This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by topcat
I believe that there was a vote and it was decided to take the statue down, which is why the far right were protesting. Yep they lost the vote. They should 'get over it.'
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by topcat
I believe that there was a vote and it was decided to take the statue down, which is why the far right were protesting. It was, the democratically elected council, took a vote, in which the outcome was to move the statue from the park (not to take it down, but to move it).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Its kind of tragic that people regard a statue as something worth killing and harming people over.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
Yep they lost the vote. They should 'get over it.' Yes, but what does Leexit really mean? Were uneducated people fooled by being told that it would be melted down and the proceeds put towards building a National Health Service?
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
| hedgehog50 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its kind of tragic that people regard a statue as something worth killing and harming people over. Yes, it is crazy that someone has died over this.
We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell] |
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
I believe that there was a vote and it was decided to take the statue down, which is why the far right were protesting. Well, a vote by a council. Councils make unpopular decisions all the time. I think the local people should decide....if that's what they want, then fair enough.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I'm trying to think of many contexts in which the side who rebelled against the state, were utterly defeated and everything they fought for is largely discredited actually get statues to commerate them as heroes and get venerated in this way. I don't think they should be destroyed per se, they're historical artefacts relating, but maybe belong in Museums etc. But the important thing here, is that democratically elected officals, through legal democratic process, voted to move the statue (not tear it down or destroy it).
|
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I'm trying to think of many contexts in which the side who rebelled against the state, were utterly defeated and everything they fought for is largely discredited actually get statues to commerate them as heroes and get venerated in this way. I don't think they should be destroyed per se, they're historical artefacts relating, but maybe belong in Museums etc. But the important thing here, is that democratically elected officals, through legal democratic process, voted to move the statue (not tear it down or destroy it). It's also worth highlighting that while people say 'this isn't only about slavery or race' most of the confederate statues were not erected until several decades after the civil war, in the lynching era and another spike in the civil rights era. They are as political as they are historical.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The civil war was primarily about slavery...well, to be precise the money from it. But it wasn't only about slavery and symbols like General Lee came to represent the independence of the south. But there is no doubt that if Lincoln hadn't been elected president the war wouldn't have happened. It's one eyed to suggest that a statute of General Lee is just about slavery for everyone. I was annoyed about the bringing down of this statue as well and I don't support slavery at all. Plenty of people died on the confederate side and most of them didn't own slaves. It's air brushing of history, it's what extremists do when they seek to make society in their image. Not good. Edited by Stirlingsays (16 Aug 2017 10.36am) Read what the Confederate Vice President said. The war was about slavery, and not just the money from it, as it fundamentally related to the place and role of slaves within Southern society and identity. The leaders of the slaves states were extremely clear on this in what they said and what they wrote and did. Second, stop using a false analogy. The fact most southerners did not own slaves is irrelevant as they were largely conscripted: it would be like saying the average German soldier was not a NAZI so the war was not about NAZI ideology. That's just silly. Many white Southerners have attempted, for far more than a century, to airbrush their own history by pretending the war was not about slavery. Clearly, they have been successful. As for air brushing history, who precisely is doing that? Those pretending the symbols have nothing to do with the main cause of the Civil War, i.e. slavery, or those pointing out it was about time there was a debate about whether such symbols should be acceptable in a modern society. I would have them removed and placed in museums with interpretation or, it is felt they should stay where they are, provided with an interpretive plaque. And by the way, there was a vote just as there has been elsewhere. Most of the prominent cases have been a democratically elected official exercising the will of the public. By the way, here are the key parts of the Confederate Vice President's speech: "The new constitution has put at rest, forever, all the agitating questions relating to our peculiar institution African slavery as it exists amongst us the proper status of the negro in our form of civilization. This was the immediate cause of the late rupture and present revolution. Jefferson in his forecast, had anticipated this, as the “rock upon which the old Union would split.” He was right. What was conjecture with him, is now a realized fact. ... The prevailing ideas entertained by him [Jefferson] and most of the leading statesmen at the time of the formation of the old constitution, were that the enslavement of the African was in violation of the laws of nature; that it was wrong in principle, socially, morally, and politically. It was an evil they knew not well how to deal with, but the general opinion of the men of that day was that, somehow or other in the order of Providence, the institution would be evanescent and pass away. This idea, though not incorporated in the constitution, was the prevailing idea at that time. ... Those ideas, however, were fundamentally wrong. They rested upon the assumption of the equality of races. This was an error. It was a sandy foundation, and the government built upon it fell when the “storm came and the wind blew.”
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
First Dippy the Diplodocus ...and now this ?!
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by wordup
It's also worth highlighting that while people say 'this isn't only about slavery or race' most of the confederate statues were not erected until several decades after the civil war, in the lynching era and another spike in the civil rights era. They are as political as they are historical.
