You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref vs Liverpool
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref vs Liverpool


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 31 Mar 18 6.41pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Mane lost out in the tackle near the corner of his own box and fell on his arse. He thought he should be getting a free kick, which was not the case. So he palmed at the ball, then grabbed it, pre-empting the decision and preventing us from getting the ball back into the box. Handball, and also ungentlemanly conduct, oh and probably simulation as well. Three different kinds of yellow card in one.

Mindboggling decision for sure, should have been cautioned for unsporting behavior ( that's the term they use these days - politically correct !) and hence sent off. That might have swung the game towards us but apart from that "indecision" he had a reasonable match. Dermot Gallagher (commenting on Sky) said he should have been sent off. Like I said before there's one rule for the big 6 and another for the rest of us!

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

pizzapat Flag Caterham 31 Mar 18 6.41pm

Originally posted by Pigglelet

Don't you know? It's when it happens to a member of a top six side playing against one of us lesser mortals.

Edited by Pigglelet (31 Mar 2018 6.26pm)


is the CORRECT answer.... wheres our resident referee with his opinion when you want him??!!!

 


2010 decided my services were no longer required after 10 years service on the WHITEHORSE LANE FAMILY STAND

#CRPS

please read [Link] to find out what #CRPS is

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 31 Mar 18 6.42pm

The Mane decision bought back memories of Clattenburg. Once again a referee was left with no alternative, but to send off the player from the big team and inexplicably he refused to do so. His job is to enforce the laws of the game, not make up his own. I can only call him a cheat, because there is literally no other reason for him doing this. Some decisions are down to interpretation, not this one. He's on a yellow and deliberately hand balls it to stop Andros and Yohan having a 2 on 1 with Van Dyke in the area. There is no other decision than a yellow card, it's the law.
At both ends we made mistakes, but they were players, some woefully out of form making genuine mental or technical errors. This was a man consciously making a decision to not do his job. Disgraceful.
Sorry I've put this in two places, but I can't believe what I witnessed.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

pizzapat Flag Caterham 31 Mar 18 6.45pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Add to that - he had a word with Henderson which was presumably - "you had best take him off because the next thing he does wrong I will send him off"!
Refs should not do that - it is not for them to advise a team - absolutely against the rules!


they picked that up on Sky;he was subbed just after that incident?
also its NOT the 1st tiem i have seen an opposition captain be "asked/told" to sub someone or they are in danger of getting sent off;happened in a home game against arsenal but cant remember the player or the ref....

 


2010 decided my services were no longer required after 10 years service on the WHITEHORSE LANE FAMILY STAND

#CRPS

please read [Link] to find out what #CRPS is

boo909 Flag Figeac 31 Mar 18 6.56pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Ridiculous that referees never have to come out and explain themselves. How can you not give a yellow for a deliberate handball?


Totally agree. I keep banging on about this but I also think they should be mic'd up like in rugby. Apart from the insight into their decisions it would drastically reduce cases of teams pressuring the ref.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Pigglelet Flag Deepest Darkest Sussex 31 Mar 18 7.02pm

Originally posted by pizzapat

they picked that up on Sky;he was subbed just after that incident?
also its NOT the 1st tiem i have seen an opposition captain be "asked/told" to sub someone or they are in danger of getting sent off;happened in a home game against arsenal but cant remember the player or the ref....

Yes, the player was Coquelin and the ref was Lee Mason who let him get away with his persistent fouling - until he decided he wouldn't be able to let him do it any longer.

 


"Better to keep your mouth shut and appear stupid than to open it and remove all doubt."
Mark Twain.

IMilburn Flag Chiang Rai / Rayong 31 Mar 18 7.03pm

In reply to Pizza Pat's post, the player was Coquelin and the referee was Lee Mason.

Also happened in the home game vs Tottenham last season when Moussa Dembele wasn't given a second yellow in the first half;instead the ref (can't remember who it was) signaled a warning to the bench, and Dembele didn't reappear for the second half.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 31 Mar 18 7.42pm

I would agree with all that say he had no excuse but to book Sane for the handball and therefore send him off . I would also say that had our Keeper wiped out one of their strikers at Anfield in the manner that Zaha was taken out not only would the penalty have been given but we would have seen a red card being held up in the air .

The incompetence of our referees in general is shocking ,its no surprise that not one from the supposed best league in the world will be at footballs showpiece this summer .

 

Noz Flag North Hampshire 31 Mar 18 7.51pm

I might be wrong, but isn’t there a double jeopardy rule where a keeper can’t be sent off and give away a penalty now?

Originally posted by Elpis

I would agree with all that say he had no excuse but to book Sane for the handball and therefore send him off . I would also say that had our Keeper wiped out one of their strikers at Anfield in the manner that Zaha was taken out not only would the penalty have been given but we would have seen a red card being held up in the air .

The incompetence of our referees in general is shocking ,its no surprise that not one from the supposed best league in the world will be at footballs showpiece this summer .

 

Mstrobez Flag 31 Mar 18 7.53pm

I’m by no means a member of the referee fan club but I do feel at times we latch on the refereeing decisions too easily instead of just conceding that we didn’t do enough.

After seeing the first incident again I’d say it was a penalty and had it been Wilf at Anfield we’d all be screaming for it. Was there contact? Yes. Was there enough for him to go down? Yes. Was there enough for him to fall to the ground in the fashion he did? No, and that’s the reason he didn’t get the decision, so more fool him, but to me it was a penalty.

The second one was undeniably a booking, but given the above I think it actually balanced out a bit.

Fact of the matter is, sticking 10 men behind the ball, passing the ball about like it’s a game of rugby and still not being able to see games out can be classed as unlucky as much as we want it to. But it’ll count for nothing if we’re in the championship next year.

