You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?
November 16 2026 6.31am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?


Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >
ChrisGC Flag Wantage 28 Dec 18 9.35am

Here's a question:

Win the FA cup and relegated or out in the third round and a mid table finish?

I'd take the cup every time personally.

 

YT Flag Oxford 28 Dec 18 9.39am

Originally posted by timmyb

It saddens me that it is ever even a consideration that we should not take the FA cup seriously.

We have emerged from our second worst Autumn of the last two years with 7 points from the last 3 home games and have just taken 4 points from two trips to Manchester. Roy has managed this with a team with no centre forwards.

We are significantly better than the bottom four and this will not change.

I well understand the desire to preserve top flight status after decades of swift returns to the championship...but if that is the sum total of our ambitions then we will one day become Stoke City...a club almost losing the will to live after a decade in the Prem becoming increasingly uncompetitive.

I have said this before...being as Palace fan has taught me a great deal of life lessons; perseverance, groundless optimism and so forth. I don't feel like I am owed anything, I never expect to see Palace as league champions, but oh my goodness an FA cup win would make 40 years of roller coasting worthwhile.

I am still not over the 1990 final...have tried to erase the 2016 one from my memory. I couldn't give two hoots about playing in Europe...that's not a reason for not trying to win the oldest cup competition in the world. Win the cup and play the youth team in Europa qualifying...please can we just take the tournament seriously?

You could be ‘me’ posting this! I too haven’t got over 1990, nor have I got over 1976. I hoped 2016 would exorcise the demons of those massive disappointments, but it wasn’t to be and - like you - I’ve erased 2016 from my memory (until I wander into the John Lewis TV section, where it’s STILL being played as a demo video).

I WANT PALACE TO WIN THE CUP. How about winning the cup and then declining the Europa Cup place? Why not?

One small point I take issue with you on though...can something be the second worst out of two things? Isn’t that the same as saying it was the better of the two? Just teasing; I do get what you meant

Edited by YT (28 Dec 2018 10.07am)

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 28 Dec 18 10.00am

I'm baffled why anyone would turn their nose up at winning a cup or playing in European competition, what else are we in the league for? To consolidate 12th place every season?

What's your best memory as a Palace fan? The answer might differ depending on your age but I'm willing to bet that, for most of you, the answer will involve a day out at Wembley and a playoff win and isn't that what football's all about, those big days out?

I would happily see us relegated if it meant winning either of the cups because ultimately playing in the Premier League comes and goes but seeing Luka stand up there and lift a cup would be a memory that we'd never forget.

Additionally I don't agree with the Burnley example as a reason for not trying to qualify for the Europa League. In my opinion we have a far stronger squad than them and we did last season as well. They played with unsustainable efficiency last year and set themselves impossibly high standards but are now reverting to the mean. Even if it did affect our form though, the chance to get through a few rounds and have an away day against the likes of Inter of Sevilla would be an incredible experience for us.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 28 Dec 18 10.06am

I certainly think we should be trying to win these competitions. There must be more to football than just trying to avoid relegation every year.

I understand the financial aspects of staying in the prem however when I was a young boy I used to dream of us scoring at Wembley and lifting trophys, not celebrating because we finished 17th.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 Dec 18 10.35am

I don’t think we should prioritise it, but if a premier league football clubs first choice team can’t play a potential half a dozen extra games there’s something seriously wrong. I know times have changed, but we should play our best side in every game and see where it takes us.

 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 28 Dec 18 1.00pm

well it seems i'll be the unpopular minority on this one , i think prem survival comes first and cups second . we don't have enough depth in our squad to put out our best side every game , lets face it we are more than likely not going to win the cup and i dont think its worth risking our potential match winners on the cup. if wilf or andros luca or any of the others get their leg broke or do their ligaments because of some grimsby player bad tackle how would our season go , no cup no prem no player . just my opinion

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 28 Dec 18 1.15pm

Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle

well it seems i'll be the unpopular minority on this one , i think prem survival comes first and cups second . we don't have enough depth in our squad to put out our best side every game , lets face it we are more than likely not going to win the cup and i dont think its worth risking our potential match winners on the cup. if wilf or andros luca or any of the others get their leg broke or do their ligaments because of some grimsby player bad tackle how would our season go , no cup no prem no player . just my opinion

I wholeheartedly endorse these sentiments.PL survival is the priority and without being disrespectful to Grimsby we really cannot be risking key players in a home game against League Two opposition.

Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2018 6.14pm)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Dec 18 3.59pm

Originally posted by Tipp_Eagle

well it seems i'll be the unpopular minority on this one , i think prem survival comes first and cups second . we don't have enough depth in our squad to put out our best side every game , lets face it we are more than likely not going to win the cup and i dont think its worth risking our potential match winners on the cup. if wilf or andros luca or any of the others get their leg broke or do their ligaments because of some grimsby player bad tackle how would our season go , no cup no prem no player . just my opinion

The facts bear you out. Only 3 teams outside the Big 6 have won the FA Cup since this start of the Premier League, Everton, Portsmouth and Wigan the later 2 imploded and fell through the leagues after winning.
Premier survival is paramount and this is how about 12 Premier teams will view the FA Cup as winning against the odds.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Dec 18 5.12pm

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I'm baffled why anyone would turn their nose up at winning a cup or playing in European competition, what else are we in the league for? To consolidate 12th place every season?

