You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Another 20 games of Puncheon
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Another 20 games of Puncheon


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Johnny Byrne Flag Pinner 11 Sep 17 9.50pm

Punch is CPFC born and bred. However, his best days are long past based on performances since 2015.

We need a strong midfield 3 of Luka, Cabaye and RLC. Jimmy Mac did ok on Sunday and is a great squad player. Sadly, Punch really is now a squad player.

Sakho is a leader. He was PSG captain at 17. LFC's loss is going to be our gain, provided he stays fit.

Hope the new manager, whoever that is, gets our squad and gives it some stability, playing the Palace way.

 

pssguy Flag 11 Sep 17 9.57pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

like i said with the right players around him hes decent.

in his new position he does the simple work very well in my eyes, ok granted doesnt pull up trees like he used to in an attacking sense but thats not his job anymore.

nobody used to chastice KG for the unsung job he did alongside jedi, and if they did they were idiots who didnt understand the job of a team player.

At the most, he pulled his weight. He has been on the decline ever since he joined us. He hasn't scored a league goal in over 3300 minutes and has just one assist of any description in the past 1000
Those are unbelievably awful figures.

KG was a placeholder as a Premier League player and at least brought some physicality

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 12 Sep 17 2.00pm

If the new manager was to watch ANY of Punch's games in the past season would he honestly say "Look at that bloke, fantastic leader, great contributor to the team. I want him as my captain and I will never sub him or drop him."
?

There is not one single Palace fan in the world who would agree.


Personally I am astonished, confused and utterly downcast by Punch's contuining 'role' in the team. All this "...there are others who aren't good enough" claptrap only serves to cloud the real issue.

Please can I have my faith in Palace-humanity restored?

 


Spirit of 1974

bodge Flag 12 Sep 17 2.18pm

Originally posted by joe_cpfc

Does he? I must have missed that game.

Yes every game he gives his all as do most players being out of form or on the decline is nothing to do with not trying.

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 12 Sep 17 2.21pm

I love Puncheon. I love everything about him except the football part.

Last few games I have watched him like a hawk and I have noticed that all wont attempt anything, he wont put a ball in or take a chance, but he will try to set other people up to do it.

Its so frustrating to watch because you just shout at the tv for him to do something dynamic, just put a cross in, take a shot, beat a defender, anything will do...then he plays a simple ball to another player who might...

Does that make him a bad footballer? Not really and seeing the rest of the team give the ball away taking a badly calculated risk is probably more frustrating but I wish he would learn from someone like Cabaye. Take a chance, it probably wont work but a bit of a lucky bounce and it might land at Bentekes head or Zahas feet. He just keeps possession. Which makes it even worse if he misplaces it.

As for communication, sure he talks, but so does Cabaye, Sakho, Milo and Wayne. That does make a good candidate for captain, but more important is leading by example and taking a game by the scruff of the neck and trying to make something happen.

Every fault he has is lack of confidence. We have too much talent that can do his job...

 

bodge Flag 12 Sep 17 2.23pm

KG was a key part of our promotion when fit he was very good when fat he was poor i wonder if Sako is the same one day he may be fit again and we can find out.

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 12 Sep 17 2.29pm

How about not getting tackled all the time and passing the ball to one of his own team?

That would be a 75% improvement

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 12 Sep 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by cpj

Hopefully Roy will only take one game to see what we can all see (well most of us).[/quote]

I agree and put Jules in goal and Wayne on the bench

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 12 Sep 17 3.04pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Yep, we've got four quality players for three positions. No way Punch should be on the pitch if any three of Cabaye, Luka, McArthur or RLC are fit.

Hopefully Woy will surprise us all and pick our strongest players for the starting XI.

AND play them in their right positions?

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

cpj Flag Kent 12 Sep 17 3.44pm

Originally posted by susmik

Originally posted by cpj

Hopefully Roy will only take one game to see what we can all see (well most of us).[/quote]

I agree and put Jules in goal and Wayne on the bench

Only you could turn this into another Hennessey debate!

