This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
Sterling... You may dislike the term institutional racism and fair enough, it was lazy. but do black people do less well in job applications, and do women get less money than men for the same job? I simply believe they do. You may not. But I hire people and have first hand experience of how these things go in practice. As for 'a little bit' (and it's to redress racism and sexism, and even social background)...let me take it to an extreme... Eton boy, daddy had to earn half a mill to educate him, and he gets 0.000001% better academic/appplication results than the son of a convict & dirt poor single mum who, despite all the odds has kept his nose clean and excelled in the shytest education environment in the country, with violence all around him. I can't help but want the poor kid to get the nod and think that's right. He has the merit in this meritocracy. Not the rich kid who had every possible help. You either support meritocracy or you don't. You either place someone's ability ahead of the colour of someone's skin or you don't. Essentially you have made statements here that show that you support affirmative action. I criticise it for the reasons I've stated and support those who sue for how it has disadvantaged them over their race. Now in my view you make valid points about class advantage and we would probably agree about some aspects of that. However, affirmative action is most definitely not the answer to that sore. For me meritocracy and innate IQ must override all......So I'm suspicious of private schools which are based upon subject knowledge and reward networking and wish for a system that was based more purely on innate IQ.....though attitude to hard work is also important so this is a difficult topic.....Essentially I'd be looking to avoid advantage by class....but not excluding someone because of it. Now, I'd agree that this still leaves a problem over how society treats the less genetically gifted....which would still hit the poorest more due to the higher number of less successful genes....and there are valid concerns there....but they are different questions.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You either support meritocracy or you don't. You either place someone's ability ahead of the colour of someone's skin or you don't. Essentially you have made statements here that show that you support affirmative action. I criticise it for the reasons I've stated and support those who sue for how it has disadvantaged them over their race. Now in my view you make valid points about class advantage and we would probably agree about some aspects of that. However, affirmative action is most definitely not the answer to that sore. For me meritocracy and innate IQ must override all......So I'd abolish private schools which were based upon subject knowledge and base them purely on innate IQ.....Essentially looking to avoid advantage by class. Now, I'd agree that this still leaves a problem over how society treats the less genetically gifted....which would still hit the poorest more due to the higher number of less successful genes....and there are valid concerns there....but they are different questions. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jan 2019 9.25pm) in my specific example, rich boy gets the nod despite clear evidence that poor boy is probably smarter given where they came from? I'm only saying it's complicated. you're being pretty binary on something I don't believe is binary. affirmative action is as unhelpful a catch-all as institutional racism. it's a complex topic deserving of careful thought.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
in my specific example, rich boy gets the nod despite clear evidence that poor boy is probably smarter given where they came from? I'm only saying it's complicated. you're being pretty binary on something I don't believe is binary. affirmative action is as unhelpful a catch-all as institutional racism. it's a complex topic deserving of careful thought. I'd agree with you that some aspects are complex topics......though it can be seen here where we disagree on fundamental issues. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jan 2019 10.05pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I'd agree with you that some aspects are complex topics......though it can be seen here where we disagree on fundamental issues.
we both believe in meritocracy. I have strong conviction that a person who is heavily disadvantaged but 99.999999% matches the achievements of a highly privileged individual...the disadvantaged person should get the nod in an application for Oxbridge. And that is far more meritocratic than giving the Eton graduate the reward. once you accept that premise...and you may not, that's your prerogative, the question becomes how flexible the system needs to be to accommodate the disadvantaged. I think 1 or 2 percent is fair. but it's a fiendishly difficult thing to measure. I went to a god awful school and everything I've achieved in life is in spite of it. same with all my school friends. it wasn't our fault we went there, or had our upbringings. I'm sure many people will know the feeling...
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
we both believe in meritocracy. I have strong conviction that a person who is heavily disadvantaged but 99.999999% matches the achievements of a highly privileged individual...the disadvantaged person should get the nod in an application for Oxbridge. And that is far more meritocratic than giving the Eton graduate the reward. once you accept that premise...and you may not, that's your prerogative, the question becomes how flexible the system needs to be to accommodate the disadvantaged. I think 1 or 2 percent is fair. but it's a fiendishly difficult thing to measure. I went to a god awful school and everything I've achieved in life is in spite of it. same with all my school friends. it wasn't our fault we went there, or had our upbringings. I'm sure many people will know the feeling... Well, we are kind of back to where we were at the beginning. I have sympathy for your intent but I think that once you accept the premises that you have....then essentially you have opened Pandora's box and the loonies won't let you close it again.....and that's what indeed what essentially already happened with affirmative action. Indeed, I feel that I can criticise you for supporting this as it's this enabling at all levels which leads to lesser performing institutions and companies. I'm fully behind social mobility for talented people at the bottom. However, that isn't what is happening......Instead of words like meritocracy I see the word equity. Equity is the next step from the philosophy of equality. It leads to the very destruction of meritocracy. That is what has been enabled.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
Left winger alert! Refusing to have the flag of your location on your profile. Ashamed to be English due to some weird guilt you have invented? That's a really weird response
Check out our Croydon-based football comedy series 'Road to F.A. Cup'! |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr Fenandes
That's a really weird response
The condition of 'white guilt' is quite common amongst a certain demographic. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Jan 2019 1.17pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr Fenandes
That's a really weird response He's like Emily Thornberry who thinks the St George's flag makes you a racist or compliant. Why would you remove it? It was my idea to have flags programmed into the message board posts to indicate where fans are posting around the world.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
He's like Emily Thornberry who thinks the St George's flag makes you a racist or compliant. Why would you remove it? It was my idea to have flags programmed into the message board posts to indicate where fans are posting around the world. Maybe you should add a EU one Pengey ?
