You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our greatest player ever
November 16 2026 7.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Our greatest player ever


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Fatherken Flag 15 Apr 18 1.38pm

for me it has to be John ( stonewall ) Jackson

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 15 Apr 18 1.52pm

[Link]

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 15 Apr 18 2.24pm

Originally posted by fozzaisere

I have just got in from a day out and watched the motd highlights.

From my standpoint will we ever see a player greater than Wilf Zaha? I am 29 been supporting palace for 19 years so missed the glory years etc but it's not just the skill, trickery etc but the passion this guy shows for the club. The way he celebrates goals - particularly brighton ones - feels me with so much happiness. Maybe i am being silly but can't see another talismanic homegrown player like him coming along for a life time. Long live king Zaha

Remind me when we had those !!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 15 Apr 18 3.18pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Remind me when we had those !!

Agreed a colleague told me he was Palace through thick and thin. I said remind me of the "Thick".

 


One more point

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 Apr 18 3.24pm

One can compare zaha and Lombardo easily and fairly due to being of the same position

Zaha is more like Ryan giggs with speed and tricks, Lombardo was more like an alien, he didn’t need the speed or tricks, shielding the ball, keeping possession, playing passes that no other palace player could read cos he was light years ahead in the way his footballing brain worked. Lombardo would have no looked out of place in a team consisting of zidane and Ronaldinho, not quite sure wilf would’ve looked quite in the same catagory, yet, anyway

Lombardo world class, wilf champs league quality .

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 15 Apr 18 4.17pm

Wilf has been brilliant. let's see how we feel about him if/when he bangs in a hat trick for Big Team X to relegate us. (No badge kissing, mind, I'm sure of that)

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 15 Apr 18 4.35pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Wilf has been brilliant. let's see how we feel about him if/when he bangs in a hat trick for Big Team X to relegate us. (No badge kissing, mind, I'm sure of that)

You're assuming he'll move on? I'm hopeful he'll stay if we keep Premier league status, or is that wishful thinking...

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 15 Apr 18 8.58pm

Depending on your age will have a reflection on your answer but for me it has to be Ian Wright.

I started supporting Palace in the late 80's & his goals got us promoted,to an FA Cup final which we almost won & finish 3rd in the top flight which I doubt we will ever match again.

Its unfair to say it was only him that contributed to that golden era because we did have a fantastic team but he was a world class goal scorer.

He had to endure alot of vile abuse when he played for Arsenal against us which lead to him kissing the badge when we got relegated which he regrets now.His only crime was to leave to better his career & earn more money.Also his mother's house was getting vandalised alot after he left which also upset him which I can understand.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 15 Apr 18 11.49pm

Hmmm,
I doubt Zaha would make my top 10

Cannon
Sansom
Wright
Taylor
Rogers

Theres 5 and I haven't even started thinking
He's good Zaha because in this current team he stands out
But to be a top top player his finishing and crossing would have to be a LOT more consistent

 

adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 15 Apr 18 11.55pm

[quote=Blue'n'red;3327597]

His reaction at the final whistle ... shouting “yes” at the HF ... ignoring Knockhart who was trying to shake his hand!!!

Thats just plain rude, but Wilf will be forgiven what with the excitement

 

Kentbaldeagle64 Flag Swanscombe 16 Apr 18 12.29am

Jim Cannon

Geoff Thomas

John Burridge

Billy Gilbert

 

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 16 Apr 18 1.45am

I think he's the best ever.

'93/94 onwards for me.

Edited by Qwijibo (16 Apr 2018 1.46am)

 

Terry Vegetables Flag Forest Hill 16 Apr 18 2.07am

Absolutely has to be Zaha, because unless he's the greatest actor on Earth he absolutely bleeds red & blue. So many mercenary footballers, just dont see this in Wilf.

I came across palace in primary school, and my superstars were the team of the 80s. Out of that team Vince Hilaire was undoubtedly my hero. So much so that when he left after Mullery sacking, I wrote to him as a naive 14 year old begging him to stay. A couple weeks later he replied, by sending me a picture of himself torn out of a program and addressing it to me with the words "thanks for the great support, Vince Hilaire"

So for me Vince will always be my hero, but Zaha has taken everything to another level, and has to go down in a Palace folklore as our no.1 player to date, based not just on skill but his absolute total dedication to the club...

