You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why has there been no progress in 5 years?
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why has there been no progress in 5 years?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
michaelpearce Flag grays 02 Oct 18 6.42pm

Originally posted by EagleinSF

LOL - This. I've been a fan for 50 years and its the Palace rollercoaster.

We have made progress, but in the Lodsa money league unless you're spending ungoldly amounts you start to go backward.

It would be nice to have a season or 2 looking up rather than down but hey its Palace

no you wouldnt you would be bored what fun would we have if we was always safe ,

still say the best season to be a palace fan was when we went into admin deducted 10points stay up on the last game away,march to lloyds get told we are still alive 10 mins after deadline,come on thats why we support them :'(

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 02 Oct 18 6.45pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I think there's a law of diminishing returns when it comes to being a PL football club. Our spend is broadly commensurate with our status. Are we finding gems though? Perhaps not.

Wan Bissaka?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 02 Oct 18 6.47pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

We seem to make a lot of costly individual errors but - no one can legislate for a £30m striker suddenly not scoring for the thick end of a year albeit he should have been outed regardless of the loss.
With a decent Centre Forward we would be in this pickle.
We are bemoaning Ward and Sakho missing gilt edged chances but in reality we are having a go at two defenders missing the target - where were our forwards and midfielders is what bothers me more!
Another worry is the purchase/loans of Ayew, Koyoute and the like - middle of the road players who won't make us better.
They take the place of Cabaye and RLC - no contest in that they are inferior players.
I accept they are better than the Puncheons of this world butI would prefer to bring youth through to be honest and have a proper spend up on fewer players.
As someone else posted yesterday we are going down again - it is just a question of which season - true - unless we get a couple of better players in and soon and I hate to say it but we need to sell Wilf to do it.
Last night showed that the lesser teams will crowd him out now and so he is less effective and suddenly we can't rely on him and there is no Plan B. If he is marked by two then don't give him the ball I guess - use it elsewhere.
Against the better teams he will get more space hopefully.
We should get out of it this time but January will be very important for us and the Summer even more so.
Still - it's going to be another hard season - it's never dull with CPFC!

Meyer can fit into the role of Cabaye. Think we tried very hard to get RLC back on loan from Chelski but they didn't budge. Think we will try again in Jan. The striker position is really hitting us hard though. The likes of Bournemouth and Watford have scored double our amount of goals whilst our defence has been better and equal. In the transfer market you need to spend £20 million plus nowadays to get anybody who looks capable of bagging goals in this league.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 02 Oct 18 6.48pm

Seriously, look at us 5 years ago and look at us now. We have made progress, but then so has everyone else, except for those who haven’t, like Sunderland.

We might do a Burnley one year, but I am going to savour the days when we are fighting relegation from the Premier League. We will be fighting to stay in the Championship soon enough.

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 02 Oct 18 6.52pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

pray tell

haha. oops

typo

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Maine Eagle Flag USA 02 Oct 18 7.23pm

2 words, Rakip, and Jach.

Or Jach, and Rakip, if you prefer.

We have had about 2 good transfer windows since we came up.

Hennessey has turned things around and looks good value to keep Guaita at bay but how on earth is he still at the club? He has to count his lucky stars. He was awful in the post Mandanda era but we messed around (see Ronnow, Frederic) and didnt address the issue. Ironically we finally sort it out, sign one of La Liga's best keepers and the bloke cant get a game as Wayne is playing out of his skin lately. Comedy, but not for Guaita who was playing first team against Spain's best not long ago.

When Pap Souare went down we had no left backs at the club. When Benteke went down a while back we had no fit senior strikers at the club. Murray, Glenn springs to mind. Too many poor decisions, too many mistakes. Too many times listening to a dumb manager, then blocking a good one.

The amount of times we played games and messed around on transfers, leaving things to the last minute, then got burned is unbelievable.

Think about Pardew, how on God's green earth was he not fired sooner. Remember Swansea 5-4?

But the most heinous and calamitous act that our chairman has ever committed - De Boer, Frank. Hiring a master of possession based football, with a questionable management style, after a 4 week long search, into our club which is built on counter attacking football and good team spirit. You couldn't make this stuff up. How can such a clanger be made, such a massive error of this nature? How can that happen? Then he tweets about togetherness then fires the guy after we actually should have easily beaten Burnley but Scott Dann missed an open goal, to name but one glaring miss.

I started a thread some months back called "Parish unable to progress us" and there was much chatter therein about the man running the show.

