You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No blame for mr parish for de Boer appointment ?
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

No blame for mr parish for de Boer appointment ?


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 10.12pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Blimey you're mental. What next after we sack FDB after one game??

We don't have the players for this fantasy system. Either parish backs him in the market or should of gone for someone who would of used the tools effectively like dyche. He gave pardew and big Sam millions. Why has de Boer only been given a poultry budget in comparison.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 12 Aug 17 10.13pm

Originally posted by Dan89

How about we underprepared most seasons under his guidance. Last season jedinak played before transfer to villa. Bolasie was a sub. No decent strikers from the bench today. The most prepared we have been is the year we bought Cabaye and wickham.

How do you know theres not transfers being worked on? I don't think its as straight forward as football manager to get all these players in.
I don't understand what your getting at about Jedinak and Bolasie either?

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 10.14pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Transfer window's not closed.

So do we throw the first 3 games because we underprepared for yet another season. If de Boer want Mensah why wasn't he bought in before the schalke match?

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Aug 17 10.15pm

The problem with this wonderful counter-attacking game that apparently we're so brilliant at is that it relies on the other team pushing up and our defence being quick enough when the game goes back the other way. You don't generally have control of the game and when teams sit deep we haven't had the players who were able to break teams down. Before we get all dewy eyed about the end of last season remember we lost four out of the last five games including 2-0 at home to Burnley and a 5-0 thrashing by Man City.

Don't get me wrong, Big Sam did a great job in keeping us up and I would have liked to have seen what he could have done this year. He identified our two big weaknesses that being a lack of fitness and the defence being disorganised and he motivated the players and helped them get on a run which ensured our safety. In reality he wasn't here long enough to truly judge him. If Pardew had left at the end of his first (half) season and the first half of the following then I imagine our views on him would be very different too.

For me I want to see two things: progression in our play and signs that FdB has the tactical nous to adjust things according to what is happening in a game. The first point would be ridiculous to judge for at least half a dozen games, and the second part was seen today when he shifted things around and we looked a better (if not great) team.


If we're still playing as badly as we did today after half-a-dozen games with no improvement then I'll start to worry, but personally I think we'll see a big improvement next week even if we lose.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 10.16pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

How do you know theres not transfers being worked on? I don't think its as straight forward as football manager to get all these players in.
I don't understand what your getting at about Jedinak and Bolasie either?

Both jedinak and bolasie both done pre season last season yet they had moves lined up before wba. Why did they play on that day then. The season starts on the 12th. It's not a shock to anyone. Not attacking subs on the bench today. That's underprepared but yet no blame is pointed at parish.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Aug 17 10.18pm

Originally posted by Bangell

We are not relegation favourites with this squad. Either we'll get the reinforcements to make this system work or ditch it, but FDB isn't enough of a mug to blindly persist with it if it repeatedly fails, I'm sure. If he does stick with it and we're bottom at Christmas, I'll hold my hands up.

As for investment, 'abysmal' is a silly assessment. £50 million spent last summer, about £32 million last January. You can have a go at Parish for not getting transfers sorted quickly enough, which is a gripe I have too. Hopefully today's performance will prove to be the bi-annual kick up the arse he seems to require.

£10 mil net last Summer. A big reason for the mess. And he was excused by some because we didn't understand the structure of contracts (what the actual fvck), only for us to go and do the business in January that we should've done in the summer.

I hope you're right on Frank not being a mug, but managers can be stubborn beasts, plus their repeated bizarre selections.

 


COYP

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 12 Aug 17 10.21pm

FFS, it could have been so much worse, we could have got spanked by BHA & that would have been something to whinge about. First game with new tactics, took Big Sam several weeks to get the players round to his way of thinking.

 


Red & Blue since 73'

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 12 Aug 17 10.23pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Both jedinak and bolasie both done pre season last season yet they had moves lined up before wba. Why did they play on that day then. The season starts on the 12th. It's not a shock to anyone. Not attacking subs on the bench today. That's underprepared but yet no blame is pointed at parish.

I don't know.Does it matter?
Maybe FDB hasn't made his mind up what striker he wants yet? If thats the case (nobody knows but those inside the club) what would happen if Parish went and got a striker in that FDB didn't 100% want? He'd be an interfering t***.So he's not going to win either way.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 10.24pm

Originally posted by thechaddyboy

FFS, it could have been so much worse, we could have got spanked by BHA & that would have been something to whinge about. First game with new tactics, took Big Sam several weeks to get the players round to his way of thinking.

Put this way. We start really badly no wins in 6 games for instance. The players lose confidence like they did under pardew. This is the big concern. Where we could of ticked by with dyche. Not as exciting but keep us in the division for a couple more years. Give us stability.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 12 Aug 17 10.27pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We don't have the players for this fantasy system. Either parish backs him in the market or should of gone for someone who would of used the tools effectively like dyche. He gave pardew and big Sam millions. Why has de Boer only been given a poultry budget in comparison.

I agree that De Boer's maybe been restricted (perhaps caged) but there's also something to be said for holding off for a while and being patient with bids.
It's still the start of the season. If we'd splashed the cash early we might have put all our eggs in one basket with big transfer fees. After today's catastrophe at least Parish can see where the team is lacking. But he isn't like Levy. Time is of the essence and today was not a job well-done. Something bad could be coming our way and we can't duck or play chicken. We need three or four players in my opinion for the squad to really spread its wings and fly. I do think the board will provide de Boer with the funds and the players.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 10.30pm

Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles

I agree that De Boer's maybe been restricted (perhaps caged) but there's also something to be said for holding off for a while and being patient with bids.
It's still the start of the season. If we'd splashed the cash early we might have put all our eggs in one basket with big transfer fees. After today's catastrophe at least Parish can see where the team is lacking. But he isn't like Levy. Time is of the essence and today was not a job well-done. Something bad could be coming our way and we can't duck or play chicken. We need three or four players in my opinion for the squad to really spread its wings and fly. I do think the board will provide de Boer with the funds and the players.

