You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have we really made progress ?
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Have we really made progress ?


Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
the.universal 23 Oct 18 2.31am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Moaning Minnies' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We have had hundreds of millions of pounds thrown at us. I would hope we would have replaced Dean Moxey.

Good you talk about left backs, when Pap Souare had a car accident we didnt have a single other senior left back at the club - how many years was that into SP's reign? That is p&ss poor squad management.

Again after several years if we had not assembled some players who can play a bit more football than Mile Jedinak then Parish would want shooting.

SP has done some things well, and made some good signings hear and there. Vastly outweighing that he has made error after error, recklessly ill equipping the club to compete in the Premier League. Lets review some of those howlers:

1 - When Mandanda left we just forgot to replace him, maybe the post it note fell of SP's desk. Through some lucky miracle Hennessey has actually come good, after we finally get a player in to challenge him....hmmm....coincidence?
2 - We left the Niasse deal (like oh so many) so so late that when it collapsed we had no plan B - remember not having a single fit senior striker at the club?
3 - After a manager search lasting 2 weeks too long Parish hires a manager famous for possession based football with a questionable man management style...oops
3a - Then tweets about unity and then fires the guy after the Burnley game where we should have won 4-0 if our players could actually hit the target
4 - Sorloth, Alex
5 - Inability to hold on to any managers for any length of time
6 - Look at our current attacking options and tell me SP knows who to manage a squad?
7 - Handling of the HF tantrum - secretive, protracted, takes a stand then does a total 180 and no real explanation/discussion with all the affect parties, and a seemingly ballsed up approach to the singing section already
8 - Murray, Glenn

Yes SP has presided over our longest stay in the top flight, but its more through luck than judgement.

Edited by Maine Eagle (22 Oct 2018 9.36pm)

No, it’s because he gets more of the big decisions right than wrong, specifically manager appointments.

Untangle your knickers and realise we’ll be ok this season.

 


Vive le Roy!

The Dolphin Flag 23 Oct 18 8.09am

I don't want to start another Alan Pardew thread because my dislike for him is absolute!
Man Utd won the FA Cup and sacked their Manager the very next week.
We lost it and gave our Manager a new contract when he had taken 11 points from the previous 19 games!
I think Parish has done okay to be honest but keeping Alan Pardew in a job was where he let emotions take over his business brain.
That man put us back light years!!

 

geoff Flag Midhurst 23 Oct 18 10.27am

In terms of progress i think our playing squad has improved (on paper) than the team that got us promoted. However our fighting spirit has been lost and the spirit the squad had that won us promotion was awesome.

Apart from that we have failed to progress in key areas. Those areas are in the board room. Our recruitment has been hit and miss and mainly panicky, our dealing with managers and their recruitment has been shocking. Our scouting network seems non existent. We lost Stephen Reid a huge loss and replaced him with a cheap option. Yes we have spent money but badly. Beneteke has been poor (polite), Sakho was a Parish purchase to please the fans, Jach- why, Sorloth poor player etc etc.

Its in the corridors of power we need to learn and quickly and we need to stop becoming an old boys club and start becoming a serious business.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Oct 18 11.00am

Originally posted by the.universal

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Moaning Minnies' by Midlands Eagle

No, it’s because he gets more of the big decisions right than wrong, specifically manager appointments.

Untangle your knickers and realise we’ll be ok this season.

It’s because Parish gets the 2nd decision in the season right, after getting the first decision wrong, whether that be hiring, not firing, signing or non signing of players. Each time we’re in dire straits when it was avoidable in August. It ends up costing more money than it originally would’ve done and those additional costs chip away at the average spend allowed per summer and the % of revenue on wages according to FFP rules. Then there’s the lack of continuity issues in the squad. The most obvious one is Benteke last season in a team trying to play triangles through the 2 back lines at SP. Don’t get me started on FDB and his 3-4-3 and Huddersfield debacle. I and the whole sports broadsheet media community were predicting a failure and that’s exactly what happened.

Back to basics now this month. Hopefully it may just suit and help us.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Oct 18 11.13am

One can measure progress in a plethora of ways.

In terms of our league positions since being promoted to the PL :

2017-18 11th Won 11 Pts 44
2016-17 14th Won 12 Pts 41
2015-16 15th Won 11 Pts 42
2014-15 10th Won 13 Pts 48
2013-14 11th Won 13 Pts 45

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 23 Oct 18 11.41am

Obviously, being in the PL allows a club to trade at a higher level and our squad now is 100 times better than the one that got promoted.
Unfortunately, most of the teams in the PL have improved considerably during our time there as well. Therefore, we have not improved in relative terms so far but just about stayed the same.
Our useless efforts in the last two window have seen us slip back as could have been predicted and was predicted by me for one.

If you don't spend you go backward. We must find a way to improve in January or risk relegation. Our chairman looks frightened of failure every season and then makes the very same mistakes again the next. When will he learn that you can't wing it year after year? To rely on Benteke to find form again was bonkers and to have no decent back up was lunacy.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 23 Oct 18 12.12pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

I think a lot of fans underestime how touch it is to stay in the Premier league. As teams stay up for longer, the expectations of fans grow to want to achieve something that's beyond their means. After they start to want someone that unachievable they clubs start to turn on themselves and become toxic.

There's been 49 premiership clubs. Loads have been in for a season or two, then completely disappeared. Lots have had a boom or bust business model which has distroyed them.

Only 6 teams have never been religated. It's pretty much inevitable that we will at some point. I couldn't find a stat on how many have lasted 6 consecutive seasons but I'm sure it will be lower than people expect.

Going up and staying up was a fluke. Expecting to stay up shows progress.
Building the new stand will make us more competitive.

We just have to be patient and hope we don't mess it up.

This sums it up for me. Too often people underestimate the PL. there's 20 Teams in the league - guarenteed 15 of them have fans who have aspirations/expectations of fighting for a European place, as ludicrous as that sounds. We are one of those team who every year seem to expect survival and want to be pushing onto the next level, spouting our league positions of 10/11/14 whatever as evidence we are ready. In reality, the bottom 13 clubs are so close in quality, any of them/us are 'relegation fodder'.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Oct 18 12.23pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

This sums it up for me. Too often people underestimate the PL. there's 20 Teams in the league - guarenteed 15 of them have fans who have aspirations/expectations of fighting for a European place, as ludicrous as that sounds. We are one of those team who every year seem to expect survival and want to be pushing onto the next level, spouting our league positions of 10/11/14 whatever as evidence we are ready. In reality, the bottom 13 clubs are so close in quality, any of them/us are 'relegation fodder'.

May I congratulate you on a very good post.
I am wholeheartedly in agreement with the general thrust of your message.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 23 Oct 18 1.39pm

Originally posted by Willo

May I congratulate you on a very good post.
I am wholeheartedly in agreement with the general thrust of your message.

Why thank you! The irony, of course is that I was one of those who was one of those fans hoping a year away from the relegation dogfight... more fool me.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

KAOS Flag In a tree 23 Oct 18 2.04pm

Bottom line … we just have to avoid relegation this season again and get a season closer to building our new stand. AND, when we start the build guess what?! We’ll have to ensure we don’t get relegated again that season until we become more of an attractive proposition for bigger investors than we have already got. AND until such a point, we will always be where we are and tbh we can’t honestly hope for more?!

Think about the last 6 or seasons … a play off final win, a host of very expensive players have arrived in different forms (whether or not they’ve been value for money is another things), our 6th consecutive season in the Prem, a number of internationals in the 1st team squad, the most talented player outside the top 4, an FA cup final appearance, a firm plan to start redevelopment the Main Stand … need I go on?!

If that’s not making progress from where we were 7-8 years ago I don’t know what is!

Yes, we’re shoddy at the minute. Yes, we can’t buy a win. Yes, we run the gauntlet of going down again (see 1st point in this comment) … but f*ck me, if you don’t like it then don’t go and let someone else have your ticket!

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 23 Oct 18 2.39pm

Originally posted by the.universal

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Moaning Minnies' by Midlands Eagle

No, it’s because he gets more of the big decisions right than wrong, specifically manager appointments.

Untangle your knickers and realise we’ll be ok this season.

I bet my list is longer than yours.

Oo er.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 23 Oct 18 2.46pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Obviously, being in the PL allows a club to trade at a higher level and our squad now is 100 times better than the one that got promoted.
Unfortunately, most of the teams in the PL have improved considerably during our time there as well. Therefore, we have not improved in relative terms so far but just about stayed the same.
Our useless efforts in the last two window have seen us slip back as could have been predicted and was predicted by me for one.

If you don't spend you go backward. We must find a way to improve in January or risk relegation. Our chairman looks frightened of failure every season and then makes the very same mistakes again the next. When will he learn that you can't wing it year after year? To rely on Benteke to find form again was bonkers and to have no decent back up was lunacy.

This is the key.

Parish has done and does do a lot of good things for the club, but one of the things Steve Parish hasn't figured out after all of these years is how to manage a squad. If he hasnt got it down by now he probably never will.

Benteke has been an abject failure for over 14 months now, and to address that we signed a guy in Sorloth who failed in the Dutch top flight, and Ayew on loan.

Its not good enough.