The latest handling of this HF topic - stand firm, then cave in, is classic Parish. This could have been sorted out 6 months ago with a strong leader taking control of the situation, being open and public about what was going on. Instead its rumors and theories about what is going on, followed by a show of force then a total 180.

My view is we are limited, held back, and not progressing as a club because of Steve Parish in many ways, plain and simple. Could someone else have done better? Yes. Could someone else have done worse, and rebranded us as the "Crystal Palace Eagles" and changed the colours - also yes. Both statements can be true, but the answer to the question is also still the same - we are not making progress because of the captain of the ship taking too many wrong turns.

This is all ironic though as for the first time in the premier league we started this season settled, with a half decent transfer window, and seemingly on the cusp of mid table mediocrity.

Alas not so far into the season and we have Jordan Ayew (a winger) or Alex Sorloth (million miles from Premier League starter) to choose from up top, next to Zaha.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Kant Flag exeter 02 Oct 18 10.51pm

Short of acquiring a super rich owner willing to pump hundreds of millions into the club without return we are destined to fight a yearly battle against relegation in our mini league of 14 or 13.

Each new season we are at the mercy of a cocktail of risk factors: injuries, poor refs, individual mistakes, bad signings, lack of confidence, pure bad luck etc.

It’s a game of musical chairs. Chances are that sooner or later we will find ourselves in the bottom 3 when the music stops - as will all the other cannon fodder teams.

In fact over the course of the next 10 years I suspect every team bar the top six and Everton will go down.

So don’t fret about ‘progressing to the next level’ as if there is some sort of middle ground where safety is assured. There isn’t a next level - not for us, not for any of ‘the rest’. Just ask West Brom and Stoke.

Put your unrealistic expectations away and enjoy the good times while they last. It may not be perfect, but this is as good as it gets.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 02 Oct 18 11.58pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

this league gets stronger year on year

all we do is play keeping up with the jones’

that is all we can do unless we get brought out by some billionaire

i genuinally do know what people expect

The two yanks are Billionaires.....

 


Pro USA & Israel

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 03 Oct 18 1.22am

1) A year on year failure to obtain an effective striker for the way we play. It’s reached a point now where I’d genuinely ship all of our strikers out and replace them with unknowns from the lower leagues or Europe in case we unearth a gem.

2) A complete over reliance on Zaha, to the extent that we have effectively convinced ourself that we can’t win if he doesn’t play or doesn’t play well. Teams can just double up on him now and know that if he is kept quiet we won’t beat them.

In short, a lack of attacking options.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

exiled eagle Flag Southampton 03 Oct 18 3.40am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

1) A year on year failure to obtain an effective striker for the way we play. It’s reached a point now where I’d genuinely ship all of our strikers out and replace them with unknowns from the lower leagues or Europe in case we unearth a gem.

2) A complete over reliance on Zaha, to the extent that we have effectively convinced ourself that we can’t win if he doesn’t play or doesn’t play well. Teams can just double up on him now and know that if he is kept quiet we won’t beat them.

In short, a lack of attacking options.

Agree entirely with above post

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 03 Oct 18 6.33am

Originally posted by Jimenez

The two yanks are Billionaires.....

sadly we needed them before the fairplay lge kicked in,chelsea and man city got in before the rules changed,only arsenal,man utd and liverpool had global support before the other 2,spurs and everton are trying to build,everton are 1 of 2 teams in Liverpool so get a large following,

we need a bigger ground that is going ahead,could do with a couple of trophy's to up our profile,that way we can get global support not just local support,to get all this is going tobe a long hard run,we are getting better and stronger, please let one of our strikers find there goal scoring boots, but I think its still 5 years off were the fans want us, no matter who runs the club.

as someone said just enjoy the moment, we maybe close to something good but no guarantees that is the nature of the beast

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Oct 18 6.45am

Originally posted by dp

Wan Bissaka?

I meant in the market really. AWB is an absolute gem. How many players would you say "wow, what a player for 5 million quid"?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

YT Flag Oxford 03 Oct 18 6.48am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I meant in the market really. AWB is an absolute gem. How many players would you say "wow, what a player for 5 million quid"?

Or indeed lots more than £5m.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 03 Oct 18 11.19am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I meant in the market really. AWB is an absolute gem. How many players would you say "wow, what a player for 5 million quid"?