It’s gonna go right to the death.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

boo909 Flag Figeac 31 Mar 18 8.24pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

I’m by no means a member of the referee fan club but I do feel at times we latch on the refereeing decisions too easily instead of just conceding that we didn’t do enough.

Normally I'd be with you there, especially with the tendency round here to latch on to theory that the big clubs get all the decisions whilst conveniently ignoring borderline stuff (looking at you Wilf) that goes our way all the time.

The first decision there wasn't enough contact for him to go down at all (proved by the fact that he didn't even come close to going down, wasn't impeded at all in fact) and if he did it would been simulation, whether the ref would have seen that if Mané's acting ability was better is another issue.

The second was one of the more ridiculous decisions I've ever seen by a ref, it was just straight out wrong and he only wasn't carded because he already had one. Refs just seem to be disinclined to send people off these days, as I said in the match thread it's almost as if players are safer if they have one card than if they didn't have any.

As I said before normally I would agree with you 100% but on this occasion I just can't. The second decision completely changed the nature of the match, could they have still beaten us 2-1? Of course, might even have been worse if we'd pissed them off by knocking them down to ten men but we'll never know because the ref decided he was above the rules of the game.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

Elpis Flag In a pub 31 Mar 18 8.30pm

Originally posted by Noz

I might be wrong, but isn’t there a double jeopardy rule where a keeper can’t be sent off and give away a penalty now?

Only in certain circumstances . The way I read it is the keeper gets off with a yellow if he has made a genuine attempt to play the ball. The Liverpool keeper had no chance of playing the ball and some would say was also guilty of dangerous play ,both still straight reds .

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Mar 18 8.31pm

The referee was spot-on with the penalty and deservedly awarded a yellow to Mane for diving.

We don't know how the game would have unfolded if Mane had been sent off but we do know that Benteke's efforts in front of goal were embarrassing and Sakho was responsible for inept defending for the 2 Liverpool goals.

This is why we lost, NOT because of the referee who overall had a very good game.

Going out now for a tipple or two and watching the big fight !

Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2018 8.31pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 31 Mar 18 8.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee was spot-on with the penalty and deservedly awarded a yellow to Mane for diving.

We don't know how the game would have unfolded if Mane had been sent off but we do know that Benteke's efforts in front of goal were embarrassing and Sakho was responsible for inept defending for the 2 Liverpool goals.

This is why we lost, NOT because of the referee who overall had a very good game.

Going out now for a tipple or two and watching the big fight !

Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2018 8.31pm)

and the handball/no yellow card???? Avoiding the issue again???? Swarbrick screwed up, why not just admit it? if that was a Palace player on a yellow, he would most certainly have been sent off, yes or no??

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 31 Mar 18 8.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee was spot-on with the penalty and deservedly awarded a yellow to Mane for diving.

We don't know how the game would have unfolded if Mane had been sent off but we do know that Benteke's efforts in front of goal were embarrassing and Sakho was responsible for inept defending for the 2 Liverpool goals.

This is why we lost, NOT because of the referee who overall had a very good game.

Going out now for a tipple or two and watching the big fight !

Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2018 8.31pm)

Whilst I agree it may not have changed the result, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the Mané handball incident Willo, don't chicken out on us

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 31 Mar 18 8.47pm

Originally posted by boo909

Whilst I agree it may not have changed the result, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the Mané handball incident Willo, don't chicken out on us

Seems like he already has

 

saveloy Flag carmarthen 31 Mar 18 8.51pm

Poll on BTsport still stating Swarbrick got it right saying that there's deliberate handball and handball where he didn't do it for his own advantage,to me deliberate is exactly that.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 31 Mar 18 8.53pm

Originally posted by boo909

Whilst I agree it may not have changed the result, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on the Mané handball incident Willo, don't chicken out on us

I think his silence on the matter speaks volumes, after his "tipple" it will be I dont want to turn this into another Willo thread.
Answering other posters, I was very close to the penalty incident...minimal contact, he slipped, didn't even fall down immediately, squeeled like a child and rolled around holding his shin. Absolute disgrace

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 31 Mar 18 9.23pm

I do not see the difference between a defender handling on the line and receiving a red and a striker diving but only receiving a yellow.
My seat is upper Holmesdale and three from the back and it was a dive as the defender was at least a foot away when Mane dived.
There were a number of weird decisions such as Benteke being pulled down and the free kick going their way or Wilf being taken out on the line and play on being waved. Swarbrick gave decisions based on who was fouled or fouling and it happens too often for the FA or Premier League to continue ignoring it.
Finally anyone expecting to receive a descriptive answer from the Brighton fan is either a newbie or extremely hopeful/naive

Edited by crystal-purley (31 Mar 2018 9.26pm)

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 31 Mar 18 11.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee was spot-on with the penalty and deservedly awarded a yellow to Mane for diving.

We don't know how the game would have unfolded if Mane had been sent off but we do know that Benteke's efforts in front of goal were embarrassing and Sakho was responsible for inept defending for the 2 Liverpool goals.

This is why we lost, NOT because of the referee who overall had a very good game.

Going out now for a tipple or two and watching the big fight !

Edited by Willo (31 Mar 2018 8.31pm)

Total waffle.
Referee decided to make up his own rules to enable a player to stay on the field. What happens if he doesn't cheat, I don't know, but f***ing hell I'd love to have the chance to find out.
Blame your own, fine, but they made genuine mental and technical errors. Swarbrick did neither, he cheated. No referee can overall have a good game when he flatly refuses to do his job.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref vs Liverpool