You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and substitutes
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy and substitutes


Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 21 Oct 18 7.03pm

Originally posted by Willo

Yes I agree.

Just looking at the last two games, we certainly didn't deserve to lose both of them.We have hit the woodwork 4 times this season which I think is more times than any other PL team.

Problem is being an attacking threat - only Huddersfield have scored less goals than us this season.Unless we can suddenly conjure up some magic in this aspect of the game, it is going to be a long hard season.

Spot on. This problem hasn't been rectified from last season and may well of been compounded by losses in midfield. Any team with an attacking threat in the league, which is the majority, are more than likely to turn us over. We look like we are heading to a 5 team scrap at the bottom.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

georgey wood Flag South London and Proud 21 Oct 18 7.10pm

I'm frustrated after the game and had a beer but need to have a rant. The club's in good hands in Parish and Roy and I think with a few players back and some luck well just about be ok. Even if have to wheel and deal in Jan. However: I've not enjoyed watching palace this season not because of the results but I'm sick of watching the same game. It's like ground hog day what do they review in training? Battle hard, decent shape and some individually good players so always in a game . However can't keep possession, no game management, no bite in the tackle, Schlupp and PVA constantly giving the ball away with rushed 1st time passes, Wilf wanting to fight the world like that good kid in the playground despite being fouled 1000 times he has to be smarter and give and go. A poor game from Luca and Townsend who just play no matter what, a flat footy Hennesey with terrible distribution and no subs when we're treading water last 20. Sakho switching off and actually trying too hard chasing and blocking everything when just needs to defend the area. Tomkins and AWB strong all season and Kouyoute did well today but surely people need to be told they're making same mistakes every fkin week. We're not far short which makes it worse but whole club seems a bit flat with ultra dramas too. It was only 6 months ago I was crowing away at Stoke where we looked fast, organised and clinical and the crowd were buzzing. What is going on in confused? Have to be honest palace a hard watch at the moment and I've seen Barber, Lee, Dorman, Andrew and watched Bassett and Taylor teams home and away. Just lost something so quickly unspent 90 minutes frustrated as losing to teams that are similar to ourselves but we never learn week on fkin week. Anyway rant over let's turn over the Arsenal. EAGLES...

 

SeagullHunter Flag Reading 21 Oct 18 7.27pm

Rarely comment on here anymore but I felt after today it was only necessary to. I am astounded at the lack of blame apportioned to Parish here. He's failed to invest properly for over 4 windows now & has not backed Roy when need backing. This past summer, and past January, lacked sufficient investment and it was painfully obvious that our luck wouldn't last much longer.

Yes Roy is at fault for lack of subs, completely agree & today all it could have taken was Ayew & Riedewald to freshen the side. But I am slightly perplexed at the Parish protectors who seem to let him get away with daylight robbery.

 


Dont let Cabaye go

Painter Flag Croydon 21 Oct 18 7.39pm

Originally posted by Master Coin

Does he know what they are? Today’s loss was increasingly obvious. We look increasingly tired and let them back in

Used all 3 subs against Bournemouth and lost. So your point is?

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 21 Oct 18 7.44pm

Originally posted by Cannonball

I'm afraid Roy is past his sell by date.
He has run out of ideas,he looks like a rabbit caught in the headlights.

Totally agree. Roy’s old fashioned ways and inability to bring on fresh legs when players are starting to tire is indefensible. Not to mention the fact that he’s had two transfer windows and the only decent player he’s brought in, Meyer, sits on the bench every week.

 

Bert's Boys Flag 21 Oct 18 7.49pm

Spot on.

Rarely comment on here anymore but I felt after today it was only necessary to. I am astounded at the lack of blame apportioned to Parish here. He's failed to invest properly for over 4 windows now & has not backed Roy when need backing. This past summer, and past January, lacked sufficient investment and it was painfully obvious that our luck wouldn't last much longer.