Point taken. I didn’t mean to be obtuse. I am just on my soapbox that we have to be able to grow our own that are better than some of the people we are buying.

I mean, we are buying strikers that we don’t expect to score, so surely we can save our money and grow our own. If they don’t score then at least we have saved our money. That said Sorloth is still young, but we must have had someone else in the academy who could have done the same job.

Edited by dp (03 Oct 2018 11.26am)

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 03 Oct 18 11.43am

I think the clear and obvious reasons theres been no real progress are

1) The constant changing on managers
2) Recruitment, or lack of.

Its hard to build a team when theres not a solid managerial team youre building it for. Every manager has preferences and their own ways of playing, as well as their coaching staff having their own ways of doing things.
So for much of our premier league existance we have started a season learning a new managers way, and its no coincidence we start poorly and end up mid table, probably beacuse the players take time to learn that managers way and by the end it has some what clicked.

In terms of recruitment, I understand Parish is cautious of FFP but he still keeps referring back to the Jan window we signed Luka, PVA and schlupp etc.
We've had 3 windows since then and all we've bought for big money is Sakho, not to mention we have had high value departures in that time with the likes of Cabaye and Sako amongst others leaving.
We havent addressed the problem areas that have been glaring for quite a while. We have failed to find a striker who is upto the job probably since we lost Glenn Murray.
Ayew was a rushed last resort who might get us 5 goals this year but certainly wont pull up any trees and has no realy commitment to palace due to him only being here on loan.
Why isnt Parish out there during the season making contact with teams and having players ready to go when a window opens.
Meyer was a great signing and he excites me, but we lost RLC & Cabaye, so we havent progressed, we've just tread water and attempted to even it up again.
For us to progress we need a deeper squad, we need a capable premier league striker and we probably need a No10.
Defensively i do believe we have progressed, but offensively we are miles off the pace and it should have been sorted.
We will continue to be frustrated week after week with chances being missed until we secure the signing of a genuinely good finisher and someone who can play the final pass and chip in themselves.
We cant rely on Wilf and PVA to score our goals to see us safe.

 

palacebob Flag melton mowbray 03 Oct 18 12.20pm

Watford and leicester come to mind they look solid dont rely on managers wasting money or chairmen buying players there is more than one way to survive its a back room problem for sure but not a manager issue any manager will only be short term that is the way of the game either let Dougie do his job which means trusting him or get someone in that you will trust.
The managers only known fact from the start is he will go one way or another he will be gone even the good ones go.
A quick rant .....
i really dont understand fans that say we need to spend big to succeed look at the the top six you could build several teams around the players they wasted money on Chelseas fixation with center forwards is horrific city no different with young players no team outside the top 6 could survive playing that game its a pundits answer to everything "you are with the big boys now" absolute Boxxoxs ....in my opinion...Rant over
Mind you what do i know i thought Frank was the answer as previously stated the Burnley game looked like a new beginning was starting.. in my defense no one mentioned his megalomaniac personality in any press conference

Edited by palacebob (03 Oct 2018 12.21pm)

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Oct 18 12.25pm

where do people believe we should be by now?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

RyWa Flag Beckenham 03 Oct 18 12.30pm

I believe we should be finishing between 8th & 12th after a season of solidity and not panic.

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 03 Oct 18 12.43pm

Whilst I understand the sentiment I think we've come a long way since promotion.

There have been ground improvements, new pitch, lights, PA system, disabled access etc all needed to remain in the PL.

The squad is probably the best we've had but that could be said for most PL teams as the league has improved/got tougher year on year.

To put things into perspective, the year we were promoted the teams that went down are Wigan, Reading & QPR & they've suffered since.

The teams that were in the PL in our first season back included Villa, Cardiff, Fulham, Hull, Norwich, Stoke, Sunderland, Swansea & WBA, none of which has 'survived' like we have. Several of those were referred to as "a solid, mid-table club" yet here we are with most not in the PL & the other two just promoted.

I think it's reasonable to say that any team outside the top 5 or 6 is susceptible to relegation & they are all running just to stand still (or possibly even accepting their fate already).

Edited by Nobbybm (03 Oct 2018 12.44pm)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 03 Oct 18 12.48pm

Originally posted by RyWa

I believe we should be finishing between 8th & 12th after a season of solidity and not panic.

And who's to say we won't is my point? I'm certainly not feeling even slightly panicky about where we're at and think we're capable of (and will deliver) significantly improved performances & results.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why has there been no progress in 5 years?