You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year and young player of the year
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player of the year and young player of the year


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
fledgling Flag Beckenham 01 May 18 10.23am

Originally posted by mattteo

Townsend is also there with 2 goals and 8 assists (FROM OPEN PLAY)

What's that per minute?

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 10.24am

Originally posted by Adamoc123

Because as a defensive midfielder it's impressive regardless of how many were penalties

Not really, no. It's 3 goals and 1 assist without the penalties. Many more defensive midfielders have pulled this off this season

 

chateauferret Flag 01 May 18 10.35am

Originally posted by mattteo

Not really, no. It's 3 goals and 1 assist without the penalties. Many more defensive midfielders have pulled this off this season

Compare the number of penalties we win (largely because defenders can't handle Wilf) with the number Burnley win and consider where we would be if Benteke were taking them all instead of Milivojevic.

 


============
The Ferret
============

se25 rudy Flag se25 01 May 18 10.40am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Can you not see that Luca is a DEFENSIVE midfielder whose main job is to break up play!! A job he does extremely well, it is not all about goals and assists. I wonder have you ever seen a live game involving Luca? I doubt it.

Precisely the point - he's not there primarily to score but his contribution to team has been immense.

Kante is a shoe-in for POTY at Chelsea but has only (gasp!!) 1 goal & 1 assist - he must be toilet then I suppose...........

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 10.53am

Originally posted by se25 rudy

Precisely the point - he's not there primarily to score but his contribution to team has been immense.

Kante is a shoe-in for POTY at Chelsea but has only (gasp!!) 1 goal & 1 assist - he must be toilet then I suppose...........

I never said that. Others have brought up Milivojevic's goals and assist contribution. I didn't say it's what makes a good defensive midfielder.

Let's talk his defensive midfielder contribution if you'd like. His recoveries, his speed. And his set pieces

 

se25 rudy Flag se25 01 May 18 10.59am

Originally posted by mattteo

I never said that. Others have brought up Milivojevic's goals and assist contribution. I didn't say it's what makes a good defensive midfielder.

Let's talk his defensive midfielder contribution if you'd like. His recoveries, his speed. And his set pieces

I made a solemn vow never again to get involved in a Matteo thread - I intend to stick to it

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 11.04am

Originally posted by se25 rudy

I made a solemn vow never again to get involved in a Matteo thread - I intend to stick to it

Come on, I'm not THAT abnoxious. Am I? )

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 11.23am

Originally posted by mattteo

I never said that. Others have brought up Milivojevic's goals and assist contribution. I didn't say it's what makes a good defensive midfielder.

Let's talk his defensive midfielder contribution if you'd like. His recoveries, his speed. And his set pieces

That is precisely what I was talking about!! His contribution as a defensive midfielder has been immense, personally if you carried on playing this role as he has I would not give a flying fig if he didn't score another goal!! Nothing wrong with his set pieces as far as I can see.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 11.26am

Originally posted by mattteo

So why bring into discussion his goals and assist if we're talking about his contribution as a defensive midfielder?? ))

I was just answering to that question. I've given reasons why he hasn't had a good season: taking set pieces without eficiency, I can also show you goals where he was at fault. Yes, he had some solid matches too. But player POTY? Come on....

I'm giving you solid facts, you're giving me personal opinions. Answer me this: was Milivojevic a good set piece taker this entire year??

Edited by mattteo (01 May 2018 10.06am)

Think we have scored quite a few goals resulting from his corners

 

benmccarthy Flag Kent 01 May 18 11.34am

Player:
Zaha - Haven't got a point without him in the team

Young Player:
Wan-Bissaka

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 11.50am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Think we have scored quite a few goals resulting from his corners

Care to back up this statement with some examples? All I remember is the Huddersfield goal which resulted from a decent corner of his: [Link]

After many attempts all season.

When Townsend took a corner one time against Arsenal, it resulted in a goal by Tomkins: [Link]

 

rikz Flag Croydon 01 May 18 12.08pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Milivojevic??????????