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 12 Sep 17 3.54pm

Originally posted by cpj

Only you could turn this into another Hennessey debate!

Have you NO sense of humour or did you just miss the winks.
I sometimes wonder with you sunshine....I really do.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 12 Sep 17 4.19pm

Originally posted by pssguy

At the most, he pulled his weight. He has been on the decline ever since he joined us. He hasn't scored a league goal in over 3300 minutes and has just one assist of any description in the past 1000
Those are unbelievably awful figures.

KG was a placeholder as a Premier League player and at least brought some physicality

i get the fact ge hasnt scored, but a lot of the tome hes been played as part of a protective 2, and its no co-incidence thats his goals /assists have dried up since he moved deeper.

lets not forget that (i think) over the past 12 months weve barely had all 3 of punch/cabaye/jimmy fit at the same time for any oeriod of time so of course hes played as he is/better than ledders/mutch/flamini.

im not saying hes the 2nd coming or amazing, im saying he doesnt deserve the s*** hes getting as right now hes getting scapegoating.

saying that i cannot understand how fdb left luca on the bench, as im ny eyes when fit the 3 midfielders should without a shadow of a doubt be lica/cabaye/flc with punch filling in when needed.

on another note 99% of this site were happy he got the captaincy.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Elpis Flag In a pub 13 Sep 17 9.50pm

Originally posted by Beanyboysmd


Its so frustrating to watch because you just shout at the tv for him to do something .

Try coming to a game , you will see a guy that regardless of form gets on the team sheet every week . Its why BFS made him skipper and why FDB agreed .

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 13 Sep 17 10.21pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Try coming to a game , you will see a guy that regardless of form gets on the team sheet every week . Its why BFS made him skipper and why FDB agreed .

Thats the problem. why does it matter wether its on the tele or at the ground?

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 13 Sep 17 11.22pm

Braunston got it right as regards our best 3 midfielders.
Loftus cheek
Luca
Cabaye
Has class written all over it.

 

eag-les Flag Coulsdon 13 Sep 17 11.50pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i get the fact ge hasnt scored, but a lot of the tome hes been played as part of a protective 2, and its no co-incidence thats his goals /assists have dried up since he moved deeper.

lets not forget that (i think) over the past 12 months weve barely had all 3 of punch/cabaye/jimmy fit at the same time for any oeriod of time so of course hes played as he is/better than ledders/mutch/flamini.

im not saying hes the 2nd coming or amazing, im saying he doesnt deserve the s*** hes getting as right now hes getting scapegoating.

saying that i cannot understand how fdb left luca on the bench, as im ny eyes when fit the 3 midfielders should without a shadow of a doubt be lica/cabaye/flc with punch filling in when needed.

on another note 99% of this site were happy he got the captaincy.

Spot on

 


If I agreed with you we'd both be wrong

matthau Flag South Croydon 13 Sep 17 11.51pm

Even the commentators have worked out hrs lost it.. They relentlessly say about the last time he scored in cup final... Well they don't say that about Mccarthur for example. Or any other midfielder. They can't just say he's turned crap now...

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Sep 17 1.20pm

Don't see what all the fuss is about Puncheon. Yeah he's not great, but he's not s**t either. About average for the team, and certainly puts in a shift.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Sep 17 1.24pm

Originally posted by bodge

KG was a key part of our promotion when fit he was very good when fat he was poor i wonder if Sako is the same one day he may be fit again and we can find out.

KG was good at one thing, defensively partnering Jedi. The pair of them, that first season we stayed up were absolutely beasts as a partnership. But, and its important to remember this, he wasn't really good at anything else.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

The Dolphin Flag 14 Sep 17 1.25pm

Punch needs to be benched for a while.
He loses the ball too often and holds up his hands instead of fighting to get it back. He doesn't score any more and he doesn't create enough.
So in fact he is just Roy's kind of player so first name on the sheet again!

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Another 20 games of Puncheon