You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sorloth injury
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sorloth injury


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
DeVito Flag Surbiton 19 Mar 18 9.33am

To be making judgements about Sorloth after a handful of games is ridiculous. He's young, just moved to a new country and new club, possibly lacking premier league level fitness etc. Not to mention the games were extremely tough with a depleted first team. Despite all that, Sorloth's performances have been encouraging IMO. I think we'll see more positives before the end of the season, but he won't be able to make a true judgement until next season after he's had a full pre-season.


 

Uphill Flag Bedford 19 Mar 18 9.42am

'Championship Standard' ??

Very harsh to judge Sorloth on his first 4 very testing games.

and Benteke's standard is ?
Chinese Super League?

We may soon find out.

He will be lucky to get back into the Belgium squad.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 19 Mar 18 10.03am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

based on what?

The hamstring injury of course. An obvious sign of a championship standard player

 

hellzdoms Flag London 19 Mar 18 10.18am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

What does that make Benteke, he has looked better than him in recent weeks.

League 2 quality?

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 19 Mar 18 10.49am

He’s going to be a PL superstar for us. A goal machine.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 19 Mar 18 11.30am

Originally posted by Uphill

'Championship Standard' ??

Most of the players in the Premiership are Championship Standard. Which is why the teams that get relegated struggle to get back up.

It is also why players such as Glenn Murray, Sam Vokes, Callum Wilson etc. etc. do well. And why Brighton, Newcastle and Huddersfield are doing alright this season.

70% of the Premiership Sides in the division are a mixture of 1-5 Premiership Standard players, and 20-24 Championship Standard players.

We should stop denigrating Championship Standard players; and we should stop thinking that we are all of a sudden going to be able to sign 25 Premiership Standard players.

The difference is a Premiership standard manager. We are where we were because of RdB, and we are where we are because of Roy. We need to stop burning through Premiership quality managers, everything else will come good.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 19 Mar 18 1.18pm

Originally posted by dp

Most of the players in the Premiership are Championship Standard. Which is why the teams that get relegated struggle to get back up.

It is also why players such as Glenn Murray, Sam Vokes, Callum Wilson etc. etc. do well. And why Brighton, Newcastle and Huddersfield are doing alright this season.

70% of the Premiership Sides in the division are a mixture of 1-5 Premiership Standard players, and 20-24 Championship Standard players.

We should stop denigrating Championship Standard players; and we should stop thinking that we are all of a sudden going to be able to sign 25 Premiership Standard players.

The difference is a Premiership standard manager. We are where we were because of RdB, and we are where we are because of Roy. We need to stop burning through Premiership quality managers, everything else will come good.

Literally one of the best posts I’ve ever read on here.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 19 Mar 18 1.18pm

Can't really judge Sorloth on the 4 games, 3 of which were against top teams. A player generally needs time to adapt to a new club as well, give the lad a chance please people.
I don't understand why some people are so negative and will never pass up a chance to criticise player when they play badly.
Being positive helps, we need to support our players and show them that we are behind them 100%, even if they play badly sometimes.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 19 Mar 18 1.48pm

Originally posted by dp

Most of the players in the Premiership are Championship Standard. Which is why the teams that get relegated struggle to get back up.

It is also why players such as Glenn Murray, Sam Vokes, Callum Wilson etc. etc. do well. And why Brighton, Newcastle and Huddersfield are doing alright this season.

70% of the Premiership Sides in the division are a mixture of 1-5 Premiership Standard players, and 20-24 Championship Standard players.

We should stop denigrating Championship Standard players; and we should stop thinking that we are all of a sudden going to be able to sign 25 Premiership Standard players.

The difference is a Premiership standard manager. We are where we were because of RdB, and we are where we are because of Roy. We need to stop burning through Premiership quality managers, everything else will come good.

