This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
Pullis didn't have a plan until later on when he could see he wasn't going to be backed by SP don't talk such rubbish like the guy came into the club thinking it would be easy pay day. SP has been in charge for many years now and is still making same mistakes and the club is not progressing because of him so he needs replacing. What is a big club? this is open to debate those names you list why are they big clubs what have they done in the premier league era not much at all and Leeds/Forest have been outside the Prem for ages. Had we not been promoted the club would of been in same state the previous owner left us in so SP got lucky because at this point was when there was a lot of money for going up and even in place if you did go down you would get something this was an issue previous owner ran into once you was outside Prem you are screwed there was no fancy tv deals or big bonus for be relegated. I really think you are in fantasy world at times Painter. It is no fantasy, that Parish has overseen the most successful period in the clubs history. You may not like it, but that is the reality.
|
|
|
I think Roy's demeanour may also have a lot to do with being asked the same questions about Zaha each week. It must make for a really soul draining experience. With regard to Parish, for me it comes down to the question of whether Parish is playing tight with the purse strings because of FFP, or because the club don't want to spend money. If it's the former then I don't really see what people expect from him as you only have to look at QPR to see what happens when you break the rules [Link] Of course if it is the latter then there are questions to be asked. Under Parish we made a profit on Zaha and signed the likes of Cabaye, Luka, PvA, Townsend, Sakho and Tomkins, and at the time (and for the first season) Bentenke seemed like a very good signing that most fans backed. I don't think there is a club in the league that has not made expensive mistakes with transfers, some of whom were linked with us such as £30 million Slimani at Leicester, £27 million Tosun at Everton (who will no doubt score tomorrow now I've said that!) and Hugill at West Ham (£9 million?), for example. The one big issue that I can see has been our failure to bring in a competent striker to challenge Bentenke. It would appear that Parish has failed to learn from our mistakes in this regard, but I have never heard anyone with an inside knowledge explain why this is? Is it poor scouting? Poor negotiators? Or are we just not an attractive proposition to the better class of player? In an era when even a fairly average Championship player can go for £10 million+ the risks are high. When we signed Sørloth Roy seemed very pleased so I'm not sure I go along with the narrative that it was just what we could afford. At the time Roy had this to say:
"He was incredibly positive in every way. I also received a positive message from Per-Mathias Høgmo, who congratulated and thought we signed a very good player, says Hodgson to Adressa .
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I think Roy's demeanour may also have a lot to do with being asked the same questions about Zaha each week. It must make for a really soul draining experience. With regard to Parish, for me it comes down to the question of whether Parish is playing tight with the purse strings because of FFP, or because the club don't want to spend money. If it's the former then I don't really see what people expect from him as you only have to look at QPR to see what happens when you break the rules [Link] Of course if it is the latter then there are questions to be asked. Under Parish we made a profit on Zaha and signed the likes of Cabaye, Luka, PvA, Townsend, Sakho and Tomkins, and at the time (and for the first season) Bentenke seemed like a very good signing that most fans backed. I don't think there is a club in the league that has not made expensive mistakes with transfers, some of whom were linked with us such as £30 million Slimani at Leicester, £27 million Tosun at Everton (who will no doubt score tomorrow now I've said that!) and Hugill at West Ham (£9 million?), for example. The one big issue that I can see has been our failure to bring in a competent striker to challenge Bentenke. It would appear that Parish has failed to learn from our mistakes in this regard, but I have never heard anyone with an inside knowledge explain why this is? Is it poor scouting? Poor negotiators? Or are we just not an attractive proposition to the better class of player? In an era when even a fairly average Championship player can go for £10 million+ the risks are high. When we signed Sørloth Roy seemed very pleased so I'm not sure I go along with the narrative that it was just what we could afford. At the time Roy had this to say:
"He was incredibly positive in every way. I also received a positive message from Per-Mathias Høgmo, who congratulated and thought we signed a very good player, says Hodgson to Adressa .
