You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > biggest poppulation & biggest debt
November 21 2026 9.31pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

biggest poppulation & biggest debt


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 29 Dec 17 12.20am

Originally posted by cryrst

We didn't give it to the banks and on reselling the shares we have made a profit.
If they thought it was goner lose dough they wouldn't have done it.
Also it isn't the same as Freddie Mac and Fannie may in the USA.
It saved thousands of jobs as well.
Also the money spent wouldn't have been spent on us anyway as it wasn't in any budget.
Need to stop blaming investing as the big problem. That is tons of people not putting in and still taking out.

Most of the shares are still in public ownership and slated to be liquidated at a massive loss by this government in next two years

Edited by CambridgeEagle (29 Dec 2017 12.53am)

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 29 Dec 17 12.24am

Originally posted by cryrst

We didn't give it to the banks and on reselling the shares we have made a profit.
If they thought it was goner lose dough they wouldn't have done it.
Also it isn't the same as Freddie Mac and Fannie may in the USA.
It saved thousands of jobs as well.
Also the money spent wouldn't have been spent on us anyway as it wasn't in any budget.
Need to stop blaming investing as the big problem. That is tons of people not putting in and still taking out.

Investing or the lack of it is a major problem. UK has one of the worst levels of corporate investment in developed world and in fact its lower than the rate of capital depreciation meaning we're now having to try and do more with less in the private sector. Hence very poor productivity. Add to this austerity and lack of public investment and bingo. Diminishing living standards and crumbling public services and infrastructure.

Businesses want immigration as it's cheap labour but don't want to pay for the means to support it and governments have been too incompetent.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 29 Dec 17 12.26am

Originally posted by cryrst

We didn't give it to the banks and on reselling the shares we have made a profit.
If they thought it was goner lose dough they wouldn't have done it.
Also it isn't the same as Freddie Mac and Fannie may in the USA.
It saved thousands of jobs as well.
Also the money spent wouldn't have been spent on us anyway as it wasn't in any budget.
Need to stop blaming investing as the big problem. That is tons of people not putting in and still taking out.

Who told you we made a profit on the shares? On some subsets a small return was made, not commensurate with returns from other investments over the period. But there were also elements carved out as bad banks where we lost our shirts.

As Cambridge says above. Check out the NAO report from July

Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2017 12.36am)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 29 Dec 17 9.36am

Originally posted by johnfirewall

I was wondering why she didn't appear in your first line but I guess that was just a clever way of saying she sold off the houses that in reality no cnut wanted to live in.

Now they do, in their millions, just in London, so how the addition of new stock to the public market has caused this problem, you'll have to explain.

Not sure why you're talking about workers and social housing in the same sentence either, or even affordable, which has always been a myth since the term's inception, not least when we're talking about national debt.

Maybe plot GDP/ debt/ population rather for a more balanced evaluation. Someone get the graphs.

Ignorant, shows you to be a snob and totally wrong.

The rest of your post lacks clarity but not, perhaps, alcohol.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Stirlingsays Flag 29 Dec 17 10.10am

Originally posted by .TUX.

Jesus wept, it's exactly the bloody same!
And yes, it did ''save thousands of jobs'' but was it really worth it at the expense of millions for 8yrs now.......that includes YOU?

Blinkered to say the least.

?

It saved millions of jobs. You are the blinkered one here. Welcome to Greek economics on acid.

Most jobs are wrapped up in smaller businessness, which survive on credit. They get by on overdrafts and all the rest of it.

Did you have money in a bank account? Because if you did you would have lost all of it and had no recourse to be certain of.

Yes it was bloody worth it......what realistic other choice was there....let the banks fold? In an ideal world....yeah....if you have money enough to get through the next five years great for you...but what everybody else?

Was it ethically ok......no it bloody wasn't....life isn't fair and it was a prime and bloody clear example of it.

What can we do about it? Nothing......it's apart of the unfairness of life that we have to put up with because there is no radically different system (which is no assurance of improvement) can be enacted without revolution....and no real revolution happens without blood...anyone telling you different is deluded or a liar.....the banking system is full of gutter low lifes with big lifestyles but it is also full of savings, accounts, pensions, government bonds and all the rest of it.....you can fiddle around the edges...ring fence this or that but that's about it if you are even going to pretend in a free market.

You can't divorce the baby from the bath water.


Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2017 10.20am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 29 Dec 17 10.24am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

?

