This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
FdB, Benteke, Sakho, Wickham etc etc. FdB it seems was a mistake, but Bentenke had a good first season and his goals played a big part in keeping us up, Sakho was a beast last season and pretty much everyone wanted him back, while Wickham was showing some really good form just before his injury and was not awful before that. Add to that signings like Dann, Tomkins, Luka, Cabaye and McArthur. You can't say all the bad ones are SP's fault and all the good ones are the manager's. Also, he was the one who fought to get Zaha back, maybe even to the point of pushing Pulis out. Would anyone rather have Pulis than Zaha? I know I wouldn't. I agree that it would appear there is something not right with the way we are managing the transfer windows and I also would hazard a guess that some of Roy's predecessors may have wanted more control over transfers and that's why they left. He has not been perfect, but in my time supporting Palace I would say he's been our best chairman and I would definitely have him over Russian mafia, Saudi blood money, Chicken dealers or the fat, unpopular bloke at Newcastle. Some people just seem to want a scapegoat to get angry at when results don't go our way and I get that and I just hope SP and the club can see it is just frustration too, plus as a fan I'm sure he is just as frustrated.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Username
Very, very harsh to call Wickham a mistake. Benteke kept us up last season with his goals. Sakho? Go back and read the threads from over the summer, the overwhelming majority of people on here wanted that deal to happen, and were annoyed that we were haggling over the price. FDB, yep he was a mistake, and one that was rectified about as quickly as possible. I don’t disagree. As I said further down, luck plays a huge part and with so many players currently injured SP’s luck has run out through injury.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Norway
Listen - without Steve Parish Palace would have been somewhere in the championship or league 1 - he has saved the club and deserves every backing The time of dining out on that have gone by long ago
|
|
|
Originally posted by collier row eagle
The time of dining out on that have gone by long ago Really? No other Chairman has taken us from Administration to 5 years in the Premiership or been anywhere near that record. Some of us have been supporters for years and are used to failure of a false dawn and appreciate where we are now.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Podyonkers
I hear you there but I also note that SP was very candid when he acknowledged this as a mistake. Didn't seem to me that he tried to make and excuse or cover it up - he admitted he got it completely wrong, from what I seem to remember. Then in the same breath eulogised Fraizer Campbell and how he should've kept him and how he's the answer as our back up striker. Sure Steve, if it was Campbell for 4 months, how great would that be? Would the new stand plans be released? He then went on to say only teenagers on twitter criticised him with rubbish when in fact there's loads of constructive criticism on HOL and the BBS. We got lucky that Roy's team playing cup finals every week earned so many points, but that took its toll with injuries. What does he do? Under deliver to the manager. Parish will never learn. Only if a new manager has come in and we're still in the sh1t in January will he deliver. In August? Nah. We'll see what happens when the window closes before the season starts, if we survive.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Then in the same breath eulogised Fraizer Campbell and how he should've kept him and how he's the answer as our back up striker. Sure Steve, if it was Campbell for 4 months, how great would that be? Would the new stand plans be released? He then went on to say only teenagers on twitter criticised him with rubbish when in fact there's loads of constructive criticism on HOL and the BBS. We got lucky that Roy's team playing cup finals every week earned so many points, but that took its toll with injuries. What does he do? Under deliver to the manager. Parish will never learn. Only if a new manager has come in and we're still in the sh1t in January will he deliver. In August? Nah. We'll see what happens when the window closes before the season starts, if we survive. You honestly believe that: a) We were lucky to get points from the matches we won and drew and b) The reason we have so many injuries is because our players tried too hard in matches? Really?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
You honestly believe that: a) We were lucky to get points from the matches we won and drew and b) The reason we have so many injuries is because our players tried too hard in matches? Really? Well I tend to agree & Roy has said as much in the past. The position we are in has players fighting hard, making big tackles & putting a foot in where others might not. The extent of impact injuries points tat this which is what Roy was saying when the poor run of incidents started.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
Well I tend to agree & Roy has said as much in the past. The position we are in has players fighting hard, making big tackles & putting a foot in where others might not. The extent of impact injuries points tat this which is what Roy was saying when the poor run of incidents started.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
In my opinion SP is a businessman who does not like to lose in a negotiation. Unfortunately the world of football is so corrupt and full of back-handers that unless you bend over and take a shafting once in a while you will never get to buy who you want. It may just be that SP's negotiating stance that he has used in business all his life simply doesn't work very well in football. His biggest mistake to date in my book was not replacing Campbell immediately with an upgraded replacement. Campbell is a third rather than a second striker and everyone knew Wickham's injury was serious and long term.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
