You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from the game


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 01 Sep 18 8.31pm

thinking about it we actually made some decent chances today, twice in the 1st 20 bentekkers thru only to fall over be tackled, jimmy mac hit the bar & PVA had a cracking effort.

meyer looks like a cabaye upgrade when he starts i think things will settle down and we will pick up points

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Surrey Eagles Flag Sutton 01 Sep 18 8.34pm

Central midfield 3 of Kouyate Meyer and Jimmy Mac. Luka was poor against Watford and today. Roy needs to keep Wilf on the wing when he returns. Ayew up front. Sorloth is a championship striker at best and Benteke has had more than enough chances.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 01 Sep 18 8.36pm

Originally posted by Surrey Eagles

Central midfield 3 of Kouyate Meyer and Jimmy Mac. Luka was poor against Watford and today. Roy needs to keep Wilf on the wing when he returns. Ayew up front. Sorloth is a championship striker at best and Benteke has had more than enough chances.

do we think luca is just tired after the world cup?

also no thanks ayew up top instead pf bentekkers

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Sep 18 9.14pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

The only way the guy next to you isn't going to moan all the way through a match like that is if you're sitting in the away end. HTH.

I draw the line at slagging off AWB for every little mistake. The guys a prick even if he apparently “supports” the team.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 01 Sep 18 9.22pm

Originally posted by trapperjohn

Agree to an extent; Schlupp was poor but I didn’t see Andros do anything to warrant not being taken off .

Pretty much everyone else was meh but sorry the worst by far was Luka. Poor passing, poor positioning, poor free kicks and most of all where was the captain after the first goal? Everyone stood round looking shell-shocked and there was no geeing them up at all. I begin to wonder if his best games were alongside Cabaye? In which case bring in Kayoute and Meyer asap. Not knocked off the ball, driving forward whenever they could and wanting the ball.

Oh and I think you are very harsh about Ayew.

I think Luka May have played too much football - World Cup and all that. Could do with a spell on the subs bench

 

Curlyeagle 2 Flag Crowborogh 01 Sep 18 9.37pm

Thought the performance today was very poor. Schlup looks to me as if he has no idea what his role is in the team. Time after time gets sucked in allowing the opposition to deliver un challenged crosses in to our box.

In my opinion Cabaye is beginning to look a huge loss. I am sure this is the reason Luka is not looking half the player he was last season.

We huffed and puffed in the second half but really never looked like breaking through a very defiant Southampton rear guard. Yet again it is so clear that we lack a natural goal scorer. Benteke and Sorloth unfortunately don’t have that killer instinct in front of goal.

All in all very disappointing and very concerning

 

srh Flag london 01 Sep 18 9.55pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

In short, Meyer should have been on earlier and Kouyate probably from the start

Schlupp poor again and Ayew a cross between Schlupp and Frazier Campbell.

Townsend too good to take off. Hennessy and Wan Bassaka true class.

Biggest lesson is the same as last week. PVA allows crosses. Never stops them. Compare to AWB. The opposition can see that.

Bring back Souare anyone? Push PVA forward again?

Hennessy true class? What was he doing for the second goal? Completely in no man's land. very odd keeping

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Sep 18 10.22pm

Originally posted by srh

Hennessy true class? What was he doing for the second goal? Completely in no man's land. very odd keeping

So in your book he's just supposed to stay on his line and wait and see what happens, jeez give me strength.


 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Sep 18 10.23pm

Originally posted by srh

Hennessy true class? What was he doing for the second goal? Completely in no man's land. very odd keeping

So in your book he's just supposed to stay on his line and wait and see what happens, jeez give me strength.


 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 01 Sep 18 11.59pm

I was sat in the Main stand directly in line with Højbjerg when he scored the second. As good as Hennessey has been this year he was completely out of position for the goal. He may have come off his line but seemed to have no idea as to where his goal was as he was protecting none of it!

Højbjerg passed it into an empty net and Hennessey should’ve done more to spread himself in front of the ball, just like the Great Dane Peter Schmeichel used to do, week in week out.

I don’t fault him for the first goal as it was just a good finish with a stroke of good fortune but for the second he was totally out of position and was left flapping lamely at thin air.

That said, he kept us in it at Fulham and also today and has generally been excellent and vastly improved on last season. I can’t however defend him for the second goal today.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (02 Sep 2018 12.05am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 02 Sep 18 6.34am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So in your book he's just supposed to stay on his line and wait and see what happens, jeez give me strength.


If you come out as a Keeper then come out and sort out.
Don't come out and faff about!!
Whilst not to blame for the first goal he should have stayed back and then no goal.
Second goal down to his positioning.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 02 Sep 18 6.42am

Originally posted by Petereagle

I think Luka May have played too much football - World Cup and all that. Could do with a spell on the subs bench

I think your right but he will get a rest now during the international break . Other players will get the time to shake off niggles and maybe a few long term absentees will be nearer a return . Poor start to the season result wise but apart from the frustrating situation with our centre forward we have looked half decent . Today we were a bit open defensively Hennessy earnt his corn but yet again no Zaha = no points .