"Most" of the players in the premiership are premiership standard, as they constitute the majority of players in the premiership. I.e. the average quality of a player is defined by the quality of the majority of players in the league, in effect. I think what you're actually saying, is that the gap between lower-mid premiership and champ is not that big, and I agree. Rest of your post is right, quality players ain't cheap.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 19 Mar 18 2.49pm

Originally posted by FairweatherEagle

"Most" of the players in the premiership are premiership standard, as they constitute the majority of players in the premiership. I.e. the average quality of a player is defined by the quality of the majority of players in the league, in effect. I think what you're actually saying, is that the gap between lower-mid premiership and champ is not that big, and I agree. Rest of your post is right, quality players ain't cheap.

Seems like we are in violent agreement then. My point about "Championship Quality" is that you can say that Sorloth is "Championship Quality" but that applies to the majority of players in the Premiership. It is wrong for us to label Sorloth as Championship Quality as if that is some sort of guarantee that he is doomed to fail in the Premiership. Plenty of Championship Quality players have done well in the Premiership.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 19 Mar 18 8.04pm

Originally posted by dp

Seems like we are in violent agreement then. My point about "Championship Quality" is that you can say that Sorloth is "Championship Quality" but that applies to the majority of players in the Premiership. It is wrong for us to label Sorloth as Championship Quality as if that is some sort of guarantee that he is doomed to fail in the Premiership. Plenty of Championship Quality players have done well in the Premiership.

Surely if they do well in the premietship that makes them premiership quality?

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 19 Mar 18 8.17pm

Leicester won the league with championship players,would say half a squad in 13 clubs have good championship players, only first 11 are premiership players,and you need to look at the top end to see quality players in numbers

 

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Mar 18 8.18pm

Originally posted by dp

Most of the players in the Premiership are Championship Standard. Which is why the teams that get relegated struggle to get back up.

It is also why players such as Glenn Murray, Sam Vokes, Callum Wilson etc. etc. do well. And why Brighton, Newcastle and Huddersfield are doing alright this season.

70% of the Premiership Sides in the division are a mixture of 1-5 Premiership Standard players, and 20-24 Championship Standard players.

We should stop denigrating Championship Standard players; and we should stop thinking that we are all of a sudden going to be able to sign 25 Premiership Standard players.

The difference is a Premiership standard manager. We are where we were because of RdB, and we are where we are because of Roy. We need to stop burning through Premiership quality managers, everything else will come good.

How do you know, if a manager is Premiership quality, unless they are given a chance. At the moment, we have a merry go round of sacked Premier managers being employed again by other Premier clubs.
By definition, they aren't any good because they were sacked by their previous clubs, some sacked by many clubs, it doesn't make sense.
Recently Pardew, Lambert, Moyes and Hughes have all been given Premiership clubs, after being an abject failure at their previous clubs.
You can take a chance of Championship standard players, as they may improve, but handing the running of your team to a serial failure as a manager is what seems to happen in football.
The most bizarre appointment is Martin Allen at Barnet, after being sacked 4 times by Barnet in the past.

 

buzzby Flag West Sussex 20 Mar 18 10.18am

Whats a Championship Player
Sorloth has been played out of position, but has put in more effort than Benteke.
Most players need time to adapt.

Originally posted by dp

Seems like we are in violent agreement then. My point about "Championship Quality" is that you can say that Sorloth is "Championship Quality" but that applies to the majority of players in the Premiership. It is wrong for us to label Sorloth as Championship Quality as if that is some sort of guarantee that he is doomed to fail in the Premiership. Plenty of Championship Quality players have done well in the Premiership.

Edited by buzzby (20 Mar 2018 10.18am)

 


rub a dub dub who's buying the next round in the Pub?

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 20 Mar 18 2.47pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Surely if they do well in the premietship that makes them premiership quality?

Yes. That was my point.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 20 Mar 18 2.49pm

Originally posted by Painter

How do you know, if a manager is Premiership quality, unless they are given a chance. At the moment, we have a merry go round of sacked Premier managers being employed again by other Premier clubs.
By definition, they aren't any good because they were sacked by their previous clubs, some sacked by many clubs, it doesn't make sense.
Recently Pardew, Lambert, Moyes and Hughes have all been given Premiership clubs, after being an abject failure at their previous clubs.
You can take a chance of Championship standard players, as they may improve, but handing the running of your team to a serial failure as a manager is what seems to happen in football.

