You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Reid in for Hodgson
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Reid in for Hodgson


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
chateauferret Flag 05 Nov 18 9.10am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not so sure as none of us really knows what goes on in the transfer department and to say that "he doesn't tell his managers who they are going to get" could well be wrong if the rumours about Parish signing Wilf over Pulis's head are true

Any manager who objected to our signing Wilf should have been out on his arse without delay.

 


============
The Ferret
============

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 05 Nov 18 10.31am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I'm not so sure as none of us really knows what goes on in the transfer department and to say that "he doesn't tell his managers who they are going to get" could well be wrong if the rumours about Parish signing Wilf over Pulis's head are true

OK, but thank goodness there is sometimes the exception to the rule

 

Rogers Don Flag Horsham 05 Nov 18 12.08pm

Hodgson's tactics remind me of the classic Morecambe and Wise sketch, where Eric says to Andre Previn " I played all the right notes, but not necessarily in the right order!" Hodgson is playing the correct players, but not necessarily in their best positions.
Zaha need to play out wide with Meyer in the centre behind Sorloth or Ayew.

 


Let's keep the ball this season!

Jacey Flag 05 Nov 18 12.39pm

Originally posted by Rogers Don

Hodgson's tactics remind me of the classic Morecambe and Wise sketch, where Eric says to Andre Previn " I played all the right notes, but not necessarily in the right order!" Hodgson is playing the correct players, but not necessarily in their best positions.
Zaha need to play out wide with Meyer in the centre behind Sorloth or Ayew.

Two more defeats likely,many would not be surprised,over the next two games,denting our goal difference as losing games to good sides,apart from the good Arsenal point,becomes the norm.
Can Roy turn this very bad run of results around by Xmas is the question before serious questions are raised???

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Nov 18 12.56pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Parish signs the chequs, he doesn't tell his managers who they are going to get, he goes by what they and the scouts recommend.

Possibly true but when the scouts are sh*te, you end up with Erdal Rakip.

Does the way we have used Max Meyer so far indicate to you that RH desperately wanted to sign the guy?

You think Roy asked us to sign Jaroslav Jach?

I would rather the manager has the last word over a scout. Scouts should recommend players based on what the manager needs.

Remember last January where RH publicly stated we needed to sign a goalkeeper? He never makes public statements like that, and even then the best the club could do was sign a pre contract for the summer.

I think on plenty of occasions Parish does tell the manager who he is going to get.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 10 Nov 18 8.24am

Originally posted by chateauferret

What makes you think they're supporting the club now? Lose away at Chelsea after giving them a decent game and they want the manager and chairman out. Absolutely pathetic.

Couldn't agree more, bloody snowflakes

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 10 Nov 18 8.33am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Possibly true but when the scouts are sh*te, you end up with Erdal Rakip.

Does the way we have used Max Meyer so far indicate to you that RH desperately wanted to sign the guy?

You think Roy asked us to sign Jaroslav Jach?

I would rather the manager has the last word over a scout. Scouts should recommend players based on what the manager needs.

Remember last January where RH publicly stated we needed to sign a goalkeeper? He never makes public statements like that, and even then the best the club could do was sign a pre contract for the summer.

I think on plenty of occasions Parish does tell the manager who he is going to get.


By the same token, do you think Parish told Roy that he(Parish) wanted to sign Jach or Mayer or Sorloth.
But i do agree with you that it should be the manager who says who he would like to sign, finds permitting.

 

JoeViper Flag bromley 11 Nov 18 10.47am

I can't see the owners digging too deep in their pockets for new signings when there is a new stand to pay for. I suspect they will want to borrow as little as possible. I also think they will be happy to just survive for next couple of years. That could be a dangerous game though.

 


One of the biggest mysteries in life is that loud stupid people normally don't have even the slightest inclination that they are stupid.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 24 Nov 18 7.35pm

Great result and performance by all accounts. Shame Roy and Ray didn’t get the 3pts their efforts have deserved. Fine margins.

 

Shootylooty Flag Croydon 28 Nov 18 12.18pm

Mindless post in my opinion. RH is doing a marvellous Job - we're playing some of the best and most coherent football that we've played in years. We played really well against Spurs, Chelsea and Man Utd - and in every game we were very unlucky to come away without more points. We fully deserved a point from both the Chelsea and Spurs games and could have beaten Man United - given the clear cut opportunities that we had. We are opening teams up and creating opportunities, we just need to start converting those chances. Certainly agree with many on this forum that if we had a proven striker, we would not be hovering at the bottom of the table! To be fair RH is making the best out of the situation he finds himself in but the club should be looking to sign a proven striker in the Jan window whether on contract or loan as our current options up front are sadly lacking and have been for 2-3 seasons now! It's a shame that we sold Murray - what did we get for him £4m? He's scoring goals for fun at Brighton! I doubt there's many would disagree that we need another Murray, who has a good positional instinct, worries and pulls defences around and can hit the target!