Ashley like Steve Parish gets pilloried. Newcastle were in a dire financial situation when he took over the club in 2007. I'm not acting as Ashley's mouthpiece, just highlighting some of the positive aspects of his ownership at Newcastle and adding that there are certainly a great deal of positives to be taken from Parish's time at our club.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Signings since Hodgson joined the club : I didnt realise we had paid this much for him. It seems an incredible amount for someone who in truth would have to fight for a place in a Championship team - and we sold Glenn Murray for £4.3?
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978 |
|
|
Originally posted by kevlee
I didnt realise we had paid this much for him. It seems an incredible amount for someone who in truth would have to fight for a place in a Championship team - and we sold Glenn Murray for £4.3? Dreadful bit of business,but then SP has the ability to sign strikers who would struggle to strike a match,let alone find the net!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by kevlee
I didnt realise we had paid this much for him. It seems an incredible amount for someone who in truth would have to fight for a place in a Championship team And to make matters worse we bought him from a club that had only recently bought him themselves for about four pence ha'penny
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
And to make matters worse we bought him from a club that had only recently bought him themselves for about four pence ha'penny Just about sums up our transfer strategy. Sell a match winning goal machine like Murray and replace him with duds.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
And to make matters worse we bought him from a club that had only recently bought him themselves for about four pence ha'penny I've just checked. Midtjylland bought him in June 2017 for about £450,000 and six months later sold him to us for about £9m
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
It is no fantasy, that Parish has overseen the most successful period in the clubs history. You may not like it, but that is the reality. But it is fantasy when we was relegated the payments for going down was in the region of only 2m now if you go down you get around 45m and for next few years extra tv money filtered down from Prem that is a massive difference that wasn't in place before (the club under SP in championship was in trouble and risk of going under again had we not been promoted) Originally posted by taylors lovechild
He has purchased those players because of the mass amount of funds from tv money nothing to do with his own pocket. Those billionaires you speak of was brought in to invest in the likes of stadium only it was a poor move even SP few times has said he would of done it different (whats the point having billionaires if they wont give you any money to spend on players they could give the club a big loan like other clubs have done) The Zaha one can be debated as well word is United get 50% of future transfer fee that is awful business. A lot of the work done on the ground had to be be done to meet regulations so it's not a case of the owners wanting to glam it up (the big stadium project has still not even been signed off yet so it may not even happen so you think of all the money wasted word was they had spent on that) As another poster pointed out Mike Ashley has done a lot for Newcastle putting in mass amounts of money he has put in way more then are current owners.
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
The Zaha one can be debated as well word is United get 50% of future transfer fee that is awful business. I've long been critical of Mr P's transfers but not the one that you have mentioned. It was an excellent deal at the time which is what is important.
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
He has purchased those players because of the mass amount of funds from tv money nothing to do with his own pocket. Those billionaires you speak of was brought in to invest in the likes of stadium only it was a poor move even SP few times has said he would of done it different (whats the point having billionaires if they wont give you any money to spend on players they could give the club a big loan like other clubs have done) The Zaha one can be debated as well word is United get 50% of future transfer fee that is awful business. A lot of the work done on the ground had to be be done to meet regulations so it's not a case of the owners wanting to glam it up (the big stadium project has still not even been signed off yet so it may not even happen so you think of all the money wasted word was they had spent on that) As another poster pointed out Mike Ashley has done a lot for Newcastle putting in mass amounts of money he has put in way more then are current owners. You haven't said anything there that changes my opinion. I still think he's made mistakes, but ultimately I also still think at the present time he is the best man to be in charge.