It saved millions of jobs. You are the blinkered one here. Welcome to Greek economics on acid.

Most jobs are wrapped up in smaller businessness, which survive on credit. They get by on overdrafts and all the rest of it.

Did you have money in a bank account? Because if you did you would have lost all of it and had no recourse to be certain of.

Yes it was bloody worth it......what realistic other choice was there....let the banks fold? In an ideal world....yeah....if you have money enough to get through the next five years great for you...but what everybody else?

Was it ethically ok......no it bloody wasn't....life isn't fair and it was a prime and bloody clear example of it.

What can we do about it? Nothing......it's apart of the unfairness of life that we have to put up with because there is no radically different system (which is no assurance of improvement) can be enacted without revolution....and no real revolution happens without blood...anyone telling you different is deluded or a liar.....the banking system is full of gutter low lifes with big lifestyles but it is also full of savings, accounts, pensions, government bonds and all the rest of it.....you can fiddle around the edges...ring fence this or that but that's about it if you are even going to pretend in a free market.

You can't divorce the baby from the bath water.


Edited by Stirlingsays (29 Dec 2017 10.20am)

Iranian revolution 1979? Fall of the Berlin Wall 1989? The Velvet Revolution also 1989?

The rest of your post is pretty much spot on but the bold bit is wrong. There have been bloody consequences in Iran but the actual revolution itself was bloodless.

Edited by Kermit8 (29 Dec 2017 10.25am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 29 Dec 17 10.39am

It is a funny argument in my mind. Take London. It has just returned to its population level of 1939, a little higher than it was post-war. That means that we, as a state, have had 70 years to plan a city around a population of 8 million, and for the most part, rising.

Why then do we have a homeless crisis? To my mind, blaming overpopulation could make sense if we had seen a sudden increase in population, but we haven't seen that, either in London or the rest of the UK. Migration has been steady, emigration is now on the increase, and if anything we have a problem with birthrates of citizens.

So what argument is overpopulation a convenient one to deploy against? Well, when we talk about overpopulation, we ignore the fact that we are the most unequal nation in Europe; that we are the 5th richest economy in the world, and yet thousands will go to sleep tonight in temporary, inadequate accommodation or worse; that the UK population gives the government nearly 800 billion a year in tax, and yet that government at the moment can't even house all of its citizens.

We aren't facing any problems that we, as humans, haven't faced before, and haven't dealt with before. All it takes is us to have the courage to tackle them, and for normal people like us to not allow the decisions to be made by vested interest groups at the very top of our society.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 29 Dec 17 11.32am

The Big Issue was founded in 1991 in response to the serious housing problems occurring with the shock of the policies of the 80's which have still to be rectified. Not one government since has really properly tackled the ongoing demands of the sector since and has just watched it get worse.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Dec 17 11.42am

Originally posted by serial thriller

It is a funny argument in my mind. Take London. It has just returned to its population level of 1939, a little higher than it was post-war. That means that we, as a state, have had 70 years to plan a city around a population of 8 million, and for the most part, rising.

Why then do we have a homeless crisis? To my mind, blaming overpopulation could make sense if we had seen a sudden increase in population, but we haven't seen that, either in London or the rest of the UK. Migration has been steady, emigration is now on the increase, and if anything we have a problem with birthrates of citizens.

So what argument is overpopulation a convenient one to deploy against? Well, when we talk about overpopulation, we ignore the fact that we are the most unequal nation in Europe; that we are the 5th richest economy in the world, and yet thousands will go to sleep tonight in temporary, inadequate accommodation or worse; that the UK population gives the government nearly 800 billion a year in tax, and yet that government at the moment can't even house all of its citizens.

We aren't facing any problems that we, as humans, haven't faced before, and haven't dealt with before. All it takes is us to have the courage to tackle them, and for normal people like us to not allow the decisions to be made by vested interest groups at the very top of our society.

Why do people bend over backwards to avoid a simple obvious reality? It's OK I already know.

Which part of an increasing population needs an increasing number of houses is too hard for them to understand?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Dec 17 11.46am

Originally posted by Mapletree

Might be better to answer the question.

Immigrants are more likely to have jobs and less likely to use any and all public services.

Our problem is dreadful productivity fuelled by poor investment decisions. Immigration has disguised the scale of the problem but can’t reasonably be claimed to have caused it.