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Jimenez
Maybe you should add a EU one Pengey ? f*** OFF!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Penge Eagle
f*** OFF!
Pro USA & Israel |
|
| steve1984 19 Jan 19 2.22pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Mr Fenandes
That's a really weird response This is basically a forum for people obsessed by flags.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steve1984
This is basically a forum for people obsessed by flags. And hot dogs.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
The BBC article on this explained that the school has 5 members of staff who focus on helping students to get into university. (source: [Link] ) Many schools that puts this time, effort and money into getting kids into Oxbridge will do so - its about learning to 'play the game'. Private schools do this far better than state schools because they have the resources and experience. Its also a snowball effect where when you learn how to get kids in, that experience helps you with the next year etc. I think some people are looking for controversy here when the solution is pretty simple Edit: Sorry the closed bracket from my text got included in the link by mistake... Edited by andyg (19 Jan 2019 4.24pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by andyg
The BBC article on this explained that the school has 5 members of staff who focus on helping students to get into university. (source: [Link] Many schools that puts this time, effort and money into getting kids into Oxbridge will do so - its about learning to 'play the game'. Private schools do this far better than state schools because they have the resources and experience. Its also a snowball effect where when you learn how to get kids in, that experience helps you with the next year etc. I think some people are looking for controversy here when the solution is pretty simple
I wager what we see now has been a deliberate change....to what extent I don't know. However, all that matters is that the intake quality hasn't been lowered due to non meritocratic ideologies. Certainly all the criticisms regarding affirmative action stand. However, this lunacy is now mainstream. The link didn't work. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Jan 2019 4.03pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by andyg
The BBC article on this explained that the school has 5 members of staff who focus on helping students to get into university. (source: [Link] Many schools that puts this time, effort and money into getting kids into Oxbridge will do so - its about learning to 'play the game'. Private schools do this far better than state schools because they have the resources and experience. Its also a snowball effect where when you learn how to get kids in, that experience helps you with the next year etc. I think some people are looking for controversy here when the solution is pretty simple The link doesn't work but this echos my previous comments the "good" schools spend a year preparing the kids for the entrance exams so fair play to this state school.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by andyg
The BBC article on this explained that the school has 5 members of staff who focus on helping students to get into university. (source: [Link] ) Many schools that puts this time, effort and money into getting kids into Oxbridge will do so - its about learning to 'play the game'. Private schools do this far better than state schools because they have the resources and experience. Its also a snowball effect where when you learn how to get kids in, that experience helps you with the next year etc. I think some people are looking for controversy here when the solution is pretty simple Edit: sorry the close brackets in my text attached itself to the link!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, we are kind of back to where we were at the beginning. I have sympathy for your intent but I think that once you accept the premises that you have....then essentially you have opened Pandora's box and the loonies won't let you close it again.....and that's what indeed what essentially already happened with affirmative action. Indeed, I feel that I can criticise you for supporting this as it's this enabling at all levels which leads to lesser performing institutions and companies. I'm fully behind social mobility for talented people at the bottom. However, that isn't what is happening......Instead of words like meritocracy I see the word equity. Equity is the next step from the philosophy of equality. It leads to the very destruction of meritocracy. That is what has been enabled. it's a Pandora's box regardless. somebody who grows up in extreme poverty with a dire education yet matches the achievements of somebody whose education costs hundreds of thousands of pounds... meritocratically speaking, I'm just rooting for the pauper out of these two people and thinking 'I hope he gets his place at Oxbridge'. let's be realistic rather than idealistic for one second...hand on heartwho's likely to be more intelligent of the two, given their opportunities? who has achieved more? we both know the answer. there's this ex public schoolboy at my work. idiot. genuine idiot. no initiative. yet he's got his nice degree and somehow is climbing the greasy pole and building a nice life for himself to repeat the life he grew up into. there's another lad, east London geezer type. but smart and quick witted. proactive. talented. but not an operator in a large corporation... In a meritocratic world, the posh boy gets overtaken. I'm not convinced it'll play out that way. partly that's down to their upbringing. meritocracy surely needs to reward genuine achievement. there's some crossover between equity and meritocracy.
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Affirmative action is real racism. Anything that accepts a lower standard to address some kind of social justice is the beginning of the end of true meritocracy. This cancer infects the STEM field now. Far left politics is dominant in both the IT tech field and in the world of physics. It isn't about being the best.....It's about being the best from what is politically correct. The East Asians are laughing at us.....and in respect of affirmative action they are also suing....and I back them. Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jan 2019 8.24am) I agree that assessing people solely on merit is always what should be done. However affirmative action can sometimes help to achieve that. Why? Because when making the assessment you need to not only consider what someone has already achieved but what they could have achieved if there was a level playing field of opportunity for everyone up to the point of the assessment. So finding hidden bright nuggets within areas of deprivation who can then benefit from an Oxbridge opportunity is ultimately to all our benefit. There is nothing remotely "left wing" involved. It's just common sense and good practice.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I agree that assessing people solely on merit is always what should be done. However affirmative action can sometimes help to achieve that. Why? Because when making the assessment you need to not only consider what someone has already achieved but what they could have achieved if there was a level playing field of opportunity for everyone up to the point of the assessment. So finding hidden bright nuggets within areas of deprivation who can then benefit from an Oxbridge opportunity is ultimately to all our benefit. There is nothing remotely "left wing" involved. It's just common sense and good practice. But surely anyone can apply to Oxford or Cambridge providing they have the grades. The problem with the wider issue of equal opportunities is that it doesn't work both ways. For example. A man from pakistan can come here and open a business in which he employs his family. That means no local people can apply for the jobs. How is that fair in a country where larger employers have to conform to an equal opportunities policy? In this case, why should someone with better grades be overlooked so Oxford can accept some poor kids?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.