You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dortmund after Wilf
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dortmund after Wilf


Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Casual Flag Orpington 24 Jan 19 6.57am

Not really fussed either way. Unbelievable player when on form, but not on form enough. We need money to buy goals , he hasn’t scored in 14 games. Not sure if he’s ever hit double league figures in a season?
If he was playing at his peak , would love him to stay, his body language says otherwise. If he was as motivated as his Instagram suggests he is, we’d be getting 100m. I think he may be the classic example of being a good player at one club, someone said he would be tearing it up in the Man City team, a couple of performances like he’s had recently, he’s be on the bench. If Mahrez can’t get a start Zaha can’t either.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 24 Jan 19 7.15am

Originally posted by Casual

Not really fussed either way. Unbelievable player when on form, but not on form enough. We need money to buy goals , he hasn’t scored in 14 games. Not sure if he’s ever hit double league figures in a season?
If he was playing at his peak , would love him to stay, his body language says otherwise. If he was as motivated as his Instagram suggests he is, we’d be getting 100m. I think he may be the classic example of being a good player at one club, someone said he would be tearing it up in the Man City team, a couple of performances like he’s had recently, he’s be on the bench. If Mahrez can’t get a start Zaha can’t either.

In fairness I think this would have been said in regards to how far Pep brought Sterling along in just one season. I'm sure he could do wonders for Wilf too (to an extent anyway )

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Jan 19 7.26am

Originally posted by RyWa

If you believe the reports on sky sports,there's ongoing talks between wilfs people and Dortmund. This rumour seems to be a little more believable than the others.

Didn't Roy recently have a public dig at Sky for making up stories?

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 24 Jan 19 8.01am

Can you really see wolf wanting to go Germany? Think of his personality, his kid, cars lined up outside his mansion In purley. His mates, I can’t see this happening at all. In fact even if palace wanted to sell at 70m I could see him personally rejecting the move

 

Casual Flag Orpington 24 Jan 19 8.25am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

In fairness I think this would have been said in regards to how far Pep brought Sterling along in just one season. I'm sure he could do wonders for Wilf too (to an extent anyway )

I’m sure Pep would make him better, he only needs to be told to get his body over the ball when he shoots, then he won’t keep kicking it over the bar.
But even if they were interested, which they aren’t. With Sane and Sterling starting , how many wingers do they need on the bench? Think he’d be there 4th choice winger , getting a few cup games.
He’s doesn’t like Manchester either, since Moyes daughter left

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Jan 19 8.26am

You give Wilf space and he destroys teams, like against Liverpool. The problem is not Wilf, it is our lack of other attacking threat. Put Wilf in a top team and he will only have one person marking him and when you consider he can sometimes waltz through three defenders I think it says it all. I don't like it when he seems to get on his teammates backs, but I think it is genuine frustration that we're not doing better. I think some fans seriously undervalue Zaha. Mind you, there were fans a few years back saying they'd be happy for him to leave for 10/15m!!

I can't see him moving to Germany, or any other country, but it all comes down to his ambition in the end. If he is determined to play CL football then he will eventually have to leave, but if he just wants to play PL football with his home town club, then maybe this is enough (the money surely is).

If we do sell him then I want to know who these two players are that will get 15 goals and 15 assists when you consider Eriksen, Salah and Mahrez only got 10 assists each last season, and outside of Jamie Vardy no team outside the top 6 had a player with more than 12 goals (Luka had 10 and Wilf had 9 btw).

I think AWB is the one more likely to leave and he should command a sizeable fee in excess of £25 million (I don't want him to go either, but the lad is definitely going places).


Edited by taylors lovechild (24 Jan 2019 8.28am)

Edited by taylors lovechild (24 Jan 2019 8.29am)

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 24 Jan 19 8.27am

Bored of the moaning now, he's done it for 5 years and hasn't really made him a better player. 50mil and I'd take it, we can replace him with that and invest in building a better squad.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 24 Jan 19 9.34am

Originally posted by grumpymort

Same rumor that was pitched last year and it was complete rubbish like most regarding Wilf.

No one has even asked or anything regarding Wilf for a year.

50m wouldn't get him anyway Palace would be fools to let him go for 25m basically due to contract clause with United getting 50%.

If he goes it would be 70+ and Dortmund wouldn't be paying that out

He is not worth anything near 70m. Especially on this seasons form. 50-60 max. No one will pay 70m+ for him. 50m is an insanely good return for an inconsistent player with average to below average goals and assists.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Master Coin Flag 24 Jan 19 10.06am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

He is not worth anything near 70m. Especially on this seasons form. 50-60 max. No one will pay 70m+ for him. 50m is an insanely good return for an inconsistent player with average to below average goals and assists.

His goals/assist per game ratio really isn't as bad as you suggest. Some key considerations:

1) He plays in a really mediocre goal-shy team. If the team finishes better he gets more assists. Similarly this stat is impeded by playing for a relegation straggler with limited possession per game. If he plays for a top club then naturally the stats go up as the team he is playing for are in the final third that much more. Additionally you can't triple mark him at a good side whereas he is constantly swarmed with us as they know they can, to a certain extent ignore Ayew etc.
2) He isn't a striker. Simply looking at goals returns (or even goals and assists) ignores the work he actually does. Let's cherry-pick a different arbitrary stat to prove why he's great instead. He is the 2nd most fouled player in the country behind Hazard. He gets us up the pitch and gives the defence a breather consistently with his ability to retain possession and win fouls under constant pressure from multiple players.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 24 Jan 19 10.13am

In a recent game many fans were complaining about Zaha's performance. I saw the highlights on MOTM and everything good involved Zaha. Even on a off day Zaha is still our best player.