Do you think we can have an annual population increase of the size of recent years, every year for the forseeable future? It's a simple question.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Dec 2017 12.55pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Dec 17 12.48pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Deflection. More people means bigger housing crisis.

I don't want to live in a country with an insane population density and I'm not wasting my time engaging with irrational people on ths subject.

True, but then less people means a massive crash of the housing market, and the UK economy is very dependent on that market. The route of the problem is several factors

1) EU working migration levels increasing the population
2) Shortage of Property and an unregulated property and rental market
3) An economy driven by the housing market.
4) Cuts to public spending, to pay for tax cuts and corporate tax cuts.
5) Suppression of supply to the job market through the use of migrant workers.
6) Corporations paying minimal taxes.

These are all significant factors. To see this just in terms of population levels is myopic, as there is a reason why the rental market and buy to rent market has been keeping the housing market afloat.

Of course none of this is sustainable - and the housing crisis is probably the single most likely factor to deliver a victory to Labour at an election (now that Brexit is out of the way).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Dec 17 12.54pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

True, but then less people means a massive crash of the housing market, and the UK economy is very dependent on that market. The route of the problem is several factors

1) EU working migration levels increasing the population
2) Shortage of Property and an unregulated property and rental market
3) An economy driven by the housing market.
4) Cuts to public spending, to pay for tax cuts and corporate tax cuts.
5) Suppression of supply to the job market through the use of migrant workers.
6) Corporations paying minimal taxes.

These are all significant factors. To see this just in terms of population levels is myopic, as there is a reason why the rental market and buy to rent market has been keeping the housing market afloat.

Of course none of this is sustainable - and the housing crisis is probably the single most likely factor to deliver a victory to Labour at an election (now that Brexit is out of the way).


It's not just about population but population increase can only make everything worse.

No.4 is a stretch.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Dec 17 2.32pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

Jesus wept, it's exactly the bloody same!
And yes, it did ''save thousands of jobs'' but was it really worth it at the expense of millions for 8yrs now.......that includes YOU?

Blinkered to say the least.

But TUX we would not have the dough now or in any years between.
That's the point.
It wasn't in the budget.
It was borrowed at a very low rate specifically for the bail outs.
Now on reselling any profit WILL go in the budget for us. So in effect we will all benefit ( well some will but probably not me n you !!!!) We work !!!
The yanks issue wasn't the same, as their bad bits made our bad bits look like peanuts.
Speculate to accumulate was the mantra.
It's like you getting a house and not wanting to borrow for it.
You won't have a house then.
It's done and dusted.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 29 Dec 17 3.55pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

Giving hundreds of billions to the banks might have something to do with it.

Does anyone actually think that a country can use billions and billions of public money to bail out private finance and that country would not face decades of hardship.

I think that where you should be looking..

You do realise that the Government made a profit on selling the Lloyds shares...don't you!?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Dec 17 4.18pm

Bailing out the banks was the best of a bad deal. The alternative was to let the banks go bust. I assume that Labour would have protected small savers up to about 75 / 85k. However
- Any individual with savings over the threshold would have lost the lot.
- Any investors / share holders / bond holders would have lost the lot meaning the markets losing confidence in the UK.
- Thousands of ordinary people who work for high street banks would have been laid off through no fault of their own. I worked at Barclays HQ for 3 years the average salary of the folks on the tills outside of London was 16k hardly big money.
- Thousands more people would have lost their jobs indirectly. There are many jobs in Canary Wharf which are only there because of the bankers e.g. shops.
- Thousands of businesses would be in jeopardy. The liquidator's only concern is to get back as much money as they can. Business loans would have been called in companies and people with cash flow problems would not get any leeway.
- Unemployment would go up and the economy would take a hit as less tax money to spend.
- Because the economy is tanking the Chancellor would need to borrow money from the markets to pay the increased benefits bill. Guess what? The markets are made up of the very investors the government knocked. They are not going to want to lend money and if they do they will demand a high rate of interest. I saw this when Argentina knocked the American banks in the 1980's. It killed their economy and of course the ordinary folk suffer.

I could go on as I have previously stated I wasn't happy bailing the banks out. At least this way we could borrow money at a low rate of interest and to some extent the governments (Labour and Tory) have managed the economy. As for getting our money back we will eventually and there is an argument that says the banks should be taxed more to compensate for the grief they caused.