The point that I was trying to make is that we have been burning through proven Premiership Quality managers recently. (i.e. Managers who have proven that they can perform for us in the Premiership). That includes Pulis and Allardyce. We need to stop doing that, and keep hold of Roy.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 20 Mar 18 2.57pm

Originally posted by buzzby

Whats a Championship Player
Sorloth has been played out of position, but has put in more effort than Benteke.
Most players need time to adapt.

Edited by buzzby (20 Mar 2018 10.18am)

A Championship player is one that will do well in the Championship. It applies to many of the players who are playing in the Premiership. Most of the sides in the Premiership have plenty of Championship quality players and a few Premiership quality players.

Sorloth is a Championship quality player. It doesn't mean that he won't be successful for us in the Premiership. But you wouldn't place him in the same bracket as Aguero, Sanchez, Salah, Lukaku et al.

I would put him in the same bracket as Ashley Barnes, Sam Vokes and a fair few ex-Palace strikers who are doing OK in the Premiership. Still plenty capable of doing a job for us.

It is no criticism, in my view, to say someone is Championship Quality. Teams like Palace are rarely likely to have more than 4 or 5 Premiership Quality players and we need to make up the numbers with decent Championship players.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 20 Mar 18 4.19pm

Originally posted by dp

A Championship player is one that will do well in the Championship. It applies to many of the players who are playing in the Premiership. Most of the sides in the Premiership have plenty of Championship quality players and a few Premiership quality players.

Sorloth is a Championship quality player. It doesn't mean that he won't be successful for us in the Premiership. But you wouldn't place him in the same bracket as Aguero, Sanchez, Salah, Lukaku et al.

I would put him in the same bracket as Ashley Barnes, Sam Vokes and a fair few ex-Palace strikers who are doing OK in the Premiership. Still plenty capable of doing a job for us.

It is no criticism, in my view, to say someone is Championship Quality. Teams like Palace are rarely likely to have more than 4 or 5 Premiership Quality players and we need to make up the numbers with decent Championship players.

There is however players that belong in the championship and can’t cut it in the PL. not naming any names.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 20 Mar 18 4.37pm

Originally posted by dp

A Championship player is one that will do well in the Championship. It applies to many of the players who are playing in the Premiership. Most of the sides in the Premiership have plenty of Championship quality players and a few Premiership quality players.

Sorloth is a Championship quality player. It doesn't mean that he won't be successful for us in the Premiership. But you wouldn't place him in the same bracket as Aguero, Sanchez, Salah, Lukaku et al.

I would put him in the same bracket as Ashley Barnes, Sam Vokes and a fair few ex-Palace strikers who are doing OK in the Premiership. Still plenty capable of doing a job for us.

It is no criticism, in my view, to say someone is Championship Quality. Teams like Palace are rarely likely to have more than 4 or 5 Premiership Quality players and we need to make up the numbers with decent Championship players.

strange to pick these as being representative of typical PL players. They're among the best in the division.

I'd pick someone like Townsend or Tomkins.

But more to the point, how anyone can instantly really categorize a player who's been thrown into a league 2 or 3 tiers above their previous playing level -- and was basically in a kind of pre season -- is beyond me.

Nobody knows what Sorloth can achieve.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 21 Mar 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

strange to pick these as being representative of typical PL players. They're among the best in the division.

I'd pick someone like Townsend or Tomkins.

But more to the point, how anyone can instantly really categorize a player who's been thrown into a league 2 or 3 tiers above their previous playing level -- and was basically in a kind of pre season -- is beyond me.

Nobody knows what Sorloth can achieve.

Agree with this 100%. I think its exciting that we dont know if hes the new wonder kid rather than have the expectation of a proven player like benteke and then not perform.

COYP

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sorloth injury