Booted Eagle Bristol 12 May 18 7.47pm |
|
Originally posted by tonymikejoe
Surely it has to be Pulis.
When Holloway left we had just got stuffed 1-4 at home to Fulham, had one win and seven defeats in eight games and were 4 points adrift.
He had no Zaha, had Cameron Jerome up front, turned Puncheon into a playmaker, shifted Ward to midfield enforcer / left back and played a masked Mariappa at r/b.
Talk about making a chicken salad out of chicken s***
Signed Scott Dann, a fantastic buy, and finished 11th!
Tend to agree. First season back in the Prem, having to deal with Ollies sweet shop transfer window of 13 new players, with a half new wafer thin inexperienced PL squad light years from ours this season, no talismanic player. How he managed to turn that squad into 11th place was magic.
Edited by Booted Eagle (12 May 2018 7.49pm)
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
Jonnyg121 Tunbridge Wells 12 May 18 7.59pm |
|
|
In terms getting the most out of players, it's Pulis, without a shadow of a doubt.
A lot of fans will say Pulis' tactics were negative, but lets not forget, we scored 3 against Cardiff in a crucial 6 pointer away from home. We also put 3 past Everton away from home.
As for stats, granted, we have scored 10 more goals this season, compared to 13/14, but we won 13 games in 13/14, compared to 10 (so far) this season.
Roy however has had a bigger task at hand, the Palace players looked so dejected and clueless during their games against Swansea & Huddersfield, I have never seen anything like it. Roy has done very well to stabilise the team and bring confidence back to the players, but had Roy been here from the start of the season, finishing mid table would have been less of a surprise.
|
pssguy 12 May 18 8.03pm |
|
Originally posted by leejaneagles
Pep has to win Manager of the Season. In any other season if City had just won the league normally, Hodgson would pick up the award. Doesn't mean he's had a lesser achievement than Pulis.
I expect Pep to win but that does not mean Hodgson would be runner-up. Fans of all three promoted clubs feel their manager should be. Obviously, Dyche also has a strong case. I'd argue Zaha has been more important to our survival than Hodgson
Personally, if Liverpool win the Champion's League I feel Klopp deserves it (though the CL may not be taken into account). It's the big one, they beat Man City 2x to get there, have played some great attacking football and hardly missed a beat whilst pocketing a fortune on Coutinho. Of course if they miss out on the Top 4..
|
steeleye20 Croydon 12 May 18 8.16pm |
|
|
An interesting thread...
I think, if RH can bring a competitive team fully prepared for the PL, next season, that would ensure his legacy as the best of the bunch.
What happens to Palace in the close season I don't know - why does the upcoming season become such a battle, a manager who can break that record is my choice.
Do hope it is RH.
|
Dan1994 Wallington 12 May 18 8.20pm |
|
|
Definitely Frank de Boer.
[Link]
|
Bangell Oxford 12 May 18 8.33pm |
|
|
Pulis's squad had by far the least quality in the division - it's a marvel we stayed up
|
eagle6764 Quilty 12 May 18 8.35pm |
|
|
We officially had the worst start in Premier League history so the stats alone speak for themselves. But to inspire and motivate a deflated squad to get the results we did and survive is amazing - and I didn't want Roy as manager. Roy for me.
|
Medway Eagle Whitstable Kent 12 May 18 9.03pm |
|
|
I agree with the above. Especially with the exciting type of football we are playing
|
pssguy 12 May 18 9.07pm |
|
Originally posted by eagle6764
We officially had the worst start in Premier League history so the stats alone speak for themselves. But to inspire and motivate a deflated squad to get the results we did and survive is amazing - and I didn't want Roy as manager. Roy for me.
Hodgson took over after 4 games. We were three points from 17th spot. 10 Premier League teams have not got a point in the first 4 games, including us and Bournemouth this year. Six of them avoided relegation
He did a great job - particularly given the injuries - but it's not a miracle
|
Palace 1979 Surrey 12 May 18 9.19pm |
|
|
I would say Roy as he has had by far the hardest start and also by far the worst luck with regards to injuries. I also think he has the greatest potential to help the club push on the following season whereas Pulis, Fat Sam and Pardew are one trick ponies...
