You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke
November 16 2026 8.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
steven_t92 Flag Orpington 14 Aug 17 12.22pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

£120k a week........need to do a lot more Mr Benteke.

Statements like this annoy me more than anything, no concept of football. If he plays at right back would you still expect him to play well just because he's on 120k a week?

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 14 Aug 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

We buy a £27m striker and play a style that creates nothing for him in open play, leaves him isolated and forces him to chase CB's even though he's no comfortable with it and never was (ask Liverpool). We know he's probably the best in the air in the league and we stay narrow and keep it on the ground?

wtf?!

No, not really. If you factor in he should be being fed from both the others in the front three and from two wingbacks then he should actually be getting a better service than before.

Add to that the ability to flick on for others running beyond him and we should be far more effective up front than just relying on wide men hitting teams on the break.

Saturday's biggest issue from what I saw was an imbalance with Ward at RWB which meant that HT could simply shut down our left side as there was no real threat from our right (which changed in the second half with RLC dropping back & Andros coming on). This over exposed the back three as well as leaving the front three more than a little isolated.

He showed that he will win headers if we get the ball in (only a top class save prevented him scoring) & he did win a few balls deeper for Wilf to run on to.

Do you need reminding of the goal he goat against Chelski? Surely that showed he has a great touch & cool head - as do many of his international goals. He's a goal taker rather than maker so give him the chances & he'll convert them.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

matthau Flag South Croydon 14 Aug 17 3.07pm

everyone banging on how poor ward was as Rwb, PvA wasn't much better either on sat.

 

Part Time James Flag 14 Aug 17 3.23pm

Originally posted by matthau

everyone banging on how poor ward was as Rwb, PvA wasn't much better either on sat.

I'd love to see the stats (which no doubt will prove me wrong) but it felt like Townsend won more balls than any other Palace player on Saturday and he didn't even play the whole game!

 




Part Time James Flag 14 Aug 17 3.26pm

Originally posted by Bangell

He's not exactly lazy, but there were plenty of occasions on Saturday when I wanted to see all 6 ft 3 of him committing to challenges and getting stuck into defenders. He's under no pressure for his position so you can see why he might not bother to put himself at risk.

As for playing to his strengths... Well, one of our best moments was a Hennessey long ball, flicked on by Benteke to Zaha, who was already running off him anticipating that Benteke would win it.

I thought that about a few of our players. Not many players seemed to want to risk a bruise.

Agree regarding the second point too. When Hennessey did hoof it up field we seemed to fair better on most of the occasions.

 




EddieMac Flag 14 Aug 17 3.27pm

Benteke is not the complete player but if we play to his strengths we will give ourselves a fighting chance. He is lethal in the air and his hold up play is spot on, the problems lies with not having someone close to him for flick ons etc.

Play with Milivojevic, Loftus Cheek, Cabaye in Midfield with Zaha having a bit of a free roll.

I think Townsend should be given a fair crack at right WB, He has the energy to get up and down that line all day. Poor Ward was like a lost soul in that position.

 

est1905 Flag 14 Aug 17 5.04pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

We buy a £27m striker and play a style that creates nothing for him in open play, leaves him isolated and forces him to chase CB's even though he's no comfortable with it and never was (ask Liverpool). We know he's probably the best in the air in the league and we stay narrow and keep it on the ground?

wtf?!

He was a massive success at Villa (not Liverpool) and they at the time played a similar way to how trying to now

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Aug 17 5.28pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Benteke is not the complete player but if we play to his strengths we will give ourselves a fighting chance. He is lethal in the air and his hold up play is spot on, the problems lies with not having someone close to him for flick ons etc.

Play with Milivojevic, Loftus Cheek, Cabaye in Midfield with Zaha having a bit of a free roll.

I think Townsend should be given a fair crack at right WB, He has the energy to get up and down that line all day. Poor Ward was like a lost soul in that position.

Sounds like 3-5-2 with PVA or Schlupp at LWB.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 14 Aug 17 5.43pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Maybe a £27 striker should be able to do more than head a ball.....
Watching him saturday, He's either lazy, unfit or just useless with the ball at his feet. Don't know how much HT paid for their new striker, but he looked miles better than Benteke.

He is Steve Mounie and they paid £11.5 Mill for him.
I did say before the game he was strong aerially and thrives on delivery from wide areas !

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 14 Aug 17 5.58pm

Originally posted by Willo

He is Steve Mounie and they paid £11.5 Mill for him.
I did say before the game he was strong aerially and thrives on delivery from wide areas !

Plus he made runs wide and behind the defence, and closed down our defenders ....but apparently benteke can only score if you put it right on his head in the box....

 

palacenomatterwhat Flag Kings Lynn 14 Aug 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by Bangell

He's not exactly lazy, but there were plenty of occasions on Saturday when I wanted to see all 6 ft 3 of him committing to challenges and getting stuck into defenders. He's under no pressure for his position so you can see why he might not bother to put himself at risk.

As for playing to his strengths... Well, one of our best moments was a Hennessey long ball, flicked on by Benteke to Zaha, who was already running off him anticipating that Benteke would win it.

Corner which he met with a thumping header and HT goalie made a cracking save.
Is it just easier for you to pick up on his weaknesses because our defence were so sh**. If our defence was more solid and knew what they were doing, then C.B could more easily focus on what he s paid for, why buy a striker and expect him to defend ? What s Dann etc for ?

 


and it's goodnight from me.......

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 14 Aug 17 7.13pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Plus he made runs wide and behind the defence, and closed down our defenders ....but apparently benteke can only score if you put it right on his head in the box....

