This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle
As much as I like him if he is not going to be available to play until the last few games of the season then he should be returned to Chelsea. Our injury issues mean that we need a player on loan that is fit to play now, this is the reality of the situation we are not in a position to carry injured loan players. My feelings too. Shame mind you but has to be.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
This is an easy answer, if he is injured with little prospect of playing again this season then of course he has to go back. We desperately need that loan spot for a prem player. Yes it is. I can't believe Roy truly believes hanging onto him in case he can recover in time for the last few games. We need someone for the many not the few surely? How can we afford to carry someone and take up a valuable loan space in our condition? I'm not sure if Ruben has been fully assessed yet. Maybe Roy is holding on to make a decision? The other factor being none of us know if we can even send him back.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Yes it is. I can't believe Roy truly believes hanging onto him in case he can recover in time for the last few games. We need someone for the many not the few surely? How can we afford to carry someone and take up a valuable loan space in our condition? I'm not sure if Ruben has been fully assessed yet. Maybe Roy is holding on to make a decision? The other factor being none of us know if we can even send him back. Good point. Another thought suppose we want to sign him at the end of the season and privately Chelsea say it is possible. Wouldn't it make sense to wait a few days before returning him so that he feels the love. Not sure I would join a club that kicks me out 5 mins after I got injured especially if the extent of the injury is unclear. So manage his return to Chelsea so he knows we want him.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Yes it is. I can't believe Roy truly believes hanging onto him in case he can recover in time for the last few games. We need someone for the many not the few surely? How can we afford to carry someone and take up a valuable loan space in our condition? I'm not sure if Ruben has been fully assessed yet. Maybe Roy is holding on to make a decision? The other factor being none of us know if we can even send him back. Yes and further to that, were the boot on the other foot and we had loaned someone a player, only for him to pick up a long term injury, how happy would we be if the other club was saying "take this injured player back and give us another one"?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by sxp55
Surprised by the comments about RLC. Think he's a class act and if you looked at him when playing you could spot him out of the crowd as one that was on loan from a bigger club. Was brilliant for England in centre mid, but shunted out wide when playing for Palace. Still don't understand that. This ^^
|
|
|
Originally posted by BelfastEagle
The guy has shown very little playing for us. He seems to have built a reputation based on one England game....even then he was injured for the second England game. At least he is consistently injured. Huge warning signs that somebody so relatively young is plagued by so many injuries. Send him back if possible and move on. Any thoughts of buying him would be utter folly....we have enough sick notes already. There's been a few posts like this. I'm surprised that people feel this way - he was quality when we played him in the middle, switched him wide and he didn't have the same effect (unsurprisingly as this clearly isn't his position) but still chipped in with a couple of assists. He is a class footballer and if people can't see that I'm surprised - not sure the last player I saw at Palace that so rarely loses the ball or gives it away cheaply. The injuries thing is a concern though, especially given his age. I agree he should go back if he isn't going to be fit any time soon, makes little sense - unless of course we don't believe we are likely to loan anyone that will help us out anyway so may as well keep him since I can't imagine we will get any of our loan fee back - which also makes me wonder re fines etc. Read on the weekend (can't remember the player) that if the club that have loaned him don't play him enough, they have to pay an extra fee. Unlikely but possible we face a fine if we send him back as he won't hit a game qouta - one that has a caveat if he is injured. Or I could be talking nonsense. think it's probably nonsense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
There's been a few posts like this. I'm surprised that people feel this way - he was quality when we played him in the middle, switched him wide and he didn't have the same effect (unsurprisingly as this clearly isn't his position) but still chipped in with a couple of assists. He is a class footballer and if people can't see that I'm surprised - not sure the last player I saw at Palace that so rarely loses the ball or gives it away cheaply. The injuries thing is a concern though, especially given his age. I agree he should go back if he isn't going to be fit any time soon, makes little sense - unless of course we don't believe we are likely to loan anyone that will help us out anyway so may as well keep him since I can't imagine we will get any of our loan fee back - which also makes me wonder re fines etc. Read on the weekend (can't remember the player) that if the club that have loaned him don't play him enough, they have to pay an extra fee. Unlikely but possible we face a fine if we send him back as he won't hit a game qouta - one that has a caveat if he is injured. Or I could be talking nonsense. think it's probably nonsense. Us TFM if we cancel the loan there was an extra £1 million fee
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
Remy went back to Chelsea for treatment, the loan wasn't cancelled. Usually with long term injuries the parent club treats them as the player is their asset and wants to make sure they are treated correctly. We should have cancelled Remy's loan as soon as he was injured. Chelsea have stitched us up with loan the last 3 seasons. Players are insured against injury, so their wages and treatment should be covered. Bit of a cvntish situation, though
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by sxp55
Was brilliant for England in centre mid, but shunted out wide when playing for Palace. Still don't understand that.
He played like 1 match. 1 match! How much brilliance was there?? Or do you mean in the U21s? Ok, he was good against the mighty youth teams of Kazahstan and Norway
|
|
|
Conte liked him as a striker not that long ago - I think we should keep our fingers crossed and hope he's back before the end of the season.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.