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 02 Sep 18 9.01am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

So in your book he's just supposed to stay on his line and wait and see what happens, jeez give me strength.


Even Kouyate was pointing where he should be as he chased the ball down clearly trying to limit the angles. By coming out into no mans land it made the finish a simple one.

He’s been great this season but that was shades of old Hennessey - offset by the saved pen but still leaves a nagging doubt.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Sep 18 9.18am

Originally posted by Curlyeagle 2

Thought the performance today was very poor. Schlup looks to me as if he has no idea what his role is in the team. Time after time gets sucked in allowing the opposition to deliver un challenged crosses in to our box.

In my opinion Cabaye is beginning to look a huge loss. I am sure this is the reason Luka is not looking half the player he was last season.

We huffed and puffed in the second half but really never looked like breaking through a very defiant Southampton rear guard. Yet again it is so clear that we lack a natural goal scorer. Benteke and Sorloth unfortunately don’t have that killer instinct in front of goal.

All in all very disappointing and very concerning

I totally agree.

I am certainly not hitting the 'Panic button' but when one loses three on the bounce and regularly plays a striker who has only scored 1 goal (Penalty) since the end of January then certainly cause for concern.

Lose at Huddersfield on the back of yet another abject Benteke performance and I suspect supporters will really start to vent their spleen.

 

jackosperoni Flag Penzance, Cornwall 02 Sep 18 9.19am

Zaha reported his groin strain at the end of training, after Hodgson had picked the team?

If this is the case, is there still not the possibility of Roy accepting that with nobody to take the pressure off the defence like Wilf, he needs to change the team?

In which case starting with Meyer and Kouyate would have given us more creativity and drive going forward. If Meyer is the new Cabaye why is he on the bench? Kouyate looked exceptional when he came on and can clearly run from the back with the ball.

Living in Southampton the drive home was a long, miserable one. Bill Shankly used to call them a 'pub team' because they were always rough and physical. With Sparky in charge they seem to have gone back to their old habits.

I thought it was men vs boys today. The Palace players allowed themselves to be bullied out of a perfectly winnable game.

I don't think Roy's selection helped and we still have a problem keeper despite improvements. He was caught in 'no man's land' for the second goal, when he needed the conviction to come for the ball (Jacko would have been out like a shot in years gone by)

I know Roy only ever seems to play 4-4-2, but I wonder if a 3-5-2 might use the talents of a small squad better?

Hennessey/Guaita

Tomkins, Kouyate, Sakho

Wan Bissaka, Milivojevic, Meyer, MvCarthur, Van Aanholt

Ayew, Zaha

The A-Z of deadly finishing!!!


 


55 years on the Palace rollercoaster!

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Sep 18 9.22am

Well I remember Mandanda against Liverpool when he came out and spread himself and all Firmino did was dink it over him for a goal. Dead easy this goalkeeping lark when you're sitting in the stands. And that's the second time this season at home that late breakaways have left our keeper exposed.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

jackosperoni Flag Penzance, Cornwall 02 Sep 18 9.49am

Keeping is not remotely easy, but the best keepers have a confidence and conviction that I don't see yet in Wayne. I like the way he has tried to improve his game, but he is still work in progress IMO

 


55 years on the Palace rollercoaster!

Sportyteacher Flag London 02 Sep 18 10.09am

Originally posted by portlandeagle4

With every miss, Benteke is digging himself a bigger and bigger hole of low confidence to get out of. Macca and AWB were solid, as was Hennessey, but Schlupp and Ayew didn't do enough. I think we should line up like this v Huddersfield

Hennessey
AWB Tomkins(if he's back) Sakho Souare
Meyer Kouyate Macca PVA
Zaha Townsend

Hard to disagree. Benteke for sub and to give him time in Reserves & 'B- string' Cup team. Palace needs to regroup especially up front with desperate need to rack up wins against opposition whom we should be beating. Southampton yesterday was one helluva warning shot to both The Eagles. (Shane Long transfer request in January?)

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 02 Sep 18 10.12am

I think most of us felt a slight sinking feeling when we arrived at the match to find the Blessed Saint Wilfred would not be appearing. Thoughts of those statistics from last season and not winning without him immediately sprang to mind.

The question is, does not only affect the confidence of the fans when he is out, but also the mentality of the other players? I hope not, but perhaps there is a little lurking nag in the back of their minds that they are being sent into battle with a shortage of ammunition.It is certainly worrying though that we currently seem so dependent on one player to be fit.

Edited by Pete53 (02 Sep 2018 10.13am)

 

jackosperoni Flag Penzance, Cornwall 02 Sep 18 10.30am

I think that's right, Pete.

The Palace players seem to depend too much on Wilf, and Roy's tetchiness at the press conference on Friday seems to suggest that he feels that way too.

One bad tackle and heaven forfend Wilf could be out for the season. Roy has to develop a plan B and a different mindset in the players. It would also help if he picked players like Meyer who can hold onto the ball and use it creatively.

The first half yesterday was defend deep and hit and hope.

 


55 years on the Palace rollercoaster!

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game