The fact that he won more aerial battles than anyone else in the EPL this weekend should make you think that maybe, just maybe, he could do with some support...........like Mounie had.

Look at any side playing 3-4-3 and it's clear the (attacking) intention is to have the main striker as a focal point, not simply a goal scorer - it gives him support & options (when done correctly).

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

palacenomatterwhat Flag Kings Lynn 14 Aug 17 7.14pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Plus he made runs wide and behind the defence, and closed down our defenders ....but apparently benteke can only score if you put it right on his head in the box....

And hats the way FDB wants to play !!!
Tippy tappy football to the feet, how does that help a striker who thrives on crosses.
The reason Huddersfield s striker did so well, BECAUASE they played to his strengths, not fannying around with it, back and forth around the halfway line.

 


and it's goodnight from me.......

Bangell Flag Oxford 14 Aug 17 7.19pm

Originally posted by palacenomatterwhat

Corner which he met with a thumping header and HT goalie made a cracking save.
Is it just easier for you to pick up on his weaknesses because our defence were so sh**. If our defence was more solid and knew what they were doing, then C.B could more easily focus on what he s paid for, why buy a striker and expect him to defend ? What s Dann etc for ?

Not demanding that he become a defender or aimlessly chase the opposition, but do you really believe that he's making the most of his presence when challenges present themselves? I don't think opposition defenders feel particularly intimidated when he's in the sort of mood he was in on Saturday.

Fire up the whole team + give him some competition and he's terrifying.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 14 Aug 17 7.27pm

Originally posted by palacenomatterwhat

And hats the way FDB wants to play !!!
Tippy tappy football to the feet, how does that help a striker who thrives on crosses.
The reason Huddersfield s striker did so well, BECAUASE they played to his strengths, not fannying around with it, back and forth around the halfway line.


FDB has specifically said he wants to use the wingers to cross the ball. He has also said 4-3-3 is his preferred system but that he felt the latter meant Wilf spent too much time doing defensive work: hence the switch. Given that he also said he is prepared to switch formations, I think he means it would be good to have more than one way of playing.

Furthermore, He has made it clear he would like to create options other than wing play, because, as we have seen over the last four years, we have been worked out and are all too easy to nullify either in terms of our predictable formation or tactics (especially at home).

Tippy-tappy, as you call it, works where the team keeps the ball rather than hoofing it forward, as we have done all too often over the years (to groans from the crowd). The problem right now is that the players seem to think that inane tippt-tappy is all they can do. For professional athletes, it is pretty pathetic that some of them cannot pass properly let alone read the game well.

If we don't change, we will end up like Sunderland or Villa. Unfortunately, change involves risk too, but the potential rewards are higher. I'm all for it.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

palace chick Flag South Croydon 14 Aug 17 7.40pm

Originally posted by kevlee

So basically, Benteke should ditch his primary (and widely recognised) asset - aerial power- and adapt to the experiment? Fine.
In that case why not just sell him to a team that wants to play to those strengths and buy a striker whose primary strengths are on the ground?
That would avoid everyone slagging off Beneteke for not changing his natural playing style and satisfy FDB's ego/grand plan.
I think CB is one of the best headers in the PL - get those crosses in from the wings and he will score.

Absolutely!

 

Den1923 Flag 14 Aug 17 8.32pm

Originally posted by Nobbybm

The fact that he won more aerial battles than anyone else in the EPL this weekend should make you think that maybe, just maybe, he could do with some support...........like Mounie had.

Look at any side playing 3-4-3 and it's clear the (attacking) intention is to have the main striker as a focal point, not simply a goal scorer - it gives him support & options (when done correctly).


yes but Mounie was much more mobile and industries, he worked defenders when he did not have the ball created spaces for other and he even had enough energy to help out in defence when required. CB maybe he is good in the air but 12 corners and not one converted would seem to suggest he is not that brilliant and more to the point his ground skills are zero so for me not the complete striker and certainly not worth 27mil!

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 14 Aug 17 8.56pm

Originally posted by Den1923


yes but Mounie was much more mobile and industries, he worked defenders when he did not have the ball created spaces for other and he even had enough energy to help out in defence when required. CB maybe he is good in the air but 12 corners and not one converted would seem to suggest he is not that brilliant and more to the point his ground skills are zero so for me not the complete striker and certainly not worth 27mil!

So Den, your strategy is sell him? Ok maybe we will get £25m. Who do you replace him with? And I would like a comparable. So an experienced international with lots of PL experience and guaranteed to score goals. Can you give us your suggestions and probable prices?

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

gaz1959 Flag Bamford Lancashire 14 Aug 17 9.06pm

Originally posted by kevlee

So basically, Benteke should ditch his primary (and widely recognised) asset - aerial power- and adapt to the experiment? Fine.
In that case why not just sell him to a team that wants to play to those strengths and buy a striker whose primary strengths are on the ground?
That would avoid everyone slagging off Beneteke for not changing his natural playing style and satisfy FDB's ego/grand plan.
I think CB is one of the best headers in the PL - get those crosses in from the wings and he will score.

Agree 100% we need to be able to play different systems but square pegs in round holes doesn't work let's go to 433 we understand it it works and have they players if and when we have the points experiment.

 

bashy2 Flag London 14 Aug 17 9.25pm

I totally agree with what CB has said about the new formation its a new system maybe but Chelsea adapted very quickly last season to it and won the title lots of teams in the premiere league now play it and the players are paid handsomely enough its like starting a new job takes a couple of weeks to get used too and they have been playing it now sin e pre season so us CB has said get used to it and no excuses

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke