You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Leroy Sane left out Low's World Cup squad
November 22 2026 7.46pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Leroy Sane left out Low's World Cup squad


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 05 Jun 18 8.18am

There is a simple reason Sane wasn't picked - he has never performed well for Germany. His competition is as follows

Reus - World class. Consistently performed at domestic and international level for years. Obviously has major injury problems, but seems to be fit and firing and is probably the first name to be picked for Germany.

Draxler - Not had a great season on the bench at PSG but another who has always performed for Germany and Lowe when called up.

Brandt - Had a fantastic couple of seasons for Leverkeusen and again, performs well at international level so far.

Goretzka - Again, fantastic couple of seasons at domestic level and is also versatile enough to play in the middle.

Added to those four you have the "king of the tournaments" for Germany in Thomas Mueller who can also play on the wing if needed.

Sane's time will come, but he hasn't done enough in his brief international career to be picked over the above.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 05 Jun 18 12.57pm

have the German's got their knickers in a twist about this or is it just the English?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 05 Jun 18 1.06pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

have the German's got their knickers in a twist about this or is it just the English?

From what I've seen, most agree with the decision.

 

mattteo Flag 05 Jun 18 2.40pm

There is no way to justify Ozil, Draxler and Gorezka as being better for the national team! I think I could accept Reus getting the nod over him. Even Muller, because he offers a stamina and defensive contribution that not many players do. I'd even be willing to accept Brandt being in the squad because he;s really young and good for his age.
But Ozil, Draxler and Goretzka?? People are busting Sane for not playing very well for the national team. He's recently turned 22! 6 of his 12 caps came when he was 19 or 20, didn't have the great seasons with Man City. So let's not count those. In the other 6 caps that he had this year he provided 1 assist.

Let's see what the other "great" players did for the national team in the last year:

Draxler: 1 goal and 1 assist in 8 matches.
The guy barely has 6 goals and 6 assists in 2600 minutes played as left wing for the national team (that's worse than 1 in 200 minutes). He's 24 not 22 like Sane and is not that good at club level either.

Goretzka: 1 goal in 4 matches played as right midfielder for the national team. Seriously? That 1 goal in a 6-0 trashing of Norway counts more than all that Sane has done the entire season for Machester City??? 14 goals and 19 assists??

Brandt: 1 assist in 5 matches for the national team.

Where's the fairness in that???


Edited by mattteo (05 Jun 2018 2.41pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Tez Flag Epsom 05 Jun 18 3.38pm

Originally posted by mattteo

There is no way to justify Ozil, Draxler and Gorezka as being better for the national team! I think I could accept Reus getting the nod over him. Even Muller, because he offers a stamina and defensive contribution that not many players do. I'd even be willing to accept Brandt being in the squad because he;s really young and good for his age.
But Ozil, Draxler and Goretzka?? People are busting Sane for not playing very well for the national team. He's recently turned 22! 6 of his 12 caps came when he was 19 or 20, didn't have the great seasons with Man City. So let's not count those. In the other 6 caps that he had this year he provided 1 assist.

Let's see what the other "great" players did for the national team in the last year:

Draxler: 1 goal and 1 assist in 8 matches.
The guy barely has 6 goals and 6 assists in 2600 minutes played as left wing for the national team (that's worse than 1 in 200 minutes). He's 24 not 22 like Sane and is not that good at club level either.

Goretzka: 1 goal in 4 matches played as right midfielder for the national team. Seriously? That 1 goal in a 6-0 trashing of Norway counts more than all that Sane has done the entire season for Machester City??? 14 goals and 19 assists??

Brandt: 1 assist in 5 matches for the national team.

Where's the fairness in that???

Edited by mattteo (05 Jun 2018 2.41pm)

You're quoting stats that actually disprove your own point, because Sane has 0 goals and 1 assist in 12 games for the national team, therefore contributing less than any of the players you have mentioned above.

And on the subject of age, this is completely irrelevant at international level ... what is needed in tournament football is instant results and ideally (not all the time) experience.

Despite Ozil getting a lot of abuse since he's been at Arsenal, he has consistently been one of Germany's best players in the last few tournaments and if you suggested to any German that he be replaced by Sane I think they'd probably think you were inSane.

 

mattteo Flag 05 Jun 18 4.04pm

Originally posted by Tez


And on the subject of age, this is completely irrelevant at international level ... what is needed in tournament football is instant results and ideally (not all the time) experience.


