You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Return of big ben
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Return of big ben


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
FairweatherEagle Flag London 10 Nov 17 11.54am

Originally posted by Reknaw

What are you going on about? The argument was that he ‘wins so few headers’. The stat completely proves that statement wrong. How can he be blamed if no one wins the second ball? Ludicrous.

What I mean and the stat people count as winning differ. I mean we win the ball ultimately as a result of his header, where as they mean he gets his head first to the ball, which results in a misleading stat.

He doesn't take full blame for his inefficacy, it's also how we use him that counts, so it's the managers fault too. I think Roy will make more of him as a ball player and not some beanpole target to always mindlessly hit the ball at like under Frank. That looked to be the case against City.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 10 Nov 17 12.02pm

Benteke from his Villa days was a monster, now he loses the ball too easy and his touch is simply not good enough. Talks about Chelsea interested? Take 45 mill and get Ulloa (Leicester) and Ings (Liverpool) for much less in January...maybe tempt Chelsea to sell RLC as well.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Nov 17 12.07pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Benteke from his Villa days was a monster, now he loses the ball too easy and his touch is simply not good enough. Talks about Chelsea interested? Take 45 mill and get Ulloa (Leicester) and Ings (Liverpool) for much less in January...maybe tempt Chelsea to sell RLC as well.

Ings has not played for over a year and has only made 12 apps since the start of the 2015/16 season.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Nov 17 12.11pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Benteke from his Villa days was a monster, now he loses the ball too easy and his touch is simply not good enough. Talks about Chelsea interested? Take 45 mill and get Ulloa (Leicester) and Ings (Liverpool) for much less in January...maybe tempt Chelsea to sell RLC as well.

Didn't Benteke have Agbanlahor and/or Weimann near him? Who's Benteke had? 2 CBs and a def mid mopping up. We all know Pardew couldn't get the most out of his signings and for a while when Sam did.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 10 Nov 17 1.10pm

I reckon with Benteke up front, wilf and andros wide, RLC just behind, we'll score goals. ...what we probably need in jan is a smaller nippier forward in case plan A doesn't work...

 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Nov 17 2.04pm

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Benteke from his Villa days was a monster, now he loses the ball too easy and his touch is simply not good enough. Talks about Chelsea interested? Take 45 mill and get Ulloa (Leicester) and Ings (Liverpool) for much less in January...maybe tempt Chelsea to sell RLC as well.

So you would swap him for someone who is 4 years older and who has a weaker scoring record (despite his goals for them the Brighton fans I knew weren't too sorry to see him go and Leicester fans don't seem too keen to keep him either) and a player who has played 6 games in the last two years and who also has a weaker scoring record? I try and respect opinions, but that's just bonkers.

With Zaha back Bentenke will prove the doubters wrong (in terms of goals...maybe not on the effort front!) and then hopefully we can bring in some competition for him in January (in addition to a returning Wickham).


Edited by taylors lovechild (10 Nov 2017 2.04pm)

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Nov 17 3.46pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

You do understand, and if not I'll explain... it's our silly fans trying to ignor facts to suit the feeling they have that he's not actually a quality player.

Similar to Wilf making more chances than most yet still gets accused of not being consistent. Except the facts would suggest he consistently creates chances...

We need to get behind Benteke when he's back as we desperately need him to hit the ground running.

Really!


 


Bring back Brolin

KB Flag 10 Nov 17 4.08pm

[quote=Tim Gypsy Hill '64;3265288]

I can't really understand what you mean here. He wins more than anyone else, but loses some too. He cannot win them all. What do you expect?

If we didn't hit it long to him, he wouldn't get the opportunity to win/lose aerial duals. He would neither win or lose, as the ball isn't aerial!

Of course he cannot win them all. I mean that I think he's good with his head, but I think there are better target men for winning the ball and that other teams don't play as many long balls which is why their headed stats are less impressive. Their forwards have less aerial duels.

I think he could be better troubling defenders and letting them know they're in for a game. For his size he is not as physically imposing as he could be.

I don't mean to knock him as a player. I'm grateful we have him, his goal return is very good, and I think he is one of the best headers of the ball in the premier league when he's in the box.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 10 Nov 17 5.11pm

I'm hoping for much more from him than he seemed to be offering recently. Under De Boer he looked laboured and even uninterested - then again, so did most of the team.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Jon1ukg Flag 10 Nov 17 5.32pm

Roy does seem to prefer 442 although he may go with the 433 but getting someone wether it's wilf, andros or RLC to get closer to tekkers when possible as I feel FDB tactics didn't suit him leaving him isolated which doesn't suit his style and with wilf and andros playing as a two up front I feel 'hope' they may be more inclined to want to play off him.

