This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Southampton: sold van Dyck. Nearly relegated. If we divest ourselves of Wilf we will go down the toilet. Results last season when he hasn't played bear that out. The question is not how much can we get for him, or with whom do we replace him, but WTF we do if he suffers a lengthy outage. Nail on the head, we are worryingly Wilf dependent if you look at results. I'd add that there's some sort of parallel with Spurs and Bale - up another level or two of course. Even when you do spend the cash on new players as they did and Swansea and Soton didn't,it's really hard to rebuild a team with new imports.Having too much money in the transfer kitty brings it's own problems as Everton too discovered.
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
I have absolutely no idea who we'd replace him with to get that same level of impact, or the confidence that the big money signing wouldn't be a comparative flop. For me, that makes him fairly priceless. If we were offered £70m, I guess you'd take it. Then probably sign Shaqiri and use the remainder to sign a couple of top players who you'd hope hit the ground running and move us up a level. The only players I could think of would be Messi, Salah, perhaps Sane like any of those would be coming to Palace anytime soon. Maybe Rashford? The other problem is that whilst these might be good players and could do a job, the difference with Wilf is that he plays for the badge and (said he) wants to be at Palace whereas the others would be just looking for the contract. Shaqiri more or less failed to turn up in a relegation decider so no thank you. If we can't answer the question "WTF do we do if he's not available" then a fortiori we are not in a position to sell. Edited by chateauferret (20 May 2018 11.04am)
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by SeagullHunter
I think this sums it up perfectly. Selling a player with whom we had 0 points when he didnt play last year, would be absolutely farcical. For me, if Stoke are asking 50+ for butland, wilf is right up there in the 60-70m range. He is a game changer, fit, powerful and athletic, and scarily as we all know he still has room for improvement. I think he'd be a star under Pep, IF anywhere it would be best for us if Wilf went abroad! He'd be a huge loss to us but if Everton are reportedly willing to offer £60m his value will soar in any bidding frenzy. Would certainly cover the ground's development but where would the club be without its talisman?
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by sotac464
Played 10 w0 d0 l10. That's how many games we played without Zaha in the team last season. He lifts the whole team when he plays and we are a match for any side. So to us us he should be priceless unless we get an offer where we could rebuild the whole team. £200 million but no team is going to pay that. £60 million is paltry and we'll end up with has beens. He lifts the fans the player's the manager every time he plays, whether he has a good game or not. He really is our Gerrard. We cannot of course prevent other clubs showing an interest in Zaha and submitting bids for him. I happen to believe that IF we happen to accept a £60 Mill offer for Zaha and he decides to sample 'Pastures new, gladitorial hostility and more eruptions than Vesuvius will be aimed in the direction of Mr Parish.
|
|
|
The story her is that Marcel Brands from PSV Eindhoven has signed for them. As director of football that is. Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
That story is probably made up as Everton currently have no manager or director of football so who is making these so called decisions?
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
The story her is that Marcel Brands from PSV Eindhoven has signed for them. As director of football that is. Yes indeed. A clear-out at Everton and a re-organisation with Denise Barrett-Baxendale being appointed as Chief Executive replacing Robert Elstone. Edited by Willo (20 May 2018 1.08pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Henry of Peckham
He'd be a huge loss to us but if Everton are reportedly willing to offer £60m his value will soar in any bidding frenzy. Would certainly cover the ground's development but where would the club be without its talisman? I think that price quoted is largely misleading, Everton wont be forking out 60m on one player after their large expenditures last summer, unless they have any significant outgoings. As mentioned, he is practically irreplaceable, you would only really sell if you had a ready made replacement, and for that quality it will cost you 70m+. On top of that we'd want extra to strengthen elsewhere, and the fact he is tied down LT. I really dont see us entertaining any offers south of 70m!
Dont let Cabaye go |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
I have absolutely no idea who we'd replace him with to get that same level of impact, or the confidence that the big money signing wouldn't be a comparative flop. For me, that makes him fairly priceless. If we were offered £70m, I guess you'd take it. Then probably sign Shaqiri and use the remainder to sign a couple of top players who you'd hope hit the ground running and move us up a level. Priceless is priceless “without price; beyond money”. No such thing as “fairly” priceless, and if we would indeed take £70m, then he isn’t priceless.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
The whole situation has changed from years ago, when we needed to sell to survive. One reason is that you want to upgrade on the other players. One argument for keeping Zaha is that when he is injured we lose. If all your eggs are in 1 basket you are risking trouble if he had a Dann/Puncheon/Sako setback. He is after all the target man for the opposition The problem, as other posters have, is getting the right players. If the January window was intended to upgrade side rather than making sure we had squad players, that is not too encouraging. I'd say, overall, since Holloway the transfers have been reasonably successful
|
|
|
Originally posted by Brentmiester_General
So bored of all this already. Just as well you are not on the board then Hodgson is pushing hard for some new players to come in early. That will be tough and cost. What's he going to do if it doesn't happen. He could walk and it wouldn't affect any future job prospects he has. His reputation has been restored at least for other than elite clubs - though he would probably have done a good job for Arsenal Obviously the TV money may be enough, but with the new stand there may be pressure to sell an asset. I'm sure Benteke would be first choice if there are any takers but there has been little talk about any one else - though Luka might get some interest if he has a good WC I'm guessing the board are hoping Villa win next week and decide thay need Benteke back. That would also make Fulham players more likely to be available
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.