You're not getting it. Sane has come of age this year. He doesn't need to grow anymore. He is at maximum level NOW to provide for instant results.

I was talking about his national team matches at the age of 19 when I said he he wasn't fully developed yet.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 Jun 18 5.45pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I believe anyone is more qualified than a person who leaves Leroy Sane out of his squad. Why do you think all these managers became managers? Do you think they are really smart or good at what they do? No. It's mostly about connections and influence, Low became manager of Stuttgart because he had played for that team and the owner knew him and became national team manager because Klinsmann had met him years earlier at a coaching school.

Mourinho became manager because he had connections with Bobby Robson. Most former players become managers because they were big players and have influence. What has Lampard done in managing to deserve being named as Derby County manager?

You have excelled yourself with some of the bull**** you have come out with on here.
Do you honestly think Low would have kept this job for 12 years if he was a scam? World Cup winner not Championship Manager winner.
This may come as a surprise to you but I personally rate Low more of a manager than you and if he feels Sane isn't ready for his squad that will do for me.
To say they had no-one to beat in 2014 is ridiculous

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 Jun 18 5.48pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

have the German's got their knickers in a twist about this or is it just the English?

English media love-in and Matteo

 

Casual Flag Orpington 05 Jun 18 10.38pm

Getting too close to the World Cup to be interested in players that the Germans haven’t picked. F*ck em. All about England. Kane top goal scorer and England to win the World Cup double. Put your house on it. It’s coming home , it’s coming home
Even named our new puppy ‘pickles’ just in case the cup goes missing.

 

mattteo Flag 06 Jun 18 12.03pm

Walker's tweet says it all:

 

A89M Flag Streatham 06 Jun 18 12.30pm

Sane is clearly a talented player but to suggest he’s at his maximum level already is ridiculous. He still has so much to learn with decision making and more importantly tactically, at 22 years old it is impossible to have learnt everything therefore meaning he is not at his maximum potential – you only have to watch him against Fosu-Mensah at Selhurst and both legs against Liverpool in the Champions League to realise there’s still a lot for him to improve on.

A quick browse online and it seems it’s not just his football that has kept him out the squad:

[Link]

 

mattteo Flag 06 Jun 18 1.04pm

Originally posted by A89M

and both legs against Liverpool in the Champions League

If I remember correctly, Sane had a perfectly good goals wrongly disallowed in the match against Liverpool in the Champions League, which could have made all the difference.

He also scored 3 in the direct macthes against Liverpool in the Premier League. 2 assists against Spurs, 1 goal and 1 assist against Arsenal, 1 assist against Man United, 2 assists against Napoli.
Goals against Arsenal, Spurs and Monaco in the Champions League last year, gals and assists against Borussia Dortmund, Bayern and Bayer Leverkusen in Germany.

And many more agaist lower teams. It may be a fluke once or twice, but he has played very well in matches against top opponents in the last year and a half every time he had them.

Edited by mattteo (06 Jun 2018 1.13pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jun 18 1.11pm

I can understand some in this country viewing Sane's omission with incredulity given his performances for Man C.

Sane started both of Germany's recent friendles against Brazil and Austria and they lost both games.Presumably if he had sufficiently impressed Low he would have been selected - Low did say it was a close call and he sees players play for both club and country.

Low has been criticised on here - Under him, Germany have not failed to reach at least a semi-final in 5 tournaments and is the first coach of a European country to win the WC in S.America.He actually might know something about coaching and selecting players at International level !

Edited by Willo (06 Jun 2018 1.13pm)

 

mattteo Flag 06 Jun 18 1.17pm

Sane played better than most against Brazil and Austria. Low even said that he did his defensive contribution really well, it had nothing to do with him not picking him. He just thinks Brandt and Goretzka- as a winger- are better!!

In respect to your other point, everyone would have taken Germany to the semifinals the last 3 World Cups. Is that such a big acomplishment? Is it a big accomplishment if Real Madrid or Bayern reach the semifinals of the Champions League 3 times in a row??

It would have take a total idiot not to reach at least the semis with Germany. What if this time they don't make it past the first 16? Will you agree with me that Low's a total *****?

Edited by mattteo (06 Jun 2018 1.19pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 06 Jun 18 2.23pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Sane played better than most against Brazil and Austria. Low even said that he did his defensive contribution really well, it had nothing to do with him not picking him. He just thinks Brandt and Goretzka- as a winger- are better!!