He'd be a turkey if he didn't.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Den1923 Flag 12 Aug 17 11.13pm

Originally posted by Bangell

We are not relegation favourites with this squad. Either we'll get the reinforcements to make this system work or ditch it, but FDB isn't enough of a mug to blindly persist with it if it repeatedly fails, I'm sure. If he does stick with it and we're bottom at Christmas, I'll hold my hands up.

As for investment, 'abysmal' is a silly assessment. £50 million spent last summer, about £32 million last January. You can have a go at Parish for not getting transfers sorted quickly enough, which is a gripe I have too. Hopefully today's performance will prove to be the bi-annual kick up the arse he seems to require.

The investment is abysmal since the end of last season, what happened in the past we can't change, except to look at the team we finished with last season and accept it was not fit for purpose despite all that investment. A complete rebuild is needed at the back at the very least if we are to make any progress. Today's performance underlines all that, we were comprehensively beaten by one of the weakest, if not the weakest team in the PL. This is a serious warning to SP, why can't he see it or is he burying his head in the sand like he did with Pardew?

 

davehuggins Flag 12 Aug 17 11.21pm

One day we will get it right but I don't think I'll live long enough to see it.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 12 Aug 17 11.28pm

Whilst we need to get some players in we had some good ones available for today's game but the team selection and set up was a joke.

Don't want to see another vid of de Boer juggling, doing press ups etc.

Writing been on the wall for a few weeks IMO.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Aug 17 11.40pm

Originally posted by Dan89

We don't have the players for this fantasy system. Either parish backs him in the market or should of gone for someone who would of used the tools effectively like dyche. He gave pardew and big Sam millions. Why has de Boer only been given a poultry budget in comparison.

He gave pardew and big Sam millions

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 12 Aug 17 11.51pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

He gave pardew and big Sam millions

So, let's not kid ourselves spartakev these squad/team barely survived last season and someone pointed out barring hull game. Lost 4 out 5 back end of the season. If we want de Boer to be successful surely we have to make funds available for him. I mean Huddersfield have spent more than us. Even teams in the championship. Underinvested at your peril. You get 100+m for staying in this division. He's not a miracle worker and deserves a similar budget. Sod ffp rules, no one else follows them. It's just an excuse not to buy players. 2 loans and an untried Ajax defender. Hardly giving him your full support. Look at Watford for instance, their backing their manager.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 13 Aug 17 12.07am

We need a goalkeeper painfully, we only have one striker and are lacking in depth. The money in football is ridiculous yet we are only spending £9mil!

I seriously doubt we will sign more than one more player if that. I have always backed SP but have lost complete faith in him, today was only the evidence I needed for backing my thinking. We cannot play possession football without buying about 7-11 new players capable of doing so, we saw that under Pardew so I have to think that SP has bought into a ludicrous fantasy of De Boers here due to a complete absence of any footballing knowledge.

Unless De Boer takes a reality check we are in serious trouble here far worse than some of the s***e we have seen in the last couple of years.

I just can't believe this situation, it defies belief

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

lefty27 Flag ipswich 13 Aug 17 12.20am

As has been pointed out FDB needs time like Sam, I think it was about nine games until we sorted our s*** out.
Still not sure if we underperformed last season or were lucky to escape relegation last season, it's clear though that we need strengthening, Gk, rwb, and a striker are essential imo.
I like what I hear from FDB, he seems a genuine fella and really hope this works out for him, we need to get behind him and the team and not become negative after one game however s*** it was today.
One bad result is not an excuse for pant wetting, Stoke had a s*** start last season! Coyp.

 

new_in_Wait Flag Lewisham 13 Aug 17 12.45am

Originally posted by lefty27

As has been pointed out FDB needs time like Sam, I think it was about nine games until we sorted our s*** out.
Still not sure if we underperformed last season or were lucky to escape relegation last season, it's clear though that we need strengthening, Gk, rwb, and a striker are essential imo.
I like what I hear from FDB, he seems a genuine fella and really hope this works out for him, we need to get behind him and the team and not become negative after one game however s*** it was today.
One bad result is not an excuse for pant wetting, Stoke had a s*** start last season! Coyp.

I don't know why we need to wait for 7-8 games till we get back on track. Why can't we play something fairly reasonable from the beginning? 7-8 lost games means we're the foot of the table with 25% of the league played. As a guy said behind me, it's going to be a long, s*** winter again. I don't know why it's considered to be normal to suffer for most of the season just to (maybe) avoid relegation.

Also, some of us (call us what you want) are sick and tired of seeing Punch lose the ball 25 yards from our goal, tired of seeing Dann unable to play a vertical pass, Ward always (but always) out of position etc. But I guess being a Palace fan means to hope to not get relegated and to see some nice Zaha footwork up close.

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Aug 17 1.00am

Originally posted by Dan89
Why has de Boer only been given a poultry budget in comparison.

Because he's hen pecked?

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > No blame for mr parish for de Boer appointment ?