Yes we have assembled a solid defense and defensively solid midfield but other than Meyer, who often doesnt get to play, where is the creativity in the middle of the park?

Other than Wilf Zaha and our left back where are the goal threats?

RH does not have enough attacking options, and we are suffering for it with a serious lack of goals in our game at the moment.

RH not having enough attacking options is the responsibility of the chairman.


 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 23 Oct 18 3.27pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

This sums it up for me. Too often people underestimate the PL. there's 20 Teams in the league - guarenteed 15 of them have fans who have aspirations/expectations of fighting for a European place, as ludicrous as that sounds. We are one of those team who every year seem to expect survival and want to be pushing onto the next level, spouting our league positions of 10/11/14 whatever as evidence we are ready. In reality, the bottom 13 clubs are so close in quality, any of them/us are 'relegation fodder'.

Great Post

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 24 Oct 18 3.30pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

Why thank you! The irony, of course is that I was one of those who was one of those fans hoping a year away from the relegation dogfight... more fool me.

Within seconds of the final whistle at Fulham hundreds were planning for Europa Cup travel in 2019.

Others, like myself, just wanted a season without the constant worry that has been a hallmark of our PL escapade, sometimes to the last couple of games, sometimes one or two more but I can't think we have ever been safe, mathematically or pragmatically after 32 0r 33 games and that being likely after say 25 games

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 24 Oct 18 3.32pm

This

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

This is the key.

Parish has done and does do a lot of good things for the club, but one of the things Steve Parish hasn't figured out after all of these years is how to manage a squad. If he hasnt got it down by now he probably never will.

Benteke has been an abject failure for over 14 months now, and to address that we signed a guy in Sorloth who failed in the Dutch top flight, and Ayew on loan.

Its not good enough.

Yes we have assembled a solid defense and defensively solid midfield but other than Meyer, who often doesnt get to play, where is the creativity in the middle of the park?

Other than Wilf Zaha and our left back where are the goal threats?

RH does not have enough attacking options, and we are suffering for it with a serious lack of goals in our game at the moment.

RH not having enough attacking options is the responsibility of the chairman.


 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Oct 18 3.48pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

This is the key.

Parish has done and does do a lot of good things for the club, but one of the things Steve Parish hasn't figured out after all of these years is how to manage a squad. If he hasnt got it down by now he probably never will.

Benteke has been an abject failure for over 14 months now, and to address that we signed a guy in Sorloth who failed in the Dutch top flight, and Ayew on loan.

Its not good enough.

Yes we have assembled a solid defense and defensively solid midfield but other than Meyer, who often doesnt get to play, where is the creativity in the middle of the park?

Other than Wilf Zaha and our left back where are the goal threats?

RH does not have enough attacking options, and we are suffering for it with a serious lack of goals in our game at the moment.

RH not having enough attacking options is the responsibility of the chairman.


I disagree with your last statement. It is the manager and coaches job to improve and get the best out of their players. For all their good points, Roy and Ray have failed in the striker department. Benteke was a top striker a few years ago, he has gone backwards under Roy, why?
It’s an easy cop out to blame the chairman, but isn’t working with the players everyday.

 

East G Eagle Flag 24 Oct 18 5.51pm

I have to agree with you.
Roy doesn't exactly look like a motivator of men
More like an old uncle whom players respect but don't get the kick up the arse they need.
As well as palace I go see Crawley Town whom changed coaches just after season started.
Italian coach with lots of motivation and constantly a presence on the sidelines
The team has been completely revitalised
Playing fast attacking football with confidence on the ball & Infront of goal
No signings just good coaching & team building.
Palace are lacking in these attributes.


 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Oct 18 5.56pm

Originally posted by East G Eagle

I have to agree with you.
Roy doesn't exactly look like a motivator of men
More like an old uncle whom players respect but don't get the kick up the arse they need.
As well as palace I go see Crawley Town whom changed coaches just after season started.
Italian coach with lots of motivation and constantly a presence on the sidelines
The team has been completely revitalised
Playing fast attacking football with confidence on the ball & Infront of goal
No signings just good coaching & team building.
Palace are lacking in these attributes.


Since Cioffi took charge they have won all their Home league games but lost all their Away games.
They have gone from 15th to 9th since he was appointed Head Coach so travelling in the right direction.

Edited by Willo (24 Oct 2018 6.00pm)

 

East G Eagle Flag 24 Oct 18 6.07pm

Yes true.
Away form needs working on.
But you can feel the enthusiasm of him.
It must work for the players.
Not getting that from Roy unfortunately.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Oct 18 6.52pm

We are in both cups still. Could be Wembley bound yet.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 2 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have we really made progress ?