I think its kind of damning that the people who seem to be saying that, also tend to be backed by groups for who race and racial supremacy is very important.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by wordup
It's also worth highlighting that while people say 'this isn't only about slavery or race' most of the confederate statues were not erected until several decades after the civil war, in the lynching era and another spike in the civil rights era. They are as political as they are historical.
Much like the reintroduction of the Confederate flag in the 1950s in direct response to the growing civil rights movement.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its kind of tragic that people regard a statue as something worth killing and harming people over. basically this.
La la la your mum |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Is it better that we all live according to the will of those who would use violence to dictate politics. Its always held on to its identity, its pride and its racism. You forgot to add that element, whether it was Jim Crow Laws, the Klan etc the South has a worrying history of clinging to very outdated and illegal views of race in America.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, a vote by a council. Councils make unpopular decisions all the time. I think the local people should decide....if that's what they want, then fair enough. Local councils are chosen by local people to decide such things. That is what representative democracy is all about. What you are suggesting is already what happens.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Is it better that we all live according to the will of those who would use violence to dictate politics. Its always held on to its identity, its pride and its racism. You forgot to add that element, whether it was Jim Crow Laws, the Klan etc the South has a worrying history of clinging to very outdated and illegal views of race in America. Agree with all of that but all they have done by removing statues is to pander to small mindedness and stir up resentment. All totally unnecessary.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Agree with all of that but all they have done by removing statues is to pander to small mindedness and stir up resentment. All totally unnecessary. Thing is, and I'm pretty sure we can all agree on this, Neo-Nazism and White Supremacy are dead ends politically, and anti-social in their own right, being products of a small mindedness and exist entirely to stir up resentment and represent a tiny minority in the US (certainly not enough are local to have influenced the council elections - or take part in the democratic process of selecting the council). But then these are people who aren't interested in democratic process, due process, taking part in democratic society or participation in mainstream politics - They're only interested in the use of intimidation, force and violence as a means to exert their political agenda, and have no interest in a compromise solution. F**k them. Those right wing protestors who aren't far right f**ktards, I feel sorry for them being tainted with such a filthy brush. But Neo-Nazis and White Supremecy are not compatable with a democratic society.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| wordup |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Agree with all of that but all they have done by removing statues is to pander to small mindedness and stir up resentment. All totally unnecessary. I don't disagree that it should remain if the people had wanted it to. We should also remember though that this very statue initially appeared in 1924, at the height of the KKK, lynchings and mass monument building to similar figures. That is part of its history too, and its message. Were these monuments designed to be a benign presence or a message? As I say though, ultimately these things should be down to the people or their elected representatives to decide. If there is enough agreement to build or remove then go for it. I dare say that people were much more in favour of this particular monument at the time than they are now though and the crowd protesting its removal or the terror attack on the day did little to win anyone over. Edited by wordup (16 Aug 2017 1.26pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Thing is, and I'm pretty sure we can all agree on this, Neo-Nazism and White Supremacy are dead ends politically, and anti-social in their own right, being products of a small mindedness and exist entirely to stir up resentment and represent a tiny minority in the US (certainly not enough are local to have influenced the council elections - or take part in the democratic process of selecting the council). But then these are people who aren't interested in democratic process, due process, taking part in democratic society or participation in mainstream politics - They're only interested in the use of intimidation, force and violence as a means to exert their political agenda, and have no interest in a compromise solution. F**k them. Those right wing protestors who aren't far right f**ktards, I feel sorry for them being tainted with such a filthy brush. But Neo-Nazis and White Supremecy are not compatable with a democratic society. Of course, pride in Southern heritage is not all about 'racism' but if the objectors are simply 'racists' then I don't think their objection is valid.
|
|
|
Originally posted by nickgusset
You don't want the danger of airbrushing history though. The statue also serves as a reminder that Lee was on the losing side and his vile racist ideology defeated. Out of interest, is it going to be replaced with a statue of Trump. Or Miley Cyrus. Many of these statues were erected with the intention of airbrushing history and rewrite why the American Civil War happened and the result of the war. They paint actions by those who supported perpetual slavery as having been engaged in a noble struggle. Many were erected by wealthy white landowners as part of a political project to keep black people marginalised in society and to stop populist movements of black and white working class people together. They were part of a strategy to divide the working classes along racial lines and as part of a story which helped "justify" Jim Crow laws and the treatment that went along with those laws. Plenty of these statues were also erected during the civil rights movement as symbols designed to evoke white resistance to this movement (a genuine noble struggle). They should be in museums with explanations of who they people were, the reasons for the Civil War and the history behind why the statues were erected where they originally were. They have no place in the public realm.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.