 


Cowardice lasts longer than pain.

Maine Eagle Flag USA 28 Nov 18 1.48pm

Originally posted by Shootylooty

Mindless post in my opinion. RH is doing a marvellous Job - we're playing some of the best and most coherent football that we've played in years. We played really well against Spurs, Chelsea and Man Utd - and in every game we were very unlucky to come away without more points. We fully deserved a point from both the Chelsea and Spurs games and could have beaten Man United - given the clear cut opportunities that we had. We are opening teams up and creating opportunities, we just need to start converting those chances. Certainly agree with many on this forum that if we had a proven striker, we would not be hovering at the bottom of the table! To be fair RH is making the best out of the situation he finds himself in but the club should be looking to sign a proven striker in the Jan window whether on contract or loan as our current options up front are sadly lacking and have been for 2-3 seasons now! It's a shame that we sold Murray - what did we get for him £4m? He's scoring goals for fun at Brighton! I doubt there's many would disagree that we need another Murray, who has a good positional instinct, worries and pulls defences around and can hit the target!

Agree we have looked much better lately against the bigger sides, but we were awful against the likes of Newcastle and Wolves, really awful in fact.

Burnley is a huge game for us, we need to show up, perform and take our chances as our performances against lesser sides this season have been seriously poor.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Nov 18 2.06pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Agree we have looked much better lately against the bigger sides, but we were awful against the likes of Newcastle and Wolves, really awful in fact.

Burnley is a huge game for us, we need to show up, perform and take our chances as our performances against lesser sides this season have been seriously poor.

Absolutely right.

We are going to be under huge pressure to get a win and should we get into the latter stages drawing or losing the tension will be high-volt crackly.That said, we have been under severe pressure before and succeeded - just think about last season when against all odds we managed to survive.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Nov 18 7.50pm

Fearful for Saturday. They caused us problems when they resorted to route one in the second half of the game last season and not sure we have the quality to break them down when they put players behind the ball.

 

Den1923 Flag 29 Nov 18 8.46pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Parish signs the chequs, he doesn't tell his managers who they are going to get, he goes by what they and the scouts recommend.

I think he is more hands on than you seem to think!

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 29 Nov 18 9.05pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Parish signs the cheques, he doesn't tell his managers who they are going to get, he goes by what they and the scouts recommend.

A credible explanation. These scouts ... are they from the 5th Sutton or the 1st Beddington scout groups?

In recent years, I thought we'd recruited blind men to search for our players but the final recommendations were actually submitted by their guide dogs?

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 30 Nov 18 8.49am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

A credible explanation. These scouts ... are they from the 5th Sutton or the 1st Beddington scout groups?

In recent years, I thought we'd recruited blind men to search for our players but the final recommendations were actually submitted by their guide dogs?

Be it blind men or their dogs, i still think it isn't Parish who says what players to sign, no decent manager would stand for that, (yes, i know about Zaha), its got to be Freedman as far as i can see.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 18 9.03am

Gone are the days when teams were wholly reliant on the manager/scouts attending games in all weathers,running the rule over certain players.

In this modern era, teams are reliant on technology such as WyScout,Scout7 etc etc to identify players from around the globe with data-led analysis very much in evidence.Recruitment teams in conjunction with the manager painstakingly trawl through a plethora of players based on team requirements but this is just the staging post to an eventual transfer and of course as we are all aware getting players 'Over the line' can prove very frustrating and end in disappointment.

Edited by Willo (30 Nov 2018 9.04am)

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 30 Nov 18 9.04am

Roy chose sorloth. I know that much

Jach and Erdal were dougie and his previous side kick who has since left

 

TomThePalaceFanatic Flag 30 Nov 18 2.27pm

Originally posted by matthau

Roy chose sorloth. I know that much

Jach and Erdal were dougie and his previous side kick who has since left

Understandable from his Scandivian links.

We've had a lot of unlucky moments this season and the team is worse.

It's easy to vent anger at Hodgson, but I feel as if this week really is make or break. Poor results against Burnley, Brighton and West Ham and I'll begin to sway towards a change of manager. But he's done enough to earn our backing for now.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Nov 18 2.42pm

Originally posted by TomThePalaceFanatic

Understandable from his Scandivian links.

We've had a lot of unlucky moments this season and the team is worse.

It's easy to vent anger at Hodgson, but I feel as if this week really is make or break. Poor results against Burnley, Brighton and West Ham and I'll begin to sway towards a change of manager. But he's done enough to earn our backing for now.

A sample of who's available : Bruce,Carvalhal,Jokanovic,Moyes,O'Neill,Strachan,Poyet.
Would you be happy with any of these ?

Hodgson performed a miracle last season so there is a great deal of faith in him reviving our fortunes.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Reid in for Hodgson