You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and subs
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy and subs


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Aug 18 9.34am

My only concern is there "appears" to be no consideration of who we are playing against when selecting the team(and I say appears because we tend to see identical line ups for each match) . Unless Kouyate is looking seriously garbage in training then surely the management knew yesterdays game was going to be hotly contested match. We lost the ball in 50:50's far too often and surely the addition of Kouyate to the middle of the park would have helped.

I would have gone with this forward six

Luka
Andros Kouyate Meyer Wilf
Ayew

But.... I aint the manager so I guess we have to trust in his decisions.


 

Bangell Flag Oxford 27 Aug 18 9.50am

Originally posted by george1212

People are going to hate this, but I honestly think we did well last season in spite of Roy, not because of him.

Games like this are won and lost on making effective changes early.

Roy either forgets or doesn't believe the subs will make a difference, it's just not good enough from a top manager. We need a manager who can make some bold decisions a bit earlier on.

We should have got at least a draw today.

Bentecke should be off. Why play him when Ayew scored 10 goals last season?

There is no rationale. Giving Bentecke can come on from the bench to score. He doesn't have a right to start games anymore, it's f***ing shocking that he starts.

Most of us agree that his lack of use of subs is frustating, but no way does that justify this claim. You think any average manager could have come in and ended up on 44 points playing decent football?

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 27 Aug 18 10.24am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Just to clear it up guys, Ayew is not match fit cuz he's a sulky t*** and bunked off pre-season with Swansea - that's why he's not being fielded at the moment.

Before the match Roy said ayew, kouyate and Meyer all fit and ready to play a part, which makes even less sense to leave them out, Meyer excluded but that was too late to win the match. Look.what he did in the he short time he was on

 

REBECCA Flag Rustington 27 Aug 18 10.57am

The team is set up incorrectly n my view.
Zaha should be out wide with AYEW and Tekkers up top.

 


This roller coaster I am on just won't stop.

01CPFC Flag central coast NSW (The Mariners Mi... 27 Aug 18 11.27am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

why are you belittling a comment nobody said sack Roy,
he is poor when making subs timing is his worst trait,lot of the time he wont change the team he picked to start with,every manager has faults and that is Roys,
when the first 11 are doing well nobody notices when it starts going wrong people start to notice,we all made excuses last year due to injurys why he didnt bring players on until last min dot com or not at all ,its the best bench we have had for awhile, he just needs to use it earlier,minor details not total change


And your Footballing qualifications are?????

Nothing more to be said

COYP

 


Where is the Joker shown, I haven't used it ?

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Aug 18 11.34am

Originally posted by 01CPFC


And your Footballing qualifications are?????

Nothing more to be said

COYP

So you don't think he should havd brought subs on earlier, for both this game and liverpool? Motd 'experts' certainly thought so, saying bentekes performance was shocking.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Aug 18 1.59pm

Was listening to Danny Murphy on talksport earlier, he said that our subs should have been made quicker. Then he said that Roy picks his 11 and trains with them all week and always gives them a long time in a game as he believes that’s the best 11 to win that game. Says he’s always been like it and will never change.

 

Portuguese Flag Porto 27 Aug 18 2.14pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

My only concern is there "appears" to be no consideration of who we are playing against when selecting the team(and I say appears because we tend to see identical line ups for each match) . Unless Kouyate is looking seriously garbage in training then surely the management knew yesterdays game was going to be hotly contested match. We lost the ball in 50:50's far too often and surely the addition of Kouyate to the middle of the park would have helped.

I would have gone with this forward six

Luka
Andros Kouyate Meyer Wilf
Ayew

But.... I aint the manager so I guess we have to trust in his decisions.


You're right mate!
Roy is a wise fellow so he doesn't need to be sttuborn and give away wisdom trying to push the envelope!
COYP

 


1861 Football Club

FPL

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 27 Aug 18 2.21pm

Originally posted by est1905

He only recently turned 71.
We dont have the benefit of working with players on the training ground all week, only for 90 mins on a match day and only those picked to play so I'd have to bow to Roy's vastly superior knowledge, experience, football knowledge and opinion of the individual.
We all do. Nobody deserves unconditional, unending praise or is immune from criticism indefinitely but I think after the miracle he pulled off last season he deserves at least the benefit of the doubt that he knows a bit more than any of us what he's doing wouldn't you say?

Couldn't have put it better myself.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Aug 18 2.39pm

Originally posted by 01CPFC

Exactly,u know nothing
Obviously u have no qualifications or experience so stop criticising our manager,
in the future WATCH and LEARN Sonny!!!
COYP

This is a discussion forum sonny. A lot of fans have questioned why he didn't use subs earlier. Which is a valid question as he said before the game that Meyer koyoute and Ayew were fit and he wouldn't hesitate to play them. So why don't you tell us why you think he didn't, rather than just be abusive.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Aug 18 3.07pm

Originally posted by 01CPFC

Exactly,u know nothing
Obviously u have no qualifications or experience so stop criticising our manager,
in the future WATCH and LEARN Sonny!!!

Originally posted by 01CPFC

What would be your tactics be for the Swansea game,
looking forward to your recommendations for Roy,

Originally posted by 01CPFC

And your Footballing qualifications are?????

Nothing more to be said

COYP

Your comments are getting more and more stupid. This is a discussion forum and if posts were limited to those with the sort of experience that you are insisting on there would be no posts at all.

Either post something constructive or don't post at all as your posts in other threads are along the same lines too


 

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 27 Aug 18 3.13pm

I was at the game and it looked pretty obvious to me, and others around me, that we were struggling in the second half and that something needed to be changed. The Meyer/Schlupp change could have been made earlier and I agree with those who think Ayew could have replaced Benteke rather than Sorloth. We had also lost the centre midfield and I would have liked to have seen Kouyate on to counter that - probably for Jimmy.

Edited by Direwolf (27 Aug 2018 3.15pm)

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 27 Aug 18 3.23pm


I guess this is probably the main reason. Roy works out how we are going to beat the opposition works on it and sticks with it It also probably explains why Sorloth replaced Benteke as they play in a similar way whereas Ayew would probably have meant a change in style which in Roy’s opinion would not win us the game. It could so easily been very different had all our chances been put away.
He is our Manager and will stand or fall by his decisions which are certainly based on intimate knowledge of our players ability and of the opposition.


Was listening to Danny Murphy on talksport earlier, he said that our subs should have been made quicker. Then he said that Roy picks his 11 and trains with them all week and always gives them a long time in a game as he believes that’s the best 11 to win that game. Says he’s always been like it and will never change.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Aug 18 4.16pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle


I guess this is probably the main reason. Roy works out how we are going to beat the opposition works on it and sticks with it It also probably explains why Sorloth replaced Benteke as they play in a similar way whereas Ayew would probably have meant a change in style which in Roy’s opinion would not win us the game. It could so easily been very different had all our chances been put away.
He is our Manager and will stand or fall by his decisions which are certainly based on intimate knowledge of our players ability and of the opposition.


Was listening to Danny Murphy on talksport earlier, he said that our subs should have been made quicker. Then he said that Roy picks his 11 and trains with them all week and always gives them a long time in a game as he believes that’s the best 11 to win that game. Says he’s always been like it and will never change.

Every manager starts with the 11 he thinks will win the match. But if it starts going wrong, most will use subs to change it, that's what subs are for. Totally pointless putting on a centre forward for the last few mins. Roy was saying last season that one of the reasons for our injuries was that he had to play thd same players every week because of lack of options on the bench. Before yesterday's game he said that all our new signings were fully fit and he wouldn't hesitate to play them and yet he still didn't use them until thd last minute.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 27 Aug 18 7.22pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

so it seems like weve got people already starting threads questioning Roys decisions & tactics.

what unappreciative philistines we have as fans.

some or you guys dont even know your born when it comes to supporting palace.

people seem to think they have the right so sceond guess sebody with 30 years management experience from their keyboards

Edited by Midlands Eagle (27 Aug 2018 6.45am)

I was just about to post a very similar response, its looking like a LETS BLAME R.H.thread coz we lost an away game,no mention of the bad luck and ref decisions that went against us. its all roy's fault we have 3 similar strikers, one is off form, one injured still,and one very raw, we also have another option for a striker,but he is not fit yet.
Its as you said Braunstone, some "supporters" just can't wait to blame the club or management for a loss,they don't even think about the rubbish they are writing.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Aug 18 7.24pm

Apparently macarthur has asked Scotland for a break from international football because of a back injury. So why is he playing 90 mins for palace?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 27 Aug 18 7.26pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

I was just about to post a very similar response, its looking like a LETS BLAME R.H.thread coz we lost an away game,no mention of the bad luck and ref decisions that went against us. its all roy's fault we have 3 similar strikers, one is off form, one injured still,and one very raw, we also have another option for a striker,but he is not fit yet.
Its as you said Braunstone, some "supporters" just can't wait to blame the club or management for a loss,they don't even think about the rubbish they are writing.

Don't be childish. Of course it wasn't RH fault we lost. But you can't blame fans for questioning why he doesn't use his subs when things aren't going well.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 27 Aug 18 7.39pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

Before the match Roy said ayew, kouyate and Meyer all fit and ready to play a part, which makes even less sense to leave them out, Meyer excluded but that was too late to win the match. Look.what he did in the he short time he was on

Meyer did look good when he came on for a SHORT TIME. i believe it was a SHORT time coz he hasn't trained for months.
Ayew and Kouyate may or may not be fit, but it dosn't mean they are yet familiar with the way R.H. wants them to play. It took quite a time to get our team to play the way he wanted after he became manager

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 27 Aug 18 7.41pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Don't be childish. Of course it wasn't RH fault we lost. But you can't blame fans for questioning why he doesn't use his subs when things aren't going well.

Agreed - it would be pretty boring if every post was "oh well - in Roy we trust". A forum is intended for discussion and debate, although all too often many posts come off as needlessly abrasive, a lot of the time, people are just bewildered and there's nothing wrong with expressing that.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 27 Aug 18 7.46pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle


I guess this is probably the main reason. Roy works out how we are going to beat the opposition works on it and sticks with it It also probably explains why Sorloth replaced Benteke as they play in a similar way whereas Ayew would probably have meant a change in style which in Roy’s opinion would not win us the game. It could so easily been very different had all our chances been put away.
He is our Manager and will stand or fall by his decisions which are certainly based on intimate knowledge of our players ability and of the opposition.


Was listening to Danny Murphy on talksport earlier, he said that our subs should have been made quicker. Then he said that Roy picks his 11 and trains with them all week and always gives them a long time in a game as he believes that’s the best 11 to win that game. Says he’s always been like it and will never change.


But Danny Murphy is a Jockey on a crap radio station, R.H. is a manager of Premiership club with years and years of success behind him, i know who i would rather put my trust in.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and subs