This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Roy's lack of substitution awareness if baffling. He's run Cabaye into the ground, the bloke looks knackered after 60 mins, make some changes, liven it up a bit!
|
|
|
As many have already said I reckon he’s sticking two fingers up to Steve, Dougie & co.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle
Parish also happens to be the only chairman in our 113 year history to have kept us in the top flight for 5 consecutive seasons during his reign. That seems to be forgotten. We don't have a god given right to be top half of the prem table - for most of us (i'm sure you too Stan) we have all experienced many seasons floundering in the depth of the second tear. I'm sure Parish is as annoyed as rest of us but do we really need to keep blaming him mate.
Parish, and his 3 co-owners before his two American co-owners, did that. The other chairmen (Jordan, Goldberg, Noades, Boyle, etc) were on their own with a board. All this Parish is a god talk is utter rubbish. He is to blame for the mistakes. Do you keep rewarding a kid for making one good decision that corrects two bad ones? We have had how many poor transfer windows in a row? But Parish should get a pass. How many managers has be pi**ed off? Yes, Parish has made some good decisions but they more often than not were made to correct a cock up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle
This is exactly right , with all our injury problems any substitution would have weakened the team. How on earth can this be interpreted as Roy is pissed off with Parish and the transfer dealings. Roy felt from all his managerial experience that there was no need for a change nothing more than that. You may not agree with his decision but don’t make things up about him. COYP 3-1 down with 5 minutes to go... Yeah, you keep the players on who are knackered when you have fresher legs on the bench, who would be more effective.
|
|
|
Sorloth was playing on the left...
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
Substitutions to do what? The game was difficult after the first 4 minutes of the second half but it was not necessarily lost with over 40 still to go. Our best team was already out on the pitch and it might have been expected to show some fight back. Yes, and if Benteke hadn't missed yet another golden chance we'd have been back in it. If we are relegated, he will be the player most to blame. He doesn't seem to read the game, he reacts too slowly, he doesn't gamble on positions, and he doesn't put himself about. His one strength is winning long balls but even then his passing his clumsy and Palace keep losing possession. A total disaster.
The right place at the right time |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
TFM IS a center half. One mistake doesn't make it otherwise Not heading the ball that came down from above him after Tomkins connected would prove Mensah is not a centre half for the English leagues. That was truly pathetic and pathetic isn't a word that should describe a CB in this league. Head that ball away and they don't score. Simple as that. A mistake of not doing anything is pretty difficult to forgive and it's arguably lack of ability in, or understanding the role of, a centre back, than a 'mistake.' Also his defensive work vs Newcastle was poor. Complacency towards his marking and duties vs his marker. Too far away from him and when he went over to meet him in possession it was slow, late and too far away. They scored and created chances from this. Good in possession for a full back. Not good enough without possession. And he's had a bit of a run in the team too.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by peterg
Yes, and if Benteke hadn't missed yet another golden chance we'd have been back in it. If we are relegated, he will be the player most to blame. He doesn't seem to read the game, he reacts too slowly, he doesn't gamble on positions, and he doesn't put himself about. His one strength is winning long balls but even then his passing his clumsy and Palace keep losing possession. A total disaster. All this.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
3-1 down with 5 minutes to go... Yeah, you keep the players on who are knackered when you have fresher legs on the bench, who would be more effective. More effective in your opinion not the managers. Injuries have left us with such a weak bench that, despite having fresh legs, bringing any subs on would not have made us stronger or any more likely to score.
|
|
| Tipp_Eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
As many have already said I reckon he’s sticking two fingers up to Steve, Dougie & co. I reckon your right mate . And I don't blame him.
oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton. |
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
More effective in your opinion not the managers. Injuries have left us with such a weak bench that, despite having fresh legs, bringing any subs on would not have made us stronger or any more likely to score. So the manager is always correct? They never do things because they are stubborn, trying to make a point or just out of ignorance?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Not heading the ball that came down from above him after Tomkins connected would prove Mensah is not a centre half for the English leagues. That was truly pathetic and pathetic isn't a word that should describe a CB in this league. Head that ball away and they don't score. Simple as that. A mistake of not doing anything is pretty difficult to forgive and it's arguably lack of ability in, or understanding the role of, a centre back, than a 'mistake.' Also his defensive work vs Newcastle was poor. Complacency towards his marking and duties vs his marker. Too far away from him and when he went over to meet him in possession it was slow, late and too far away. They scored and created chances from this. Good in possession for a full back. Not good enough without possession. And he's had a bit of a run in the team too. Why do you say TFM is good in possession for a fullback? That's exactly what I think he isn't. He doesn't know what to do with ball, can't really cross. I'd say he's better without possession, but that doesn't make him a fullback. He made a mistake. He's young, there's still much he has to learn. We have to have patience with him. But in the end, he'll either stop making those mistakes and be a solid centre back or make them again and prove he's not good enough for the league. But a right back...never. aaaa, ok, he ca be a right back the same way Ward or Simon Francis or Simpson are....invisible (many describe this as "being constant", but constantly invisible is not what should be sought by clubs)
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
3-1 down with 5 minutes to go... Yeah, you keep the players on who are knackered when you have fresher legs on the bench, who would be more effective. Goodness some people have short memories, I can remember this forum raging at Pardew for making substitutions when we were level, or ahead, and then disaster occurring. ie taking of Maca against Manure and then watching them go straight down the channel Macca was guarding and scoring the winner. It happened more than once but now some of you are moaning we didn't make any substitutions. It's a pity a lot of people don't understand tactics.
Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes. |
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
Mutch wasnn't on the bench. However he could have given Rakip a run out, brought on Riedewald for someone to give fresh energy in midfield. Or how about taking off Benteke, moving Sorloth into the middle with Rakip on the right, put Townsend on the left? We'd lost the game, save some leg and try things out. Oh, and I don't think out best 11 was on the pitch because Sorloth isn't better than one or two on the bench at this stage of his career. Really, what other striker was on the bench, you didn't mean lee surely.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheExpatEagle
Sorloth was playing on the left... Was voted MOM on the BBS, by huge majority
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Why do you say TFM is good in possession for a fullback? That's exactly what I think he isn't. He doesn't know what to do with ball, can't really cross. I'd say he's better without possession, but that doesn't make him a fullback. He made a mistake. He's young, there's still much he has to learn. We have to have patience with him. But in the end, he'll either stop making those mistakes and be a solid centre back or make them again and prove he's not good enough for the league. But a right back...never. aaaa, ok, he ca be a right back the same way Ward or Simon Francis or Simpson are....invisible (many describe this as "being constant", but constantly invisible is not what should be sought by clubs) Is he really? If he has the chance to use his speed to get himself out of trouble.
COYP |
|
|
Game was lost after 3rd goal went in. Should have bought rakip on for a run out and given cabaye/macarthur a rest. Nothing to loose.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PZ Eagle
Goodness some people have short memories, I can remember this forum raging at Pardew for making substitutions when we were level, or ahead, and then disaster occurring. ie taking of Maca against Manure and then watching them go straight down the channel Macca was guarding and scoring the winner. It happened more than once but now some of you are moaning we didn't make any substitutions. It's a pity a lot of people don't understand tactics. Erm... Unless you can provide proof that I have slated Pardew for making subs then kindly direct your drivel elsewhere. I understand tactics just fine, maybe you should try to understand tactics yourself because as we saw, leaving things the same resulted in a 3-1 loss. Not to mention the previous 6 games which also resulted in a 4-1 spanking at Arsenal. If you are getting a beating why not change things around, give someone a run out, try a different idea? You seem to be more clueless than those you are berating.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER
Was voted MOM on the BBS, by huge majority And you point is? I said he was playing on the left and you say he was voted MOM... So what? How is that a reply or even connected to my point?
|
|
|
Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER
Really, what other striker was on the bench, you didn't mean lee surely. Sorloth was on the left. I'm sure you've seen Palace play before so you'd know Townsend could go there. Rakip has played on the right for Malmö so he could go there. Bring Benteke off and put Sorloth in the middle. It's not rocket science, is it? But, I doubt Rakip is as good as Lee ATM because he needs to get used to the PL and get match fit. Even so there were options.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.