You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > You should go in Jan wilf
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

You should go in Jan wilf


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 Oct 18 7.00pm

Somebody actually wrote that because Wilf recently signed a long contract, why should he be going? Pretty obvious, the longer the contract the bigger the buy out. Where have people been over the last few years?

 

Fred Bassett Flag rotherfield 08 Oct 18 9.31am

I blame the management , it has been obvious for nearly a season and a half that what is needed are forwards that can actually score goals , goals win matches and until they get this Palace will struggle until relegated, and then Wilf will be sold at half the price in a fire sale, and whose idea was it to get rid of Glen Murrey you couldnt make it up.

 

AERO Flag 08 Oct 18 9.46am

Don’t see the point in keeping Wilf and not giving him & Palace the tools to do you he job ie signing a decent centre forward

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 08 Oct 18 10.20am

Get in the bin (not Wilf).

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 08 Oct 18 10.32am

Is this topic the most absurd/stupid ever on this site? I vote for it....

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 08 Oct 18 10.42am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Is this topic the most absurd/stupid ever on this site? I vote for it....

Agreed, has my vote.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Oct 18 10.47am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

Is this topic the most absurd/stupid ever on this site? I vote for it....

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

Agreed, has my vote.

Why not make a constructive comment instead of just rubbishing someone's suggestion

 

taylors lovechild Flag 08 Oct 18 11.04am

Wilf appears to have been negatively impacted by the media attention following his comments about being targeted. Roy didn't exactly back him when questioned about Wilf's comments and I wonder if this has upset him? I love Wilf, but he is very much still ruled by his emotions. When he's happy and smiling he is unstoppable, but when things go against him he is prone to disappearing.

I find it frustrating as the next person that we seem to struggle creatively without him, but selling him would just significantly weaken us. The key is not playing without him, but getting him to lift his chin and get back to playing as he was only four games ago. In the age of the internet it is hard to have patience, but I believe that is all that is required here.

It may also be time to rock the cradle a bit and start both Meyer and Kouyate, as the midfield is not contributing with goals and both of our new signings look like they could find the net if given more time on the pitch.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 08 Oct 18 11.27am

It's not a question of whether he should go - its a question of whether a club will pay what we're looking for and the answer to that is NO.

He's not worth 60m to anyone else but he is to us. He's signed a long contract and we should build the team around him and improve.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 08 Oct 18 11.29am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why not make a constructive comment instead of just rubbishing someone's suggestion

Is it constructive to suggest selling your best player? The thread was started by someone who is frustrated at current progress, but encouraging the best player to go is stupid.
Zaha is bit of enigma, it’s all or nothing with him. When he plays well, he is unstoppable, but when clubs mark him out of the game, he appears clueless and goes missing.

 

I'mPalace Till I Die Flag 08 Oct 18 11.33am

The answer isn't to sell him imo. I think Wilf needs to go back on the wing and given less of a free role for now. Townsend should be on the other wing. We are playing too narrow and haven't been good enough to play this system

 

robforbe Flag cornwall 08 Oct 18 11.36am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

The OP is obviously a br*ton fan.


I'm no seaweed pal!!

Wilf is magic, we would not be where we are now without him.

But here's the truth, he is on an extended contract to ensure we get decent money for him.

He will leave sometime, prob in summer, but if he gets dissolutioned may agitate for a move come Jan.

HE is carrying us, opponents know if they nullify wilf they nullify palace.

Winter window is crucial..but I don't think we have vast financial resource to flop out 50m on the striker we need..even if we did 32m bentekkers anyone??

We may NEED to sell to get that striker.

Might as well do it Jan while wilfs stock is high and get used to a way of playing that isn't centric around him, if we limp through and manage to stay up then we will be better prepared for the next.

Another poster also said if we go down then wilf will 100% be sold ..for a lesser value..vultures aren't vultures for nothing.

Enjoy him now, hope he gets us some points before Jan, then we have have a swift revolution..we HAVE to change or we will be back to square one in the championship.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Oct 18 11.48am

Originally posted by Painter

Is it constructive to suggest selling your best player? The thread was started by someone who is frustrated at current progress, but encouraging the best player to go is stupid.

Under certain circumstances it could be of benefit to sell your best player as long as the proceeds are used wisely and that is where I disagree with the suggestion as I don't have sufficient faith in the club's management to spend the money wisely

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 08 Oct 18 12.22pm

wilf's price should only ever be: can we improve the team from the proceeds of selling him. it doesn't matter if that price is £1 or £300m. I don't believe we have the skills in the transfer market to do that based on the price we'd likely get.

I wonder if the capoue tackle actually put fear in his heart, or whether he's injured. what I do find odd is how placid he's become. it had been that he almost needed to wind himself up and get a yellow before he could play. now he's calmer but the aggression and desire to humiliate a full back has gone (for a while).

maybe Roy's told him he's got to adapt his game bit and he's learning some new skills.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

slubglurge Flag welling 08 Oct 18 12.32pm

[quote=I'mPalace Till I Die;3373438]

The answer isn't to sell him imo. I think Wilf needs to go back on the wing and given less of a free role for now. Townsend should be on the other wing. We are playing too narrow and haven't been good enough to play this system

Not much point him being on the wing. He can put a 100 balls across the box but while we have the invisible man to get on the end of them its pointless

 

Mystic Smeg Flag Here 08 Oct 18 12.50pm

Originally posted by robforbe

With the majority( I hope) blessing.

Needs to be for the sake of your career and the club to be able to move forward, we have been found out..stop zaha, by whatever means, stop palace.

Wilf would have more time to do his 'thing' with quality players around him,because it would not just be him.

And palace desperately need to find a way to play without him.

Miraculously we may not even go down, because there are 3 teams worse than us ..at the moment..but I would expect all of them to rally.

PALACE need to look to the future, sadly wilf is part of the past now.

Behave Rob

 


Against the disease of writing one must take special precautions, since it is a dangerous and contagious disease

KAOS Flag In a tree 08 Oct 18 12.54pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Under certain circumstances it could be of benefit to sell your best player as long as the proceeds are used wisely and that is where I disagree with the suggestion as I don't have sufficient faith in the club's management to spend the money wisely

Exactly! I wouldn't trust Muggy Freedman with £50 and my Tesco's shopping list clearing stating what I need!

 

Aray Flag South London 08 Oct 18 1.02pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why not make a constructive comment instead of just rubbishing someone's suggestion

If someone makes a rubbish suggestion we are surely entitled to make that point in the manner we please without breaking the site's rules about abuse.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 08 Oct 18 1.22pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why not make a constructive comment instead of just rubbishing someone's suggestion

So by this you are implying that getting rid of Wilf is constructive? Jog on

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 08 Oct 18 1.52pm

Originally posted by Aray

If someone makes a rubbish suggestion we are surely entitled to make that point in the manner we please without breaking the site's rules about abuse.

I can't see that anyone here has made a rubbish suggestion.

Some have made suggestions that you and/or others may disagree with but that doesn't make them "rubbish"

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > You should go in Jan wilf