In respect to your other point, everyone would have taken Germany to the semifinals the last 3 World Cups. Is that such a big acomplishment? Is it a big accomplishment if Real Madrid or Bayern reach the semifinals of the Champions League 3 times in a row??

It would have take a total idiot not to reach at least the semis with Germany. What if this time they don't make it past the first 16? Will you agree with me that Low's a total *****?

Edited by mattteo (06 Jun 2018 1.19pm)

No I don't share your viewpoint at all about Low and his record with Germany
Totally disagree with you on this.

And to reach the CL Semi-finals in successive seasons is still a worthy achievement given the quality of the teams.

Clearly you believe that any manager can achieve titles on a regular basis if that team is somewhat high-profile.Perhaps Real Madrid will go for FDB !

To save you further embarrassment by constant hole digging, I shall agree to disagree with you and concentrate my efforts on other subjects rather than respond to any of your further dis-crediting of the German national team manager.We have both made our views patently clear, we are on 'Opposite sides of the house' so there is really nothing of any value to add.

Edited by Willo (06 Jun 2018 2.27pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 06 Jun 18 8.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

No I don't share your viewpoint at all about Low and his record with Germany
Totally disagree with you on this.

And to reach the CL Semi-finals in successive seasons is still a worthy achievement given the quality of the teams.

Clearly you believe that any manager can achieve titles on a regular basis if that team is somewhat high-profile.Perhaps Real Madrid will go for FDB !

To save you further embarrassment by constant hole digging, I shall agree to disagree with you and concentrate my efforts on other subjects rather than respond to any of your further dis-crediting of the German national team manager.We have both made our views patently clear, we are on 'Opposite sides of the house' so there is really nothing of any value to add.

Edited by Willo (06 Jun 2018 2.27pm)

Totally agree with you Willo. I cannot believe some of his comments, presumably he feels Pardew would have won the Champions League with Bayern or the World Cup with Germany&#128514;

 

mattteo Flag 08 Jun 18 6.53am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Totally agree with you Willo. I cannot believe some of his comments, presumably he feels Pardew would have won the Champions League with Bayern or the World Cup with Germany&#128514;

Spiderman, even you could have won the Champions League with Bayern if the locker room accepted you as a manager. It's not that big of a deal. You have doctors, physios doing their thing, the training sessions are practically done by someone else, you have people telling you who is suspended and who you should rest and what strategy you need for every match according to its importance.

 

mattteo Flag 27 Jun 18 4.59pm

Just wanted to revive this old thread.
Out of the European teams at the World Cup, 10 made it past the group stage: Spain, France, England, Belgium, Portugal, Croatia, Switzerland, Russia, Denmark, Sweden. Only 3 went out: Iceland, Germany and perhaps Serbia (depending on today's match).
That shows a lot about Germany's manager knowledge.

Today he played with Goretzka as right midfielder. A great player, but he has played all his matches this year in the Bundesliga as central midfielder for Schalke, not right midfielder. And Leroy Sane, who could have played as right midfielder, a player with 23 goals and 27 assists in all competitions as a winger this season was left at home.

I rest my case. The sentence has already been passed.

Edited by mattteo (27 Jun 2018 5.00pm)

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 27 Jun 18 5.03pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Just wanted to revive this old thread.
Out of the European teams at the World Cup, 10 made it past the group stage: Spain, France, England, Belgium, Portugal, Croatia, Switzerland, Russia, Denmark, Sweden. Only 3 went out: Iceland, Germany and perhaps Serbia (depending on today's match).
That shows a lot about Germany's manager knowledge.

Today he played with Goretzka as right midfielder. A great player, but he has played all his matches this year in the Bundesliga as central midfielder for Schalke, not right midfielder. And Leroy Sane, who could have played as right midfielder, a player with 23 goals and 27 assists in all competitions as a winger this season was left at home.

I rest my case. The sentence has already been passed.

Edited by mattteo (27 Jun 2018 5.00pm)

Germany have been s***. Sane probably should have been in the squad but he may not have made much of a difference.

Sterling had a great season for City but is really s*** for England.

Can't blame Germany going out on one player not playing.

 

chateauferret Flag 27 Jun 18 5.04pm

Out. Hilarious.

Tschüüüüüüß!

Edited by chateauferret (27 Jun 2018 5.43pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Leroy Sane left out Low's World Cup squad