays (31 Jul 2017 8.00pm)

Stupid fcuking bint. The three females who accompanied YT (Mrs and Misses YT) had no such prejudice and thought the movie was excellent. And my daughters are pretty PC. I suspect this bint had written her 'piece' before she'd even seen it. Who reads this sh*t anyway, as opposed to watching something and making your own mind up?

Edited by YT (31 Jul 2017 8.13pm)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 31 Jul 17 9.01pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I saw it a week ago. I really enjoyed it. I'm not a history buff so I'm sure there could've been historical inaccuracies but if a film is good then I couldn't really care less. I enjoyed Harry Potter but I have my doubts he could really do magic.

That's because you are a Muggle.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 31 Jul 17 9.06pm

Originally posted by Direwolf

That's because you are a Muggle.

Oh come on! He can't even correct his own four-eyes problem!

Beta wizard....He needs to get in the gym and get himself some proper tail!

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Oliver Flag Bodega Bay 31 Jul 17 10.53pm

Loved the film Mark Rylance was superb.

On a historical note The RAF inflicted more losses on the Luftwaffe than they received. The RAF played an an important part in the evacuation of Dunkirk. The Luftwaffle were virtually non-existent in the last three days of the evacuation

 


I have prepared one of my own time capsules. I have placed some rather large samples of dynamite, gunpowder and nitroglycerin. My time capsule is set to go off in the year 3000. It will show them what we are really like.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Aug 17 10.07am

Originally posted by steeleye20

I have been rescued !!!!!!!!!

It has been pointed out to me (as though I am an idiot how absurd) that there is a reason for the RAF and luftwaffe seemingly being absent.

In fact there was a pitch battle going on inland with the RAF attacking airfields and the luftwaffe in the air and that this was to prevent them finishing off our men at Dunkirk.

Sounds much more feasible to me and apparently from the records of the men who flew at the time must have been many personnel lost.

And seemingly the men on the beach did resent the RAF not being there but had no idea why. Bad feeling that was restored by the forthcoming battle of Britain?

France well within range of our aircraft - closer than Birmingham.


Well they'd probably see them go flying over, on their way to attack airfields, and those on the ground probably assumed they should be fighting in the air over Dunkirk and supporting the evacuation.

Meanwhile the British pilots were probably providing more air cover than they could if they'd just stayed over the beaches.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Aug 17 10.09am

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

If the Battle of Britain was their finest hour, Dunkirk was seen as a failure by the RAF (that usually gets glossed over in the telling of the Dunkirk story). However, for reasons you cite, they were doing their best with what they had.

A bit of movie trivia: Nolan used real Spits and "Yellow-Nosed b******s" making the movie. No CGI involved; he had the real aircraft flying around and chased them with a camera plane.

I don't know how many Spitfires would have been at Dunkirk. Most of the RAF's backbone at the time, even during the Battle of Britain was the Hurricane.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 01 Aug 17 10.16am

In reply to Elgrande, my father was in the Royal Artillery (Field) & served for 8 years in total. Sorry if I should have posted this in a different section.
On a similar subject, what do you think of the Remembrance for the 100th anniversary of Passchendaele? Personally, I don't like the "Black Adder"-style of history: war is futile-angle. I think both World Wars were disasters, but stopped power-crazed evil from spreading.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 01 Aug 17 5.14pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I don't know how many Spitfires would have been at Dunkirk. Most of the RAF's backbone at the time, even during the Battle of Britain was the Hurricane.


Good point. And I haven't seen the movie yet, so I don't know if he had any 'Canes in there too. Spitfires are just far more evocative despite being much less numerous and, ironically, much more susceptible to their opponents canons due to their monocoque construction.

Of course, there were a number of Fokkes...some of whom were in Messerschmidts.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dunkirk