You honestly believe that: a) We were lucky to get points from the matches we won and drew and b) The reason we have so many injuries is because our players tried too hard in matches? Really? I said earn so many points in total, not lucky in every single match getting the points. Have you ever noticed how once teams reach 40 points the workrate and results slide? So yes, we were going at it full pelt every match, as Roy pretty much said we were going to, because we were up against it with a pathetic start, again, and it took its toll. How good were we in the closing minutes? We were fighting more when the opposition had us all over them, and them hoping the clock runs out.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
You honestly believe that: a) We were lucky to get points from the matches we won and drew and b) The reason we have so many injuries is because our players tried too hard in matches? Really? I said earn so many points in total, not lucky in every single match getting the points. Have you ever noticed how once teams reach 40 points the workrate and results slide? So yes, we were going at it full pelt every match, as Roy pretty much said we were going to, because we were up against it with a pathetic start, again, and it took its toll. How good were we in the closing minutes? We were fighting more when the opposition had us all over them, and them hoping the clock runs out.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Dont make a habit of doing that but we were in desperate need, the club had targeted Niasse, had him in the building, and then didnt get it done. Wouldn't have made a blind bit of difference because the deal hinged on the same from Everton for his other agent (cousin) as a 'selling fee' & they stuck two fingers up too. What SP should have done is identify targets early & put a time scale on offers then agents like these two wouldn't be able to punt their client around the market to see if anything bigger rocks up then accept our offer at the last knockings. Why do folk think signings are easy business when you haven't got billions sloshing around? I doubt we are seen as an attractive destination for many established players & clearly have to pay over the top in both fees & wages to make things happen. That puts us right up against FFP, the penalties for breaching which are now far worse than mere fines which is why even teams like PSG are having to balance the books.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Lets talk Wickham, as some folks mentioned him here. In a vacuum, signing Wickham was good business, he wasnt too expensive and many in the game probably feel he has not fulfilled his potential yet and could be very effective. The problem with Parish, time and time and time again is he cannot seem to put together any kind of cohesive strategy on anything we do. Wickham had a history of injuries, so great, go out and sign Wickham, but DONT leave the strike force so thread bare by failing in other transfer attempts that he is basically your number 2 guy, in a group of 2, because he has a history of injuries. Some players are simply more injury prone than others, and many people in the game try to understand why that is, sometimes to no avail apparently. Lo and behold he goes down with a lengthy and serious injury. The failure of Parish is depth in the squad. When you totally fail to have any kind of depth in attack, then when you get injuries or dips in form (which sometimes are created by complacency when there is no competition) you are opening yourself up to trouble. When Niasse's brother wanted a brown paper envelope we should have given him one, a season ticket, a dinner date with the crystals and a free pass to Speroni's restaurant, if that is still going. Dont make a habit of doing that but we were in desperate need, the club had targeted Niasse, had him in the building, and then didnt get it done. Parish really, really struggles to get it done. Look at this keeper we are supposed to be getting in, he is training with us already and still we havent signed him up. We went into the Spurs game without getting that sorted out beforehand. Why? Why cant we ever get something sorted out in a timely fashion? Something is wrong with the way we operate with the amount of time it takes to get deals to limp over the line, and the amount which fall through at the last minute. At least learn your lesson Steve? But no, again we go into the last day of the transfer window scrambling around like mugs. That's a bit unfair. He said a few years ago that the models to follow were Southampton and Swansea. I'd say he's now achieved that
Old, Ungifted and White |
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
They didn't start the season pathetically, again, with no points in 7 and no goals in 11. Remember that?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I said earn so many points in total, not lucky in every single match getting the points. Have you ever noticed how once teams reach 40 points the workrate and results slide? So yes, we were going at it full pelt every match, as Roy pretty much said we were going to, because we were up against it with a pathetic start, again, and it took its toll. How good were we in the closing minutes? We were fighting more when the opposition had us all over them, and them hoping the clock runs out. I agree with you to an extent on us playing catch up early on, but they are professional sportsmen and supposed to be super fit. Don't forget half the league are in the same boat as us but we haven't seen them generally picking up as many injuries. I genuinely think we have been unlucky to a great extent and sometimes such bad luck can have a massive impact on your season more particularly when our best team probably has always been the pick of say 15/16 players from the squad.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.