 


One more point

Mapletree Flag Croydon 29 Dec 17 4.58pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Do you think we can have an annual population increase of the size of recent years, every year for the forseeable future? It's a simple question.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (29 Dec 2017 12.55pm)

This is deflection and is not related to the points I was making or the OP was making.

Like I said, answer the question. You need to respond to the specific point of why aren't we more productive if you want to be taken seriously on this thread, instead of taking it back to your own personal agenda.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 29 Dec 17 5.00pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

You do realise that the Government made a profit on selling the Lloyds shares...don't you!?

I repeat my point above. The Government did not and therefore there is nothing to 'realise'. Please use facts instead of the sound bites fed to us all by the media.

I recommend the NAO July report.

This link is also interesting

[Link]

Another really crucial point is what would the Government have done with the money had it not bailed out the Banks. We missed out on a generation of investment.

I am not saying it was the wrong thing to do, in all probability needs must. But it has affected us way more than people realise.

Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2017 5.02pm)

Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2017 5.04pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Dec 17 5.25pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

I repeat my point above. The Government did not and therefore there is nothing to 'realise'. Please use facts instead of the sound bites fed to us all by the media.

I recommend the NAO July report.

This link is also interesting

[Link]

Another really crucial point is what would the Government have done with the money had it not bailed out the Banks. We missed out on a generation of investment.

I am not saying it was the wrong thing to do, in all probability needs must. But it has affected us way more than people realise.

Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2017 5.02pm)

Edited by Mapletree (29 Dec 2017 5.04pm)

Except Lyons is talking about Lloyds and the NAO report is about RBS.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Dec 17 5.31pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


It's not just about population but population increase can only make everything worse.

No.4 is a stretch.

I think its kind of a true state, that between 1980 and 2010 we had governments that effectively kept cutting tax, as a means of winning elections - and fundamentally filled that revenue gap by either privatisation, cuts to government services and stealth taxes.

If you make cuts to public services, you get worse public services - as increasingly what's accessible become less, and more fees are levied - and in the end people end up paying extra.

The problem of increased migration in and of itself isn't a problem for public services, if those services are funded accordingly. A consequence of tax cuts is that you have less funded public services, coping with greater population.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Dec 17 5.36pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Bailing out the banks was the best of a bad deal. The alternative was to let the banks go bust. I assume that Labour would have protected small savers up to about 75 / 85k. However
- Any individual with savings over the threshold would have lost the lot.
- Any investors / share holders / bond holders would have lost the lot meaning the markets losing confidence in the UK.
- Thousands of ordinary people who work for high street banks would have been laid off through no fault of their own. I worked at Barclays HQ for 3 years the average salary of the folks on the tills outside of London was 16k hardly big money.
- Thousands more people would have lost their jobs indirectly. There are many jobs in Canary Wharf which are only there because of the bankers e.g. shops.
- Thousands of businesses would be in jeopardy. The liquidator's only concern is to get back as much money as they can. Business loans would have been called in companies and people with cash flow problems would not get any leeway.
- Unemployment would go up and the economy would take a hit as less tax money to spend.
- Because the economy is tanking the Chancellor would need to borrow money from the markets to pay the increased benefits bill. Guess what? The markets are made up of the very investors the government knocked. They are not going to want to lend money and if they do they will demand a high rate of interest. I saw this when Argentina knocked the American banks in the 1980's. It killed their economy and of course the ordinary folk suffer.

I could go on as I have previously stated I wasn't happy bailing the banks out. At least this way we could borrow money at a low rate of interest and to some extent the governments (Labour and Tory) have managed the economy. As for getting our money back we will eventually and there is an argument that says the banks should be taxed more to compensate for the grief they caused.

Bailing out the banks was a non-question - it had to happen. What I disagree with is the easy with which it was delivered, and the gentle ease with which banks have found their way out.

The UK should have become major shareholders of those banks (if not majority shareholders) and retain those assets indefinitely - effectively part nationalising the industry and maintaining a significant influence over the future of that industry.

Given the amount put in, to save those banks going to the wall, the state should have taken up to 49% shareownership of them.

Also when it came to 'profit' on the money thrown in, it should have been in the region of 20% plus sum for the banks to free themselves of government ownership.

We were far to lenient for a capitalist economic entity lending that amount of money, to prop up a failing business.


Edited by jamiemartin721 (29 Dec 2017 5.38pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > biggest poppulation & biggest debt