What's your best memory as a Palace fan? The answer might differ depending on your age but I'm willing to bet that, for most of you, the answer will involve a day out at Wembley and a playoff win and isn't that what football's all about, those big days out?

I would happily see us relegated if it meant winning either of the cups because ultimately playing in the Premier League comes and goes but seeing Luka stand up there and lift a cup would be a memory that we'd never forget.

Additionally I don't agree with the Burnley example as a reason for not trying to qualify for the Europa League. In my opinion we have a far stronger squad than them and we did last season as well. They played with unsustainable efficiency last year and set themselves impossibly high standards but are now reverting to the mean. Even if it did affect our form though, the chance to get through a few rounds and have an away day against the likes of Inter of Sevilla would be an incredible experience for us.

Should be a thread ; best palace moment...sod it im in. Check the titles in 5 min.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 28 Dec 18 5.59pm

if we had a goal scorer.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 28 Dec 18 6.00pm

well thats where we differ mate id rather be in the prem league than the second tear of english football . been there done that , maybe when the squad is stronger ok, but that's not likely to happen any time soon .

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 28 Dec 18 11.15pm

Should put all into it as love the FA Cup! Should have won both finals but have curse of Man U (spit)

GT

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 29 Dec 18 3.31pm

Odd thinking among Palace fans.

It would have been great to win the cup on the three occasions where we have got close but the cup is not what it was and winning it would not be the thrill that it once would have been.
There is no way that jeopardising our position in the PL is an option or winning the cup in any way a consolation for relegation. Getting into the Europa Cup would be a ball and chain for a club at our level. We cannot win a cup in Europe and the strain on the squad and the fitness timetable could be terminal.

If you can get to the Cup Final while safe in the league then great, but any season with a sniff of relegation threat, forget it.


 

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 29 Dec 18 4.23pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Odd thinking among Palace fans.

It would have been great to win the cup on the three occasions where we have got close but the cup is not what it was and winning it would not be the thrill that it once would have been.
There is no way that jeopardising our position in the PL is an option or winning the cup in any way a consolation for relegation. Getting into the Europa Cup would be a ball and chain for a club at our level. We cannot win a cup in Europe and the strain on the squad and the fitness timetable could be terminal.

If you can get to the Cup Final while safe in the league then great, but any season with a sniff of relegation threat, forget it.



agree 100 percent mate .

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

est1905 Flag 29 Dec 18 5.37pm

Prioritising the cup really worked out for Pardew didn't it!
We are not strong enough to guarantee survival year in year out to take one eye off the league. If we could manage say 3 or 4 years established as a top 10 team and at no stage during the season get anywhere near the relegation zone then maybe but right now? No way

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 31 Dec 18 7.38am

Financially its all about the premier , a cup run is a welcome diversion though where knock out football can give the team a bounce that in turn can reflect in league games .


Prioritise no , enjoy yes .

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 31 Dec 18 8.29am

Originally posted by est1905

Prioritising the cup really worked out for Pardew didn't it!
We are not strong enough to guarantee survival year in year out to take one eye off the league. If we could manage say 3 or 4 years established as a top 10 team and at no stage during the season get anywhere near the relegation zone then maybe but right now? No way

It wasn’t the cup that caused Pardew to destroy our squad. It was just Pardew himself. As soon as he lost players he didn’t have a clue. At that time it was first Jimmy and wasn’t it Bolasie straight after? Not only that but any long term big players just had to go in his eyes, odd and insecure man that he is.

 


COYP

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 31 Dec 18 12.19pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

It wasn’t the cup that caused Pardew to destroy our squad. It was just Pardew himself. As soon as he lost players he didn’t have a clue.

Spot on.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 01 Jan 19 4.38am

Also, a good run in the cup can build confidence and translate into (obviously that didn't happen for us) the league, chance to blood younger/fringe players.

 


This was once a quality forum....

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 01 Jan 19 7.50am

Originally posted by Willo

I wholeheartedly endorse these sentiments.PL survival is the priority and without being disrespectful to Grimsby we really cannot be risking key players in a home game against League Two opposition.

Edited by Willo (28 Dec 2018 6.14pm)

Yeah, another season of dross and a late scramble for 11th. Then wildly over promote our 7th season in the top division.

We're getting relegated eventually, let's take a trophy with us. You can't put the occasional giant killing in a trophy cabinet!

All out for the cup and go down. Championship is a better division with quality away days anyway. Poke modern football.

 

Page 2 of 3 < 1 2 3 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Should Palace prioritise the FA CUP?