If he does want to go we should let him as long as it is early in the summer window and for a good fee.

 


One more point

Tipp_Eagle Flag Tipperary 24 Jan 19 10.27am

Originally posted by Badger11

In a recent game many fans were complaining about Zaha's performance. I saw the highlights on MOTM and everything good involved Zaha. Even on a off day Zaha is still our best player.

If he does want to go we should let him as long as it is early in the summer window and for a good fee.

that would be alright if the money was invested in new players , i wouldnt trust that it would be .

 


oh yeah ,fcuk off brighton.

premier fan Flag BR4 24 Jan 19 10.28am

I' be gutted if he went - best player for us by a mile.

I still think he's worth keeping and wouldn't sell for less than 70m if he really wanted to go.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 24 Jan 19 10.29am

Originally posted by Master Coin

His goals/assist per game ratio really isn't as bad as you suggest. Some key considerations:

1) He plays in a really mediocre goal-shy team. If the team finishes better he gets more assists. Similarly this stat is impeded by playing for a relegation straggler with limited possession per game. If he plays for a top club then naturally the stats go up as the team he is playing for are in the final third that much more. Additionally you can't triple mark him at a good side whereas he is constantly swarmed with us as they know they can, to a certain extent ignore Ayew etc.
2) He isn't a striker. Simply looking at goals returns (or even goals and assists) ignores the work he actually does. Let's cherry-pick a different arbitrary stat to prove why he's great instead. He is the 2nd most fouled player in the country behind Hazard. He gets us up the pitch and gives the defence a breather consistently with his ability to retain possession and win fouls under constant pressure from multiple players.

Exactly. Also, of the 5 penalties scored by Luka this season 4 were won by Wilf weren't they? Last season his record was 1 goal every 3 games. It's dipped this year, but I put that down to Bentenke being out as he was the perfect foil to Wilf last season with 5 assists to his name. Wilf is also generally involved in most goals we score, it's just that it is often not him that delivers the final assist. Key passes may be a more accurate stat, where he compares favourable against the likes of Mahrez, with Wilf having an average of 1.5 key passes per game (Mahrez has 0.8 and Eriksen has 1.8, for example). It is hard to equate Wilf's value based on stats though as just by being on the pitch he creates space for others. When he has been injured we have looked solid but lacking in creativity. I think many of us would like to see Meyer lining up alongside Wilf more often and this I think coupled with Tekkers returning could be a springboard for a strong second half of the season.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 24 Jan 19 10.31am

Genuinely difficult to form a clear opinion on this. On one hand I certainly wouldn't begrudge him a move and feel that it's needed for him to kick on in his career. Would be genuinely intrigued to see how damaging he could be playing for a huge side.

On the other hand I simply don't trust us to replace him and he leaves a huge hole in our team. The fact that he allegedly half the fee would go to United means we're looking at 25-35m max which certainly doesn't go as far as it used to and I doubt it will all go back into transfers anyway.

I'd hope that we'd buy a couple of young wingers from the Championship/overseas with the potential to grow rather than spunking loads on an established winger who might flop.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 24 Jan 19 11.03am

Wilf's price reflects his low conversion rate, it is actually a huge sum to pay for someone who would not necessarily side-foot the ball into an empty net from 6 feet.

And yet outrageously talented !!

 

Fred Bassett Flag rotherfield 24 Jan 19 11.14am

Wilf commands respect in whichever move he decides upon or not, lack of goals is a consequence of creativity within the team generally although the team has got better technically as has Wilf this season. With Dortmund they have many technical players thats why they are 6 points ahead of Bayern and top of the Bundesliga having scored 45 goals.

This transfer rumour if true must be tempting for Wilf the question is to coin a phrase "home or away", which might be the decider does he for go all of what he has in the UK or take a chance abroad we will see.

My opinion is go for it , its his life , he has done a great deal for the Palace and owes us nothing but leaves with a potential golden goodbye of say 35 mil our halve of any transfer if 70 mil was agreed transfer figure

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 24 Jan 19 11.39am

I think it’s time to let go. He’s been great for us but he hasn’t looked the same player recently and he deserves a chance to play for a team that can offer him Champions League football rather than staying with us and never really knowing what he might have achieved. We’ve become too reliant on him and the money would help us rebuild and move forward.

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 24 Jan 19 11.43am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

I think it’s time to let go. He’s been great for us but he hasn’t looked the same player recently and he deserves a chance to play for a team that can offer him Champions League football rather than staying with us and never really knowing what he might have achieved. We’ve become too reliant on him and the money would help us rebuild and move forward.

I kind of agree with you, I feel like maybe we're holding him back a little, I'd like to see him play in a good team surrounded by decent players, forget the Man Utd debacle, that was the wrong time and as it turned out the wrong manager who didn't use him. I'd love him to stay but I don't begrudge him a decent move.

However I don't trust us to reinvest the money wisely.

 

IMpalace Flag London 24 Jan 19 12.04pm

It blows my mind to see terms like "average player" being used and how ready people are to sell him. We are abysmal without him. Do people think it was just a coincidence that we didn't win for two and half years when he wasn't in the squad?

If he played in a top team where he didn't have three men marking him constantly and had players around him who can get in positions/finish, his stats would be miles better.

His end product could obviously be better, but to suggest that we wouldn't be severely impacted losing him (even if we got £60m) to me is rubbish.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 24 Jan 19 12.15pm

I remember hearing that it's even longer since we won a game without McArthur in the team but that's never mentioned (if true).

 

Page 2 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dortmund after Wilf