You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who is our Second-Greatest Ever Manager?
November 16 2026 7.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who is our Second-Greatest Ever Manager?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Beastie Flag 15 Dec 17 11.34am

Has to be Pardew.

Achieved our only top 10 Premier League finish. Second highest finish of all time. Reached only our second ever FA cup final. Not associated with any relegations or boring sides (unlike Copell). May well keep WBA up at our expense.

We really should name the new stand after him.

 

Fatherken Flag 15 Dec 17 11.46am

Bert Head the best after Sir Steve

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 15 Dec 17 11.48am

I want to give it to Pardew, just for his involvement in Speronis testimonial! The place erupted. Like he was as a manager he looked amazing for a few minutes and then looked exhausted and broken, but what a few minutes...
Pretty much sums up his time as manager too...

 

YT Flag Oxford 15 Dec 17 12.04pm

Originally posted by Zimeagle

For starting the club then taking over as manager for 25 years I'd say Edmund Goodman ( for that achievement he may even shade Steve Coppell ). Bert Head, Arthur Rowe and Dick Graham also brought success and progressed the club. Big Mal for the excitement and raising our profile, followed by Venables who built on Big Mal's work. It's difficult to choose one, given that they operated at different times under different constraints.

You could be the next Reverend Nigel Sands

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

pssguy Flag 15 Dec 17 2.46pm

Originally posted by Joe Bloggs

Bert Head ( although he did buy a lot of players)

Nothing wrong with that if you can integrate them well
He got some very useful Scottish players - when there were still some good ones - at low prices

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 15 Dec 17 3.17pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Steve Bruce.

That's who sprung to mind for me, I've said it on another thread but we were playing some of the best football I've seen us play under him. Such a shame he fooked off after such a short amount of time, the fcuking fat, ugly pig

 

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 15 Dec 17 4.01pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Nothing wrong with that if you can integrate them well
He got some very useful Scottish players - when there were still some good ones - at low prices

I had no intention on writing an essay on Bert Head but as much as I liked the man the reason that I made such a comment was because ultimately he did quantity over quality.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 15 Dec 17 4.26pm

Originally posted by Joe Bloggs

I had no intention on writing an essay on Bert Head but as much as I liked the man the reason that I made such a comment was because ultimately he did quantity over quality.

He did bring us Don Rogers though, possibly one of the most exciting players to watch, along with Johnny Byrne, the Palace ever had.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

dg1937 Flag 15 Dec 17 8.27pm

Congratulations to the OP for an interesting thread.

Dick Graham, mentioned once earlier, did introduce the innovation of giving random shirt numbers to players so the opposition couldn't work out the formation (this was in the days when No.3 was always the left back and so on). I kid you not. The man was 50 years ahead of his time!

More seriously I will always have a soft spot for Bert Head and that first ever season in the top flight. And, as has already been mentioned he brought Don Rogers to the club.

Big Mal will always be a hero too. When we played Chelsea in the cup at Stamford Bridge I was pretty terrified of the Shed's fearsome reputation for thuggery. Big Mal came out and strolled round the pitch doffing his fedora to the baying mob. He'd be on an FA charge for incitement these days.

Terry Venables would be my choice were it not for what happened when he left the club (the first time). I still think there was something very dodgy about it all and were it not for fear of the libel laws I might suggest he was the Harry Rednapp of his day.

I'm going to opt for Bert Head simply because just hearing his name makes me feel young again.

 

Co Derry Palace Flag maghera co derry 15 Dec 17 8.46pm

What an excellent idea for a thread. Had me thinking all day.
Coppell tops by a mile.
Venables in 2nd place, became manager of a 3rd Division team in the summer of '76 and had them top of the 1st Division by Sept'79. You can't do any better than that, although he did tarnish his legacy after.
Bert Head 3rd.
I am sorry, but 2 relegations, Allison will always be bottom.

 

Mstrobez Flag 15 Dec 17 9.07pm

In my lifetime and at the time (and controversially) - Dougie Freedman. I've never seen Palace dominate games in the way they did on occasions at Selhurst in the first half of that promotion season.

I'm also in the very small minority who thinks, had he been given more time, Frank de Boer could've gone to be one of the best we had but we'll never know.

In terms of Roy, I will never judge how great a manager is until they've been with the club for 2 years minimum. Anything prior to that is just how well they can solve an immediate problem. Big Sam was fantastic at it for example, would've he still been a hero a year or 2 down the line? I'm not so sure. I also remember warring with HOLers at the end of Pardews first season, questioning if he was really the messiah some were adamant he was.