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
But it is fantasy when we was relegated the payments for going down was in the region of only 2m now if you go down you get around 45m and for next few years extra tv money filtered down from Prem that is a massive difference that wasn't in place before (the club under SP in championship was in trouble and risk of going under again had we not been promoted) You claims of fantasy are not backed up by facts, only your view. There is no evidence the club was in danger of going under, if we weren't promoted, unless you would like to provide it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Originally posted by grumpymort
But it is fantasy when we was relegated the payments for going down was in the region of only 2m now if you go down you get around 45m and for next few years extra tv money filtered down from Prem that is a massive difference that wasn't in place before (the club under SP in championship was in trouble and risk of going under again had we not been promoted) You claims of fantasy are not backed up by facts, only your view. There is no evidence the club was in danger of going under, if we weren't promoted, unless you would like to provide it.
the former chairman failed because of the collapse of ondigital deal so clubs got no money they was promised so he had to resort to silly methods to get some and as i said before there was no fancy big pay outs you can claim the relative stuff all you want that is false look at the claimed big clubs it happened to now days because of the wealth shared even when dropping you have big chance of retaining lots of talent pushing to come back up back then you didn't you really are in a bubble you dont have a clue thats it need to find ignore button for you
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
Originally posted by grumpymort
But it is fantasy when we was relegated the payments for going down was in the region of only 2m now if you go down you get around 45m and for next few years extra tv money filtered down from Prem that is a massive difference that wasn't in place before (the club under SP in championship was in trouble and risk of going under again had we not been promoted) You claims of fantasy are not backed up by facts, only your view. There is no evidence the club was in danger of going under, if we weren't promoted, unless you would like to provide it. Everyone is entitled to their opinion - painter, yours is just as valid, however, i disagree - reason why, i'll try and keep it simple - we have had the most successful spell in the prem, but only on paper - it's through luck, changing things mid season, panic and short term buys and 3 teams being worse than us.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
Everyone is entitled to their opinion - painter, yours is just as valid, however, i disagree - reason why, i'll try and keep it simple - we have had the most successful spell in the prem, but only on paper - it's through luck, changing things mid season, panic and short term buys and 3 teams being worse than us. Finishes in the Premier League: 11th So at our worst there were five worse teams, on average we finish around 12th, which is pretty comfortable. We've won away at Anfield twice, Stamford Bridge twice, we've beaten quality Spurs and City sides. Not prepared to break the bank, apart from when a small club from South London signed players like Sakho and Benteke or paid the wages required to keep Wilf and sign Cabaye and Meyer. Not too mention the cost of signing Van Aanholt, Schlupp, Townsend, Sørloth, Tomkins, Luka and even Jimmy Mac. None of them were particularly cheap. How is spending more money using his head rather than his heart anyway? I'd say a better example is being able to know when he's made a mistake, like moving on from FdB.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
the former chairman failed because of the collapse of ondigital deal so clubs got no money they was promised so he had to resort to silly methods to get some and as i said before there was no fancy big pay outs you can claim the relative stuff all you want that is false look at the claimed big clubs it happened to now days because of the wealth shared even when dropping you have big chance of retaining lots of talent pushing to come back up back then you didn't you really are in a bubble you dont have a clue thats it need to find ignore button for you Blimey, that's a great excuse. So Jordan went bust im 2010 because of a deal that collapsed in 2002. Ignoring the fact we got promoted and relegated in the eight years between that, if ITV digital was the reason, why did he Jordan continue to spend all that money on players like Kuqi? The year before we went into admin we paid £1m for Nick Carle FFS. Back then you couldn't keep talent if you got relegated? We kept hold of AJ!
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
I am sure he is frustrated with it at the moment, because all the games apart from the Liverpool one,we should have picked up points. Our finishing has been a joke, we have created some great openings and wasted them. Look how many Jimmy Mac has had, he should have had about 5 goals so far, but it hasn’t gone for him. We need a bit of luck to go our way and we will be fine... It's a disgrace, what do they do all week? Football is a relatively simple game ... and the aim is to put the ball in the net. What game are we playing?
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by Username
why did he Jordan continue to spend all that money on players like Kuqi? The year before we went into admin we paid £1m for Nick Carle FFS. Simon Jordan has made the point that he always backed the manager so I'm guessing that Kuqi and Carle weren't his idea
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.