This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
My opinion is that he was decent second half of last season and unless he's been awful pre-season Guaita has to earn the shirt. But don't like the frequency of niggly cry-offs and injuries. Not sure what you mean here. One pre season game? Hardly representative. I thought as I have done for years that if you place a decent defence in front of him he is a more than able Prem keeper. Thought he played very well today.
|
|
|
Originally posted by orpingtoneagle
Not sure what you mean here. One pre season game? Hardly representative. I thought as I have done for years that if you place a decent defence in front of him he is a more than able Prem keeper. Thought he played very well today. Twice first half of last season but don't want to detract from his / the teams start today. Didn't go today but well done to him based on the reports. As I said he was decent second half of last season and deserves his place. If we're being picky I'm not sure that he's always looked as reliable as you're suggesting and the defence goalkeeper relationship is a two way street.
|
|
|
He was excellent yesterday.
'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more' |
|
|
Originally posted by saveloy
Overall he had a good game but still has a habit of saving and pushing the ball back into the danger area which one another day could of proved costly but perhaps our luck is in this year.
|
|
|
He was excellent. Just hope the crowd no get behind him and gets his confidence up.
|
|
|
Hennessey has not raised his game. Been excellent for at least 8 months now.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
Unpopular opinion time... We’re so used to Wayne Hennessey making the most fundamental & basic of errors that when he has a busy game and successfully does the basics right, as any premier league keeper should, we rave about him as if he’s put a Buffon-esque performance in. It reminds me of the useless kid at Sunday league level that you’d stick at left back to make up the numbers. Could barely run in a straight line, let alone kick a ball, that when he managed to pass a ball that actually landed somewhat in the direction of a guy wearing the same kit as him, you’d react as if he should be playing Barcelona Youth rather than Balgowan FC. As for Guaita. It’s not very encouraging that he hasn’t been identified as someone emphatically better than Hennessey, given the trouble we went to signing him and the assurance of many on this board that it was an absolute coup when some expressed legitimate doubts. FFS! Hennessey played really well and has been playing really well for over 6-months. His kicking is 100 times better than Jules ever was, his distribution better and he is taller. He was just as good against Chelsea last season. He is a good premier league keeper. He is not in the top 3; but he is not in the bottom 3 either. He is also a nice bloke who had come good despite the vitriol he has had from some nasty fans.
|
|
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
Hennessey has not raised his game. Been excellent for at least 8 months now. agreed...he has always been a good keeper, like others have said,never world class but good enough for us. ots also no suprise his rise in form has co-incided with sakho & tomkins forming a great partnership in front of him. probably goves him more confidence he hasnt kept out mandanda/speroni/mccarthy for no reason
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway |
|
|
Originally posted by BarEagle
FFS! Hennessey played really well and has been playing really well for over 6-months. His kicking is 100 times better than Jules ever was, his distribution better and he is taller. He was just as good against Chelsea last season. He is a good premier league keeper. He is not in the top 3; but he is not in the bottom 3 either. He is also a nice bloke who had come good despite the vitriol he has had from some nasty fans. If you can name 3 first team goalkeepers worse than Hennessey feel free. Not based on the last 6 or so months either, when assessing someone’s quality you have to take into account the fact that they’ve been generally poor for the years they’ve played, despite ample chances. Of course when a players form has improved (mainly due to an improved defence IMO), you’re not allowed to then have an opinion that in general he’s still pretty garbage. But I think it’s just that some of us can see beyond an improvement defensively & accept there is a time in which this won’t be enough to pave over the cracks. Would love to be proved wrong and am happy to accept he put in a solid performance yesterday, not as amazing as people are making out, but solid nevertheless. But I think given the 5 or so years he’s been with us, there has been enough evidence to seriously suggest he lacks the quality required for a goalkeeper at this level when it really matters for us. I agree on the last point, though. He seems thoroughly decent as a person and I have felt sorry for him due to some of the abuse he’s received from “fans”. I think it’s entirely acceptable to make the case amongst fans in the pub/on forums etc. that he’s not very good. But would never dream of hurling abuse at him on a match day/directly sending him abuse on social media. That’s pathetic and embarrassing for any “fan” to do to a player of their football club, regardless of ability.
We're the Arthur over ere! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
If you can name 3 first team goalkeepers worse than Hennessey feel free. Not based on the last 6 or so months either, when assessing someone’s quality you have to take into account the fact that they’ve been generally poor for the years they’ve played, despite ample chances. Of course when a players form has improved (mainly due to an improved defence IMO), you’re not allowed to then have an opinion that in general he’s still pretty garbage. But I think it’s just that some of us can see beyond an improvement defensively & accept there is a time in which this won’t be enough to pave over the cracks. Would love to be proved wrong and am happy to accept he put in a solid performance yesterday, not as amazing as people are making out, but solid nevertheless. But I think given the 5 or so years he’s been with us, there has been enough evidence to seriously suggest he lacks the quality required for a goalkeeper at this level when it really matters for us. I agree on the last point, though. He seems thoroughly decent as a person and I have felt sorry for him due to some of the abuse he’s received from “fans”. I think it’s entirely acceptable to make the case amongst fans in the pub/on forums etc. that he’s not very good. But would never dream of hurling abuse at him on a match day/directly sending him abuse on social media. That’s pathetic and embarrassing for any “fan” to do to a player of their football club, regardless of ability.
And yet he has help to keep us at this level for five years. Also if you took three first team keepers apart from De Gea , Courtois, and put them in the Palace team watched them every week and judged them as harshly as some on here judge Hennessey you would find more than 3 to name.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
If you can name 3 first team goalkeepers worse than Hennessey feel free. Not based on the last 6 or so months either, when assessing someone’s quality you have to take into account the fact that they’ve been generally poor for the years they’ve played, despite ample chances. Of course when a players form has improved (mainly due to an improved defence IMO), you’re not allowed to then have an opinion that in general he’s still pretty garbage. But I think it’s just that some of us can see beyond an improvement defensively & accept there is a time in which this won’t be enough to pave over the cracks. Would love to be proved wrong and am happy to accept he put in a solid performance yesterday, not as amazing as people are making out, but solid nevertheless. But I think given the 5 or so years he’s been with us, there has been enough evidence to seriously suggest he lacks the quality required for a goalkeeper at this level when it really matters for us. I agree on the last point, though. He seems thoroughly decent as a person and I have felt sorry for him due to some of the abuse he’s received from “fans”. I think it’s entirely acceptable to make the case amongst fans in the pub/on forums etc. that he’s not very good. But would never dream of hurling abuse at him on a match day/directly sending him abuse on social media. That’s pathetic and embarrassing for any “fan” to do to a player of their football club, regardless of ability.
Luckily your opinion doesn’t matter, all the recent managers have had him as their first choice, they can’t all be wrong. Buying Guiata was to keep Hennessey on his toes and it has worked, since he was announced as arriving at the end of Jan he has been first class.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Luckily your opinion doesn’t matter, all the recent managers have had him as their first choice, they can’t all be wrong. Buying Guiata was to keep Hennessey on his toes and it has worked, since he was announced as arriving at the end of Jan he has been first class. I agree.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Luckily your opinion doesn’t matter, all the recent managers have had him as their first choice, they can’t all be wrong. Buying Guiata was to keep Hennessey on his toes and it has worked, since he was announced as arriving at the end of Jan he has been first class.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.