You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ben Foster caught on the ball
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ben Foster caught on the ball


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
chateauferret Flag 03 Dec 17 2.31pm

Originally posted by peterg

I suspect the ref was so preoccupied with not giving Wilf a penalty that he forgot about the back-pass. If he had been more clever, he could have given the indirect free-kick for handling the back-pass as a way of evening up for not giving Wilf the pen. Still, since Wilf never gets pens (apart from the blatant one in the Watford play-off) and is usually booked for diving instead, the ref probably thought - well I won't book Wilf this time and we'll just leave things there, so he evened up that way.

Maybe, but there's another of the unwritten laws of football: players don't fall over. Either it's a foul or a dive. Which, of course, is nonsense.

Edited by chateauferret (04 Dec 2017 9.48am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

hastingseagle67 Flag 03 Dec 17 3.01pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Zaha went crazy at the ref because he thought he should have had a penalty. He may well have been right. I suppose the ref was probably more interested in that than the handling issue or as you say had forgotten that there had been a back pass as it was sonetime earlier. Easy for him to miss and not something he'd be looming out for, like a trip or a shove. And if he isn't sure he won't give it. He might also have thought Wilf touched the ball.

If it were a penalty and not an IFK for handling I'd be a lot more animated about it. But then it would fall under the gaze of a VAR, when and if we get those, and refs would be better primed to spot it.

Seems a bit silly to me that a keeper can't hadle when an opponent is interfering with play, though, given that the spirit is to prevent timewasting. It's not as if timewasting itself isn't a bookable offence.

As for the refs they have been so poor lately and they have been getting wrong much, much easier decisions than this on a regular basis.


Edited by chateauferret (03 Dec 2017 11.57am)

I have to disagree with you here. Although not a hundred per cent certain, I think that wilf was going crazy because he knew that he hadn’t touched it before Foster handled it. The commentators on the stream I was watching, made the same assumption as you that wilf was shouting for a penalty, and I remember thinking at the time that sometimes these pundits don’t have a clue about some things they are watching.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 03 Dec 17 6.50pm

Originally posted by ta11berg

I was sitting immediately behind that goal with the baggies fans, and had no doubt it was a penalty, and nor did they. It went very quiet and the abuse of Zaha paused significantly. He was fouled by Foster with an open goal in front of him,was my impression,I have not seen the replays. It seems the ref was equally unpopular at my end of the ground. Incidentally sitting with the home support gave you a very good feel about how well we played and our possession was a delight

yeah but it was Zaha, and as you know, any fouls on Zaha in the box dont count as fouls, at least with any referee we've had this season

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 03 Dec 17 7.07pm

Every game yesterday seemed to produce an incident similar to this, where a video referee would be in a far better position to make a better decision than an on field referee.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Elpis Flag In a pub 03 Dec 17 7.24pm

The ref just got it wrong , an indirect free kick was the correct decision but when was the last time anyone saw an indirect free kick given ? (I think I may have asked that before )
WBA got lucky on that occasion and again when Zaha was fouled in the box .

Maybe we will get lucky next week

 

The Dolphin Flag 03 Dec 17 10.07pm

Chris Kamara said penalty and i stand corrected from my post earlier.
It was.

 

chateauferret Flag 03 Dec 17 10.32pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Chris Kamara said penalty and i stand corrected from my post earlier.
It was.

Excellent gamesmanship by the keeper then. Get away with an illegal handling by giving the ref a penalty shout to think about instead, and make sure the penalty isn't given by making sure it's Wilf.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Dec 17 3.47pm

Good to see MOTD couldn,t even be bothered to discuss it.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 04 Dec 17 4.00pm

Originally posted by berlinpalace

What should've given the ref a clue was the lengths Foster was going to to not put a hand on the ball before deciding that the risk of Wilf scoring was too great.

Agreed.

A bit like the Enckelman own goal v Birmingham. He could've let it go in the goal from the throw in and it wouldn't have counted, but as he'd tried to play the ball and then frantically tried to stop it going in after messing it up, whether he'd actually touched the ball or not was irrelevant by then as his actions/panic made it look like he certainly had.

 


Optimistic as ever

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 04 Dec 17 4.04pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Good to see MOTD couldn,t even be bothered to discuss it.


They were out of time, suprised they even showed the match, you know how much they love putting us on......last......again.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 04 Dec 17 4.28pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


They were out of time, suprised they even showed the match, you know how much they love putting us on......last......again.

To be fair the match was poor with no goals and deserved to be last. Not even discussing the incident was shocking though

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 04 Dec 17 4.29pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

They were out of time, suprised they even showed the match, you know how much they love putting us on......last......again.

To be fair, a 0-0 draw between 4th from bottom vs. 3rd from bottom - with the only real talking point being the non-award of an indirect free kick (although I still think it was a penalty) - hardly deserves top billing.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

MikeCrete Flag Crete 04 Dec 17 4.39pm

Originally posted by chateauferret palace twitter feed shows a picture which has Fosters hand in front of Wilfs foot, from behind!
I thought it was a pen Saturday & asked my wife; who was watching a live feed in Crete; she said the commentators said the goalie was very lucky a pen was not given. Would need a proper ref ruling on once the goalie tries to dribble it is the back pass no longer an issue; but don’t want Willo to take over the thread.

Zaha went crazy at the ref because he thought he should have had a penalty. He may well have been right. I suppose the ref was probably more interested in that than the handling issue or as you say had forgotten that there had been a back pass as it was sonetime earlier. Easy for him to miss and not something he'd be looming out for, like a trip or a shove. And if he isn't sure he won't give it. He might also have thought Wilf touched the ball.