Unfortunately in recent times, Pardews the only one we've ever really been able to assess over a sustained period of time.

Edited by Mstrobez (15 Dec 2017 9.08pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

chateauferret Flag 15 Dec 17 9.08pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

In my lifetime and at the time (and controversially) - Dougie Freedman. I've never seen Palace dominate games in the way they did on occasions at Selhurst in the first half of that promotion season.

I'm also in the very small minority who thinks, had he been given more time, Frank de Boer could've gone to be one of the best we had but we'll never know.

In terms of Roy, I will never judge how great a manager is until they've been with the club for 2 years minimum. Anything prior to that is just how well they can solve an immediate problem. Big Sam was fantastic at it for example, would've he still been a hero a year or 2 down the line? I'm not so sure. I also remember warring with HOLers at the end of Pardews first season, questioning if he was really the messiah some were adamant he was.

Unfortunately in recent times, Pardews the only one we've ever really been able to assess over a sustained period of time.

Edited by Mstrobez (15 Dec 2017 9.08pm)

Too sustained a period of time IMHO.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 15 Dec 17 9.12pm

Steve Kember - Portsmouth and Stockport. Miracle worker.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Mstrobez Flag 15 Dec 17 9.16pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Too sustained a period of time IMHO.

Definitely, but there were many who viewed as him as a hero at the end of that first season. Same with Sam and undoubtedly Roy if he keeps us up.

Although I must admit, out of the 3, Roy has impressed me the most at this stage. As a long term option, his age on its own makes him unlikely to ever be the answer. But we've genuinely played some very decent stuff under him in certain games and I'd have eternal respect for him if he keeps us up. Seems a gent too.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

davidpercival Flag Croydon 15 Dec 17 10.42pm

Got to be Bert Head. 1st manager to get Palace in top division.

Originally posted by TheBigToePunt

Whilst reading some of the positive comments about Roy Hodgson on another thread it struck me that it really doesn't take too much for a manager to become a potential CPFC managerial 'legend', or at least to be a serious contender for a place in our all time best top five.

Number one on the list is of course taken, most likely forever, by Steve Coppell (after whom the new stand absolutely must be named in my opinion) but after that there are fairly few obvious contenders.

We have quite a reasonable list to pick from when considering our five best ever players, but if you try to make a top five of managers it becomes quite hard work pretty quickly, which probably says quite a bit in itself.

Even so, who is your (second) greatest ever manager, and why?

Most of my nominations have some sort of black mark against their names which cancel out their achievements to some extent:

Freedman - Built a great side for a pittance in the championship which went on to get promoted and form the foundation for staying there (so far). Also buggered off to Bolton.

Dowie - Injected life into a corpse when he came in, created fantastic momentum which ended in promotion, and came a goal away from keeping us up. Then left to be 'closer to his family in the Northwest', which he achieved by managing Charlton.

Pulis - Easy to forget how dead in the water the team was when he came in. Rightly awarded League Manager of the Year for keeping us up, not only was this a near-miracle in itself, it was also the key to everything that the club has become since. Then walked out on the eve of the season leaving us in the lurch, lied to the club to get a load of money, and had to be dragged through the Courts where he was found, in no uncertain terms, to have acted with the utmost disdain for CPFC.

Any other ideas?


Edited by TheBigToePunt (14 Dec 2017 1.59pm)

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 16 Dec 17 7.27am

Originally posted by eagleman13

^^^^^ This. Seconded. Agreed. ^^^^^


Yea, me to, can't argue with (1) coppel (2)Venables (3)head, but also loved Big Mal

 

pssguy Flag 16 Dec 17 12.07pm

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

He did bring us Don Rogers though, possibly one of the most exciting players to watch, along with Johnny Byrne, the Palace ever had.

Plus, for peanuts, McCormick and Blyth - one of our best-ever partnerships in central defence. Not forgetting, Cliff Jackson, whose many goals in the promotion seasons were crucial

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 16 Dec 17 2.52pm

Enables first time by a mile , and Allison .

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 16 Dec 17 3.11pm

It could end up being Woy in a few years time!

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 16 Dec 17 5.49pm

Venables has to be blacklisted. He destroyed Allison's team of the eigties and our last big chance of a long stint in the top flight for personal gain and then nearly destroyed the club in his second stint demanding full payment for his contract when we went into administration. To think he is our second best manager just highlights what a terrible bunch of managers we have had.

I would put Bert Head probably at number two.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who is our Second-Greatest Ever Manager?