This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Player ratings:
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Lakeview Lincoln 12 Aug 17 7.48pm |
|
|
Luka certainly looked injured. I thought Huddersfield got away with a lot of fouls in the first 25 minutes or so and Milo was one victim. Bookings should have been given earlier. Having said that, they had the better of it and deserved to beat us. They spent £30+ million over the close-season so should not be underestimated. Cabaye could make a difference, as would a central defender and a R.W.B. A close-season for a month or so would be helpful.
|
Alex1991 Ashford 12 Aug 17 7.57pm |
|
Originally posted by teedee
Our best 2 players were the 2 loanees - says it all really
Dann isn't good enough in a 3 - pay the money and get Sakho ASAP
Quite a tough job he had today, being the main man in between a 20 year old making his PL debut and a 19 year old who's been playing RB for the last 2 years. I think he was shafted today, Fosu-Mensah shouldn't be playing RCB right now, particularly in his first game after 3 days training.
"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.
|
Alex1991 Ashford 12 Aug 17 7.58pm |
|
|
He was having a shocker, sure it was a one off but he was really off the ball today.
"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.
|
Part Time James 12 Aug 17 8.06pm |
|
Originally posted by Alex1991
He was having a shocker, sure it was a one off but he was really off the ball today.
It wasn't his best, but if he hadn't been injured I reckon he'd have provided more than Puncheon.
|
Dan89 Se25 12 Aug 17 8.12pm |
|
|
Here my ratings Hennessy- could do much with goals but FDB wants him to play out but the crowd want him to smash up field 5 Ward - shocking first touch, too slow over run too many times 3 Fosu- Mensah-pacey but looks too raw 5 Dann- poor in possession 4 Riedewald- good for 10mins after that just hoofed 4 PVA - worse set pieces ever seen, couldn't beat first man 2 Puncheon- dithers in possession 3 Luka- terrible 1 hauled of at h/t Zaha - quiet 5 Benteke- had good chance fluffed it 3 RLC - best player in red and blue 6.5 Townsend- overrun it too many times 4 Left when it was 3-0. De Boer 3
Edited by Dan89 (12 Aug 2017 10.26pm)
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
joe_cpfc Basingstoke 12 Aug 17 8.23pm |
|
|
Hennessy: 5 Ward: 3 - Total sh1t PVA: 4 - Sh1t Dann: 5 - Alright Reidewald: 3 - Total sh1t Mensah: 5 - Alright Luka: 3 - Total Sh1t while he was on Puncheon: 4 - Sh1t Loftus Cheek: 7/8 - Thank God for him Zaha: 4 - Sh1t Benteke: 4 - Sh1t but no service (Townsend: 5 - Alright) (Tomkins: 4 - Sh1t but not easy being thrown in with all the other sh1t)
And if there was another sub I can't remember but I'm sure he was sh1t too.
|
Bangell Oxford 12 Aug 17 8.23pm |
|
|
I think Fosu-Mensah had a lot of decent moments mainly because he was charging around covering for other defenders' f***-ups
|
tpuffpendants 12 Aug 17 8.43pm |
|
Originally posted by Bangell
I think Fosu-Mensah had a lot of decent moments mainly because he was charging around covering for other defenders' f***-ups
Noticed that often as well
|
eddiqc Tunbridge wells 12 Aug 17 10.09pm |
|
|
RLC definitely an 8.. if only the players around him had helped.. ward played like he was in league 2, I don't understand why he wasn't taken off.. I still believe in the team and the manager though. Only the first game.. Takes a few games for a squad to adapt to a new tactics, it was the same with allardyce and his run turned out well. We need to be a bit patient and supportive, rather than negative. I was not impressed with the boos at half time :/
|
palace chick South Croydon 12 Aug 17 10.25pm |
|
Originally posted by eddiqc
RLC definitely an 8.. if only the players around him had helped.. ward played like he was in league 2, I don't understand why he wasn't taken off.. I still believe in the team and the manager though. Only the first game.. Takes a few games for a squad to adapt to a new tactics, it was the same with allardyce and his run turned out well. We need to be a bit patient and supportive, rather than negative. I was not impressed with the boos at half time :/
How can you still believe in the team and manager after being shafted by Huddersfield? 0.3 is the worse defeat of the day in the prem. No team shouldn't be prepared for the first match of a new season - unbelievable!
|
glazedallover Allier 12 Aug 17 10.35pm |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
Here my ratings Hennessy- could do much with goals but FDB wants him to play out but the crowd want him to smash up field 5 Ward - shocking first touch, too slow over run too many times 3 Fosu- Mensah-pacey but looks too raw 5 Dann- poor in possession 4 Riedewald- good for 10mins after that just hoofed 4 PVA - worse set pieces ever seen, couldn't beat first man 2 Puncheon- dithers in possession 3 Luka- terrible 1 hauled of at h/t Zaha - quiet 5 Benteke- had good chance fluffed it 3 RLC - best player in red and blue 6.5 Townsend- overrun it too many times 4 Left when it was 3-0. De Boer 3
Edited by Dan89 (12 Aug 2017 10.26pm)
You left before the end. Nuff said .
|
Dan89 Se25 12 Aug 17 10.38pm |
|
|
Your didn't even go enough said.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
glazedallover Allier 12 Aug 17 10.43pm |
|
|
Its a bit difficult from france, but i have never left a game early. Never.
|
n wales eagles llandudno 12 Aug 17 10.46pm |
|
|
Can't blame Hennessey ffs puncheon has to go together with a system that the squad we have will never be able to play Hopefully I would love to be proved wrong but see you in Jan big Sam
|
Dan89 Se25 12 Aug 17 10.48pm |
|
|
Probably Because you never been. I see you at anfield then. Oh forget your an armchair fan.
Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football
|
glazedallover Allier 12 Aug 17 10.54pm |
|
Originally posted by Dan89
Probably Because you never been. I see you at anfield then. Oh forget your an armchair fan.
And how exactly did you deduce i have never been sherlock? Personally, if we struggle and lose w***ers like you, it might not all have been in vain.
|
GlaziertoEagle Coventry 12 Aug 17 10.54pm |
|
Originally posted by Alex1991
Quite a tough job he had today, being the main man in between a 20 year old making his PL debut and a 19 year old who's been playing RB for the last 2 years. I think he was shafted today, Fosu-Mensah shouldn't be playing RCB right now, particularly in his first game after 3 days training.
Agree with all of this. The team didn't look ready for the 343 yet and as you say, the defence is completely untested. Two very young players playing key positions and seemingly out of their depth today. There are lots of issues we have seen today but no reason to lose faith that the system, manager and players won't be successful in time.
|
kevlee born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 12 Aug 17 11.56pm |
|
|
having just seem the highlights made it look worse for me than from being at the match. Riedewald should be ashamed of his defending and Dann also needs to reflect on his general performance. Liverpool will go straight for the wings and where you would find a traditional left back and right back - we have huge gaps there and unless a new game plan is worked out in training this week that's where they will attack us from.
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978
|
AldwickEagle88 Bognor Regis 13 Aug 17 12.10am |
|
|
I think these ratings are spot on....especially about Puncheon, adds nothing playing that role and is often a hinderence passing behind the midfielders. Ward looked like he was well out of his depth and I struggle to remember too many goals coming from his crosses.
|
Bangell Oxford 13 Aug 17 12.12am |
|
|
Wow, those highlights make Dann, Riedewald and Ward look a little pathetic.
De Boer says afterwards that we didn't play well enough 'technical-wise, to do the things that we spoke about.' I think he might soon realise that whatever he tells the defenders to do regarding passing out from the back, they just can't.
|