If it were a penalty and not an IFK for handling I'd be a lot more animated about it. But then it would fall under the gaze of a VAR, when and if we get those, and refs would be better primed to spot it.

Seems a bit silly to me that a keeper can't hadle when an opponent is interfering with play, though, given that the spirit is to prevent timewasting. It's not as if timewasting itself isn't a bookable offence.

As for the refs they have been so poor lately and they have been getting wrong much, much easier decisions than this on a regular basis.


Edited by chateauferret (03 Dec 2017 11.57am)

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 04 Dec 17 4.51pm

Originally posted by MikeCrete

Seems a bit silly to me that a keeper can't handle when an opponent is interfering with play, though, given that the spirit is to prevent timewasting. It's not as if timewasting itself isn't a bookable offence.

I have seen this wrinkle in the thread - that a keeper can handle a backpass if threatened by an opponent - and I'm completely confused by the sentiment. It's just not in the rules or in the referees guidelines. In fact, keepers only handle backpasses when under pressure from an opposing player, so having this be a "Get Out of Jail Free" card makes no sense.

Forster was not allowed to handle that ball as it was deliberately kicked back to him by a team mate and had not been touched by any other player in the meantime. It ticked all the boxes for a deliberate handball which, as many have said in this thread, is an indirect freekick and yellow card. It's so clear that Forster chose to take the IFK and card rather than let Zaha whip in for an easy goal.

In fact, in his enthusiasm to get his hands on the ball, he got his arms tangled up in Zaha's legs, which is why I think it was penalty. "Play on", which is what was given, was the only thing it wasn't.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

MikeCrete Flag Crete 04 Dec 17 4.54pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I have seen this wrinkle in the thread - that a keeper can handle a backpass if threatened by an opponent - and I'm completely confused by the sentiment. It's just not in the rules or in the referees guidelines. In fact, keepers only handle backpasses when under pressure from an opposing player, so having this be a "Get Out of Jail Free" card makes no sense.

Forster was not allowed to handle that ball as it was deliberately kicked back to him by a team mate and had not been touched by any other player in the meantime. It ticked all the boxes for a deliberate handball which, as many have said in this thread, is an indirect freekick and yellow card. It's so clear that Forster chose to take the IFK and card rather than let Zaha whip in for an easy goal.

In fact, in his enthusiasm to get his hands on the ball, he got his arms tangled up in Zaha's legs, which is why I think it was penalty. "Play on", which is what was given, was the only thing it wasn't.

Actually Ray, that’s not mine, is in the post I was replying to, only just sussed how to put a reply in so it’s mine, not included at the top of the post I want to reply to. Pen all day long for me.

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 04 Dec 17 8.04pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I have seen this wrinkle in the thread - that a keeper can handle a backpass if threatened by an opponent - and I'm completely confused by the sentiment. It's just not in the rules or in the referees guidelines. In fact, keepers only handle backpasses when under pressure from an opposing player, so having this be a "Get Out of Jail Free" card makes no sense.

Forster was not allowed to handle that ball as it was deliberately kicked back to him by a team mate and had not been touched by any other player in the meantime. It ticked all the boxes for a deliberate handball which, as many have said in this thread, is an indirect freekick and yellow card. It's so clear that Forster chose to take the IFK and card rather than let Zaha whip in for an easy goal.

In fact, in his enthusiasm to get his hands on the ball, he got his arms tangled up in Zaha's legs, which is why I think it was penalty. "Play on", which is what was given, was the only thing it wasn't.

I disagreed with you in the match thread and said I'd have to see it again. After having actually seen it again I have to agree with you, unsurprisingly. Though I'm still not sure it was a pen, it was a definite indirect free kick.

Edited by boo909 (04 Dec 2017 8.05pm)

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

boo909 Flag Figeac 04 Dec 17 8.04pm

Crap. Quoted myself instead of editing.


Edited by boo909 (04 Dec 2017 8.05pm)

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 05 Dec 17 10.30am

Perhaps we haven’t noticed the change to the back pass rule that allows the keeper to pick up the ball (or push it away) when he is under pressure and so the ref can now judge when the keeper is under sufficient pressure that the back pass rule should be ignored. Which of course is a perfect opportunity for refs to make a decision that favours one team over another, which of course couldn’t happen because we know that they are all scrupulously fair.

Why don’t we just go back to the old days of simply letting the keeper always pick up the ball?

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 05 Dec 17 12.13pm

It's a handball as clear as day. His incompetence in fielding a backpass doesn't then allow him to handle it. He had simpler options, he lacked -- momentarily -- the skills/decision-making to take them, and put his hand on the ball to stop Wilf from getting it. The fact he lets go of the ball instantaneously is clear proof he knew he handled it. It's a free kick for Luka to blast toward the net/foolish defenders heads.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 05 Dec 17 12.20pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

It's a handball as clear as day. His incompetence in fielding a backpass doesn't then allow him to handle it. He had simpler options, he lacked -- momentarily -- the skills/decision-making to take them, and put his hand on the ball to stop Wilf from getting it. The fact he lets go of the ball instantaneously is clear proof he knew he handled it. It's a free kick for Luka to blast toward the net/foolish defenders heads.

The Palace fans see this, its always the idiot with the responsibility for managing the game that misses it. Getting a bit sick of poor refereeing and more particularly against us.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ben Foster caught on the ball