Yes Roy is at fault for lack of subs, completely agree & today all it could have taken was Ayew & Riedewald to freshen the side. But I am slightly perplexed at the Parish protectors who seem to let him get away with daylight robbery.

 

boo909 Flag Figeac 21 Oct 18 7.50pm

"The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results."

Should be our new club motto. Fair enough we don't have an amazingly strong squad but when you're losing nearly every game something has to change, it can't really get any worse, at least your putting on fresh legs, giving other players some match time, you never know they may surprise us, the current first 11 certainly isn't. Roy's sub policy was the same last season, it lost us games then and it's losing us even more games now. I don't think he's a bad manager but, at the risk of being patronising, I do think his age is showing, with his stubborness, the way he can't seem to react quickly enough to changes in the game and his inability to switch from his preferred tactics when they don't work. Not putting all the blame on Roy (as has been pointed out we don't have the best squad) but when you're stuck with a team like ours you need someone who can get the best out of them and Roy, unfortunately, doesn't seem to be that person.

 


Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.

chateauferret Flag 21 Oct 18 7.56pm

Originally posted by Painter

Used all 3 subs against Bournemouth and lost. So your point is?

Bournemouth hadn't just brought on Calvert-Lewin, Lookman and Cenk Tosun to break a deadlock.

That tactical change by Everton required some sort of response: either we try to freshen up our own attack and exploit the space they leave at the back trying to carry the game to us; or we stoke the midfield and add to the defence by sacrificing a few Townsend crosses-to-nobody. The former was unlikely given the attacking options available (although we might have tried Ayew); the latter was manifestly possible with Riedewald and Kelly available but McArthur evidently spent.

Hodgson did neither.

Edited by chateauferret (21 Oct 2018 8.00pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Oct 18 7.58pm

Originally posted by boo909

"The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results."

Should be our new club motto. Fair enough we don't have an amazingly strong squad but when you're losing nearly every game something has to change, it can't really get any worse, at least your putting on fresh legs, giving other players some match time, you never know they may surprise us, the current first 11 certainly isn't. Roy's sub policy was the same last season, it lost us games then and it's losing us even more games now. I don't think he's a bad manager but, at the risk of being patronising, I do think his age is showing, with his stubborness, the way he can't seem to react quickly enough to changes in the game and his inability to switch from his preferred tactics when they don't work. Not putting all the blame on Roy (as has been pointed out we don't have the best squad) but when you're stuck with a team like ours you need someone who can get the best out of them and Roy, unfortunately, doesn't seem to be that person.

Poor Hodgson went through thr wringer last season and performed a miracle in keeping us up.

What many saw as his strengths last season IE rigid tactical discipline and organisation is now seen as a weakness.

Reading a number of the posts, in many eyes he has gone from hero to zero.

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Oct 18 8.03pm

Originally posted by Willo

Poor Hodgson went through thr wringer last season and performed a miracle in keeping us up.

What many saw as his strengths last season IE rigid tactical discipline and organisation is now seen as a weakness.

Reading a number of the posts, in many eyes he has gone from hero to zero.

His tactical discipline was evident today in eighty-five minutes of a strong defensive display. We looked solid and well-organised. There was no weakness there.

The weakness was failing to respond to, much less anticipate, tactical changes being made by the opposition and the tiredness of our own players.

So 8/10 for discipline and organisation minus several million for game management.

 


============
The Ferret
============

deetee Flag 21 Oct 18 8.19pm

We need to be far more positive in the final 3rd at least 4 occasions where players could shoot but didn't

Roy has to realise Macca doesn't last more than 70 mins. We badly miss Cabaye and RLC


Parrish must get a striker in ASAP.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 21 Oct 18 8.32pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

His tactical discipline was evident today in eighty-five minutes of a strong defensive display. We looked solid and well-organised. There was no weakness there.

The weakness was failing to respond to, much less anticipate, tactical changes being made by the opposition and the tiredness of our own players.

So 8/10 for discipline and organisation minus several million for game management.