So happy he is here and hope he will stay in football for a few more years to come!
Some people are like Slinkies … not really good for anything, but you can’t help smiling when you see one tumble down the stairs.
|
The Dolphin 12 May 18 9.22pm |
|
|
Hodgson has been brilliant but Pulis had the worst squad and somehow managed to keep us up. In addition teams around us were stronger then as well. I love Roy and we are playing great football but it is Pulis for me.
|
Aray South London 12 May 18 9.47pm |
|
|
Pulis, surely.
We were shambolic when he took over. Now we've seen all 3 promoted teams survive this season, which illustrates that a well organised set of Championship players can survive, if not thrive at this level. But to achieve that without a pre-season is incredible. Mind you the football was dire at times.
Then Roy - we're playing some of the best footie i've ever seen at Palace. And lets remember the super team under Coppell wasn't that pretty to watch, if you ask me.
Big Sam was a bit too cautious and we got beat 4 nill by Sunderland!
|
Welsh Eagle 12 May 18 9.49pm |
|
Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch
Pulis, we had a championship squad following a chaotic summer window.
Roy who. is the better manager, has the potential to leave the bigger legacy.
Totally agree with the above!
Pulis had a worse squad to work with, the football wasn't great at times but very effective.
Roy has done a wonderful job & we have played some excellent football recently but he had a much stronger squad to work with although there was a spell when we had 12 players out.
Edited by Midlands Eagle (13 May 2018 6.17am)
|
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 12 May 18 9.51pm |
|
|
Pulis. That team had such weaknesses and he made it so tough. And it was also in a dire position when he began (far later in the season) and we began the season as the red hot favourites for the drop. Remember Roy actually took over after 4 games...he'll have had 34 to get it sorted so all he missed was a pre season and a few games. (Which sounds more belittling of what was actually an outstanding achievement).
Edited by Ginger Pubic Wig (12 May 2018 9.51pm)
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
PA Bedfordshire 12 May 18 10.22pm |
|
|
All of them done good. ( including Pardew)
But it’s Pulis for me.
Shame he acted like a complete cock over his departure.
|
rollercoaster Cornwall 12 May 18 10.41pm |
|
|
Pulis had the worst squad to work with,However he had luck whilst Roy might have had the far better squad but was afflicted by a horrendous injury list and a run of very bad luck. So really hard to call but I'rd probably have to give it to Pulis just because he achieved so much with so little, If asking for best football, then Hodgson's team by a country mile. The team are probably playing the best football we've seen since the 1972 team occasionally managed.
|
Mwncisee Middlesbrough 12 May 18 10.53pm |
|
|
Most will say Hodgeson due to him being the current manager and hasnt done anything to sour his achievements like Pulis and Sam did but fir me its Pulis. There is no comparison between the squad we have now and the one we had under Pulis. As others have said it wasnt pretty to watch but it was functional, what we needed and he got very average players to perform as a team greater than the sum.of their parts.
|
Ali_Campbell New Addington 12 May 18 11.05pm |
|
|
Pulis - all day long
All managers have done good jobs, especially Roy considering the injuries and not having a striker all season.
But TP had none of the stars we have today. I remember going to Villa away when we won 1-0 and we had Moxey at left back, Ward in midfield, Bannon on the left....Just a team of championship players and we managed to stay up. I often wonder where Palace would be if he didn't come in.
|
FairweatherEagle London 12 May 18 11.07pm |
|
Originally posted by Welsh Eagle
Totally agree with the above!
Pulis had a worse squad to work with, the football wasn't great at times but very effective.
Woy has done a wonderful job & we have played some excellent football recently but he had a much stronger squad to work with although there was a spell when we had 12 players out.
Ah, that old chestnut...
Would you call him that to his face?
He's done the best job of the three, confidence was brittle even though we have the best squad we've had since the early nineties, we had so many setbacks and injuries, plus Roy's a better human being than Pulis.
|