That includes wrighty, I watched him from the arthur Waite terracing when his nickname was super sub, and although total phenomenon, and I'm sure he's forever grateful to Palace for giving him his chance in football, but he isn't Palace in the same way Zaha is.. He sees Palace as his apprenticeship, and Arsenal as his achievement. So he can never be our greatest.

Zaha for me is greatest of all time, because he doesn't just where the shirt, he is the shirt...

 


catford kid, caught up supporting "team of the 80s" in the 70s..
1st actual Match - PALACE 1-1 LEEDS (Sat 13 Nov 1982)

michaelpearce Flag grays 16 Apr 18 6.11am

Originally posted by Terry Vegetables

Absolutely has to be Zaha, because unless he's the greatest actor on Earth he absolutely bleeds red & blue. So many mercenary footballers, just dont see this in Wilf.

I came across palace in primary school, and my superstars were the team of the 80s. Out of that team Vince Hilaire was undoubtedly my hero. So much so that when he left after Mullery sacking, I wrote to him as a naive 14 year old begging him to stay. A couple weeks later he replied, by sending me a picture of himself torn out of a program and addressing it to me with the words "thanks for the great support, Vince Hilaire"

So for me Vince will always be my hero, but Zaha has taken everything to another level, and has to go down in a Palace folklore as our no.1 player to date, based not just on skill but his absolute total dedication to the club...

That includes wrighty, I watched him from the arthur Waite terracing when his nickname was super sub, and although total phenomenon, and I'm sure he's forever grateful to Palace for giving him his chance in football, but he isn't Palace in the same way Zaha is.. He sees Palace as his apprenticeship, and Arsenal as his achievement. So he can never be our greatest.

Zaha for me is greatest of all time, because he doesn't just where the shirt, he is the shirt...

based on that 3 players come to mind Jules,Kemper,and big Jim Cannon.dont forget he left us to go to man utd only come back because he got no game time, other wise we wouldnt have him,so yes palace is in his heart but very quick to go to the promise land,which i dont blame him but when it comes to loyalty big Jim,Jules,Kemper are way ahead

 

fozzaisere Flag 16 Apr 18 12.10pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

Remind me when we had those !!

I missed the late 80's early 90's so thinking of the dizzy heights when we finished 3rd ;

 

Arthur Blackpudding Flag 17 Apr 18 12.50pm

It's Zaha for me and by a long way.

I'm 30 so been following Palace since about 95/96.

 

mars Flag Folkestone 17 Apr 18 2.09pm

As a fan of over fifty years standing I think Zaha gets the nod over Don Rogers

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 17 Apr 18 9.50pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

You're assuming he'll move on? I'm hopeful he'll stay if we keep Premier league status, or is that wishful thinking...

oh I'm hopeful of that too pal. but there's got to be a chance. somebody chucks 65m our way and offers him 175k a week...going to be tough I'd say. it depends on the bids we get.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Glazier#1 Flag 17 Apr 18 10.43pm

Absolutely.

Attilo Lombardo

Originally posted by matthau

One can compare zaha and Lombardo easily and fairly due to being of the same position

Zaha is more like Ryan giggs with speed and tricks, Lombardo was more like an alien, he didn’t need the speed or tricks, shielding the ball, keeping possession, playing passes that no other palace player could read cos he was light years ahead in the way his footballing brain worked. Lombardo would have no looked out of place in a team consisting of zidane and Ronaldinho, not quite sure wilf would’ve looked quite in the same catagory, yet, anyway

Lombardo world class, wilf champs league quality .

Edited by Glazier#1 (17 Apr 2018 10.47pm)

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 18 Apr 18 5.13am

I think in answer to that question, you have to think 'who was great for the club'.

Freedman in my time, was great for the club - his important goals, his work ethic, his second spell, as coach, manager.

Lombardo, was great to watch - but he didn't bleed red and blue.

Martyn - he was good, but excelled when left - unsurprisingly.

Johnson, he was great for the prem, but it didn't help us.

Rambo, that promotion season, behind the scenes, the passion on the field, was great.

Morrison, was great for the club but we were always in lower leagues.

Zaha, this season has been great for the club.

Next season, if in the prem, Zaha will, if he continues this fine form, with be the greatest player in my time, freedman a close second.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Our greatest player ever