Against Wolves seemed to be outdone earlier with them as they did not do as expected but gave us a lot of possession and we did not adapt early to them and went behind as well. As you say game management seems to be non existent at the moment.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 21 Oct 18 9.10pm

The substitutes wouldn't have made any difference it's the system that needs to change we need some sort of attacking intent which we don't have were like stoke of last year what difference would ayew have made he's average at best Wickham hasn't played for 2 years puncheon is past it nobody on today's bench would have changed a thing in my humble opinion what needed to change was the tactics

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

gerry theagle Flag newbury 21 Oct 18 9.26pm

Agree entirely with baldeagle, look at Evertons bench then look at ours, we do not possess game changers so when you are doing ok at 0-0 with three minutes left there is nothing to be gained from changing the team.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 21 Oct 18 9.35pm

Originally posted by baldeagle73

The substitutes wouldn't have made any difference it's the system that needs to change we need some sort of attacking intent which we don't have were like stoke of last year what difference would ayew have made he's average at best Wickham hasn't played for 2 years puncheon is past it nobody on today's bench would have changed a thing in my humble opinion what needed to change was the tactics

Agree with this but to have attacking intent you need decent attacking players.

The chances we made today only really came from set pieces although Tomkins chance was gilt edge.

Don't like to dig out individuals but Townsend really starting to give me the bollock ache.

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 21 Oct 18 9.39pm

For substitutions to change a game you need players who are either different or better than the players on the pitch. Our problem is nobody on the bench was of better quality than the players on it nor of a type to change the shape of the game. We were matching Everton , for 85 minutes , so why would you want to bring on players of lesser ability or players that could not change the shape of the team. Roy did nothing wrong the footballing Gods are just not with us at the moment.

 

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 21 Oct 18 9.43pm

Maybe Roy has reached the mourinho stage were his style of management is outdated tactically at the level he's trying to perform at but without a striker in the mould of a Murray or Johnson type character we aren't going to get much better than we are now

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

Painter Flag Croydon 21 Oct 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

For substitutions to change a game you need players who are either different or better than the players on the pitch. Our problem is nobody on the bench was of better quality than the players on it nor of a type to change the shape of the game. We were matching Everton , for 85 minutes , so why would you want to bring on players of lesser ability or players that could not change the shape of the team. Roy did nothing wrong the footballing Gods are just not with us at the moment.

A sensible post at last. Everton fielded a team that cost over £300m and had expensive subs on the bench. Their Thai owners have thrown a lot of money in to try and break into the top 6. Roy had a game plan, that was working well to get a point or maybe 3 if we got a breakaway goal.
It was working well until the 87 min, why change if the plan was working, we were never going to get anything after that, we pushed up and got caught on the break.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 21 Oct 18 10.02pm

Originally posted by Painter

A sensible post at last. Everton fielded a team that cost over £300m and had expensive subs on the bench. Their Thai owners have thrown a lot of money in to try and break into the top 6. Roy had a game plan, that was working well to get a point or maybe 3 if we got a breakaway goal.
It was working well until the 87 min, why change if the plan was working, we were never going to get anything after that, we pushed up and got caught on the break.

Sorry but that’s rubbish. They brought on two fresh faces in the 82nd minute and our response to that was a big fat zero just like usual. If he had made a couple of changes things could have been completely different.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 21 Oct 18 10.05pm

Originally posted by Painter

A sensible post at last. Everton fielded a team that cost over £300m and had expensive subs on the bench. Their Thai owners have thrown a lot of money in to try and break into the top 6. Roy had a game plan, that was working well to get a point or maybe 3 if we got a breakaway goal.
It was working well until the 87 min, why change if the plan was working, we were never going to get anything after that, we pushed up and got caught on the break.

Changing shape yes i know the players arnt there.
But on 70 mins a point would have been a good result. So swap like for like and 'respect the point' (BFS).
When at i0 mins they made fresh changes and all strikers roy should have pushed their midfield back with fresh legs.
Thats surely minimum to give our defenders a slight rest.

 

Page 2 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy and substitutes