Took set pieces all year, didn't hit a single assist (edit: had one assist in the 34th matchday against Brighton, with only 4 matches to go until the end of the season, but it wasn't one of his set pieces). Makes you wonder why does he take set pieces actually? Ok, he scored 1 very nice goal from a free kick and is good from the penalty spot (7 of his 10 goals were from the penalty spot) but he couldn't cross for a goal an entire season despite taking set pieces!!

Guilty at plenty of goals (the one in the 90th minute against Man United easily comes to mind, but there were others too).

It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more.

Edited by mattteo (01 May 2018 10.00am)

Townsend ???? His been consistently solid but not had a season that should be him mentioned anywhere near player of the season, zaha has by far been our best player and milo has had a better season than Townsend

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 01 May 18 12.08pm

RLC for young player of the year. Lovely to see AWB making the step up to the first team but difficult to give it to him after only six appearances.

Wilf for player of the year. I would have gone for Wayne but he has no goals and no assists

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Aray Flag South London 01 May 18 12.11pm

Lads - this really isn't difficult.

PoY - Wilf obvs.

YPoY - Wann Bissaka obvs.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 01 May 18 12.14pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I think I can safely discount every comment you ever post on here after that one. Time to take your eyes off the data and watch the bl00dy football.

That said, Tomkins just shaves it for me with Luka a very close second.

Youth player a no-brainer.

The only football he sees is an animation on a computer screen; he badly needs to get out of his bedroom at his mum's and find some real friends.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 12.26pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

The only football he sees is an animation on a computer screen; he badly needs to get out of his bedroom at his mum's and find some real friends.

You're turning this into a personal agenda you have against me instead of answering the points made by the discussion. I'd really, really like to punch your stupid ass face in real life, to see if you'd still have the balls to talk like that

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 01 May 18 12.30pm

POTY: Wilf, We have not got a point without him & would have been relegated a long while ago. Luca & Tomkins runners up.

YPOTY: Loftus-Cheek, AWB has not played enough games; as promising as he looks.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 12.50pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Care to back up this statement with some examples? All I remember is the Huddersfield goal which resulted from a decent corner of his: [Link]

After many attempts all season.

When Townsend took a corner one time against Arsenal, it resulted in a goal by Tomkins: [Link]

First goal against Brighton (look it up) Second goal against Brighton (look it up) Free Kick against Huddersfield (look it up) shall I go on? Perhaps getting your facts correct would be a start.

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 1.15pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

First goal against Brighton (look it up) Second goal against Brighton (look it up) Free Kick against Huddersfield (look it up) shall I go on? Perhaps getting your facts correct would be a start.

What Huddersfield free kick????? The one in the video I posted above? A decent effort, I admit, but nothing came of it. Maybe you're refferring to another Huddersfield match, but there haven't been any other goals against Huddersfield, so please tell me what free kick are you talking about please stop telling me about facts until you clarify this)

1st corner against Brighton was a trick. Kuddos to Luka for thinking it, but it doesn't show great corner delivery abilities.

All in all, 2 or 3 corners that resulted in goals in 30+ matches of taking corners in a Premier League season is not much

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 01 May 18 1.17pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Care to back up this statement with some examples? All I remember is the Huddersfield goal which resulted from a decent corner of his: [Link]

After many attempts all season.

When Townsend took a corner one time against Arsenal, it resulted in a goal by Tomkins: [Link]

Are you suggesting Townsend hasn't also been taking set pieces all season? Did you see his attempt direct from a free kick on the weekend?

To approach this as you normally would; Townsend has contributed 2 goals in 2956 mins this season, one of which was deflected, playing as a winger/forward for the vast majority of that - that's a return of roughly one goal every 16.5 games... to suggest he's been better than Luka is not even debatable.

For what it's worth; I would have Zaha as POTY and Loftus Cheek for YPOTY.

 

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year and young player of the year