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 10 Nov 17 6.11pm

People going on about how Benteke was a different player at Villa...I think highlights determine how you view a player as we see a lot more of him now than when he was at Villa. His stats for the last few seasons have barely changed.

I have actually just written a blogpost on this very subject - have a read!

[Link]

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

victor43 Flag St. Albans 10 Nov 17 6.19pm

Originally posted by KB

He loses a lot of them too though. That stat really surprised me, but is very impressive. I feel though that his rate of winning them would not be so impressive, and that this stat is partly due to our style of play and hitting it long to Benteke so often. Some of the headed goals he's scored are phenomenal, but I think Murray was better at winning aerial duels and retaining possession (not trying to turn this into a Murray thread)

Murray has averaged 47% aerial duel success rate since 13/14, Benteke 57% since 12/13.

Murray averages 4.7 possession losses/ unsuccessful touches per game, Benteke 4.8.

I'd say based on those stats Benteke edges it.

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

KB Flag 10 Nov 17 7.20pm

Originally posted by victor43

Murray has averaged 47% aerial duel success rate since 13/14, Benteke 57% since 12/13.

Murray averages 4.7 possession losses/ unsuccessful touches per game, Benteke 4.8.

I'd say based on those stats Benteke edges it.

Wow, I find that a bit surprising. But if that's the stats, fair enough.

I suppose my opinions come from feeling Murray worked harder (Benteke's running stats may be better, i don't know). From games like beating Man city at home and Sunderland away where his graft created goals. The only Benteke goal I can think of in the same mould was when he scored against us, pinching it off Scott Dann. Still, I don't care where the goals come from and can't wait for him to come back.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 11 Nov 17 6.09am

Originally posted by victor43

People going on about how Benteke was a different player at Villa...I think highlights determine how you view a player as we see a lot more of him now than when he was at Villa. His stats for the last few seasons have barely changed.

I have actually just written a blogpost on this very subject - have a read!

[Link]

He was the complete player at Villa! Winning the ball, taking on players, create chances and of course, scoring goals. Now he's just a pale shadow of that player...whatever way you look at it!! Ex. lost the ball at half way line vs Man City just before halftime for their 1-0 goal.....? Yeah, you are right - Tekkers!

 

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 11 Nov 17 11.09am

Victor 43's blog on Benteke was informative. In the Spurs game, it was striking how many aerial contests such as throw ins and goal kicks/kicks from keepers' hands we did not win. With Benteke we win a lot of those kind of balls.It's true, however that his isolation in the early part of the season meant it was ineffective. Because of this impact and because of his record over several seasons as a goal-scorer, having him available is potentially crucial to our success. Him with A.J would have been effective, but finding another A.J or playing a 2 up front are options we may not have.

 

simlaboy Flag coulsdon 14 Nov 17 3.50pm

Anybody know if he’s available On Saturday, Everton very poor through the middle at the back

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 14 Nov 17 4.26pm

Originally posted by simlaboy

Anybody know if he’s available On Saturday, Everton very poor through the middle at the back

Think we'll only find out from Roy's pre match press conference whenever the f*** they are these days...

 

The Dolphin Flag 15 Nov 17 8.55am

According to the Premier League injury list his return date has been put back to November 25th.
Just in time to get injured again by a Stoke thug!

 

mattteo Flag 15 Nov 17 2.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

Benteke did score 15 PL goals for us last season which is not bad at all, especially as we were a struggling team.

2 of those were penalties. The other 13 came in 3100 minutes of gametime. Add to that 600 more minutes of Premier League football without any goal this season. That gets him to roughly 1 goal every 300 minutes.
That's very little if you want to stay in the Premier League.

And about the struggling team excuse: all teams from number 10 downwards were struggling last season. Yet their strikers have a better goals to minutes ratio than Ben. I'm talking here about Abel Hernandez, Niasse, Andre Gray, Josh King, Llorente, Vardy, Rondon, Andy Carroll, Charlie Austin, Slimani, Benik Afobe, Jay Rodriguez, Gabbiadini, Enner Valencia, pretty much any starter for low table PL team had better goals to minutes played ratio than Benteke, even some substitute ones.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 16 Nov 17 3.08pm

According to Talksport Bentenke is fit for the game against Everton. Loftus Cheek missed training and maybe out.

 


One more point

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Return of big ben